I love Villager. Granted, I supported Tom Nook until the very end (with the same moveset), but that was unrealistic and wasn't going to happen. It's my prejudice against nameless avatars. And just think, if this rumor is true, THREE nameless avatars will be confirmed by the end of the week. Regardless, Animal Crossing is absolutely deserving of a rep and it looks like Sakurai absolutely nailed it with Villager.
That being said, if this rumor is true, the roster is starting out of the gate with a total of THREE wasted character slots (And I think we can all more or less agree that WFT, Mii, and Pacman are wastes). HOWEVER, I guess you could argue that Brawl had the same, depending on how much you liked ROB, Wolf, and Toon Link (Personally, I think all three of these are far more worthy than WFT, Mii, and Pacman). The silver lining is that once all of the terrible characters are out of the way, there aren't many more awful choices left for him to reveal, right? Maybe we can start seeing the characters that people actually WANT (K. Rool, Ridley, Takamaru, Shulk, etc).