My sister downloaded Five Nights at Freddy's, so I played it for a while.
Mmm, I don't think it's a game for me, in a sense that I'm too impatient for it. Those animal monster things that pop up in cameras and in your room do look freaky (also goofy), yet I didn't get shocked too much when they appeared. I appreciate the game for what it's trying to do, as I do find it innovative. Interesting gameplay and lore.
Of course, what's scary does vary from person to person. Rather than "shocking" me (like jump-scares), in video games, I prefer if the horror is being portrayed in a more gradual (for lack of better word) sense, and can relate to me on an emotional and psychological level (especially mind****s, love those). I usually get more frightened and disturbed in those scenarios, especially if such horror themes are portrayed abstractly (and throw in some symbolism, I love that).... if I'm making any sense idk it's hard to explain.