Your Top 10: First Parties and Third Parties

[APC99]

I want to change mine, as I've had a recent change in opinion. I'm also refraining from putting threads I created, so no Donbe & Hikari, Tamagon or Nintendog. Consider Shulk #11.

First Parties:

10. Tingle. My top choice for any Zelda character. I'm just not too much of an Impa fan, and Ghirahim isn't too likely in my eyes.
9. Muddy Mole. A cool retro character who I think has a lot of moveset potential.
8. EarthBound/ Mother character (Ninten, Porky or Masked Man, preferably Porky).
7. Mii (I think they've earned a spot).
6. Palutena. From what I've seen of Kid Icarus Uprising, I think Palutena's definitely worth a spot.
5. Mewtwo (I'm not a huge Pokemon fan, but this guy deserves a spot).
4. Tie between Sukapon and Little Mac. I want a retro fighting character in, one way or another. And these two fit the bill.
3. Ridley. The space dragon deserves to be here, he's the BIGGEST all-star not in!
2. Bandana Waddle Dee. Spears for the win!
1. King K. Rool. Donkey Kong Country 3 was my first Nintendo game, so he's nostalgic for me. And to see this crocodile crook finally defeat DK would be a dream.

Third parties: (A lot of them aren't really too important to me, the top 3 are the ones I want the most, however). Mega Man would've been the only one on the list before E3. Sora and Lloyd Irving tie for #11.

10. Dig Dug. Inflation powers ACTIVATE!
9. Rayman. He's important enough to Nintendo now where seeing him would make sense.
8. Shantae. Another unlikely dream
7. Simon Belmont. Just for Captain N.
6. Professor Layton. A puzzle character would be really cool.
5. Banjo-Kazooie. I miss Rare...
4. Bomberman. I'd prefer him over Snake any day, but to see them together fighting Sonic and Mario would be amazing.
3. Geno. I serve... a higher authority.
2. Quote from Cave Story. This is a pipe dream, but I REALLY want him.
1. Pac-Man. To see the 4 gaming icons brawl it out would be amazing.

 

[YoshiandToad]

1st
1. Toad
2. Roy
3. Isaac
4. Dillon
5. Meowth
6. Duck Hunt Dog
7. An Advance Wars Rep(either Andy or Sami)
8. Mewtwo
9. Waluigi
10. Paper Mario

3rd
1. Tails
2. Rayman
3. Pac-Man
4. Bomberman
5. Bill Overbeck(Left 4 Dead)
6. Heavy and Medic(Team Fortress 2)
7. Frank West(Dead Rising)
8. Roland/Maya/Claptrap(Borderlands)
9. Agumon(Digimon)
10. Valentine(Skullgirls)

I'm glad I'm not in charge of third party. I actually don't like that many Japanese made games outside Nintendo based ones...

The **** is this mess, past me?

1st Party

1. Toad. Will continue to be number one until the seas burn and the mountains crumble. SMB2 quad needs to be completed, Wario's Woods is awesome, and he's one of the most recognised Nintendo individuals not currently in Smash.
2. Meowth. Seriously, why the **** did I put him as 5th? He and Toad have been wanted since Smash 64 for me.
3. Samurai Goroh. Wanted since pre-Brawl. No idea why he wasn't even on Past Me's list. The hell, man?
4. Robin or Roy. I like both Fire Emblem characters and I think Roy could be given some more unique abilities with the sword of seals. Robin is obviously our best shot at a magic user.
5. Duck Hunt Dog. Only retro that people actually remember, even if it's for a negative reason. Great Troll character possibilities.
6. Bandana Dee. I blame Chandelure, Axel, Lonekonwolf, Josh Bones, etc
7. Dixie Kong. Don't care what people say, she's more likely and more recognised. Casuals will know who Dixie is more than K. Rool because they spend all of DKC2 and DKC3 looking at her.

8th, 9th and 10th are a mix of Lip, Dillon, Isaac, etc but I honestly don't care about anyone else's inclusion. At best it'll be a mild "good for the fans" at worst I'll be using them as my personal punching bag in the game.

3rd Party

1. Pac-Man. THE mascot character. Screw the haters, this dude is the most deserving.
2. Bomberman. Grew up on Bomberman.
3. Rayman. One of the most creative platforming mascots full of personality in recent years.
4. Tails. Sort of. Only secondary character I'd consider.

No one else seems worthy of that 3rd party spot to me.

