• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Individual Character Polling: Source Gaming Edition (1800+ Votes!) RESULTS ARE HERE!

Click yes if you voted on all 5 parts of the Individual Character Poll!


  • Total voters
    57

BluePikmin11

Akko is my dear daughter!
Joined
Jan 5, 2013
Messages
28,373
Location
https://twitter.com/BPikmin11
NNID
blue

INDIVIDUAL CHARACTER POLL:
Greetings! BluePikmin11 here, making another appearance on Source Gaming. I have created another, more organized version of the individual ballot poll, previously posted in Smashboards. (See below for current polls)

Despite the number of characters, the poll was designed to be finished rather quickly. The first page shows pictures of the characters. The second page then has those characters (in a random order) with just the names. Select the bubble on how much you want the character, with 5 being the highest and 1 is the lowest. If you are truly indifferent about that character then please select “3” as that is the middle. There are multiple sets of pages within each poll.

With the 1-5 scale, we hope to calculate how “wanted” the characters are. When the results are finished, we will take an average of all the responses and rank the characters from most “wanted” to least “wanted”. There are a lot of characters on the poll — some you may be unfamiliar with! I hope that this poll will raise awareness of some lesser known Nintendo characters, and perhaps introduce you to a new favorite!


A sample of the poll.

You are free to vote at anytime before October 3rd ends. This poll require a login to vote as it is needed to prevent multi-voting. This is SG’s biggest poll, and we need your vote to get the best in-depth results! Please share this poll on Twitter, Facebook, reddit, Tumblr, with your grandma, etc. The more poll votes, the more likely this poll will actually represent the community’s feelings towards each of those characters.

RECOMMENDATIONS:
  1. Use your TAB and arrow keys to navigate through the poll quickly!
  2. You don’t do all of the polls/questions at once. Take your time to do each one. You can answer the polls in any order and anytime you wish before October 3rd.
  3. Share the polls! Spreading the polls will help make the results more useful.
  4. If you really don’t care either way about a character, leave it as a “3”.
NOTE: We have “pre-filled” out the poll with all 3s. Please change the votes up or down. This was done to make filling out the polls as easy as possible.

Part 1 Playable Represented FranchiseThese are characters that have a franchise in the game already.

Part 2 Other Nintendo SeriesThese are characters from either “retro” series, or unrepresented series from Nintendo’s history.

Part 3 “Deconfirmed” Characters and VeteransThese are characters that already have an in-game role, or used to be a fighter.

Part 4 3rd PartiesThese are the notable 3rd party characters.

To check the results, go back to the poll link you've done, click previous responses, results should be there:


Ultimate Smash Ballot Poll:

This poll is only one question. But choose wisely!

Source Gaming is also running an “Ultimate Smash Ballot Poll”. In this poll, each person has one choice, and one vote. It’s suppose to actually mimic the Smash Ballot (as the rules state only one vote per person). Please do not be confused, the individual character polls and the Ultimate Smash Ballot Poll are two different sets of polls. We will be using both sets of data to make conclusions in the future. Be sure to fill both out!

Share your opinions here!

Rankings:
 
Last edited:

Schnee117

Too Majestic for Gender
Joined
Aug 21, 2014
Messages
19,766
Location
Rollbackia
Switch FC
SW-6660-1506-8804
Good Lord was that a gauntlet of voting.
Well that's a lot of No's. Especially in the Indie and Square Enix section.
 

Yomi's Biggest Fan

See You Next Year, Baby
Joined
Sep 20, 2011
Messages
26,203
Location
Chicago, Illinois
NNID
Takamaru64
3DS FC
1375-7346-9605
Switch FC
SW-8277-6509-2593
Oh boy, this is going to be real fun for the day. Especially seeing what excellent choices I would find.
 

dangeraaron10

Smash Master
Joined
Apr 7, 2015
Messages
3,222
Location
Ohio
Pretty much what I was expecting. Ballot frontrunners (K. Rool, Dixie, B.Dee, Isaac (especially Isaac), Inklings), certain 3rd Partie (Banjo-Kazooie, Simon Belmont, Rayman, Bomberman), Vets (All of them not named Pichu, Young Link, or Pokemon Trainer), Bosses, Assist Trophies, and Others (Ridley, Waluigi, etc.) all did very well.

Most of the third parties that weren't listed above did very bad.

The indies did bad as well, Shovel Knight only did so-so, but Shantae did very well.

I'm surprised Achilles from LBX was up there, from a game I'm currently playing, I'm not surprised at his unanimous 1's for being Not-Ray. Still voted 5 on Ray though.
 

Nintendotard

Smash Lord
Joined
Jul 26, 2013
Messages
1,712
NNID
Mariotard
I enjoyed going through the indie page and giving all of them 1s ^_^
 

jamesster445

Smash Lord
Joined
May 7, 2015
Messages
1,174
Before I begin here's a little way that I'm judging these characters.
5- If I made a top 20 for this game, DLC, or Smash 5, these guys are on it.
4- I had at one point or another really wanted these characters but I found a character that fit that particular niche just a little better.
3- General Indifference
2- General distaste but I'm hoping to warm up to the character should they be released.
1- Nope
With that said

Part 1

Mario
Baby Mario-1
E.Gadd-2
Plum-1
King Boo-1
Daisy-4
Baby bros-1
Birdo-2
Fawful-3
Captain Toad-3
Dimentio-1
Wart-1
Metal Mario-1
Paper Mario-3

Donkey Kong
Jumpman-1
Dixie+Kiddie-4
K.Rool-5
Dixie Kong-4
DKJR-1
Diddy+Dixie-1
Cranky Kong-1
Pauline-1
Lanky Kong-3
Stanley-1

Wario
Wario land Wario-1
Captain Syrup-2
Jimmy T-3
Mona-3
9-Volt-2

Zelda
Toon Ganondorf-1
Ganon-1
Tetra-3
Lana-1
Impa-4
Zant-1
Groose-3
Vaati-4
Toon Zelda-2
Toon Sheik-1

Pokemon
Plusle & Minun-2
New Pokemon Trainer-1
Weaville-3
Blastoise-2
Hawlucha-2
Gallade-3
Absol-2
Scizor-1
N-4
Delphox-1
Sceptile-4
Gengar-3
Mirror. B-4 (If only because of that fro)
Grovyle-3
Blaziken-1

Metroid
Adam-4
Kraid-1
Sylux-4
Anthony Higgs-5
Rundas-4

Kid Icarus
Hades-5
Medusa-4
Eggplant Wizard-1

Fire Emblem
Tharja-3
Ephraim-3
Leif-1
Hector-2
Eliwood-1
Anna-5
Tiki-3
Sigurd-1
Azura-4
Corrin-2
Micaiah-4

Star Fox
Slippy-1
Peppy-1
Leon-2
Krystal-5

Punch Out
Mr. Sandman-2
King Hippo-3
Glass Joe-1
Bald Bull-2
No Mike Tyson?

Kirby
Marx-3
Daroach-3
Bandana Dee-2
Gooey-1
Magolor-3
Dark Matter-2
Galacta Knight-1
Adeleine-3
Lolo & Lala-1
Prince Fluff-5

F-Zero
Jody Summer-3
Blood Falcon-1
Pico-3
Black Shadow-5

Animal Crossing
Mr. Resetti-1
Crazy Redd-1
KK Slider-1

Mother
Giegue-4
Poo-2
Ninten-2
Porky-5
Masked Man-2
Paula-4
Kumatora-2

Pikmin
Charlie-4
Plasm Wraith-2
Louie-4
Brittany-4

Xenoblade
Melia-3
Elma-5
Cross-4
Fiora-4
Reyn-4

That's it for Part 1.
 
