I CHALLENGE YOU!!! To... create the worst roster!!! Can you beat mine?

[Leafeon523]

Here's my roster:
1. Pit
-No more complaining about characters being unbalanced
-Character selection time drastically reduced
-No arguing over who gets to be Pit
-No need to worry about characters you don't want getting in
-Would allow for the story to be set in the Kid Icarus universe
-Allows for hundreds of customizable moves
-less $$$ spent on Amiibo
Wait, this is the I Challenge you! ... To create the greatest roster ever thread, right?

 

[VictoryIsMudkipz]

*Cracks Knuckles*
Okay, here we go...

Mario: 8 Characters including: Mario, Goomba, Green shell Koopa, Daisy, Wendy Koopa, Red shell Koopa, E.Gadd, Pianta

LoZ: 4 Characters: Link, Cucco, Ococo, tingle

Pokemon: 10 characters: Pikachu, Magikarp, Feebas, Wobbufett, Diglett, Prof. Oak, MissingNo., Ditto, Zubat, Trubbish

F-Zero: 2 characters: Captain Falcon, Blue Falcon

Fire Emblem: 2 Characters: Marth, Lucina

Mother: 1 character: Lucas (#NoNess *trollface.jpg)

Kid Icarus: 3 Characters: Pit, Pseudo Palutena, Mimicutie

Animal Crossing: 3 characters: Villager, Redd, Kap'n

Pac-Man: 1 character: Pac-Man......Jr.

Yoshi: 2 characters: Yoshi, Boshi

Metroid: 2 characters: Samus, Crocomire (double trollface.jpg no ridley jutsu)

Donkey Kong: 3 characters: DK, Kranky Kong, Snowmads

Kirby: 3 characters: Kirby, Rick, Gooey

Punch Out: 2 characters: Little Mac, Doc

Sonic: 3 characters: Sonic, Chao, Sally

Pikmin: 2 characters: Olimar, Pikmin

Megaman: 2 characters: Megaman, Dr. Light

Starfox: 4 Characters: Fox McCloud, Slippy Toad, Peppy Rabbit, Pigma

Wii Fit: 1 character: Wii Fit Trainer

+ Mii

Total: 56

*wipes sweat* Now beat that..

 

[pupNapoleon]

Create the worst roster ever!!!!!

Rules:
size limit: 100 slots.
Must include the first character of EACH series. e,g, from pokemon its obviously Pikachu.


Can you beat mine?! I made this a while back... (pre e3 so. no pacman there but you can imagine its him instead of one of the Sonic's.)

View attachment 16286
by the way, Navi is top tier =D


FYI...my first thread

YOSHI IS A SMASH-RECOGNIZED SERIES

 

[BlitznBurst]

this was painful to make

 

[Luigi#1]

NEW CHALLENGER APPROACHING!

Richard Nixon [one of the 48 main USA characters tied so eh]

Tingle

Goku

Goku with a top hat

Baby Goku

Baby Goku with a top hat

Goku brony

Top hat Goku brony

Baby top hat/ fedora stack Goku brony

Shrek

One of the baby SHrek things

Adriel from Miiverse

Sponge Bob

Coin # 17 in World 4-2 in Super Mario Bros 3

Bubble Gum wrapper that was stuck on my shoe the other day

Doge meme

That rotten cantalope in the back of the McDonalds near me that a rat stole

Justin Bieber

Plastic tape that I chewed up when I was 3 and I later stuck it on the bottom of a table at Red Robins

Me personally, I would main Coin #17 in World 4-2 in Super Mario Bros 3.

 

[UltimateWario]

Current Confirmed Characters + Brawl Veterans + Sal Newcomers = Worst Roster

Sakurai wins.

 

[APC99]

Goku.

Just Goku, with 4 palette swaps.

 

[Depressed Gengar]

Mario, Pikachu, Link, DK, Yoshi, Pit, Sonic, Pac-Man, Potato, Doge, Dankey Kang, Brawl in the Family Waluigi, Talking Raddish, Pink Gold Peach, MissingNo., Ben Drowned, Cucco, Mega Magikarp, Darkwing Duck, Jeff the Goomba, Hal the Koopa, Steve the Piranha Plant, Sanic Hedgehog, Sonic Boom Knuckles, Yoshi's Island, Mama Luigi, Malleo and Weegee, Mecha Sonic, Nuts and Bolts Banjo, Ghostly Adventures Pac-Man, Palutena.
Did I win?

