I personally up taunt. If you have two Shulks facing, it's quite obviously Shulk time. I save "I'm really feeling it" for when I'm really enjoying the match (when at high tension). "
This is the Monado's Power" is something I use to poke fun at the other Shulk. I always wonder if my messages are getting across though.
Oh yeah, and if I'm using the Reyn alt I have to use the "Now it's Shulk time" taunt no matter what (for the first time I switch to the alt).
I haven't started choosing the victory screen yet, but I've thought about it.
To choose the victory screen, hit either up, left, or right on the dpad soon after the opponent dies or the time is up.
Hitting up on the dpad gets either "I've got a good rhythm going" or "The future is ours to decide."
-- I see this as something to go to if you are repeatedly winning against somebody. Could possibly work if you've just had a comeback since 'good rhythm going' implies favorable momentum while 'future is ours to decide' implies you changed the future.
Hitting left gives you either "I got through that pretty good!" or "This is a good result!"
-- I see this as something to go to if you found the match easy. It has a little bit of a lighter feel to it though.
Hitting right gives you either "I can feel the power!" or "I can change the future!"
-- I see this as something to go to if you were having a hard time against the opponent but prevailed. Also works for when you're in high tension.
What other ways do I try to communicate?
---"I'm really feeling it!" *the lag. I'll use this to complain to the other person about lag, usually after pressing and releasing my shield a few times to test the input delay.
---"This is the Monado's Power!" against non-Shulk's can mean I'm letting the person know that Shulk is pwnage.
---"Now it's Shulk time" when there has been a change in the game's momentum or I feel I'm having a comeback.
---"Now it's Shulk time" when used at the end of the match when you win... Shulk puts his hand out in front of him with his head down/eyes closed/other arm on his side. With no sound his body language looks like he's being cocky, almost like him saying "I swept the floor with you"
---In the same situation as the above one (at the end of the match), using "I'm really feeling it" can make you look angry.
---Go to Monado Shield, walk reeeaally slowly at the person. I will sometimes do this to For Glory players who refuse to move. Alternatively, it's hilarious if you go to Monado Shield and fox trot at them (looks intense but you're barely moving).
---Switching to nude Shulk. There's something fun about playing in this alt in general, so I'll go to it if having fun with another Shulk. Alternatively, it could be seen as humiliation (against any character).
---Switching to Dunban alt = Now I'm serious
---Just rapidly pressing the B button -> idk, just general spaminess.
---Hitting B to the music. Self-explanatory, lol.
So yeah, again, I realize some of this is more likely to send a message to the opponent than others