Last edited:

jamesster445

Smash Lord
Joined
May 7, 2015
Messages
1,174
Part 2

Retro
Hakkun-3
Mach Rider-2
Balloon Fighter-2
Muddy Mole-2
Max, Dion, and Jack-1
Mini Kangaroo-1
Tamagon-1
Parabo & Satebo-1
Goku-3
Lip-2
EVR Racer-1
Sukapon-1
F-Type-1
Fighter Hayabusa-1
Bubbles-2
Hiro-1
Alice-2
Harry-2
Hanafuda-1
Mike Jones-2
Urban Champion-3
Excite Biker-1
Star Man-3
Diskun-1
Ayumi Tachibana-2
Mr. Stevenson-1
Prof. Hector-1
Donbe & Hikari-2

Rhythm Heaven
Monkey-3
Chorus Kids-3
Girl-3
Karate Joe-3
Marshal-3
DJ Yellow-3
Wrestler-3

Modern
Agent J-5
Demille-1
Lark-1
Isaac-5
Reckless Safety Man-1
Ray MK-5
Pokkle-1
John Raimi-3
Chibi Robo-5
Jill-2
Andy-5
Sami-4
Ashley Robbins-2
Dr, Lobe-1
Ryuta-2
Kalas-2
Wave Racer-1
1080 Snowboarder-1
Doshin the Giant-2
Kururin-1
Alexandra Roivas-1
Mokka-2
Felix-2
Barbara-2
Pious Augustus-4

Newer
Isa Jo-5
Aeron-3
Raymond Bryce-1
Savvy Stylist-1
Welt-2
Rusty Slugger-3
Freya-2
Captain Rainbow-4
Squid Sisters-3
Tempo-2
Vince-3
Mallo-4
Monita-4
Inkling-5
Nikki-1
Wonder Red-5
Fossil Fighter-3
Action Figure-1
Maya-3
Nintendoji-2
Matthew-2
Zael-4
Aisya-3
Octoling-3
Zip-2
Heracles-2
Eddy-2
Henry Fleming-5

Smash bros. Orginial
Tetris-1
Tabuu-4
New Mii class-4
Sandbag-1
Master Hand-1
 
Last edited:

Logo12

Smash Lord
Joined
May 14, 2015
Messages
1,377
Location
Somewhere without a Smash community. Send hlep
My system goes:
  1. Ones I hate/Simply don't want
  2. Ones I wouldn't mind
  3. Ones I don't have problem with at all
  4. Ones I would be happy with
  5. Wolf
---
Just a quick table of all veterans, and 1st party repped newcomers, "deconfirmed" characters that has a >20% 5 votes:

CV: Cut Veteran
DR: Defined Role
NN: Nintendo Newcomer
 

ShinyRegice

Smash Lord
Joined
Jul 27, 2014
Messages
1,631
Location
France
Reposting what I posted in the now obsolete thread for the individual polls, here are my votes:

1 (no): 1080; 9-Volt; Absol; Adam Malkovich; Adeleine; Aeron; Agent J; Aisya; Alexandra Roivas; Alice; Andross; Anna; Anthony Higgs; Ashley Robbins; Ayumi Tachibana; Azura; Baby Bros; Baby Mario; Bald Bull; Balloon Fighter; Barbara; Birdo; Black Shadow; Blaziken; Blood Falcon; Brittany; Bubbles; Callie & Marrie; Captain Rainbow; Charlie; Chorus Kids; Chrom; Corrin; Crazy Redd; Cross; Daisy; Daroach; Delphox; Demille; Devil; Dimentio; Diskun; Dixie + Diddy duo; Dixie + Kiddy duo; DJ Yellow; Donbe & Hikari; Doshin; Dr. Kawashima; Dr. Wright; Dunban; Eddy; Eevee; Eggplant Wizard; Eliwood; Ephraim; EVR Racer; F-Type; Felix; Fighter Hayabusa; Fossil Fighter; Freya; Galacta Knight; Gallade; Gardevoir; Genesect; Gengar; Giegue; Glass Joe; Goku; Gooey; Groose; Grovyle; Hakkun; Hanafunda character; Harry; Hawlucha; Hector; Henry Fleming; Heracles; Hiro; Jeff; Jill; Jimmy T.; Jody Summer; John Raimi; Jumpman; Kalas; Kamek; Karate Joe; Kat & Ana; King Hippo; Knuckle Joe; Kraid; Kukurin; Kumatora; Lana; Lanky Kong; Lark; Leif; Leon Powalski; Lololo & Lalala; Louie; Lyndis; Mach Rider; Magnus; Marx; Masked Man; Master Hand; Max, Dion and Jack; Matthew; Maya; Metal Face; Metal Mario; Meowth; Micaiah; Mike Jones; Mini Kangaroo; Miror B.; Mokka; Mona; Monita; Mother Brain; Mr. Resetti; Mr. Sandman; Mr. Stevenson; N; Nabbit; New Mii class; New Pokémon Trainer; Nightmare; Nikki; Ninten; Nintendog; Nintendoji; Non-Specific Action Figure; Octoling; Parabo & Satebo; Paula; Pauline; Peppy Hare; Phosphora; Pichu; Pico; Pious Augustus; Plasm Wraith; Plum; Plusle & Minun; Pokémon Trainer; Pokkle; Poo; Prince Fluff; Prince of Sablé; Professor E. Gadd; Professor Hector; Raymond Brice; Reckless Safety Man; Reyn; Rhythm Girl; Rhythm Monkey; Rhythm Wrestler; Rundas; Rusty Slugger; Ryuta Ippongi; Samurai Goroh; Sandbag; Savvy Stylist; Sceptile; Scizor; Sigurd; Slippy Toad; Solo Ice Climber; Stanley the Bugman; Star Man; Starfy; Sukapon; Sylux; Toad; Tempo; Tharja; Tiki; Toon Ganondorf; Toon Sheik; Toon Zelda; Urban Champion; Vaati; Vince; Viridi; Waluigi; Wario Land Wario; Wart; Wave Racer; Weavile; Welt; Wild Gunman; Young Link; Zant; Zael; Zip; Zoroark

2 (iffy or meh): Andy; Ashley; Blastoise; Captain Syrup; Cranky Kong; Dark Matter; Dillon; Dr. Lobe; Elma; Excitebiker; Fawful; Ghirahim; Fiora; Hades; Ice Climbers; Impa; Inkling; Isa Jo; Isabelle; King Boo; K.K. Slider; Krystal; Lip; Magolor; Mallo; Marshal; Medusa; Melia; Muddy Mole; Ray MK; Riki; Sami; Sheriff; Skull Kid; Tabuu; Tamagon; Tetra; Tingle; Tom Nook

3 (indifferent or not sure): Bandanna Dee; Captain Toad; Classic Ganon; Dark Samus; Donkey Kong Jr.; Ivysaur; Midna; Paper Mario; Porky; Saki; Squirtle; Takamaru

4 (interesting): Chibi-Robo; Isaac; Ridley; Wonder Red

5 (yes please): Dixie Kong; King K. Rool; Wolf
1 (no): all of them (including non video game characters) with the following exceptions

2 (iffy or meh): Bomberman; Dr. Eggman; Professor Layton; Rayman; Snake; Tails

3 (indifferent or unsure): Banjo & Kazooie

4 (interesting): nothing

5 (yes please): Tetris character (because Tetris is technically third-party you know)
I'm very picky overall, as I'm sure I voted 1 about 80% of the time, a ratio which would become even higher with third-parties :p
Note that this is only for Smash 4 DLC. If we were talking about Smash 5, some of these votes would be different.
 