 

[Marakatu]

You doubt how **** of a roster I can make, OP. I'm gonna make the worst roster you've all ever seen. I'll edit this when it's done. I want to take my time.

Step it up.

I can see this becoming a hate thread. Because you added Ayumi, and now I hate you.

 

[SmasherMaster]

Pink Gold Baby Rosalina
Navi Epona
Baby Metroid
Slippy Toad
Landmaster
Shrek
Goku
Shadow
Steve
Spongebob
Miley Cyrus
Justin Beiber
Ronald McDonald
Slenderman

What do I win?

 

[mini paincakes]

Best Roster I could think of.

I think Shrek, Shaq, Dr. Bowser, Piers Morgan and Ronald Mc.Donald would be the DLC characters.

 

[synesthe-sia]

I decided to give it another shot. A subtle one.

 

[Robertman2]

View attachment 16424
Best Roster I could think of.

I think Shrek, Shaq, Dr. Bowser, Piers Morgan and Ronald Mc.Donald would be the DLC characters.

The Goku one is clever.

 

[Capybara Gaming]

Goku vs. Superman Final Destination No Items.










No that is my worst roster possible. Only 2; Goku and Superman

 

[BlitznBurst]

Don't forget Reggie, Iwata, Abe Lincoln, Elijah Wood and Ice-T

 

[Capybara Gaming]

Don't forget Reggie, Iwata, Abe Lincoln, Elijah Wood and Ice-T

George Washington thinks it is sinful to fight! - George Washington's tagline, 2014-in-your-dreams

 

[synesthe-sia]

 

[Wegenbarth]

this was painful to make

I would preorder Smash4 two times if it has this Roster.

 

[Kenith]

This thread is awesome.
This roster isn't. I had one rule: Three characters from every series.

 

[Robertman2]

This thread is awesome.
This roster isn't. I had one rule: Three characters from every series.

View attachment 16536

Hubba Tester is the new Meta Knight

 

[Kenith]

Hubba Tester is the new Meta Knight

I'll probably main James McCloud, James McCloud, and Gold Mario.

 

[Robertman2]

I'll probably main James McCloud, James McCloud, and Gold Mario.

Hubba, Zubat, and Reyn for me!

 

[Winchester7314]

I think I've got this one in the bag *evil sniker*
All characters were removed to appeal to casual crowd. No competitive play allowed. Only defensive play ;P

 

[Crap-Zapper]

The Best roster ever, am I right? All with unique moveset potential compared to the others ~

 

[Deleted member]

Chrom.

Twice.

 

[Mypantisgone]

"Let's make a bad roster"
Lists Ridley.

There's no such thing. Ridley is love, Ridley is life.

Sir, I think you are confused or misguided.

This is the Bad Roster thread, Heaven is that way.

 

[Kenith]

I find it hilarious that your Square Enix reps are Crono, Slime, Bub, and Lara Croft, but not Geno. XD

 

[synesthe-sia]

This thread is awesome.
This roster isn't. I had one rule: Three characters from every series.

View attachment 16536

Anthony, Karate Joe and Wonder Pink are no joke.

I find it hilarious that your Square Enix reps are Crono, Slime, Bub, and Lara Croft, but not Geno. XD

Bub is the best character Square Enix has. Geno is too big.

 

[Jarelo]

Here's my roster:
1. Pit
-No more complaining about characters being unbalanced
-Character selection time drastically reduced
-No arguing over who gets to be Pit
-No need to worry about characters you don't want getting in
-Would allow for the story to be set in the Kid Icarus universe
-Allows for hundreds of customizable moves
-less $$$ spent on Amiibo
Wait, this is the I Challenge you! ... To create the greatest roster ever thread, right?

You forgot the random slot

 

[Ultinarok]

