The Best Nintendo Character Poll

[AustarusIV]

I am disappointed that Robin has ranked so low on the list.

1. Charizard
2. Ridley
3. Mewtwo
4. Donkey Kong
5. Bowser

Took it again and got this score:

1. Charizard
2. Ridley
3. Robin
4. Zelda
5. Wario

 

[Fatmanonice]

First time I took it:

1. Mario
2. King Dedede
3. Waluigi
4. Fox
5. Miyamoto

Noteworthy matchups: Ridley vs K. Rool, Wario vs Waluigi

Second time I took it:

1. Mario
2. Wario
3.Ike
4. Fox
5. Waluigi


Noteworhty matchups: Shigeru Miyamoto vs Mario, Olimar vs Pikmin, Mario vs Wario

 

[strawhatninja]

I got

1.- What a shock haha
2. King K Rool- I can agree with that.
3. - I do like him more then Mario.
4. Robin(Avatar). I can also agree with that.
5. Ridley- I like Ridley but I wouldn't have put him this high on my list.

 

[DACSHeyes]

1. Ganondorf
2. Lucina
3. Mewtwo
4. Ridley
5. Link

 

[Swiftie_Muggle]

i'm glad with the results , it's pretty accurate

 

[PAPCGyE]

1) K.K.Rool
2) Megaman
3) Bowser
4) Link
5) Mewtwo

 

[strawhatninja]

1) K.K.Rool
2) Megaman
3) Bowser
4) Link
5) Mewtwo

Wait I don't remember Megaman being on the list I thought it was just Nintendo characters?

 

[GunGunW]

The list results I actually got were:
1. Mario
2. Luigi
3. Fox McCloud
4. Lucina
5. Wii Fit Trainer

 

[YT123]

1. Ness
2. Shulk
3. Midna
4. Birdo
5. Link

 

[Swamp Castle]

1. Ike
2. Lucina
3. Midna
4. Meta Knight
5. Pit

I find it strange that Pit is the only Kid Icarus character in the poll. Biggoron getting in over Palutena ... ugh. It makes me want to make my own version of this poll.

 

[Sabrewulf238]

I got:

1. Isaac
2. Shulk
3. Riki
4. Mewtwo
5. Tom Nook

The top 50 makes me sad.

Some of the inclusions and abscences are really odd though. It seems like the poll was made by someone who didn't know their Nintendo characters too well. Maxwell and Layton are not Nintendo characters.

Also does anyone find the inclusion of Reggie and Miyamoto weird? They're not "Nintendo characters", they're real life people.

 

[Oracle_Summon]

I got:

1. Isaac
2. Shulk
3. Riki
4. Mewtwo
5. Tom Nook

The top 50 makes me sad.

Some of the inclusions and abscences are really odd though. It seems like the poll was made by someone who didn't know their Nintendo characters too well. Maxwell and Layton are not Nintendo characters.

Also does anyone find the inclusion of Reggie and Miyamoto weird? They're not "Nintendo characters", they're real life people.

What was the hardest matchup for you?

 

[Sabrewulf238]

What was the hardest matchup for you?

I got Mewtwo vs Fiora which wasn't too pleasant.

I also got Shulk vs Robin (Avatar)

 

[InfiniteNumbers]

1.) Wolf
2.) Yoshi
3.) Fox
4.) Ridley
5.) Luigi

 

[MasterOfKnees]

It made some unfair match-ups for me, like putting Ridley up against Ike way too early and Dedede skipping over every tough battle, so I'm just going to list my actual thoughts:

1. Ridley
2. Meta Knight
3. Samus
4. Ike
5. Kirby

 

[King Sonnn DeDeDoo]

1. Professor Layton (not actually owned by Nintendo but whatever)
2. Fox
3. Yoshi
4. Red
5. KK Slider

 

[andimidna]

• [collapse=current results]
  