Last edited:

Logo12

Smash Lord
Joined
May 14, 2015
Messages
1,377
Location
Somewhere without a Smash community. Send hlep
I'm very picky overall, as I'm sure I voted 1 about 80% of the time, a ratio which would become even higher with third-parties :p
Note that this is only for Smash 4 DLC. If we were talking about Smash 5, some of these votes would be different.
Well, I'm sure I've voted 1 more than you ;). I have only voted 2 ~8 times, 3 3 times, 4 3 times, 5 once.
---
Updated result, now with unrepped newcomers:
 

Drason

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Mar 23, 2015
Messages
266
Location
West Newbury, Massachusetts
NNID
Coke
My system goes:
  1. Ones I hate/Simply don't want
  2. Ones I wouldn't mind
  3. Ones I don't have problem with at all
  4. Ones I would be happy with
  5. Wolf
---
Just a quick table of all veterans, and 1st party repped newcomers, "deconfirmed" characters that has a >20% 5 votes:

CV: Cut Veteran
DR: Defined Role
NN: Nintendo Newcomer
WHAT!? Young Link is the least voted, what blasphemy is this?
 

jamesster445

Smash Lord
Joined
May 7, 2015
Messages
1,174
Part 3
Represented Franchises
Waluigi-5
Dark Samus-3
Toad-2
Jeff-2
Gerdevoir-3
Phosphora-1
Metal Face-1
Kat & Ana-2
Riki-2
Viridi-3
Ghirahim-4
Shadow-1
Andross-2
Lyndis-2
Nabbit-1
Zoroark-3
Mother Brain-1
Isabelle-2
Kamek-3
Nightmare-1
Samurai Goroh-2
Devil-1
Ridley-5
Meowth-1
Eevee-1
Tom Nook-2
Skull Kid-3
Ashley-3
Knuckle Joe-1
Midna-4
Genesect-3
Tingle-5
Chrom-1
Magnus-1
Dunban-1

Other Nintendo series
Dr, Kwashima-1
Wild Gunman-1
Nintendog-1
Takamaru-3
Starfy-2
Dr. Wright-1
Dillon-4
Saki-5
Sheriff-1
Prince of Sable-3

Veterans
Squirtle-1
Young Link-1
Pokemon Trainer-5
Ivysaur-4
Solo Popo-1
Pichu-1
Ice Climbers-5
Wolf-5
 
Last edited:

bksbestbwoy

Smash Lord
Joined
Oct 11, 2007
Messages
1,465
Location
Brooklyn, NY
NNID
AzureJay89
3DS FC
4828-5479-7054
Switch FC
2162-7423-7143
This ballot has already provided me with some amazing information regarding what's actually in nowadays.
 

Troykv

Smash Master
Joined
Jan 24, 2015
Messages
3,990
1.- I hate it
2.- Meh/looks boring
3.- Indifferent but could be interesting
4.- I like it
5.- I LOVE IT! I FREAKING WANT IT PLEASE (This one is Micaiah's vote and some few more with luck).

I'm indifferent or meh with almost any character here.

Exceptions: The characters that I voted before with Yes or No.
 
Last edited:

jamesster445

Smash Lord
Joined
May 7, 2015
Messages
1,174
EDIT: I made this post my grand total of votes. If you have any questions about my roster choices feel free to ask here or in a PM.

Part 1

Mario
Baby Mario-1
E.Gadd-2
Plum-1
King Boo-1
Daisy-4
Baby bros-1
Birdo-2
Fawful-3
Captain Toad-3
Dimentio-1
Wart-1
Metal Mario-1
Paper Mario-3

Donkey Kong
Jumpman-1
Dixie+Kiddie-4
K.Rool-5
Dixie Kong-4
DKJR-1
Diddy+Dixie-1
Cranky Kong-1
Pauline-1
Lanky Kong-3
Stanley-1

Wario
Wario land Wario-1
Captain Syrup-2
Jimmy T-3
Mona-3
9-Volt-2

Zelda
Toon Ganondorf-1
Ganon-1
Tetra-3
Lana-1
Impa-4
Zant-1
Groose-3
Vaati-4
Toon Zelda-2
Toon Sheik-1

Pokemon
Plusle & Minun-2
New Pokemon Trainer-1
Weaville-3
Blastoise-2
Hawlucha-2
Gallade-3
Absol-2
Scizor-1
N-4
Delphox-1
Sceptile-4
Gengar-3
Mirror. B-4 (If only because of that fro)
Grovyle-3
Blaziken-1

Metroid
Adam-4
Kraid-1
Sylux-4
Anthony Higgs-5
Rundas-4

Kid Icarus
Hades-5
Medusa-4
Eggplant Wizard-1

Fire Emblem
Tharja-3
Ephraim-3
Leif-1
Hector-2
Eliwood-1
Anna-5
Tiki-3
Sigurd-1
Azura-4
Corrin-2
Micaiah-4

Star Fox
Slippy-1
Peppy-1
Leon-2
Krystal-5

Punch Out
Mr. Sandman-2
King Hippo-3
Glass Joe-1
Bald Bull-2
No Mike Tyson?

Kirby
Marx-3
Daroach-3
Bandana Dee-2
Gooey-1
Magolor-3
Dark Matter-2
Galacta Knight-1
Adeleine-3
Lolo & Lala-1
Prince Fluff-5

F-Zero
Jody Summer-3
Blood Falcon-1
Pico-3
Black Shadow-5

Animal Crossing
Mr. Resetti-1
Crazy Redd-1
KK Slider-1

Mother
Giegue-4
Poo-2
Ninten-2
Porky-5
Masked Man-2
Paula-4
Kumatora-2

Pikmin
Charlie-4
Plasm Wraith-2
Louie-4
Brittany-4

Xenoblade
Melia-3
Elma-5
Cross-4
Fiora-4
Reyn-4

Part 2

Retro
Hakkun-3
Mach Rider-2
Balloon Fighter-2
Muddy Mole-2
Max, Dion, and Jack-1
Mini Kangaroo-1
Tamagon-1
Parabo & Satebo-1
Goku-3
Lip-2
EVR Racer-1
Sukapon-1
F-Type-1
Fighter Hayabusa-1
Bubbles-2
Hiro-1
Alice-2
Harry-2
Hanafuda-1
Mike Jones-2
Urban Champion-3
Excite Biker-1
Star Man-3
Diskun-1
Ayumi Tachibana-2
Mr. Stevenson-1
Prof. Hector-1
Donbe & Hikari-2

Rhythm Heaven
Monkey-3
Chorus Kids-3
Girl-3
Karate Joe-3
Marshal-3
DJ Yellow-3
Wrestler-3

Modern
Agent J-5
Demille-1
Lark-1
Isaac-5
Reckless Safety Man-1
Ray MK-5
Pokkle-1
John Raimi-3
Chibi Robo-5
Jill-2
Andy-5
Sami-4
Ashley Robbins-2
Dr, Lobe-1
Ryuta-2
Kalas-2
Wave Racer-1
1080 Snowboarder-1
Doshin the Giant-2
Kururin-1
Alexandra Roivas-1
Mokka-2
Felix-2
Barbara-2
Pious Augustus-4

Newer
Isa Jo-5
Aeron-3
Raymond Bryce-1
Savvy Stylist-1
Welt-2
Rusty Slugger-3
Freya-2
Captain Rainbow-4
Squid Sisters-3
Tempo-2
Vince-3
Mallo-4
Monita-4
Inkling-5
Nikki-1
Wonder Red-5
Fossil Fighter-3
Action Figure-1
Maya-3
Nintendoji-2
Matthew-2
Zael-4
Aisya-3
Octoling-3
Zip-2
Heracles-2
Eddy-2
Henry Fleming-5