1. Baby Mario
2. Toon Sheik
3. Meta Sheik
4. Young Sheik
5. Dark Sheik
6. Shadow the Hedgehog
7. Wart (From SMB2)
8. Tingle
9. Krystal
10. Bizarro
11. Baby Ridley
12. Toon Ridley
13. Dragons from Bubble Bobble
14. Pipsy the Mouse
15. Devil (like the AT, all he can do is move the stage)
16. Tails
17. Silver
18. Rouge
19. Insert Sonic character here
20. Pink Gold Peach
21. Baby Rosalina
22. Froakie
23. Frogadier
24. Pichu
25. Missingno.
26. Ike's Friends
27. Slippy
28. Pigma
29. Raiden (from MK)
30. Raiden (from MGS2)
31. Bullet Bill
32. Devil's Machine (not to be confused with Devil)
33. Superman (from the classic N64 game specifically)
34. Gold Skulltula
35. Geno
36. Reggie
37. Baby Marth
38. Baby Falco
39. Baby Luigi
40. Mercedes GLK
41. Baby Ike
42. Baby Pikachu (not to be confused with Pichu)
43. Rainbow Road (the whole road)
44. Dark Pit
45. Baby Pit
46. Toon Pit
47. Toon Dark Pit
48. Toon Baby Pit
49. Pokemon Trainer, with no Pokemon
50. Fat Princess
51. Kratos
52. Big Daddy
53. Cloud Strife
54. Master Chief
55. Duck Hunt Duck
56. Original Donkey Kong
57. Mr. Resetti
58. Mr. Gay Man Watch (not to be confused with Mr. Game & Watch)
59. Baby Master Chief
60. Custer (from the classic Atari Porn game, complete with 8-bit penis)
61. Toon Snake
62. Snake's Box
63. 8-bit Pac-Man
64. Metal Sonic
65. Metal Mario
66. Metal Meta Knight
67. Metal R.O.B.
68. ROB 64
69. Baby R.O.B.
70. Toon R.O.B.
71. That Ocarina of Time guard who dies post Zelda-escape
72. Mudkip
73. PTSD Zero Suit Samus
74. PMS Zero Suit Samus
75. Menstrual Ms. Pac-Man
76. Pyrosphere, complete with Ridley Stage Boss
77. Harry Potter
78. Shadow the Hedgehog again, cuz hez zo kewl
79. Master Chief again, cuz he doesnt afriad of ANYTHING
80. Waluigi
81. Toon Baby Metal Dark Waluigi
82. Sheik/Impa duo (as clones)
83. Ice Climbers, but all of their moves are grabs
84. Pikaman
85. Captain Ganondorf (the two-man hybrid)
86. Shadow *insert character here*, because "Shadow" makes everything cooler
87. Warth (unholy fusion of Wario with Marth's moveset)
88. Mew2King (playable)
89. Baby Ganondorf
90. Baby Zelda
91. Baby Samus
92. The Great Fairy
93. Baby Captain Falcon
94. The Flaming Eagle that appears during Falcon Punch
95. Big Mac (the sandwich, and mortal enemy of Little Mac)
96. Zero-Two, cuz hez zo creepy n kewl
97. Palutena wearing pants (shout-out to that awesome thread)
98. Zero Suit Samus in a dress (also my awesome idea)
99. Dr. PeePee (playable)
100. Mii Fighters

100-man roster, I win. Moar is better.

 

[General-Guy]

Heres my roster

 

[Robertman2]

1. Baby Mario
2. Toon Sheik
3. Meta Sheik
4. Young Sheik
5. Dark Sheik
6. Shadow the Hedgehog
7. Wart (From SMB2)
8. Tingle
9. Krystal
10. Bizarro
11. Baby Ridley
12. Toon Ridley
13. Dragons from Bubble Bobble
14. Pipsy the Mouse
15. Devil (like the AT, all he can do is move the stage)
16. Tails
17. Silver
18. Rouge
19. Insert Sonic character here
20. Pink Gold Peach
21. Baby Rosalina
22. Froakie
23. Frogadier
24. Pichu
25. Missingno.
26. Ike's Friends
27. Slippy
28. Pigma
29. Raiden (from MK)
30. Raiden (from MGS2)
31. Bullet Bill
32. Devil's Machine (not to be confused with Devil)
33. Superman (from the classic N64 game specifically)
34. Gold Skulltula
35. Geno
36. Reggie
37. Baby Marth
38. Baby Falco
39. Baby Luigi
40. Mercedes GLK
41. Baby Ike
42. Baby Pikachu (not to be confused with Pichu)
43. Rainbow Road (the whole road)
44. Dark Pit
45. Baby Pit
46. Toon Pit
47. Toon Dark Pit
48. Toon Baby Pit
49. Pokemon Trainer, with no Pokemon
50. Fat Princess
51. Kratos
52. Big Daddy
53. Cloud Strife
54. Master Chief
55. Duck Hunt Duck
56. Original Donkey Kong
57. Mr. Resetti
58. Mr. Gay Man Watch (not to be confused with Mr. Game & Watch)
59. Baby Master Chief
60. Custer (from the classic Atari Porn game, complete with 8-bit penis)
61. Toon Snake
62. Snake's Box
63. 8-bit Pac-Man
64. Metal Sonic
65. Metal Mario
66. Metal Meta Knight
67. Metal R.O.B.
68. ROB 64
69. Baby R.O.B.
70. Toon R.O.B.
71. That Ocarina of Time guard who dies post Zelda-escape
72. Mudkip
73. PTSD Zero Suit Samus
74. PMS Zero Suit Samus
75. Menstrual Ms. Pac-Man
76. Pyrosphere, complete with Ridley Stage Boss
77. Harry Potter
78. Shadow the Hedgehog again, cuz hez zo kewl
79. Master Chief again, cuz he doesnt afriad of ANYTHING
80. Waluigi
81. Toon Baby Metal Dark Waluigi
82. Sheik/Impa duo (as clones)
83. Ice Climbers, but all of their moves are grabs
84. Pikaman
85. Captain Ganondorf (the two-man hybrid)
86. Shadow *insert character here*, because "Shadow" makes everything cooler
87. Warth (unholy fusion of Wario with Marth's moveset)
88. Mew2King (playable)
89. Baby Ganondorf
90. Baby Zelda
91. Baby Samus
92. The Great Fairy
93. Baby Captain Falcon
94. The Flaming Eagle that appears during Falcon Punch
95. Big Mac (the sandwich, and mortal enemy of Little Mac)
96. Zero-Two, cuz hez zo creepy n kewl
97. Palutena wearing pants (shout-out to that awesome thread)
98. Zero Suit Samus in a dress (also my awesome idea)
99. Dr. PeePee (playable)
100. Mii Fighters

