TheMintyCookie
Smash Journeyman
- Joined
- Jul 1, 2003
- Messages
- 201
lol @ fonz. YEAH DONT CALL ME MONEY GRUBBING OR ELSE I WILL CHARGE YOU MORE! NOW WHO HAS MY $500 stool?!?!?
Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
who said fc and oc are alike? whos restricting anything? we make dvds and if people want to buy them great, if not they can wait online till someone who does rips them. And if this person decides to rip them it is our right to know who it is. All i can say is the code method is quite genius. Also this new dvd wont be just matches like last year. Even if someone rips it, good luck uploading 4.7 gigs of files. As for sueing people, i dont want to waste my time on a smasher who has nothing better to do then hide behind his computer, but i know for a fact if i make a product even if it has nintendo footage, that product is mine. I can sue someone.Part of what made 0C and FC great were the match videos that followed afterward. So, now 0C is separating itself from FC by restricting access to its match videos simply because ManaCloud has some beef with the online community. You are actually going to collect all of that personal information to aid you in hunting down pirates? So, everyone starts sharing codes and the videos show up on YouTube. Then what? You ban them from future 0C events and DVD sales? You certainly can't sue anyone.
when read on a dvd player its fine. When it is a file it needs a code.not to be a negative nancy but no protection scheme is perfect
unless you're sony who changes theirs every time a new blockbuster comes out, those matches are getting ripped
and even if you are sony
they're getting ripped a week later
as far as 4.7gb goes, they can always be compressed and even so, 5 gb only takes about a day to upload if you have base-level cable modem
whats this code thing you're talking about, are you encrypting each file?
how is that supposed to be played on a dvd player like you claimed?
Quoted for truth. All I see mana trying to do is blame the smashers, make up excuses for reasons for why things happened.... instead of actually apologizing.Mana, I am utterly confused at your logic. After all of the accusations placed on you and the 0C3 staff (some with good reason), you have the audacity to say, "Well, I hate you all, so I am going to attempt to profit off the match videos (in the name of supporting 0C) just to spite you all." Now, call me crazy, but if I were in you shoes, I'd say, "Well, everyone, I'm sorry things did not quite turn out as expected. Anyway, here are some matches of the best players in the world! Enjoy!"
Obviously, you can do whatever you want. sugarpoultry was not implying that 0C and FC are supposed to be the same tournament. She was just pointing out that 0C is only further alienating itself after what many noted as a very negative experience. All I can say is this: good luck selling DVDs after this whole escapade. You are right; we will never understand how stressful it is to be the host of a massive tournament, but you put on an extremely unprofessional front, so many people feel that you should not be the face of 0C.
if you didnt go to oc3 thats none of your concern. I already mentioned for the people who did attend the dvds will be cheaper than for those who didnt. Logic has nothing to do with this. For the people who didnt go to oc3 if they want matches they can pay for them on dvd, otherwise they shouldnt care for them. Everyone wants matches released online for free that is not my concern either. People who went to oc3 saw the matches and if they want the dvds as a memorial thing then great. For people who didnt go and want the matches we already have some online for them. If they want the good matches then pay for it. Myself release the matches for people who put down oc3 is a joke right? Why release something to someone who wants videos of oc3 but hates the way it was handled. I only see complaints from people who didnt attend oc3, and like you said whether or not i would like to release those matches is entirely up to me. Buy the dvd or dont i really dont care. I am just putting something out there for those who want it.Mana, I am utterly confused at your logic. After all of the accusations placed on you and the 0C3 staff (some with good reason), you have the audacity to say, "Well, I hate you all, so I am going to attempt to profit off the match videos (in the name of supporting 0C) just to spite you all." Now, call me crazy, but if I were in you shoes, I'd say, "Well, everyone, I'm sorry things did not quite turn out as expected. Anyway, here are some matches of the best players in the world! Enjoy!"
Obviously, you can do whatever you want. sugarpoultry was not implying that 0C and FC are supposed to be the same tournament. She was just pointing out that 0C is only further alienating itself after what many noted as a very negative experience. All I can say is this: good luck selling DVDs after this whole escapade. You are right; we will never understand how stressful it is to be the host of a massive tournament, but you put on an extremely unprofessional front, so many people feel that you should not be the face of 0C.
I went to OC3. I still don't see why you're charging for the videos.if you didnt go to oc3 thats none of your concern. I already mentioned for the people who did attend the dvds will be cheaper than for those who didnt. Logic has nothing to do with this. For the people who didnt go to oc3 if they want matches they can pay for them on dvd, otherwise they shouldnt care for them. Everyone wants matches released online for free that is not my concern either. People who went to oc3 saw the matches and if they want the dvds as a memorial thing then great. For people who didnt go and want the matches we already have some online for them. If they want the good matches then pay for it. Myself release the matches for people who put down oc3 is a joke right? Why release something to someone who wants videos of oc3 but hates the way it was handled. I only see complaints from people who didnt attend oc3, and like you said whether or not i would like to release those matches is entirely up to me. Buy the dvd or dont i really dont care. I am just putting something out there for those who want it.
hydro if you went to oc3 the matches will be offered for a cheaper price then for those who didnt go. If oc3 is alienated it is because people made it that way after the tournament was over. No matter what we do people are always going to complain about how things were ran etc.I went to OC3. I still don't see why you're charging for the videos.