Smash bros. Orginial
Tetris-1
Tabuu-4
New Mii class-4
Sandbag-1
Master Hand-1

Part 3
Represented Franchises
Waluigi-5
Dark Samus-3
Toad-2
Jeff-2
Gerdevoir-3
Phosphora-1
Metal Face-1
Kat & Ana-2
Riki-2
Viridi-3
Ghirahim-4
Shadow-1
Andross-2
Lyndis-2
Nabbit-1
Zoroark-3
Mother Brain-1
Isabelle-2
Kamek-3
Nightmare-1
Samurai Goroh-2
Devil-1
Ridley-5
Meowth-1
Eevee-1
Tom Nook-2
Skull Kid-3
Ashley-3
Knuckle Joe-1
Midna-4
Genesect-3
Tingle-5
Chrom-1
Magnus-1
Dunban-1

Other Nintendo series
Dr, Kwashima-1
Wild Gunman-1
Nintendog-1
Takamaru-3
Starfy-2
Dr. Wright-1
Dillon-4
Saki-5
Sheriff-1
Prince of Sable-3

Veterans
Squirtle-1
Young Link-1
Pokemon Trainer-5
Ivysaur-4
Solo Popo-1
Pichu-1
Ice Climbers-5
Wolf-5

Part 4
Sega
Adam Hunter-3
Ai Ai-3
Akira-3
Alex Kidd-2
Amy Rose-1
Arle Nadja-3
Azel-3
Bayonetta-4
B.D Joe-2
Beat-2
Billy Hatcher-2
Blaze-1
Chuih-2
Cream-1
Dr. Eggman-1
Derek Stiles-3
Frederica Irving-3
Gillius-4
Itsuki Aoi-1
Jack Frost-4
Joe Musashi--2
Knuckles-1
Max-2
Nights-4
Opa Opa-2
Pulseman-2
Ristar-2
Ryo Hazuki-1
Samba-3
Segata Sanshiro-5
Stocks-3
Tails-1
Tsubasa Oribe-1
Ulala-3
Vectorman-2
Vyse-2
Welkin-3

Namco Bandai
Agumon-5
Bravoman-3
Cress-1
Dig Dug-2
Gilgamesh-1
Haruka Amami-1
Heihachi-4
Klonoa-2
Kos-Mos-3
Lloyd Irving-1
Mametchi-2
Nightmare-3
Sophitia=4
Valkyrie-3
Wonder Momo-3
Yoshimitsu-4

Capcom
Everyone-1

Square Enix
Agnes Oblige-4
Bartz-2
Black Mage-5
Cecil-2
Chocobo-3
Clavat-2
Cloud Strife-1
Crono-4
Geno-4
Hero-3
Lara Croft-1
Lightning-1
Mallow-4
Montblanc-3
Neku-4
Randi-3
Riku-1
Roddick-2
Roxas-1
Slime-3
Sora-4
Terra-4

Konami
Bill Raizer-2
Bonk-1
Frogger-4
Goemon-3
Raiden-4
Simon Belmont-4
Snake-5
Sparkster-2
TwinBee-2
Vic Viper-3
Bomberman-4

Level-5
Ban Yamano-3
Endou Mamoru-2
Jibanyan-2
Prof. Layton-5
No Dark Cloud love?

Rare
Banjo & Kazooie-3
Conker-1
Gruntilda-1
Jago-1
Joanna Dark-1
Juno-1
Kuros-1
Mumbo-1
Rash-1

Indie
Beck-1
Commander Video-1
Gunvolt-3
Patricia Wagon-2
Rusty-2
Shantae-5
Shovel Knight-3
Toki Tori-2
Quote-3
Yooka Laylee-1

Other
Bub-3
Bubsy-1
Cooking Mama-4
Crash Bandicoot-1
Giana-1
Marina Lightyears-3
Maxwell-3
Miku Hinasaki-3
Non-Video game character-3 (This can honestly go either way. 1 for Shrek, 3 for Captain N, 5 for Wreck it Ralph)
Rayman-2
Rygar-2
Ryu Hayabusa-5
Scorpion-3
Spyro-1
Thomas-5
Travis Touchdown-1
 
Last edited:

BluePikmin11

Akko is my dear daughter!
Joined
Jan 5, 2013
Messages
28,373
Location
https://twitter.com/BPikmin11
NNID
blue
Thanks to you guys, we were able to reach 400-500 votes in each parts of the poll! Keep spreading the word about the poll! We intend it to be the biggest poll around!
 

Troykv

Smash Master
Joined
Jan 24, 2015
Messages
3,990
1.- Kamui/Corrin, Jumpman, non-specific figure action, RGM, Pauline, Young Link, Toon Sheik (other characters that I don't remember)

2.- The Metroid Characters, the Animal Crossing Characters, Eliwood, Hector

3.- Pretty much everything else

4.- Bandana Dee, King K. Rool, Wolf, Ice Climbers, Cranky Kong, Haruka Amami, Kos-mos, Galacta Knight, Magolor, other Kirby characters

5.- Micaiah and Adeleine
 
Last edited:

BluePikmin11

Akko is my dear daughter!
Joined
Jan 5, 2013
Messages
28,373
Location
https://twitter.com/BPikmin11
NNID
blue
I do want to note though.
Around 50 of the votes in the 3rd party section did get deleted when we start the poll, the original votes are are still in the spread sheet though. So that isn't fully accurate as of yet.
 
Last edited:

Strider_Bond00J

Smash Champion
Joined
Jul 23, 2014
Messages
2,866
Location
la-lio~n~
Switch FC
SW-2525-8699-9095
Some of my responses have slight justification. Starting with Poll 1 These are all my opinions, so please take them lightly. :
(Individual Character Votes)
Super Mario Bros:
Captain Toad - 3 (Neutral. Not invested in considering Toad for Smash Bros)
Metal Mario - 3 (Neutral, but love Metal Mario in Mario games like MK8)
Wart - 1 (NO!)
Baby Mario - 1 (NO!)
Dimentio - 3 (Neutral)
Daisy - 3 (Neutral)
Professor E. Gadd 3 (Neutral - But could be interesting)
Plum - 2 (Miss her, but best revive her within the Mario series)
Birdo - 1 (No)
King Boo - 3 (Neutral)
Baby Bros - 1 (No)
Fawful - 3 (Neutral)

Donkey Kong:
Lanky Kong - 2 (No Style, No Grace, a funny Face)
King K. Rool - 5 (WHY NOT!)
Dixie + Kiddy - 1 (No)
DK.Jr - 1 (No)
Stanley - 1 (No)
Cranky Kong - 3 (Neutral. K.Rool First)
Pauline - 1 (No)
Dixie Kong - 2 (K.Rool First)
Jumpman 0 Nope
Dixie+Diddy - 1

WarioWare/Wario Land
Mona - 3 (Mona Pizza’s got nothin’ on us!)
Jimmy T - 4 (Dad’s favourite WarioWare character)
Wario Land Wario - 2 (I’m happy with the Wario I’ve got)
9-Volt - 2
Captain Syrup - 2

Legend of Zelda:
Lana - 2 (Like her in HW, though)
Vaati - 2 (Neutral)
Impa - 3 (Neutral, could be interesting)
Toon Zelda - 3
Zant - 1
Classic Ganon - 1
Toon Ganondorf - 1
Tetra, Groose, Toon Sheik - 3
Pokémon:
Hawlucha 3
Blaziken 3
Mirror B. 1
Left all other PKMN characters at 3.

