Your Top 10: First Parties and Third Parties

[GotRest?]

1st party:
1. Saki
2. Dillon
3. Little Mac
4. Airan
5. Mike Jones
6. Isaac
7. Starfy
8. Tabuu
9. Lyn
10. Roy

3rd Party
1. No one
2. But if I have to choose
3. Bomber man
4. Proto Man
5. Amaterasu
6. Crono
7. Simon
8. Geno
9. Vectorman
10. Ristar

 

[Zuby]

1st/2nd Party

1. Palutena
2. Ridley
3. King K.Rool
4. Mewtwo
5. Dillon
6. Tetra
7. Hades
8. Saki
9. Little Mac
10. Dixie Kong

3rd Party

1. Remove Snake
2. Remove Sonic
3. Remove Mega Man
4. None
5. None
6. None
7. None
8. None
9. None
10. None

 

[Salty the SLUG]

1st/2nd Party

1. Palutena
2. Ridley
3. King K.Rool
4. Mewtwo
5. Dillon
6. Tetra
7. Hades
8. Saki
9. Little Mac
10. Dixie Kong

3rd Party

1. Remove Snake
2. Remove Sonic
3. Remove Mega Man
4. None
5. None
6. None
7. None
8. None
9. None
10. None

I get the other two, but, what's so bad about Megaman?

 

[MattX20]

1st Party:
1. Little Mac
2. Palutena
3. Mewtwo
4. Roy
5. Takamaru
6. King K Rool
7. Ridley
8. Mona
9. Captain Syrup
10. Paper Mario

As for 3rd Party characters, only 3 come to mind:
1. Rayman
2. Pacman
3. Geno

 

[Zuby]

I get the other two, but, what's so bad about Megaman?

I oppose the very concept of third party characters being in Smash Bros. It doesn't matter who they are, I would much prefer they not be included, especially when Nintendo has so many wonderful characters waiting on the sidelines.

Mega Man is certainly less offensive than Snake and Sonic, but still a bridge too far for me.

 

[Salty the SLUG]

I oppose the very concept of third party characters being in Smash Bros. It doesn't matter who they are, I would much prefer they not be included, especially when Nintendo has so many wonderful characters waiting on the sidelines.

Mega Man is certainly less offensive than Snake and Sonic, but still a bridge too far for me.

I see what you mean, I honestly couldn't care if Snake/Sonic stay or go.

 

[StaffofSmashing]

I oppose the very concept of third party characters being in Smash Bros. It doesn't matter who they are, I would much prefer they not be included, especially when Nintendo has so many wonderful characters waiting on the sidelines.

Mega Man is certainly less offensive than Snake and Sonic, but still a bridge too far for me.

Mega Man games were the biggest games on the NES (please don't quote me). He makes sense. He's had a long, successful history with Nintendo, and Capcom shut him down. Now, Mega Man is getting a revival, and from the looks of the fans, Nintendo won't be touching him unless they want to adjust his moveset.

 

[Zuby]

Mega Man games were the biggest games on the NES (please don't quote me). He makes sense. He's had a long, successful history with Nintendo, and Capcom shut him down. Now, Mega Man is getting a revival, and from the looks of the fans, Nintendo won't be touching him unless they want to adjust his moveset.

Yeah, that's precisely why I said he was a lesser evil than the others. I would have played hundreds of hours of Mega Man on my original Game Boy back in 1992. But third party is third party, and for me it doesn't matter who it is. I don't want them. And that's all I'm going to say about it in this thread because I don't want to derail it any further.

 

[low tier user]

Here it goes,

1st Party:

10. Roy
9. Roy
8. Roy
7. Isaac
6. Roy
5. Roy
4. Roy
3. Roy
2. Roy
1. Reggie Fils-Amie

3rd Party

10. Cloud
9. Sora
8. Roy
7. we1desa
6. Ray
5. I meant Roy
3.

Don't forget Roy XD and I want Melee Ganondorf back.

 

[low tier user]

I get the other two, but, what's so bad about Megaman?

He has too many projectiles and sonic isn't as cheap.

