• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

A Tough Choice: Messing with the Original Eight

Tonzura Koite

Smash Cadet
Joined
Nov 11, 2014
Messages
66
Location
Chicago
Here's the scenario:

It's 2012, and Sakurai has suddenly announced he will be retiring from game development due to a stress-related nervous breakdown. You're the next in line prospect to design Sm4sh, and Sakurai has given you his blessing to take the reigns. His last wish as a game developer was that you deliver the greatest troll in the history of the series, and you need to make him proud. Specifically, he wants you to form the biggest roster so far. The catch? You need to outright replace one of the original eight characters: Mario, Link, Pikachu, DK, Yoshi, Fox, Kirby or Samus.

The trailer for this character will feature the character you chose to cut and the character you replaced him/her with. Kinda like the Lucina and Robin reveal trailer where Chrom says he'll have to get his chance another time, and won't be playable.

Which character would you replace, and who would replace him/her?

I'd replace Pikachu with Squirtle. Pikachu was the mascot for the show, and sold the most merch, but Smash is about the original games and not the peripheral stuff. It's why you don't see Captain N hanging around.

For a lot of us, Squirtle was the first Pokemon we ever saw in action. Squirtle was our loyal companion from day 1, and Blastoise carried our team all the way to the elite four. Pikachu was primarily a mascot who wasn't willing to lay it all on the line for us when we needed it. I picked Charmander myself, but a lot of my buddies went with that little turtle and so did many others. As a nod to the show, he could get some Squirtle Squad alts with the sunglasses. I'd say Pikachu could make it in as a Pokeball Pokemon, but seeing as he's too much of a special snowflake to go in one, I guess he'd be stuck as a trophy :troll:.

Anyone else up for the challenge?
 

Luigi#1

Smash Champion
Joined
Jan 27, 2014
Messages
2,097
Location
Planet Omicron Persei 8
It feels like :4mario::4link::4kirby:and:4pikachu: are on an even higher tier then the other 4 so they stay. :4samus: stays, as she has a larger series compared to the other 3. I'd be killed if I cut :4fox:. So my answer does not expand dong. :4yoshi: is a cutesy character, better to advertise. :4dk: is older, and Donkey Kong is crazy popular but the rarified one isn't up there as much. So who could replace the heavyweight?

None other than Ridley Donkey Kong!
Wait... wat?
The OTHER ONE!

Yes, I'm cheating, but he's a retro rep, he's very popular and he has different moveset potential.
Barrel throw!
Ladder climb! [summon a ladder that he quickly climbs]
Pick up and slam! [like Bowser's]
Punch chest to make... shock...waves?
Okay, maybe use a few moves...
BUT STILL IT'S DIFFERENT YOU SEE ONE HAS A TIE!
 

Blade Knight

Smash Ace
Joined
Oct 13, 2007
Messages
722
The only Original 12 member I'd remove Jigglypuff and replace her with a then current gen pokemon rep. All of the original 8 are fine and have no reason to be cut really.
 

Tonzura Koite

Smash Cadet
Joined
Nov 11, 2014
Messages
66
Location
Chicago
It feels like :4mario::4link::4kirby:and:4pikachu: are on an even higher tier then the other 4 so they stay. :4samus: stays, as she has a larger series compared to the other 3. I'd be killed if I cut :4fox:. So my answer does not expand dong. :4yoshi: is a cutesy character, better to advertise. :4dk: is older, and Donkey Kong is crazy popular but the rarified one isn't up there as much. So who could replace the heavyweight?

None other than Ridley Donkey Kong!
Wait... wat?
The OTHER ONE!

Yes, I'm cheating, but he's a retro rep, he's very popular and he has different moveset potential.
Barrel throw!
Ladder climb! [summon a ladder that he quickly climbs]
Pick up and slam! [like Bowser's]
Punch chest to make... shock...waves?
Okay, maybe use a few moves...
BUT STILL IT'S DIFFERENT YOU SEE ONE HAS A TIE!
Maaaan, this would be killer.
And we know what his grab animation would be. Over the shoulder, then climb up a ladder out of nowhere to throw em straight up.

Gotta have Cranky Kong as his name-change alternate costume. IIRC Cranky Kong is actually Original Kong in his twilight years.
 

