FD or Battlefeild?

[Harbinger631]

Depends on what character I'm using. If I'm using Bowser I avoid platforms like the plague. If I'm using Pikachu, however, I don't mind platforms because it helps my aerial game.

 

[Meadow]

Like what the others have said, it really just depends on what character you use. Because I main Peach, I prefer Battlefield over Final Destination. Projectile users can beat me easily on FD, but on Battlefield, I can use USmash, UTilt, and a variety of other moves that make Battlefield a better stage for Peach.

 

[JuniorToons]

I'd perfer Final Destination because I just don't like battlefield too much. I mean, the platforms get in the way on Battlefield. But, on Final Destination, you can have a plain, fair match here, so yeah, I choose Final Destination!

 

[Lord Viper]

It depends on if I'm in the mood for platforms or not.

 

[Dynomite]

ima have to go with bf, platforms give it a change from the neutral playing surface with only one flat surface that can be controled easyly by spammerS :D

 

[3transfat]

Final Destination for Diddy Kong.
Battlefield for King Dedede and Wario.

 

[Skyflyer]

I don't know why people dislike platforms. I love them because I like to force an opponent to eventually land on them so I can get easy hits/KO's.

I can't count the number of times a platform allowed me to KO the enemy with Falcon's knee or Bowsers Usmash and Uair along with many other characters.

BF's platforms promote camping. A falco can go under a platform laser spam you. You can't approach from above or go straight to falco. Not even with mach tornado. Going straight will get you laser damage and trying to approach from above will lead you to be up smashed. Your only option will be to roll towards him with PERFECT timing which is a pain to do.

 

[4Serial]

Battlefield. FD is way too overplayed and campers have more of an advantage than they already do.

 

[Zevox]

They're equal in my mind, both at the bottom of my preferred neutral stages list. My favorite neutrals would be Smashville and Delphino Plaza, but pretty much every other neutral and neutral/counterpick I favor over FD and BF. Which isn't to say I dislike the stages overall, I just find them a bit on the dull side compared to every other option.

Zevox

 

[Firus]

In Melee, I preferred Final Destination but it doesn't have the same feel in Brawl, for some reason. Battlefield feels better (even though it's really the same stage with different aesthetics), I'm going to have to go with it.

But as it's been said, I like Smashville the best. It's flat without gimping edges, has a platform which makes projectile spamming less viable, and has great scenery.

 

[Anth0ny]

Battlefield easily.

In Melee, it was BF with the crappy edges. In Brawl, it's FD

 

[Finding Waldo]

Final Destination. The only thing I do not like is the slanted platforms next to the ledges.

 

[Sunstar]

BF is much fairer than FD i think... you cannot be gimped by the stage (or at least it is much harder to get gimped by the stage) and characters without projectile-attacks have no disadvantage against those who have one...

but... animal crossing is way better

 

[Collective of Bears]

Battlefield >>>>>>>>>>> Final Destination.

 

[TWILTHERO]

Battle Field. Platforms FTW

 

[Thunderbolt333]

Battle Field is ftw.

 

[SOG_Brwl]

Hmm...

Battlefield: Has platforms, smaller, gives characters without projectiles an advantage, colorful, easier to recover (IMO), and night/day transitions.

Final Destination: Flat, space background, classic deathmatch feeling, projectile's have advantage, more room to perfrom AT's (if you're a noob like me), plain awesome.

Final answer:

FD, without a doubt, but I wouldn't mind playing Battlefield at all simply because it's so close.

 

[Toadsanime]

There's actually a mixed opinion on this matter here, whereas I expected everyone to just shout out 'Final Destination'.
To choose between the two would be difficult. Admittedly, I play on FD more than the Battlefield. With that said, BF's platforms can make for a different experience to FD with it still being a fair stage.

 

[Foshy]

Smashville>Battlefield>>>Final Destination

 

[chaos_]

battle field imo its a better map

 

[Toadsanime]

All this attention to Smashville is new; it wasn't ever given a mention before. However, I agree, it is a plain, fair arena such as FD and BF. (With that said, the question at matter is 'FD or Battlefield')

 

[Meadow]

Battlefield. Why? Because most of my tilts/smashes can hit someone on a platform there.

Plus, I just love the music there (Or more than Final Destination anyways, but that's probably because I've heard the Giga Bowser theme far too much...) and has even boundaries.

 

[O.T.L]

I prefer bf, its nice and colorful. I hated bf in melee though.

 

[Bowser King]

Being a bowser main I find BF to be an awesome stage. FD is good but those ledges are annoying....

 

[Chaos Carnivale]

I prefer Battlefield, because all my online mates always chose Final Destination, so i've got pretty sick of it. You get to play it like 234604 times each day, and it's so annoying! And i hate those ''gimping'' edges...
-_-

 

[Toadsanime]

I prefer Battlefield, because all my online mates always chose Final Destination, so i've got pretty sick of it. You get to play it like 234604 times each day, and it's so annoying! And i hate those ''gimping'' edges...
-_-

You play Brawl that often every day...? I'd get sick of the game at half of that rate, let aknown the stage.

 

[Chaos Carnivale]

You play Brawl that often every day...? I'd get sick of the game at half of that rate, let aknown the stage.

Yeah, of course i play it 234604 times a day! It's that awesome.

 

[Toadsanime]

Yeah, of course i play it 234604 times a day! It's that awesome.

I applaud you for keeping note on how many times you play it, too. It must be difficult to count that far whilst playing.

 

[samai]

I personaly like battle field the most

 

[Porthos5]

I like FD but the people I brawl with DESPISE FD so Battlefield is all I can say... or else he might come to my house and whack me with a controller...

 

[mariofanpm12]

Goodness I almost forgot about this thread...

By the way, they say Final Destination got larger (longer), is that true?

It's hard to compare because the chaarcter models in Brawl a larger.

 

[chaos_]

bf for the win

 

[Draconian]

FD. Simple, clean, excellent. Not saying battlefield doesn't rock too, just... those ledges can mess up my aerials.

 

[AME2]

I like both with my G&W

FD: Can make great use of G&W's aerial game

BF: Can Dair through tiers, and to me, is the better stage.

 

[.Marik]

Final Destination is better in my opinion.

Nice, clean, and straightforward. Perfect for serious matches.

I don't care for Battlefield that much, even though the music is awesome.

 

[Diableos Auros]

Definitely Final Destination.

 

[FatalFrost]

I hate playing on BF with my IC, the platforms just seem to get in the way. Basicly:

IC: FD
Falco: BF

 

[Yoshima]

Final Destination is better to me, I love it's simple yet effective feel. As Marik Yoshi put it: ''Nice, clean, and straightforward. Perfect for serious matches.'' and who dosen't love a serious match?

 

[ON-2]

I perfer Battle Field over FD. On Battle Field my mains getting caught under FD's ledge during an Spin Attack/Cypher. That and FD is overused. /:

 

[False Soundz]

Battlefield all the way. Involves smarting playing because of the platforms.

It leaves more room for though and error. I love making people think and kicking their ***** at the same time.