 

[Salty the SLUG]

He has too many projectiles and sonic isn't as cheap.

To be honest, Megaman was never a very physical character, just look at his retro games.

 

[SpaceJell0]

Yeah, that's precisely why I said he was a lesser evil than the others. I would have played hundreds of hours of Mega Man on my original Game Boy back in 1992. But third party is third party, and for me it doesn't matter who it is. I don't want them. And that's all I'm going to say about it in this thread because I don't want to derail it any further.

Translation: I DON'T WANT CHANGE! I DON'T WANT CHANGE! EVERYTHING HAS TO STAY THE SAAAAAAMMMEE (lol jk but the 3rd parties fit in the roster nicely though)

 

[low tier user]

To be honest, Megaman was never a very physical character, just look at his retro games.

Tbh he isn't fit for smash and I don't like your profile pic. It looks dumb

 

[Salty the SLUG]

Tbh he isn't fit for smash and I don't like your profile pic. It looks dumb

Okay, so then you just straight up insult me? Evidence that he isn't for Smash, please?

 

[Falling Whistness]

Results of this thread so far:

1st Party:
---
1. Little Mac
2. K. Rool
3. Ridley
4. Mewtwo
5. Palutena
6. Isaac
7. Shulk
8. Takamaru
9. Dixie Kong
10. Roy
11. Bowser Jr.
12. Dillon
12(tie). Toad
14. Duck Hunt Dog
15. Saki
16. Mike Jones
17. Lyn
18. Meowth
19. Paper Mario
20. Wonder Red
20(tie). Starfy

3rd Party:
---
1. Pac-Man
2. Banjo & Kazooie
2(tie). Bomberman
4. Simon Belmont
5. Rayman
6. Geno
7. Tails
8. Lloyd Irving
8(tie). Professor Layton
10. Crono
11. Amaterasu
12. Bayonetta
13. Mumbo Jumbo
14. Sora
15. Cloud
16. Black Mage
17. Protoman
18. Chocobo
19. Zero
20. Conker


Added up all the lists in this thread with a method of 10 for 1st, 9 for 2nd, 8 for 3rd, etc. Counts all the posts above this one. Top 20 for each category.

 

[shinhed-echi]

Results of this thread so far:

1st Party:
---
1. Little Mac
2. K. Rool
3. Ridley
4. Mewtwo
5. Palutena
6. Isaac
7. Shulk
8. Takamaru
9. Dixie Kong
10. Roy
11. Bowser Jr.
12. Dillon
12(tie). Toad
14. Duck Hunt Dog
15. Saki
16. Mike Jones
17. Lyn
18. Meowth
19. Paper Mario
20. Wonder Red
20(tie). Starfy

I have GOT to be dreaming!
Really, Saki? Almost on the level of underratedness as Mike? O_o

 

[low tier user]

To be honest, Megaman was never a very physical character, just look at his retro games.

We'll what do you expect me to say? But will it be delayed like it as cuz of Sonic?

To be honest, Megaman was never a very physical character, just look at his retro games.

Why not?

Okay, so then you just straight up insult me? Evidence that he isn't for Smash, please?

Well what do you expect me To say? It has a crazy lookin megamam with the word derp and says you're in a wibbly wobbly place. It's kinda weird.

 

[shinhed-echi]

If Megaman 6 wasn't so criminally underrated, people would remember his Power Suit which basically allowed Mega Man to PUNCH the **** out of his opponents.

I, for example, love beating all Robot Masters this way. The Rush Power Suit armor kicks butt!!
It can even MOVE huge opponents if a punch is fully charged!

If there's ONE more DLC I would've loved having in MM9 and MM10, it's this one.

 

[Salty the SLUG]

Well what do you expect me To say? It has a crazy lookin megamam with the word derp and says you're in a wibbly wobbly place. It's kinda weird.

You didn't have to say the second part. All you had to say was: "Tbh he isn't fit for smash" (exactly from what you wrote).

 

[low tier user]

You didn't have to say the second part. All you had to say was: "Tbh he isn't fit for smash" (exactly from what you wrote).