Metroid:
Sylux - 5
All others - 1

Kid Icarus:
Eggplant Wizard - 1
Medusa - 2
Hades -3

Fire Emblem
Ephraim, Leif, Hector, Sigurd, Micaiah - 1
Tharja, Eliwood Tiki, Azura/Aqua - 2
Anna, Corrin/Kamui - 3

Star Fox
Slippy, Peppy, Leon - 2
Krystal 5

Punch-Out!!
1 to all.

Kirby
Daroach - 4
Marx/Flandre Scarlet - 4 (Seriously, they’ve both got some degree of insanity, rainbow crystal wings and extra/final boss status!)
Magolor -2
Gooey -2
Bandanna Dee - 5
Galacta Knight, Adeleine, Prince Fluff - 3
Lololo and Lalala, Dark Matter - 2

F-Zero
Blood Falcon - 1
Pico - 2
Jody Summers - 2
Black Shadow - 4

Animal Crossing
Crazy Redd - 1
K.K Slider - 2
Mr. Resetti - 3

EarthBound/Mother
Masked Man/Claus - 3
Ninten - 2
Kumatora - 2
Giegue/Giygas -3
Paula - 2
Porky Minch - 4
Poo - 3

Pikmin:
Louie - 4
Charlie - 3
Plasm Wraith - 1
Brittany - 3 Cute fan art of her, by the way :3
Xenoblade Chronicles:
Cross and Elma: 2
Reyn: 3 (Shoulda been assist)
Fiora 3
Melia : 2
 

Troykv

Smash Master
Joined
Jan 24, 2015
Messages
3,990
Fire Emblem
Ephraim, Leif, Hector, Sigurd, Micaiah - 1
Tharja, Eliwood Tiki, Azura/Aqua - 2
Anna, Corrin/Kamui - 3
Do you have something against the characters that you put it a "1" or which is exactly your reasons to prefer the other characters?

Anyway, looks like you don't like to much the idea to see a new Fire Emblem Characther... because but Eliwood, everyone else with 2 or 3 has recency in his/her side.
 

Strider_Bond00J

Smash Champion
Joined
Jul 23, 2014
Messages
2,866
Location
la-lio~n~
Switch FC
SW-2525-8699-9095
Do you have something against the characters that you put it a "1" or which is exactly your reasons to prefer the other characters?

Anyway, looks like you don't like to much the idea to see a new Fire Emblem Characther... because but Eliwood, everyone else with 2 or 3 has recency in his/her side.
I think probably I'm in the boat that after Roy, that's all I need from Fire Emblem for now. For a bit of clarification, I'm not attached to the characters I gave a 1 to outside of Ephraim since I haven't played their games (although I have FE7, but I've yet to fully devote time to it) As for Corrin/Kamui, I'm willing to entertain the idea, but I think overall I'm satisfied with Fire Emblem for now. Time for other series to shine, as they say.
 

FunAtParties

PM me ur character ideas girl
Joined
May 21, 2015
Messages
3,880
Location
Illinois
NNID
ZestyÑ
Switch FC
SW-8404-4905-2993
Posted this on the IC's boards, but feel it's more appropriate here. These characters that gathered more than 50% on 4 or 5 (positive) votes. Only ten so far, but a few are close. Some shocks, but I'm pretty happy with it.

Wolf- 74.2%
Inkling- 69.2%
Isaac- 68.7%
Ice Climbers- 66.1%
King K.Rool- 65.9%
Snake- 64%
Bomberman- 58.7%
Dixie Kong- 54.8%
Banjo and Kazooie- 54.4%
Chibi Robo- 53.7%

This is most likely outdated, (small changes happen constantly) so don't take it as final or anything. Shovel Knight is the closest to joining with 49.7% as of posting this.

Thoughts?
 

Strider_Bond00J

Smash Champion
Joined
Jul 23, 2014
Messages
2,866
Location
la-lio~n~
Switch FC
SW-2525-8699-9095
Part 2
Non-Represented Series:
Retro Characters:
Hiro (Card Hero) - 1 (No)
EVR Racer - 1 (No idea)
Mike Jones - 3 (Neutral)
Diskun - 2 (Unfamiliar)
Ayumi Tachibana - 2 (Know of her, but no real interest in seeing her become playable.)
Donbe and Hikari (Shin Onigashima) - 2 (Unfamiliar)
Professor Hector - 2 (R.O.B’s fine on his own for now, but could be interesting if Gyromite gets revived)
Mach Rider - 3 (Interesting)
Max, Dion, Jack - 1 (What the heck?)
Tamagon - 1 (No)
Mr. Stevenson (Gumshoe) - 1 (Obscure)
Sukapon - 1 (Not interested)
Parabo and Satebo - 1 (Nope.avi)
Harry (Teleroboxer) - 1 (No clue)
Hakkun - (No clue) 1
Fighter Hayabusa - 1 (No)
Excitebiker - 4 (Could be an interesting retro choice)
Bubbles (Clu Clu Land) - 1 (No)
Balloon Fighter - 3 (For Iwata, but not this generation of Smash Bros)
Star Man (Pro Wrestling) - 1 (No clue)
F-Type - 1 (No)
Goku (From Yuyuki) - 1 (No)
Urban Champion - 2 (Interesting, but probably no hope)
Muddy Mole - 2 (Unfamilar)
Mini Kangaroo - 1 (No)
Lip (Panel de Pon) - 2 (Somewhat obscure)
Hanafuda - 1 (No)
Alice (Balloon Kid) - 1 (No)

Rhythm Heaven
Chorus Kids/Men - 4 (Interesting. Maybe next time)
DJ Yellow - 2 (Not the best choice)
Marshal - 3 (Neutral)
Rhythm Wrestler - 5 (Pose for fans!)
Karate Joe - 4 (1 2!)
Rhythm Girl -3 (Neutral)
Rhythm Monkey - 2 (Not the best choice)

Modern Nintendo Franchises:
Alexandra Roivas (Eternal Darkness) -1
Kalas (Baten Kaitos) - 2
Wave Racer -1
Ryuta Ippongi (Ouedan!) -1
Chibi-Robo 3 (Future Smash games, yes)
Andy (Advanced Wars) - 3 (Prefer Sami)
1080 Snowboarder - 1 (No hope)
Dr.Lobe - 3
Pious Augustus - 1 (No hope)
Doshin the Giant - 1 (Not interested)
Sami (Advance Wars) - 5 (My preferred AW character)
Felix (Golden Sun) - 2 (Isaac first)
Isaac (Golden Sun) - 5 (Let out a Howl)
Mokka (Magical Starsign) - 1- Unfamiliar
Pokkle - (GiftPiA) 1 (who?)
John Raimi (Geist) - 2 (An interesting concept)
Agent J (Elite Beat Agents) - 3 (Neutral. Pretty whacky game, so I hear)
Jill (Drill Dozer) - 1 (Not interested)
Ray MK (Custom Robo) - 4 (Needs a new game, but he’s a cut Assist Trophy)
Reckless Safety Guy - 1(Nope.avi)
Lark (Pilotwings) - 2 (Unfamiliar)
Kururin (Kuru kuru kururin) -1
Demille (Tomato Adventure) -1 (Unfamiilar)
Barbara the Bat (Jam with the Band) - 2
Dr. Lobe - 3
Ashley Robbins - 2
Newer Nintendo Franchises
Inklings - 5 (YES!)
Octoling - 3 (Inklings first, but where are my playable Octolings in Splatoon!? :(
Callie and Marie - 1 (Squid Waifus should not fight!)
Henry Fleming (Codename S.T.E.A.M) - 4
Nintendoji - 2
Non-Specific Action Figure - 1
Aeron (Pandora’s Tower) - 2
Nikki - 3 (I can make a Mii of her. No, she is a Mii)
Maya (Spirit Camera) - 1
Rusty Slugger - 1
Raymond Bryce - 1
Eddy (Fluidity) - 1 (Who)
Zael (Last Story) - 2
Freya - 1 (No clue)
Wonder Red - 5 (Why did you become Blunder Red in the sales!? :(
Savvy Stylist -1
Captain Rainbow - 2
Zip (FlingSmash) -1
Matthew (Golden Sun) - 2 (Isaac first)
Tempo (HarmoKnight) - 3
Vince (Art Academy) -3
Heracles -1
Aisya - 1
Monita - 3
Mallo - 2
Isa Jo (Sin and Punishment 2) - 3 (Saki first)
Fossil Fighter - 1 (Assist Trophy, for sure)
Welt (Soma Bringer) -1 Who?