• 1.
  Link
  83%
• 2.
  Samus Aran
  74%
• 3.
  Mario
  72%
• 4.
  Princess Zelda
  71%
• 5.
  Red
  70%
• 6.
  Luigi
  70%
• 7.
  Kirby
  69%
• 8.
  Shigeru Miyamoto
  68%
• 9.
  Pikachu
  68%
• 10.
  Ganondorf
  68%
• 11.
  Mewtwo
  67%
• 12.
  Charizard
  67%
• 13.
  Midna
  66%
• 14.
  Yoshi
  66%
• 15.
  Bowser
  65%
• 16.
  Captain Falcon
  65%
• 17.
  Fox McCloud
  64%
• 18.
  Donkey Kong
  63%
• 19.
  Pit
  61%
• 20.
  Meta Knight
  61%
• 21.
  Professor Oak
  60%
• 22.
  Gary Oak/Blue
  59%
• 23.
  Tetra
  59%
• 24.
  Skull Kid
  59%
• 25.
  Rosalina
  58%
• 26.
  Reggie Fils-Aime
  57%
• 27.
  Princess Peach
  57%
• 28.
  Ness
  57%
• 29.
  Ridley
  57%
• 30.
  Ike
  57%
• 31.
  Marth
  56%
• 32.
  Lucina
  56%
• 33.
  Wario
  56%
• 34.
  Falco Lombardi
  56%
• 35.
  Little Mac
  55%
• 36.
  Happy Mask Salesman
  55%
• 37.
  Diddy Kong
  54%
• 38.
  Master Hand
  54%
• 39.
  Navi
  54%
• 40.
  Toad
  54%
• 41.
  Dark Samus
  53%
• 42.
  King Dedede
  53%
• 43.
  Old Man
  53%
• 44.
  Waluigi
  52%
• 45.
  Professor Layton
  52%
• 46.
  Pikmin
  50%
• 47.
  Robin (Avatar)
  50%
• 48.
  Wolf O'Donnell
  50%
• 49.
  Roy
  49%
• 50. Bowser Jr 48%[/collapse]

Love seeing how high Midna is, and Rosalina.
Mine ended up being:

1. Midna
2. Dark Samus
3. Krystal
4. Rosalina
5. Professor Layton

Even though I don't care too much about Dark Samus, Krystal, and Layton-- Dixie and Rosalina were put up against Midna, and Lucina was put up against Rosalina... so that's just how it ended up.

Personally, my list is really:
1. Midna
2. Rosalina
3. Palutena
4. Ghirahim
5. TIE- Anna and Tiki

But 4 of those weren't options

Edit: Tried it again and got some different characters and matchups which resulted in:
1. Midna
2. Rosalina
3. Zelda
4. Robin
5. Marth
I like this more
I'll be maining 4/5 of these in SSB4...

Edit 2:
Did it a 3rd time.
1. Midna
2. Rosalina
3. Zelda
4. Dixie Kong
5. Ridley

Poor Lucina always gets matched up with Rosalina early on every time I do this...

 

[CrazyChaos]

1. Yoshi
2. Midna
3. Mewtwo
4. Mario
5. Isabelle

Charizard or Rosalina should have probably found their way up there though.

 

[dezeray112]

This is what I got:

1. Pikachu
2. Lucina
3. Ike
4. Pit
5. Little Mac

 

[Sun & Moon]

I got this:

1. Kirby
2. Yoshi
3. Ness
4. Toadette
5. Meta Knight

The results would be way different if Bandanna Dee was in it.

 

[DJ3DS]

Mine:

1) Charizard
2) Rosalina
3) King K. Rool
4) PIkachu
5) Link

Link (And to a lesser extent, Pikachu) only got there through luck with brackets though. May try again, see how it goes.

EDIT: After a 2nd go, where I paid a bit more attention to the pairings (skipping if I liked both characters and knew there was a character I liked less than either still in the game), I have this list, which is much more accurate:

1) Charizard
2) Bowser
3) Rosalina
4) King K. Rool
5) Luigi

 

[sunshinesan]

1. Ike
2. Princess Peach
3. Wario
4. Isabelle
5. Lucina

 

[Aureola]

I'm not that happy with the results.

Attempt 1:
Ike
Link
Luigi
Isaac
Roy

Attempt 2:
Link
Shulk
Ike
Midna
Pit

Attempt 3:
Link
Ike
Jenna
Tetra
Shulk

2's probably the closest, but Shulk is not that high up.