Im sorry and I don't think he's fit cuz the villager from animal crossing could throw back all his projectiles and he has alot of them.

 

[Capybara Gaming]

Enough! Stop spamming and getting off topic, or you will be reported.

 

[shinhed-echi]

Is it alright if I post my Top 10 assist trophy ideas for both as well?

 

[Salty the SLUG]

Im sorry and I don't think he's fit cuz the villager from animal crossing could throw back all his projectiles and he has alot of them.

It's okay. Just think before you post next time. I suppose you're right about the Villager vs Megaman makes sense, but the "collecting" animation takes a-while, so when the Villager is collecting, Megaman could just slide right in to fight the Villager face-to-face.

 

[low tier user]

Oh ok I though it'd be like fox or falco.

It's okay. Just think before you post next time. I suppose you're right about the Villager vs Megaman makes sense, but the "collecting" animation takes a-while, so when the Villager is collecting, Megaman could just slide right in to fight the Villager face-to-face.

oh ok I thought it'd be like fox or falco.

 

[Salty the SLUG]

oh ok I thought it'd be like fox or falco.

I'd believe their projectiles would be too fast.

 

[GotRest?]

Results of this thread so far:

1st Party:
---
1. Little Mac
2. K. Rool
3. Ridley
4. Mewtwo
5. Palutena
6. Isaac
7. Shulk
8. Takamaru
9. Dixie Kong
10. Roy
11. Bowser Jr.
12. Dillon
12(tie). Toad
14. Duck Hunt Dog
15. Saki
16. Mike Jones
17. Lyn
18. Meowth
19. Paper Mario
20. Wonder Red
20(tie). Starfy

I don't understand why people want King K. Rool so badly. You'd rather have a third rep from DK Country than a rep from a new franchise? What would his moveset even be like?

Also, does Wonder Red count as first party? I thought Platinum Games would own the rights to the characters in that game.

 

[FirstBlade]

First Party:
1. Ridley
2. King K. Rool
3. Shulk
4. Starfy
5. Isaac
6. Ray MK III
7. Mewtwo
8. Takamaru
9. Little Mac
10. Mach Rider

Third Party:
1. Pacman
2. Pacman
3. Pacman
4. Pacman
5. Pacman
6. Pacman
7. Pacman
8. Pacman
9. Sora
10. Bomberman

 

[Capybara Gaming]

Is it alright if I post my Top 10 assist trophy ideas for both as well?

Sure. Go ahead.

 

[VictoryIsMudkipz]

No particular order (except Dillon, he's number one regardless)
1st.
1. Dillon (Rolling Western)
2. Knuckle Joe (Kirby)
3. Baby Bros. (Baby Mario & Luigi, Yoshi Franchise)
4. Mewtwo (Pokemon)
5. Roy/Chrom (Fire Emblem)
6. Bowser Jr. (Super Mario Franchise)
7. Wonder Red (Wonderful 101/Platinum Games)
8. King K. Rool (Donkey Kong)
9. Tom Nook/K.K Slider (Animal Crossing)
10. Waluigi (Super Mario Franchise/Wario)
Bonus: Sandbag (Super Smash Bros. Franchise), Issac (Golden Sun), Little Mac (Punch Out)

These are not counting pre-existing third parties like Snake and Sonic, who's chances of returning are unknown, and since Megaman is already confirmed, I'll leave him out of my 3rd Parties
3rd.
1. Rayman (Ubisoft)
2. Bayonetta (Platinum Games/Sega)
3. Lloyd Irving (Tales of Symphonia/Namco)
4. Pac-Man (Namco)
5. Ryu (Street Fighter/Capcom)
6. Banjo Kazooie (Rare/Microsoft)
7. Travis Touchdown (No More Heroes)
8. Mickey & Oswald (Epic Mickey, Disney)
9. Geno (Square Enix/Square Soft)
10. Sora/Neku (Kingdom Hearts/The World Ends With You, Square Enix/Disney)
Bonus: Bomberman

 

[Hong]

Since my top 10 are what will make everyone happy, my list considers the needs of the people in general, so I went with popular characters in addition to ones I think could make for the most fun gameplay. No particular order.