Smash Bros Original:
Master Hand: 5 (OF COURSE I WANT MASTER HAND IN SMASH!)
Tabuu 4 (Interesting)
Tetris Character -1
Sandbag -1
New Mii Class - 3
 
Last edited:

FunAtParties

PM me ur character ideas girl
Joined
May 21, 2015
Messages
3,880
Location
Illinois
NNID
ZestyÑ
Switch FC
SW-8404-4905-2993
Some additional characters I would've liked to see.

Judd (Splatoon)
Cap'n Cuddlefish (Splatoon)
General Scales (Star Fox)
Camilla (Fire Emblem)
Weavel (Metroid)
 
Last edited:

Babycowland

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Oct 27, 2014
Messages
305
Location
Minnesota
I think this is an interesting poll idea. It's very comprehensive and requiring people to log in will hopefully mean that everyone's response has an equal weight since people are less likely to vote multiple times. Well, I guess you can vote with multiple email addresses, but it's still better than a poll that can be easily manipulated.

Honestly, I think I ended up being relatively generous in my responses. Unless I had a strong negative opinion about a character being in Smash, I usually gave at least a 3 and I ended up giving 30 4s in the poll. I don't think anybody would really like to see me list all of that out, so I'll just mention the characters I gave 5s to below.

Playable Represented Franchises
  • Daisy: she's appeared in something like 40 games, originated in a Mario platformer, and could have sporty moves to distinguish herself from Peach. She may be an underdog, but that's part of the reason why I support her.
  • King K. Rool: a popular character from an unrepresented series with a long suffering fanbase. Please put him in.
  • Dixie Kong: one of the most, if not the most, prolific female Nintendo character that's not in Smash yet. Her hair offers a lot of moveset potential and it'd be cool to be able to rock out on her guitar or call in a bunch of animal buddies for her final smash.
  • Tetra: after that Hyrule Warriors Legends trailer she shot up my Smash fighter wishlist. Would be a neat addition to the roster, partly because she's probably my favorite version of Zelda and partly because her making it to Smash could mean the return of the Pirate Ship stage.
  • Micaiah: I feel like she'd be pretty unique as far as Fire Emblem characters go and I think her fans (many of whom seem to have supported here since before Brawl) deserve it.
  • Krystal: would be the Starfox newcomer most likely to have a totally unique moveset and I'd be interested to see what Sakurai and co. would do with her.
  • Adeleine: mostly because of her depiction in Brawl in the Family.
  • Bandana Dee: I see him as the clear 4th character for the Kirby series (feel free to disagree if you'd like) and I have to appreciate a character you goes from generic mook to recurring character with importance in a series.
  • Paula: Ness already has a lot of her moves. I think she could work as an alt too.
  • Louie: Though I'm not a huge fan of how he's portrayed in Pikmin 3, he's the original second Pikmin protagonist, and I find I gravitate to Player 2 type characters.

Other Nintendo Series
  • Isaac: while I haven't played any Golden Sun games, I was a bit disappointed he didn't at least come back as an AT. I've gotten the impression that he has some pretty good moveset potential given all of the different psynergy abilities, summons, etc. in those games.
  • Savvy Stylist: I'd be curious to see what her moveset would look like. I'd also be more than happy to get more Style Savvy music in Smash.

Deconfirmed Characters and Veterans

  • Ashley: probably one of the most popular WarioWare characters. I like her theme song.
  • Gardevoir: maybe not super likely, but it's one of my favorite Pokemon, mainly because of how it protects its trainer and how it looks like a mage (I know that's a silly reason to want somebody in Smash, haha).
  • Ice Climbers: they we're one of my favorite characters in Melee and Brawl. I'm a fan of their pair gimmick even if it's probably going to keep them out of Smash 4.

Third Parties
  • Arle Nadja: I've spent a lot of time playing Dr. Robotnik's Mean Bean Machine and finally got Puyo Pop Fever a few months ago. I think the series is fun and has the potential to inspire some original moves inspired by the puzzle games' mechanics (a fever mode final smash where you have to move puyos around to land combos for example).
  • Tails: Tails is probably my most wanted character on this list. He and Sonic are an iconic duo and I honestly think it feels a little weird for Sonic to be all by his lonesome. His gadgets and the Tornado could be used to distinguish him from Sonic, though in my mind they'd also share some moves.
  • Agnes Oblige: I think it'd be cool to see Sakurai and co. incorporate the Brave/Default system into her moveset. Given how many jobs there are in the Bravely Default series, I feel like there's a ton of potential there.
  • Banjo & Kazooie: Banjo Kazooie is one of my favorite games. I support them even if they aren't that likely to make it in...

Looking over the characters I gave 5s to, I guess there are some pretty clear patterns. I tend to want more female fighters in Smash. I'm also partial to underdog characters like Tails.
 
Last edited:

Blue_Sword_Edge

Smash Lord
Joined
May 18, 2015
Messages
1,166
NNID
Blue_Sword_Edge
3DS FC
1633-5415-5386
Here's my Third Party characters poll results

5 - Absolutely a.k.a I love the idea as Smash fighter.
4 - I like, but not too strongly.
3 - Indifferent, unknown
2 - Don't like, but I'll give a chance if enters in.
1 - Absolutely don't like a.k.a Please, no.

Shin Megami Tensei X Fire Emblem originated characters are Sega owned? I thought they were jointly held with Nintendo.

Amy Rose: 1
Blaze the Cat: 3
Cream the Rabbit: 1
Dr: Eggman: 5
Knuckles: 4
Tails: 4
Adam Hunter: 2
Ai Ai: 2
Alex Kidd: 3
Arle Nadja: 3
Azel: 2
Bayonetta: 1
B.D Joe: 2
Beat: 2
Billy Hatcher: 2
Chuih: 2
Derek Stiles: 2
Federick Irving: 2
Gilius: 3
Itsuki Aoi: 3
Jack Frost: 3
Joe Mushashi: 3
Max(Shining Force): 3
NiGHTS: 2
Opa Opa: 2
Pulseman: 3
Ristar: 3
Ryo Hazuki: 2
Samba: 2
Segata Sanshiro: 1
Stocke: 2
Tsubasa Oribe: 3
Ulala: 1
Vectorman: 4
Vyse: 3?
Welkin: 2

Agumon: 2
Bravoman: 3
Cress(Tales): 2
Dig Dug: 3
Gilgamesh: 2
Haruka: 1
Heihachi Mishima: 4
Klonoa: 2
KOS-MOS: 3
Lloyd Irving: 4
Mametchi: 2
Nightmare(Soul Calibur): 3
Sophitia(Soul Calibur): 3
Valkyrie: 2
Wonder Momo: 2
Yoshimitsu(Soul Calibur/Tekken): 4

