I have a very love/hate relationship with Sonic. I very much enjoy playing him, but I always ignore half of his moveset when I do. I love his normals and basic movement options, but I think all of his b-moves are ridiculous. I know this character has been jerked around a lot already, but rather than nerf/tweaking him, I wish he would just be redesigned for the next version of the game.
He feels very gimmicky with all of his spin moves, homing attack is just silly, and I hate the way up-b lets Sonic go from the bottom of the stage to the top and back in a second. These options really make him feel out of control, and not in the Captain Falcon way.
Homing attack - just make it Blast Attack and give it an always set trajectory. Put him into special fall unless it connects. Currently, I don't like how the move takes a degree of control out of the player's hands, I don't like how it boosts Sonic's recovery, and I don't like the way it needlessly extends combos.
Side-b/down-b - I don't even know...just make them useless like Melee Yoshi's egg roll. I haven't seen much out of these moves that appeals to me (aside from some side-b momentum stuff), and I really don't think he needs the boost these moves bring to the table. His speed/movement is good enough already. If down-b could put Sonic into a spin burst that worked kind of like a Shine, I think that'd be pretty cool. No reflecting or invincibility or frame 1, but just a close-range pressure move that pops the opponent up/away to some degree.
Up-b - I've made this suggestion before, but I'd like the move to work something like this.
The move could be charged and angled like Diddy's. Tapping would only give him a little bounce, while charging would give him something close to the distance he has now. I really don't like the idea of recovery moves that don't put you into special fall, but if any recovery move makes sense for that, it's the spring.
I don't know. This is how I would like to see Sonic in an ideal PM. In that world, everyone would be about as good as Melee Marth, so I don't know if we'll ever get that. However, the first 3.5 blog post has me hopeful that things are going to be toned down a bit. I'm not really looking for a debate here, I just figured I'd post my thoughts. I'm sure this comes off as a bit Smash/Melee conservative, but that's just how I'd like to see the character, so I don't mean to offend anyone who really likes Sonic as-is.
[/flameshield]