1) Ridley
2) Isa
3) Chrom
4) Robin
5) Palutena
6) Mach Rider
7) Mewtwo

I can't think of anymore that could offer anything new to the game, so maybe we could include Roy, Lucina and Ninten as reskins (with voice and name) for the appropriate characters.

Third party additions are not welcome (barring cases like Simon Belmont who practically felt like Nintendo characters back in the golden age) so I don't have a list.

 

[jaytalks]

1st Party
1) Lucina
2) Little Mac
3) Robin
4) Shulk
5) Isaac
6) Palutena
7) Dixie Kong
8) Krystal
9) Lip
10) Akari Hayami

3rd party:
1) Crono
2) Simon Belmont
3) Viewtiful Joe
4) Lloyd Irving

 

[Falling Whistness]

Updated results of this thread so far:

1st party:

1. Little Mac​

2. Ridley​

3. K. Rool​

4. Mewtwo​

5. Palutena​

6. Isaac​

7. Shulk​

8. Dixie Kong​

9. Takamaru​

10. Dillon​

10(tie). Roy​

12. Bowser Jr.​

13. Toad​

14. Duck Hunt Dog​

15. Saki​

16. Chrom​

17. Mike Jones​

17(tie). Starfy​

19. Meowth​

20. Lyn​

21. Wonder Red​

22. Paper Mario​

23. Lucina​

24. Mach Rider​

24(tie). Vaati​

​

3rd Party:​

1. Pac-Man​

2. Banjo & Kazooie​

3. Bomberman​

4. Simon Belmont​

5. Rayman​

6. Geno​

7. Tails​

8. Lloyd Irving​

9. Professor Layton​

9(tie). Crono​

11. Bayonetta​

12. Amaterasu​

13. Sora​

14. Mumbo Jumbo​

15. Cloud​

16. Black Mage​

17. Protoman​

18. Chocobo​

19. Zero​

20. Conker​

​

​

 

[Cheesedork]

1st Party:
10: Eevee (and Eeveelutions)
9: Mach Rider
8: Dixie Kong
7: Starfy
6: Tetra
5: Waluigi
4: Little Mac
3: Palutena
2: Robin
1: Meowth
0: Mewtwo and Roy

3rd Party:
10: Klonoa
9: Earthworm Jim
8: Cooking Mama
7: Spyro (old design, plox)
6: Crash Bandicoot (old design, plox)
5: Phoenix Wright
4: Amaterasu
3: Rayman
2: Bomberman
1: Pac-Man (I like Tales of, namely Tales of the Abyss, but ehhh. Pac-Man and Klonoa seem more fitting, sorry)
0: Sonic

 

[kikaru]

1st Party:
1). Shulk
2). Isaac (Even though Camelot is considered 2nd party)
3). Tiki
4). Little Mac
5). Masked Link
6). Ridley
7). King K. Rool
8). Palutena
9). Mewtwo
10). Chrom or Roy. Indifferent.

3rd Party:
1). Lloyd Irving
2). Geno
3). Roxas
4). Hat Kid (If Hat in Time is ported to Wii U, which developers are really hoping for)
5). Banjo-Kazooie
6). Simon Belmont
7). Phoenix Wright
8). Professor Layton
9). Ryu Hyabusa
10). Flynn (Just beat SMT IV, was quite pleased at how it went.)

 

[Zhadgon]

1st party:
1. Ridley
2. Kalas (Baten Kaitos)
3. Shulk
4. Dillon
5. King K. Rool
6. Isaac
7. Harry (Teleroboxer)
8. Mach Rider
9. Saki
10. Bowser Jr.

3rd Party:
1. Travis Touchdown (No More Heroes)
2. Lloyd Irving
3. Jack (MadWorld)
4. Bayonetta
5. Professor Layton
6. Wonder Red (Wonderful 101)
7. King (Little King´s Story)
8. Bomberman
9. Amaterasu (Okami)
10. Rayman

.n_n.