100-man roster, I win. Moar is better.

What? No Pink Gold Peach or Baby Lucina?

 

[Xenorange]

You doubt how **** of a roster I can make, OP. I'm gonna make the worst roster you've all ever seen. I'll edit this when it's done. I want to take my time.

Step it up.

Hmm, there's just something about this roster that's completely amazing, can't quite put my finger on it.


Omg look at all of those sonic characters, (dream roster)

 

[Spinosaurus]

You all joke, but I'm a sucker for bizarre choices so I like all of these rosters.

 

[Fastblade5035]

View attachment 16424
Best Roster I could think of.

I think Shrek, Shaq, Dr. Bowser, Piers Morgan and Ronald Mc.Donald would be the DLC characters.

I would insta-main Godzilla and Metal Mario.

 

[Deleted member]

Challenge excepted;

ROSTER NOTES:
-All Chroms have the same moveset, including Chrorus Men, except for Confession Chrom, who marries the nearest Chrom for his final smash.
-Chrom's down special is counter, so he cannot swap out for Lucina or Lissa. You cannot select Lucina or Lissa on the character select, so really, you're just picking Chrom.
-Chrorus Men is actually only 1 Chrorus Man for balance reasons. The other two cheer on the player controlled one from the sidelines based off of the "Pair Up" mechanic from Awakening. Please Understand.
-JP Chrom is the replacement for Marth. He speaks Japanese in all languages.
-Ike is replaced with Chrom obviously, as many predicted would happen.


DISCLAIMERS:

• I actually support Chrom only because I want an Awakening character, but c'mon. This is clearly the worst roster ever. Unless you really really REALLY like Chrom
• I apologize to Lucina fans for referring to her as "Rule 63 Chrom" here.

EDIT:

Chrom.

Twice.

I'm sorry...

 

[synesthe-sia]

Hmm, there's just something about this roster that's completely amazing, can't quite put my finger on it.


Omg look at all of those sonic characters, (dream roster)

Sounds like Crusade and SSF2 are right up your alley. I actually contemplated posting both of the most recent Crusade and SSF2 rosters in here, sort of as a joke. But I mean, let's be honest here, both have terrible rosters. I don't get why any of these fan-made games can't have good characters that people actually want. Not **** anime characters or a million Mario characters.

 

[Deleted member]

View attachment 16424
Best Roster I could think of.

I think Shrek, Shaq, Dr. Bowser, Piers Morgan and Ronald Mc.Donald would be the DLC characters.

I'd main Final Destination for sure.
NO ITEMS
FINAL DESTINATION ONLY...
final destination.

 

[Morbi]

Brawl's Roster (with slight modifications)
- Pokemon Trainer; Squirtle and Ivysaur
- Snake
+ Villager
+ Megaman
+ Wii Fit Trainer
+ Rosalina
+ Little Mac
+ Greninja
+ Mii Fighters
+ Palutena
+ Chorus Men

 

[Ultinarok]

What? No Pink Gold Peach or Baby Lucina?

Pink Gold Peach is in there.