Ameratsu: 3
Bass (Mega Man): 3
Captain Commando: 2
Chun Li: 3
Dante(Devil May Cry): 2
Dr. Wily: 3
Felyne: 1
Jill Valentine: 3
Ken(Street Fighter): 2
Leon Kennedy: 3
M. Bison a.k.a Dictator: 4
Mike Haggar(Final Fight): 2
A Monster Hunter: 2
Morrigan: 1
Phoenix Wright: 4
Proto Man(Mega Man): 3
Roll(Mega Man): 2
Sigma(Mega Man X): 3
Sir Arthur: 3
Strider Hiryu: 3
Tron Bonne: 2
Viewtiful Joe: 4

Agnes Oblige: 3
Bartz(Final Fantasy): 5
Black Mage: 4
Cecil(Final Fantasy): 3
Chocobo: 1
Clevat: 3
Cloud Strife: 2
Crono: 4
Geno: 4
Hero(Dragon Quest): 3
Lara Croft: 2
Lightning: 1
Mallow: 4
Montblanc: 3
Neku Sakaraba: 3
Randi: 3
Riku: 2
Reddick(Star Ocean): 3
Roxas: 2
Slime(Dragon Quest): 3
Sora: 2
Terra (Final Fantasy): 4

Bill(Contra): 3
Bonk: 3
Frogger: 3
Goemon: 3
Raiden(Metal Gear): 3
Simon Belmont: 5
(Solid)Snake: 5
Sparkster: 3
TwinBee: 2
Vic Viper(Gradius): 2
Bomberman: 4

Level 5 had all 3's

Rare:
Banjo & Kazooie, Gruntilda, and Mumbo all had 3's
Conker: 2
The Rest: 1

Indies:
Shantae & Shovel Knight: 3
The rest: 2

Bub(Bubble Bobble): 3
Bubsy: 1
Cooking Mama: 1
Crash Bandicoot: 2
Gianna Sisters: 3
Marina Lightyears: 3
Maxwell(Scribblenauts?): 3
Miku Hinasaki: 2
Rayman: 3
Rygar: 1
Ryu Hayabusa: 3
Scorpion (Mortal Kombat): 1
Spyro the Dragon: 2
Travis Touchdown: 2
Thomas(Kung Fu): 3
Non-Video Game Character: 1
 

Strider_Bond00J

Smash Champion
Joined
Jul 23, 2014
Messages
2,866
Location
la-lio~n~
Switch FC
SW-2525-8699-9095
Now for Parts 3 and 4!
Part 3: Vets and 'Deconfirmed'
“Deconfirmed & Veterans”
Represented Assist Trophies and Stage roles
Waluigi - 5
Ashley (WarioWare) 4
Isabelle - 3
Ghirahim 5
Devil (Devil World) 1
Gardevoir 3
Jeff (Mother/EarthBound) 2
Tom Nook 2
Ridley 5
Kamek 1
Skull Kid 1
Meowth 3
Shadow the Hedgehog 4
Kat and Ana (WarioWare)
Dark Samus 2
Nightmare (Kirby) 3
Mother Brain 1
Tingle 3
Nabbit 2
Toad 3
Lyn 2
Viridi 3
Samurai Goroh 4
Metal Face 1
Riki 1
Dunban 2
Phosphora 3
Chrom 1
Magnus 2
Midna 2
Zoroark 2
Knuckle Joe 3
Eevee 2
Other Assist Trophies:
Takamaru - 5
Saki -5
Nintendog 1 Don’t hurt the adorable puppy! >:(
Wild Gunmen - 2
Dillon - 3
Dr. Kawashima 2
Prince Sablé 2
Sheriff 2
Dr. Wright 2
Starfy 2

Veterans
Solo Ice Climber 1
Young Link 3
Ivysaur, Squirtle, Pokémon Trainer 1
Ice Climbers 5
Wolf 5
Pichu 4

Now for the third parties... To be honest, I knew quite a number of Capcom and Sega characters.
SEGA
Adam Hunter - 1
Ai Ai (Super Monkey Ball) 3
Akira (Virtua Fighter) 2
Alex Kidd - 1
Amy Rose 2
Arle Nadja 2
Azel (Panzer Dragon) 1
Bayonetta 4
B.D Joe (Crazy Taxi) 1
Beat (Jet Set Radio) 3
Billy Hatcher 2
Blaze the Cat 2
Chuih (Chuchu Rocket ) 1
Cream the Rabbit 1
Derek Stiles (Trauma Center) 1
Dr. Eggman 5
Frederica Irving (Etrian Odyssey) 1
Gillius (Golden Axe) 1
Itsuki Aoi (Shin Megami Tensei X Fire Emblem) 1
Jack Frost (SMT) 2
Joe Musashi (Shinobi) 3
Knuckles the Echidna 3
Max (Shining Force) 1
NiGHTS 3
Opa Opa (Fantasy Zone) 1
Pulseman 1
Ristar 1
Ryo Hazuki (Shenmue) 1
Samba (Samba de Amigo) 3
Segata Sanshiro 2
Stocke (Radiant Historia) 1
Miles ‘Tails’ Prower 4
Tsubasa Oribe (SMT X FE) 1
Ulala (Space Channel 5) 1
Vectorman 1
Vyse (Skies of Arcadia) 2
Welkin (Valkyria Chronicles) 1

Capcom:
Amaterasu (Okami) 3
Bass (Mega Man) 2
Captain Commando 3
Chun-Li 3
Dante (Devil May Cry) 3
Dr. Wily 2
Felyne (Monster Hunter) 1
Jill Valentine (Resident Evil) 2
Ken Masters 2
Leon Kennedy 3
M. Bison 3
Mike Haggar 2
Monster Hunter 4
Morrigan Aensland 2
Phoenix Wright 5
Proto Man 3
Roll (Mega Man) 2
Sigma (Mega Man X) 1
Arthur (Ghosts ‘n Goblins) 3
Strider Hiryu 4
Tron Bonne 2
Viewtiful Joe 4
Namco Bandai:
Agumon 1
Bravoman 1
Cress (Tales of Phantasia) 1
Dig Dug 1
Gilgamesh (Tower of Druga) 1
Haruka Amami (Idolm@ster)1
Heihachi Mishima 4
Klonoa 3
Kos-Mos 1
Lloyd Irving 4
Mametchi 1
Nightmare (SoulCalibur) 1
Sophitia (SoulCalibur) 1
Valkyrie 3
Wonder Momo 1
Yoshimitsu 3

Square Enix
Agnès Oblige (Bravely Default) 3
Bartz Klauser 3
Black Mage 4
Cecil Harvey 4
Chocobo 2
Clavat (Final Fantasy Crystal Chronicles) 1
Cloud Strife 5
Crono 1
Geno 3
Hero (Dragon Quest) 2
Lara Croft 1
Lightning 2
Mallow (Super Mario RPG) 1
Montblanc (FFXII/Tactics Advance) 4
Neku Sakuraba 4
Randi (Secret of Mana) 1
Riku (KH) 2
Roddick (Star Ocean) 1
Roxas 2
Slime (Dragon Quest) 1
Sora (KH) 4
Terra Branford 3

Konami
Snake 5
Bomberman 3
Frogger 1
Bill Rizer 1
Bonk! 1
Ganbare Goemon 4
Raiden (Metal Gear) 1
Simon Belmont 4
Sparkster 1
TwinBee 1
Vic Viper 1