 

[God Robert's Cousin]

1.) Kirby
2.) Luigi
3.) Pikmin
4.) Wario
5.) Tingle

 

[Furil]

Boney only appeared twice o_o

 

[Flaxr XIII]

1. Rosalina
2. Shulk
3. Fiora
4. Pit
5. Groose

An okay poll I guess. Disappointed by the lack of Palutena or Anna. And instead we get Boney, Nintendog, and Reggie? Sure...

Second time:
1. Rosalina
2. Lucina
3. Zelda
4. Luigi
5. Pit

 

[Espio264]

Your biases in other threads make a whole lotta sense after seeing these posts. And mine will too:

1. Mewtwo
2. Falco
3. Fox
4. Link
5. Yoshi

 

[Oracle_Summon]

Your biases in other threads make a whole lotta sense after seeing these posts. And mine will too:

1. Mewtwo
2. Falco
3. Fox
4. Link
5. Yoshi

Me?

 

[Espio264]

Me?

Just everyone in general.

 

[Oracle_Summon]

Just everyone in general.

Oh. Okay.

Yeah, this thread helps identify who really likes which Nintendo character.

 

[shinhed-echi]

In reality it should have gone something like:

Little Mac
Red
Isaac
Samus
Nester

THEN
Doc Louis
Jenna
Felix
Charizard
and I guess Pit. He's really lucky to have ended up in the Top 5.

 

[AgentHX]

1. Mewtwo
2. Lucina
3. Donkey Kong
4. Meta Knight
5. Ridley

Pretty accurate, though I would have liked to see Luigi and Ganondorf make the list.

 

[pupNapoleon]

DOG
RED
DEDEDE
MEWTWO
TOAD

Yet Chorus Boys, King K Rool, Isaac, Pit.. these were casualties.
Squirtle is not even on here... which is absurd, considering he is a veteran to Smash. ****ed up poll

SECOND ATTEMPT

1 SQUIRTLE (I used Charizard for him)
2 DUCK HUNT DOG
3 MEWTWO
4 ISAAC
5 CHORUS KIDS

 

[andimidna]

Ah man, Robin fell a place. Here are the new results.

Spoiler

• 1.
  Link
  83%
• 2.
  Samus Aran
  74%
• 3.
  Mario
  72%
• 4.
  Princess Zelda
  71%
• 5.
  Red
  71%
• 6.
  Luigi
  70%
• 7.
  Kirby
  69%
• 8.
  Shigeru Miyamoto
  68%
• 9.
  Pikachu
  68%
• 10.
  Ganondorf
  68%
• 11.
  Mewtwo
  67%
• 12.
  Charizard
  67%
• 13.
  Midna
  66%
• 14.
  Yoshi
  66%
• 15.
  Bowser
  65%
• 16.
  Captain Falcon
  65%
• 17.
  Fox McCloud
  64%
• 18.
  Donkey Kong
  63%
• 19.
  Pit
  61%
• 20.
  Meta Knight
  61%
• 21.
  Professor Oak
  60%
• 22.
  Gary Oak/Blue
  59%
• 23.
  Tetra
  59%
• 24.
  Skull Kid
  59%
• 25.
  Rosalina
  59%
• 26.
  Princess Peach
  57%
• 27.
  Reggie Fils-Aime
  57%
• 28.
  Ness
  57%
• 29.
  Ike
  57%
• 30.
  Ridley
  57%
• 31.
  Lucina
  57%
• 32.
  Marth
  56%
• 33.
  Wario
  56%
• 34.
  Falco Lombardi
  55%
• 35.
  Happy Mask Salesman
  55%
• 36.
  Little Mac
  55%
• 37.
  Diddy Kong
  54%
• 38.
  Master Hand
  54%
• 39.
  Toad
  54%
• 40.
  Navi
  54%
• 41.
  Dark Samus
  53%
• 42.
  King Dedede
  53%
• 43.
  Old Man
  53%
• 44.
  Waluigi
  52%
• 45.
  Professor Layton
  51%
• 46.
  Pikmin
  50%
• 47.
  Wolf O'Donnell
  50%
• 48.
  Robin (Avatar)
  50%
• 49.
  Roy
  49%
• 50.
  Bowser Jr.
  49%

I don't see many changes with the results. Peach passed Ness and Reggie too, but that's pretty much it.
Oh, Toad passed Navi.
Happy Mask Salesman passed Little Mac.
Ike passed Ridley.
Lucina passed Marth.
Gary Oak/Blue passed Tetra.
Yea, that's all.