As from a personal standpoint, right now, I really don't have much of a problem with OC3 was run, since that's over and done with, and nothing will be solved with pointless bickering and arguing. I, for one, would like to apologize for the unnecessary accusations that I placed upon the OC3 staff for various aspects of the tournament.
However, what most of us don't understand is why you're still going to lengths to distance and alienate yourself from the rest of the community. As general consensus has shown, most of us would like to have the matches uploaded on youtube for viewing, or simply on a site like Filefront where we can all download it for keepsaking. I for one would find having the separate matches on my computer to be much more convenient than having them all on a DVD. Each individual match is much more easily accessed, and with a computer and can go to any point in the match much more easily than I would be able to do on a DVD player. Uploading to say, Filefront, is also much less labor-intensive than creating a high-quality DVD for viewing. It also doesn't take the large numbers of blank discs you would have to buy just to create said DVDs.
If you're trying to "punsih" some people for not appreciating how OC3 was run, then I don't have much to say. We all have to learn to forgive someday. But if you wish to distance yourself further from the smash community, that's your choice.
But what's the point of doing all this; just so people who "despise" OC3 don't get the matches? You do realize that your act of going to all the trouble to encode the DVDs is quite pointless when eventually, as Buzz said, someone will find a way to crack the code, and all of your work will be for naught?hydro if you went to oc3 the matches will be offered for a cheaper price then for those who didnt go. If oc3 is alienated it is because people made it that way after the tournament was over. No matter what we do people are always going to complain about how things were ran etc.
Why make dvds instead of upload them to file front? sharing issues. it is as simple as that. We give you matches then everyone gets them, even the people that despise oc3. Atleast with the dvd people who hate oc3 wouldnt want to support it.
I really think that you should acknowledge this ManaCloud.But what's the point of doing all this; just so people who "despise" OC3 don't get the matches? You do realize that your act of going to all the trouble to encode the DVDs is quite pointless when eventually, as Buzz said, someone will find a way to crack the code, and all of your work will be for naught?
Don't you think that it'd just be better to just let grudges go, and just let everyone have them? It's not even about the money at this point, but it's whether you're willing to be the first to apologize (since both sides are at fault here), and start anew. It's just that a large portion of the smash community harbors a significant dislike for you, and this is exactly why.
That is all I needed to hear. No wonder you are acting this way.Logic has nothing to do with this.
hes saying why even make a dvd, just post them all online ? Why go through all the trouble of protection, right?I really think that you should acknowledge this ManaCloud.
Even though this may be a sudden realization, I believe that this statement does state why someone can dislike your methods of bartering.
Sure, there may be some of the afromentioned issues occuring in the future, but since they will happen regaurdless, then why go through the trouble.
That is essentially what he is saying. Taking advantage of a simple matter for Finantial gain is a great way to show your odiousity towards someone.
I know that what any of us say won't change your mind, but take your methods of video distribution into consideration. Is it really worth it?
Glenn only has a portion of the files online. And they're all either pools matches (which are quite boring, honestly), or preliminary brackets, which aren't too hot, anyways. So not all of the vids are up online.hes saying why even make a dvd, just post them all online ? right?
whos saying we havent done that?
glens done a great job by posting the matches online on
getyour tournament.com
now for the rest of the files i have. These files werent going to be online for free download in the first place. They were going to be use to make a dvd regardless of whether people like it or not. So in the end why make something like this? Ive learned quite a bit from the oc2 dvds. A lot of people did buy them but many stopped due to the people who ripped it and put it online. After this i felt bad for those who did support oc2. This year even people really want to put it online for those who dont support oc3. I think it is in my interest to make it one hell of a difficult dvd to put online.
if people have questions concerning the oc3 dvd they can aim me directly. Ill only speak to those attending oc3.
Thank you for contributing absolutely nothing to the discussion, and just regurgitating old information. Don't you understand it's not about what people wrongly did/said to him, but rather how he's going to deal with it? What he's doing right now is the act of a 7 year old child who knows no better: "You were mean to me, so now I won't share my toys with you." However, being much older than that, he should know how to forgive people for their misdeeds, not try to attempt to punish them in a futile grasp at power.Well, I don't think something as petty as this is going to "split" the smash community. Also, being called thief. crook, swindler....by like 30+ people is no fun, especially when you just did so much to try to make something good and it's not like it's over, people are still accusing them. They were even saying theyre should be legal action towards them...guilty until proven innocent...wow. Those who buy it are those that support them, and it probably will find it's way online. Really no big deal.