Level-5
Ban Yamano (LBX) 3
Endou Mamoru 1
Jibanyan 4
Professor Layton 5

Rare
Banjo and Kazooie 5
Conker 1
Gruntilda 4
Jago (Killer Instinct) 3
Joanna Dark 1
Juno 1
Kuros 1
Mumbo 3
Rash (Battletoads) 4 (If only for the cool KI trailer that convinced me to wait for the PC version)

Indies
Beck (Mighty No. 9) 1
Commander Video 1
Gunvolt (Azure Striker Gunvolt) 1
Patricia Wagon 3
Rusty 2
Shantae 5
Shovel Knight 4
Toki Tori 3
Quote (Cave Story) 2
Yooka Laylee 3

And the other guys...
Marina Lightyears 5
Bub 1
Bubsy 1
Cooking Mama 1
Miku Hanasaki 1
Giana 1
Crash Bandicoot 1
Maxwell (Scribblenauts) 3
Scorpion (Mortal Kombat) 2 (I've got a Mii of him, so I'm satisfied with that)
Non-Video game character 1
Rayman 5 (Should Ubisoft have a section? Guess it's too late for that anyway)
Rygar 1
Ryu Hayabusa 3
Spyro the Dragon 1
Travis Touchdown 1
Thomas (Kung fu) 1
And that was the poll. Very, Very big. 0_0
 

ShinyRegice

Smash Lord
Joined
Jul 27, 2014
Messages
1,631
Location
France
I've noticed that Shadow is in the "deconfirmed" section while Snake is in the "third-party" one. Maybe you should have put Shadow in third-parties or Snake in veterans for consistency reason.
 

Logo12

Smash Lord
Joined
May 14, 2015
Messages
1,377
Location
Somewhere without a Smash community. Send hlep
This is me when I do most of the votes:
*tab* *left* *left* *tab* *left* *left* *tab* *left* *left* *tab* *left* *left* *tab* *left* *left* *tab* *left* *left* ...

So I'm updating again, this time with third parties.
Something to note:
  1. Recorded as of 5:52PM (UTC+8)
  2. Almost everyone suffered a drop, some of the more popular votes even dropped out of 4 in average. Now the only character left above 4 is Wolf (4.15)
  3. Ray MK dropped out of the list as its 5 vote rate is now below 20%. He is instead replaced by Inkling which... either I missed them last time or their votes suddenly raise up to Isaac kind of higher-than-expected rate.
  4. Bomberman somehow has 10 votes less than all other 3rd parties. WHY BLUEPIKMIN PLS FIX
  5. Snake is counted towards veterans, but has lower amount of total vote relatively.
Some (1) QAs
WHAT!? Young Link is the least voted, what blasphemy is this?
Well, that is only because I included all veterans in the beginning, but only other categories with >20% 5 votes later on, but just in case, everything below Bayonetta (Tetra in the last poll) is below the minimum requirement given (notice the 0.4 gap)

So here's da list:
upload_2015-9-11_18-48-38.png

(Sorry for the font change, it's too ridley big to capture the whole thing)
upload_2015-9-11_18-49-45.png

Well that's all for now i guess
 

Troykv

Smash Master
Joined
Jan 24, 2015
Messages
3,990
... I saw you put posts in various threads... If you don't find Micaiah's one you can click the link in my signature xD
 

Troykv

Smash Master
Joined
Jan 24, 2015
Messages
3,990
I think this is an interesting poll idea. It's very comprehensive and requiring people to log in will hopefully mean that everyone's response has an equal weight since people are less likely to vote multiple times. Well, I guess you can vote with multiple email addresses, but it's still better than a poll that can be easily manipulated.

Honestly, I think I ended up being relatively generous in my responses. Unless I had a strong negative opinion about a character being in Smash, I usually gave at least a 3 and I ended up giving 30 4s in the poll. I don't think anybody would really like to see me list all of that out, so I'll just mention the characters I gave 5s to below.

Playable Represented Franchises
  • Daisy: she's appeared in something like 40 games, originated in a Mario platformer, and could have sporty moves to distinguish herself from Peach. She may be an underdog, but that's part of the reason why I support her.
  • King K. Rool: a popular character from an unrepresented series with a long suffering fanbase. Please put him in.
  • Dixie Kong: one of the most, if not the most, prolific female Nintendo character that's not in Smash yet. Her hair offers a lot of moveset potential and it'd be cool to be able to rock out on her guitar or call in a bunch of animal buddies for her final smash.
  • Tetra: after that Hyrule Warriors Legends trailer she shot up my Smash fighter wishlist. Would be a neat addition to the roster, partly because she's probably my favorite version of Zelda and partly because her making it to Smash could mean the return of the Pirate Ship stage.
  • Micaiah: I feel like she'd be pretty unique as far as Fire Emblem characters go and I think her fans (many of whom seem to have supported here since before Brawl) deserve it.
  • Krystal: would be the Starfox newcomer most likely to have a totally unique moveset and I'd be interested to see what Sakurai and co. would do with her.
  • Adeleine: mostly because of her depiction in Brawl in the Family.
  • Bandana Dee: I see him as the clear 4th character for the Kirby series (feel free to disagree if you'd like) and I have to appreciate a character you goes from generic mook to recurring character with importance in a series.
  • Paula: Ness already has a lot of her moves. I think she could work as an alt too.
  • Louie: Though I'm not a huge fan of how he's portrayed in Pikmin 3, he's the original second Pikmin protagonist, and I find I gravitate to Player 2 type characters.

Looking over the characters I gave 5s to, I guess there are some pretty clear patterns. I tend to want more female fighters in Smash. I'm also partial to underdog characters like Tails.
Yay! Micaiah Support! <3

Oh! I never saw you in the Micaiah's Thread (in this moment is a little bit... alone xDUU). If you want to enter, you can use the link in my signature (if doesn't appear, search in my oldest post in this thread's page).

This is me when I do most of the votes:
*tab* *left* *left* *tab* *left* *left* *tab* *left* *left* *tab* *left* *left* *tab* *left* *left* *tab* *left* *left* ...

So I'm updating again, this time with third parties.
Something to note:
  1. Recorded as of 5:52PM (UTC+8)
  2. Almost everyone suffered a drop, some of the more popular votes even dropped out of 4 in average. Now the only character left above 4 is Wolf (4.15)
  3. Ray MK dropped out of the list as its 5 vote rate is now below 20%. He is instead replaced by Inkling which... either I missed them last time or their votes suddenly raise up to Isaac kind of higher-than-expected rate.
  4. Bomberman somehow has 10 votes less than all other 3rd parties. WHY BLUEPIKMIN PLS FIX
  5. Snake is counted towards veterans, but has lower amount of total vote relatively.
Some (1) QAs

Well, that is only because I included all veterans in the beginning, but only other categories with >20% 5 votes later on, but just in case, everything below Bayonetta (Tetra in the last poll) is below the minimum requirement given (notice the 0.4 gap)

So here's da list:
View attachment 72865
(Sorry for the font change, it's too ridley big to capture the whole thing)
View attachment 72866
Well that's all for now i guess

Oh... Ejem, I want to ask about how did you do this? I want to try something similar with other characters.
 
Last edited:

BluePikmin11

Akko is my dear daughter!
Joined
Jan 5, 2013
Messages
28,373
Location
https://twitter.com/BPikmin11
NNID
blue
I've noticed that Shadow is in the "deconfirmed" section while Snake is in the "third-party" one. Maybe you should have put Shadow in third-parties or Snake in veterans for consistency reason.
I did it so that everyone could do all parts. :p
Most people do want Snake to happen, and he is the only one people generally care about me.
 
Top Bottom