 

[Morbi]

First-Party Characters
1. Tingle
2. Hades
3. Samurai Goroh (or Black Shadow)
4. Mewtwo
5. Bandanna Dee
6. Meowth
7. Palutena
8. Little Mac
9. Lucina (most likely with Chrom)
10. Cranky Kong

Third-Party Characters
1. Snake (Big Boss, more specifically)
2. Sonic
3. Mega Man
4. Pac-Man
5. Sweet Tooth
6. Duke Nukem
7. Sora
8. Jill Valentine (or Chris Redfield)
9. Bayonetta
10. Batman (more like "4th"-Party Character, so I put him last)

 

[Spears In Smash Bros.]

#3 : Red Savarin (Solatorobo)
#2 : Crono (Chrono Trigger)
#1 : Shantae (Shantae)

I can't believe someone else here played Solatorobo!

Top 10 1st/2nd parties:
10: Alternate Pokemon Trainer (i.e. Johto, Hoenn, etc. Trainer, Pokemon Ranger, Team Rocket Grunt)
9: Lucina
8: Little Mac
7: Bowser Jr.
6: Does Mewtwo count?
5: Mach Rider
4: Ray-01
3: Robin
2: Toon Zelda/Tetra
1: Paper Mario

Top 10 3rd parties:
10: Dillon
9: Any SNES-era Squaresoft character
8: Wonder-Red (Wonderful 101)
7: Simon Belmont
6: Dr. Eggman
5: Proto Man
4: Kunio-Kun (River City Ransom+Kunio-Kun series)
3: Quote (Cave Story)
2: Neku Sakuraba (TWEWY)
1: Klonoa

 

[Fortanono]

Top 10 3rd parties:
10: Dillon

Um... Isn't Dillon 1st party?

 

[SmasherMaster]

1st Party
10) Toad
9) Toon Zelda/ Tetra
8) K K Slider
7) N
6) Little Mac
5) Bandana Waddle Dee
4) Palutena
3) K Rool
2) Ridley
1) All Veterans except for Pichu (and Snake and Sonic but still)

What was wrong with me?

1st Party Newcomers
1) Mewtwo
2) Little Mac
3) K Rool
4) Ridley
5) Chibbi Robo
6) Palutena
7) Dixie
8) Shulk
9) Tetra/ Toon Zelda
10) Waddle Dee

 

[Knight Dude]

First Party

1. Ridley
2. King K. Rool
3. Issac
4. Dixie Kong
5. Little Mac
6. Palutena
7. Ray-01(other versions are fine too)
8. Zoroark/Blaziken
9. Captain Syrup
10. Dark Samus(Not likely but still cool)

Third Party

1. Megaman X/Zero/Bass
2. Firebrand
3. Pac-Man
4. Simon Belmont
5. Bomberman
6. Tails/Eggman/Knuckles
7. Shantae
8. Phoenix Wright
9. Rayman
10. Spyro(Though more fitting for a Sony fighter)

 

[Sarki Soliloquy]

1st Party

10: Waddle Dee
9: Krystal
8: Shulk
7: Dillon
6: Takamaru/Lip
5: Gardevoir/Victini
4: Palutena
3: Anna/Tiki
2: Little Mac
1: Chrom

3rd Party

5: Professor Layton
4: Lloyd Irving
3: Bayonetta
2: Jack Frost
1: NiGHTS

If you see a "/" in one of my choices, consider the first one to be my preference.

 

[Fortanono]

5: Gardevoir/Victini

Yay!

 

[PurpleExcadrill]

I combine both I only have 1 3rd party though.
These are the characters I want in ssb4
10. Kat and Anna (WarioWare): Ok these 2 ultimate female ninjas were almost not on the list, we need more girls in ssb and if we get Kat and Anna we got 2 more!
9. Dark Samus or Anthony (Metroid): Anthony would be a very cool man character, though hard to make a moveset for, while Dark Samus, Just put her in the game for the female and villlain role!
8. Black Shadow (F-Zero): Please not a clone! He would be so cool!
7. Mewtwo's Return (Pokemon): Mewtwo come back with Mega form for final smash
6. Little Mac (Punch Out): Omg he is just wanted!
5. Shulk (Xenoblade): OMG Xenoblades look so cool, potential for an interesting moveset!
4. Vector (Sonic the Hedgehog): This and the next one are highly unlikely but wouldn't Vector be an awesome heavyweight?
3. Yuga (Legend Of Zelda): Potential for a great moveset, painting please?
2. Krystal (Starfox): For da fans!
1. Chrom (Fire Emblem): I think I play this game too much...