No they can't; they don't have access to the original tapes. You can shut up and wait for all I care, but don't infringe on our right to post our opinions on a public forum.why dont you all just shut up and wait for the videos to be uploaded.
anyone with a capture card could re-record all of these videos and upload them without anyone needing to put in a password or any crap like that.
just shutup and wait for it to happen.....OR.....buy a DVD. both of these ways dont require any complaining on the boards.
THANK YOU! I was waiting for someone to say that. Also, I'm skimming through the old OC2 Zero Challenge Video Thread and it's as almost as if someone copied and pasted the thread here. You hear some of the same people complaining about how they don't get to see the matches and what not. Seriously, wait until someone rips off the vids and gets them posted online or buy the dvd.why dont you all just shut up and wait for the videos to be uploaded.
anyone with a capture card could re-record all of these videos and upload them without anyone needing to put in a password or any crap like that.
just shutup and wait for it to happen.....OR.....buy a DVD. both of these ways dont require any complaining on the boards.
Nothing's changed. The vids that everyone wants to watch will still be on the DVD (ie. M2K vs. PC Chris).I agree. Making a DVD AND uploading files is a great idea. If you want to know the people who "support" you, it will be pretty apparent. Making a DVD and uploading files basically makes everyone happy. Those who want to support all you've done for the tournament will buy your DVD, and those worried about just watching the matches will be satisfied. If quelling the disagreements is in interest, then making everyone happy would help, instead of making DVDs out of spite.
The only reason why i wanted to make another dvd for oc3 in the first place is to wrap up oc3. It seems after everything that has happened oc3 for some reason has a bad rap because of some outcomes that we couldnt control. If oc3 had a better venue maybe it would change the outcome of the tournament. However, with lots of people wanting housing(which is the only way people will attend tournaments) its making it much more difficult for host to provide depending where they live. With that now said,Same crap as OC2, same thing is going to happen. The DVD isn't going to be finished until the community as a whole has advanced beyond the point of what a majority of the matches display. In this case, however, Brawl will be out before this DVD, and all the information regarding this will become useless. The DVD will be nothing more than memorabilia (which I have plenty of, due to getting my controller signed by 21 professionals and 2 others, as well as taking pictures and the like). There's nothing you guys can do, Mike's made his mind up. He's not going to share them for free, this is the last squeeze before the cash cow dies. Doesn't help that everyone's hurling insults at him and the OC3 staff, either. Kinda gives him a way to validate and justify what he's doing.
My suggestion? Just go watch the FC videos and talk to anyone that was at the tournament, especially if you didn't go to OC. That's the only way you're going to get anything from this before SSBM is more than just dead where it stands. It's the grim truth. =/
In other news, there **** well better be an OC4 for Brawl. I want to see everyone gather up for the next generation, and desperately need an excuse for Ken to host another tournament. He's ****ing nice.
EDIT: Thanks Mike for at least tossing us the matches that won't make it to DVD. That makes me happy.
No they can't; they don't have access to the original tapes. You can shut up and wait for all I care, but don't infringe on our right to post our opinions on a public forum.
And Ken, I completely understand what you're saying. But if people want it to be memorable, they'll buy a DVD regardless of cost. So if you upload the files and make a DVD, those who want the footage just for the sake of watching will get that, and those who want to preserve the memory of OC3 will also be able to do so in the form of buying a DVD. However, if you force people to buy DVDs, then it'll seem like you just want to squeeze money out of people by making buy an expensive piece of memorabilia; that's because currently it is only you who has access to the original footage.
Yes, people will always complain about everything. But does that really stop us from doing what we choose to do? No, not really. So please don't use "people are going to complain anyways" as an excuse.
That's great, you feel better now that you're done calling me ********?your opinion is ******** tho. your complaining because you want the videos to be uploaded online. AND THEY WILL BE UPLOADED ONLINE. so why not just wait?
SOMEBODY IS GONNA BUY THE DVD.....AND UPLOAD THE VIDEOS.....JUST LIKE THEY DID FOR THE 0C2 DVD
Umm.... no you didn't. My friend S.O.S. picked it up at one of the biweeklys at your house, then he mailed it back to me.also kyle youve been to oc2 , and when you left your phone accidently we came out of our way to return it and paid shipping. You should know better than anyone else we arent like this.
I know that, notice how I put charge in the past tense.MLG VoD doesn't charge anything any more.
oh , i think im thinking about the other guy. Luckily sos came so arash never sent it. For that i apologize.Umm.... no you didn't. My friend S.O.S. picked it up at one of the biweeklys at your house, then he mailed it back to me.
EDIT: Not trying to be mean, but it is the truth.
BTW, it's a shame that BACH stopped doing stuff. In fact, wasn't he supposed to have gone to OC2 but declined?