Blade Knight

Smash Ace
Joined
Oct 13, 2007
Messages
722
It didn't go over my head, I'm just saying there's no point in replacing any of them. If it really had to be one of the original 8, and not the original 12, for some unspoken reason replacing Link would be easiest since there's already two of him in the game.

Thanks for being rude though.
 
Last edited:

Tonzura Koite

Smash Cadet
Joined
Nov 11, 2014
Messages
66
Location
Chicago
It didn't go over my head, I'm just saying there's no point in replacing any of them. If it really had to be one of the original 8, and not the original 12, for some unspoken reason replacing Link would be easiest since there's already two of him in the game.

Thanks for being rude though.
It's a challenge! Read the OP.
Will you honor Sakurai's last wish?
 

Luigi#1

Smash Champion
Joined
Jan 27, 2014
Messages
2,097
Location
Planet Omicron Persei 8
It didn't go over my head, I'm just saying there's no point in replacing any of them. If it really had to be one of the original 8, and not the original 12, for some unspoken reason replacing Link would be easiest since there's already two of him in the game.

Thanks for being rude though.
It it crazy and unnecessary. Something that would be difficult to do. It's the challenge, the point, which you missed. You could say
 

BubbaDuke

Smash Apprentice
Joined
Oct 17, 2014
Messages
87
if I HAD to remove one, it'd be Fox. Mostly because I feel like he's fading.

He's the kind of character where the majority of his fans come from Smash, rather than his actual games. Captain Falcon's a good example of this too.

I hope that new Star Fox game is good. He hasn't had a console release in years.
 

Munomario777

Smash Master
Joined
Nov 18, 2014
Messages
3,253
Location
Charleston, South Carolina
3DS FC
0387-9596-4480
Switch FC
SW-8229-3157-8114
Realistically I'd just say "Yeah, how about no" and keep them all in :p

That said, if I had to, um... :4ness:. He's really the character who's faded away in popularity the most, not having had a game in such a long time and all.

If we're only counting the 8, then probably :4yoshi:. He's really the one that represents the least of a unique franchise (he's a Mario character in many ways).
It's a challenge! Read the OP.
Will you honor Sakurai's last wish?
No. :)
 
Last edited:

Mav485

Smash Apprentice
Joined
Sep 29, 2014
Messages
77
3DS FC
1504-7090-2374
Switch FC
SW 7228 3594 2505
Strictly from the Original 8? It'd have to be Yoshi. I do like the Donkey Kong switch mentioned by Luigi#1 though. I'd replace Yoshi with Isaac probably. He has been my most wished for character for a long time.
 

Tails1000

Smash Cadet
Joined
Sep 5, 2014
Messages
27
I'd replace Jigglypuff with Genesect... and I'd make Genesect's final smash his extremespeed form he uses in his movie.
As for Jigglypuff, I'd then turn her into a Pokeball which would replace Bllossom. She would put everyone to sleep with her sing attack similar to how Bellossom uses sleep powder.
 

Dark Dude

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Dec 27, 2007
Messages
327
Location
North America
NNID
DudeSean
Here's the scenario:

It's 2012, and Sakurai has suddenly announced he will be retiring from game development due to a stress-related nervous breakdown. You're the next in line prospect to design Sm4sh, and Sakurai has given you his blessing to take the reigns. His last wish as a game developer was that you deliver the greatest troll in the history of the series, and you need to make him proud. Specifically, he wants you to form the biggest roster so far. The catch? You need to outright replace one of the original eight characters: Mario, Link, Pikachu, DK, Yoshi, Fox, Kirby or Samus.
I don't understand why it has to be 2012 in this scenario, but that's an easy one. Pikachu. There's plenty of other pokemon to take its spot. Or replace it with Raichu, just to be silly.
 

Tonzura Koite

Smash Cadet
Joined
Nov 11, 2014
Messages
66
Location
Chicago
I don't understand why it has to be 2012 in this scenario, but that's an easy one. Pikachu. There's plenty of other pokemon to take its spot. Or replace it with Raichu, just to be silly.
That's when Sakurai started actually working on it. Or would have.
 

Raijinken

Smash Master
Joined
Dec 8, 2013
Messages
4,420
Location
Durham, NC
I'd kick out Fox and include Lloyd Irving, opening up the Tales series and removing all traces of Starfox from Smash.

A close second would be Jigglypuff for continued irrelevance, but I dislike Fox more.
 
Top Bottom