Why in the world you belive that the clones have stolen place for DLC?! It doesn't make any sense. They have got theirs slot because they are bonus characters, made for having 51 characters instead of 48. Sakurai himself compared those characters to a free dessert that a restaurant gives you after a meal, and who hates clones and says that they should't be separate are or refusing this bonus or screing to the waiter "I don't want that, change it into a steak!!1!1!".
Smash 4 is the first to have DLC of any kind so its going to be a test bed in terms of character inclusions. It's definitely not a service where you get X characters for base with regular DLC characters and whatever interval. Right now there are 54 tiles in the Wii U version including Random and Mii fighters. Right now we know there are currently 2 hidden mario's in the code and there is space for 2 more characters. The original tiles pre Roy/Ryu/Lucas had a lot of empty space hence why the current set up cut a lot of the side space from each tile.
Sakurai has also said that they aren't going to be making too many more characters and only being a year out from the NX reveal and possibly another year before its release support for Smash is going to end sooner rather then later and be more limited than inclusive. Of course he can't be seen bagging out his characters regardless of how trivial they are. A better anology would be that they are topping on a cake. The cake itself is what people like, the topping doesn't make or break the cake and can be changed quite easily.
Character slots should be for archetype diversity, and in 95% of the time that is why they are. Different playstyles. No-one complains about Alph or Wendy because those are done right, extra's without the limits. Characters are limited and why Dark Pit and Doctor Mario aren't skins is mind boggling.
Surce that he said Dr. Mario with his Melee moveset is an insult to the fans? Because I remeber only his interwiev where he says that making him an alt would have been otrageous. Having him as it was is exactly what his fans wanted, and it also respound to all the fans who constantly asked to remove the FLUDD and re-add the Tornado. Dr. Mario accomplishes both roles.
Both Lucina anf Dark Pit where added due of their huge fan-base, since they are extremely popular in Japan, USA and Europe. Besides Pit doesn't have a Dark Pit skin, but woh this way of thinking, we shouldn't have Wolf because Fox had a Wolf skin, or Wario because Mario had his skin. It's stupid.
Statistically wolf is the least clone character in the entire series. By that logic Wario should be cut because Mario has his colours, Waluigi should never happen because Mario has his colours. Roy should have not come back because Marth has his colours. It's a throwback not a reason to not include characters.
Character wise, Doctor Mario is still Mario but with a different Job. However his smash representation makes little effort to show that. If they had even bothered to put in a tiny amount of effort to differentiate the 2 like Falcon/Ganon it would be tolerable at best. Doctor Mario is unique enough to be a fighter in his own right but not enough to give him his own playstyle that shows off his medical/doctorness? Pills is a basic visual throwback to him being a Doctor but nothing else about him makes the Connection to the Doctor part of Doctor Mario. It's lazy padding.
We have customs and skins for a reason. If Sakurai wants to have an online mode where you cant use customs thats his choice to balance it that way. Although thats more of a justification to have online modes where customs can be used not to create lazy characters for pandering purposes.
Lucina won't return in Smash 5. At least Lucina and Marth have a justification for being separate. Doctor Mario *IS* Mario. Press X on Pit 3 times and there is your Dark Pit. Press Y on Dark Pit twice and there is your Pit. Throwbacks are one thing, having both characters have the colour palette of the other character is another. Dark Pit is in because Sakurai bias. If Link can get a Fierce Diety skin, Pit can just have a dark pit skin. At least Fierce Deity would be unique.
No he isn't. No matter if the character is the same, if he had differences he should be put in a different place. Or are you saying that they also must cut Sheik and ZSS because they are Zelda and Samys?
That's a huge unjustified stretch to try to play that one and you know it.
Roy is a character you have to pay 4/5$ for, and they had 8 mounths for create him. Lucina, Dr. Mario and Dark Pit where a free bonus created in few mounths. And it doesn't matter if people don't want them, Sakurai put them and they will stay. Besides, Dr. Mario was an established veteran, so just for this he deserved his spot more than enough. No matter if you think it's justs padding.
We don't know Roy was in development for the whole 8 months after Wii U smash. They could have easily kept Doctor mario and friends back, no-one would have cared and then they could have come back as actual characters which could keep the DLC train all the way going till Smash 5. They won't make that many non-veteran character DLC because that would ruin a lot of new inclusions for Smash 5. Doctor Mario never made it to the final Brawl roster and no-body cared. If one of the main reasons Doctor Mario should come back because he was in the game once and nothing about the character itself thats a poor reason. It is padding, not I think its padding.
People are asking for Paper Mario
Little Mac adds almost nothing new. He just punchs with attacks that aren't even from Punch-Out, he is similar to Falcon not a clone, but the playstile is still "close range with no projectiles" (meanwhile they cut Snake, the only character that have added a real new playstile in the series as a trap master), but besides it I never stated they shouldn't be there (as I write even in CAPS, maybe try to read better next time), and I just think that the whole hate for clones is:
1)Childish
2)Useless
3)Boring
They haven't stolen anybody's place, they will never do that and they have enough differences for justify their inclusion as separate characters.
p
Paper Mario is a bigger franchise than Doctor Mario, he would be a million times better then Doctor Mario. Little mac is a good character for new players to try and has some potential in higher play, since he simplifies the smash mechanics (and smash mechanics are already very simple) and compensates for power and super armour. That and he is a boxer which plays differently and is the first time a fighter character from another fighting game has appeared in smash. Smash isn't cannon so having moves that arent real is going to happen (a lot of smash characters dont have moves that exist so dunno why you are trying that one).
Snake most likely got cut due to License/Konami v Kojima reasons and nothing else. He had a unique playstyle for sure and it was a shame he got cut.
Clones are a result of a lack of detailed features and options. Not because they are justified in their own right. If we had custom normal moves and not just custom specials a lot of clones would no longe be needed but because Smash hasn't reached that point yet clones are a thing. The fact we are moving towards skins and custom moves is a move towards customisation and that clones won't be needed in future if we can tweak existing characters to be them while that allows more character archetypes ina game with limited slots.[/quote]