Played again and got
1. Midna
2. Rosalina
3. Samus
4. Robin
5. Kraid

lol, Kraid's matchups...
And Lucina didn't even show up.

And again...
1. Midna
2. Rosalina
3. Zelda
4. Dixie Kong
5. Shulk
(Lucina was 6th)



How are you guys posting pictures of your top fives?

 

[andimidna]

Well, the results changed quite a bit.

Spoiler

• 1.
  Link
  81%
• 2.
  Samus Aran
  73%
• 3.
  Mario
  70%
• 4.
  Red
  70%
• 5.
  Princess Zelda
  70%
• 6.
  Luigi
  69%
• 7.
  Kirby
  69%
• 8.
  Shigeru Miyamoto
  67%
• 9.
  Pikachu
  67%
• 10.
  Ganondorf
  67%
• 11.
  Mewtwo
  66%
• 12.
  Captain Falcon
  66%
• 13.
  Charizard
  66%
• 14.
  Midna
  66%
• 15.
  Yoshi
  65%
• 16.
  Bowser
  65%
• 17.
  Fox McCloud
  63%
• 18.
  Donkey Kong
  63%
• 19.
  Meta Knight
  61%
• 20.
  Pit
  60%
• 21.
  Professor Oak
  60%
• 22.
  Gary Oak/Blue
  59%
• 23.
  Tetra
  59%
• 24.
  Reggie Fils-Aime
  58%
• 25.
  Rosalina
  58%
• 26.
  Ness
  58%
• 27.
  Skull Kid
  58%
• 28.
  Ike
  58%
• 29.
  Wario
  57%
• 30.
  Ridley
  57%
• 31.
  Marth
  57%
• 32.
  Princess Peach
  57%
• 33.
  Lucina
  56%
• 34.
  Little Mac
  56%
• 35.
  Happy Mask Salesman
  55%
• 36.
  Falco Lombardi
  55%
• 37.
  Diddy Kong
  54%
• 38.
  Master Hand
  54%
• 39.
  King Dedede
  54%
• 40.
  Toad
  54%
• 41.
  Waluigi
  54%
• 42.
  Navi
  53%
• 43.
  Dark Samus
  53%
• 44.
  Professor Layton
  52%
• 45.
  Old Man
  52%
• 46.
  Pikmin
  51%
• 47.
  Robin (Avatar)
  50%
• 48.
  Lucas
  49%
• 49.
  Wolf O'Donnell
  49%
• 50.
  Roy
  48%

Also, finally got Lucina in my top 5 with my new try

1. Midna
2. Lucina
3. Rosalina
4. Marth or Shulk (don't remember)
5. Dixie Kong

Edit: whoops, posted from the first page so I had no idea I had the most recent post on the 2nd page

 

[TerminalMontage]

First and only time, I got:

1. K. Rool
2. Skullkid
3. Ganondorf
4. Yoshi
5. Link

 

[ElPanandero]

1. Issac
2. Ganondorf
3. Skull Kid
4. Peppy Hair
5. Cranky Kong

Love this list

Got Ganon vs. Happy Mask Salesman way too early though, he should have been 3rd

 

[Da Black Rabbit]

1. Link
2. Felix
3. Andy
4. Issac
5. Ike

I took it again because something just didn't feel right. I LOVE Golden Sun but...I REALLY LOVE LoZ and Fire Emblem.
...and then I get this...

1. Link
2. Issac
3. Andy
4. Ike
5. Felix

So yeah, guess that is it. I really wish Sheik and Impa where on there or Will from Days of Ruin. He would replace Andy but, meh...

Weird Shigeru and Reggie are in the poll and I also got a Scribblenaut character. I thought he was third party belonging to WB. Some of my martchups where hard. Putting Ike against Link is not fair. Neither is Issac vs Felix. I had to skip a few when I couldn't handle the pressure. I wish Bowser Jr. and Mewtwo where up there. I wish I could tell who my top picks are beyond 5. Bowser Jr. and Mewtwo had to be top ten.

 

[Kokopops]

1. Samus
2. Dixie Kong
3. Rosalina
4. Link
5. Princess Peach