 

[andalsoandy]

7. Bop-Louie (Sunsoft) - too obscure

Liked for this :D

Here's my top ten... Number 1 would be Mega Man if this were prior to his announcement. Anything after number 3 is out of order.
1. Simon Belmont - Possible, and definitely more deserving than any other unannounced third party besides maybe Pac-Man. His moveset is pretty obvious as well.
2. Another Mega Man character. - I'd like this, but it probably won't happen.
3. Banjo-Kazooie - Too bad it's not possible.
4. Pac-Man - I don't particularly like him but he'd be interesting to play in Smash. It'd also help sales.
5. Layton - Why not.
6. Quote - I loves Cave Story.
7. Bomberman - I likes Bomberman.
8. Shantae - Only played the GBC game, and it was alright. Why not.
9. Rayman - Seems relevant and exclusive enough to Ninty.

9 is close enough.

Here's first parties in no particular order. I know I bypass ten:
0. Let the Groose be loose.
1. Starfy. Not gonna happen though.
2. Little Mac.
3. Ridley.
4. C. Syrup.
5. Mewtwo.
6. Meowth.
7. Classic Ganon.
8. That guy from Startropics... oh yeah it's Mike.
9. Palutena.
10. K. Rool.
11. Chrom
12. Mii in some form (even if we could replace other character's heads with Miis. Fun fun fun.)
13. Chibi Robo
14. NES character (ExciteBiker, Takemaru, Urban Champion *shot*)
15. Waluigi (Only to complete the Mario Bros/Wario Bros. Low priority.)
16. Black Shadow

 

[Sabrewulf238]

My 1st, 2nd party list:

1. Isaac
2. Shulk
3. Mewtwo
4. Chibi Robo
5. Fawful
6. Ridley
7. Palutena
8. Mallo
9. Dillon
10. Little Mac

3rd party list, I only really care about the first six though. Anyone else know about Hat Kid? Some reason when I first saw that game I thought how well she'd fit in smash bros.

1. Steel Samurai (Ace Attorney)
2. Hat Kid (A hat in time)
3. Bomberman
4. Jade (Beyond good & evil)
5. Bayonetta
6. Shin megami tensei rep
7. Banjo & Kazooie
8. Rayman
9. Klonoa

I can't think of any other worthwhile 3rd parties. (I didn't include veteran 3rd party characters)

New ranking:

1. Isaac
2. Shulk
3. Mewtwo
4. Chibi Robo
5. Robin/My Unit
6. Advance Wars rep
7. Mallo
8. Ridley
9. Lip
10. Little Mac

Honourable mentions: Saki, Palutena, Fawful, Alexandra Roivas/Pious, Dillon.

I'm not bothering with 3rd party since I only really care about Ace Attorney representation.

 

[dezeray112]

1st Party:

1. Chrom (Fire Emblem Awakening)
2. Little Mac (Punch Out)
3. Palutena (Kid Icarus)
4. Takamaru
5. Mach Rider
6. Isaac (Golden Sun)
7. Mewtwo
8. Saki (Sin & Punishment)
9. Black Shadow (F-Zero)
10. Ridley (Metroid)

3rd Party:

1. Megaman
2. Sonic the Hedgehog
3. Lloyd Irving (Tales of Symphonia)

 

[The Light Music Club]

1st Party:
10) Lucina (Fire Emblem)
9) Illyana (Fire Emblem)
8) Robin (Female) (Fire Emblem)
7) Pokemon Trainer (Ruby and Sapphire) (Pokemon)
6) Pokemon Trainer (Gold and Silver) (Pokemon)
5) King K Rool (Donkey Kong)
4) Roy (Fire Emblem)
3)Mewtwo (Pokemon)
2) Palutena (Kid Icarus)
1) Micaiah (Fire Emblem)

3rd Party:
7) Hatsune Miku (Project Diva)
6) Banjo and Kazooie (Banjo and Kazooie)
5) Chrono (Chrono Trigger)
4) Amaterasu (Okami)
3) Professor Layton (Professor Layton)
2) Neku Sakuraba (The World Ends With You)
1) Phoenix Wright (Ace Attorney)

Maybe I'll add 3 more later.