 

[JamesDNaux]

For first party, I'll just go with newcomers and cut veterans only, no one from Brawl or already announced for 4:
1- King K. Rool
2- Ridley
3- Dixie Kong
4- Skull Kid
5- Mewtwo
6- Palutena
7- Krystal
8- Toad
9- Takamaru
10-Waluigi

Third parties are a bit difficult, I wouldn't want so many in the first place. I'll include the three we already have, just to pad the list:
1- Rayman (would just die, perfect)
2- Banjo-Kazooie (it's saddening to even call them third party)
3- Snake (it just wouldn't be the same without him, would hate to see him cut)
4- Sonic (he's an important part of Nintendo's history, like it or not)
5- Mega Man (already confirmed, but eh)
6- Pac-Man (well, Namco)
7- Conker (again, saddening to even call a third party)
8- Mumbo Jumbo (**** M$)
9- Gruntilda (why hasn't Nintendo bought back their IPs already I mean for ****'s sake)
10-Sora (Really had to stretch for this one, better than any other choice though honestly)

 

[Venus of the Desert Bloom]

Oh ok I though it'd be like fox or falco.

oh ok I thought it'd be like fox or falco.

Low tier user, please refrain from making multiple posts one after another. Instead, please use the Edit feature. Just click on the edit button and add more. If you want to quote another use, just hit quote below the users message and it should automatically add it to your edit message box.

Consider this a verbal warning. It will be an infraction if you continue to make double or triple posts and infractions are not fun. Trust me. Thanks

1st/2nd party

1. Palutena
2. Ridley
3. Dark Samus
4. King K. Rool
5. Shulk
6. Dixie Kong
7. Mewtwo (mega form)
8. Toon Zelda/Tetra
9. Mach Rider
10. Skull Kid

3rd Party
1. Nightmare
2. Terra Bradford
3. Lloyd Irving
4. M. Bison
5. Commander Shepard
6. KOS-MOS
7. Chrono
8. Oliver (Ni no Kuni)
9. Wonder Red
10. Joanna Dark

 

[MrBigstuff]

First Party
1. Jimmy T-Not sure why, but I want him
2. Kat and Ana-If the ICs problems are fixed, they could be cool
3. Waluigi-He could represent Party/Kart/Sports titles
4. Ridley-Evil Metroid Dragons are cool
5. Little Mac-Murica
6. King Hippo-Slightly larger Murica
7. Palutena-KI:U was awesome. Love her personality.
8. Shulk-Never played his game but cool design.
9. Zoroark-Kind of Lucarioy, but dark and cool
10. Midna riding Wolf Link-Would be cool if it was Midna's magic for most specials and wolink's attacks.

3rd
1. Simon Belmont

 

[yani]

Wonder Red is first party my good chums! and seeing Banjo-Kazooie on almost every list makes me smile.

 

[Falling Whistness]

Updated results of this thread so far:

​

1st party:​

1. Ridley​

2. Little Mac​

3. K. Rool​

4. Mewtwo​

5. Palutena​

6. Isaac​

7. Shulk​

8. Dixie Kong​

9. Roy​

10. Dillon​

11. Takamaru​

12. Bowser Jr.​

13. Toad​

14. Duck Hunt Dog​

15. Saki​

16. Meowth​

17. Chrom​

17(tie). Wonder Red​

19. Starfy​

20. Mike Jones​

21. Lyn​

22. Waluigi​

23. Mach Rider​

23(tie). Robin​

25. Paper Mario​

​

3rd party:​

1. Pac-Man​

2. Banjo & Kazooie​

3. Bomberman​

4. Simon Belmont​

5. Rayman​

6. Lloyd Irving​

7. Geno​

8. Tails​

9. Professor Layton​

10. Crono​

11. Bayonetta​

12. Amaterasu​

13. Sora​

14. Mumbo Jumbo​

15. Cloud​

16. Black Mage​

17. Protoman​

18. Phoenix Wright​

18(tie). Travis Touchdown​

18(tie). Conker​

​

​