The 25 Most Requested Things In Smash

[supercopper64]

1. Mewtwo playable
2. Roy playabe
3. Reggie playabe for some odd reason
4. Miis playable
5. Wii U eshop demo
6. Customizable movesets
7. Customizable color swaps
8. Ridley playable
9. Wavedash return
10. Tripping go bye-bye
11. Gamecube controller input
12. Low prices (fyi the won't be low)
13. For this game to save Nintendo
14. Huge rostet
15. Banjo-Kazooie playable
16. Faster paced game
17. Cool adventure mode
18. A Wii U exclusive game mode
19. The break the targets are all different for each character again (from Melee)
20. Chrom playable
21. Ridley as a boss character
22. NFP to be used for smash
23. NFP NOT to be used for smash!
24. Fair release dates
25. FOR THIS GAME TO BE BETTER THAN BRAWL

 

[supercopper64]

Keep in mind, this is not a wishlist, these are requested by the fan base overall, and I definitely don't agree with some of these...

 

[Tornado_Man]

you forgot...

Spoiler

goku

 

[Gameboi834]

I don't understand what the point if this topic is. Also it doesn't have Pac Man. Or Palutena.

 

[Morbi]

The only request that isn't already listed, Black Shadow. Everyone requests him... they just don't know it, yet.

 

[Hitzel]

I don't think Mewtwo is on the list outside of this close-knit community, honestly. It's kinda fascinating to see lol. If he is on the list I don't think he's #1.

 

[Jellyfish4102]

Also Shrek at least in Miiverse lol.

 

[Ragel]

I need my Roy boy back .
I always see a lot of people asking for some "Chorus Men" but honestly I find them pretty dull.

 

[Canuckduck]

1. Mewtwo playable - (...eh)
2. Roy playabe - (Maybe)
3. Reggie playabe for some odd reason - (YES!)
4. Miis playable - (DEFINITELY, I'D PROBABLY MAIN THEM!)
5. Wii U eshop demo - (It would be much appreciated)
6. Customizable movesets - (That's already happening)
7. Customizable color swaps - (Nope)
8. Ridley playable - (Eww, no)
9. Wavedash return - (It'd be cool)
10. Tripping go bye-bye - (No, tripping can stay, RANDOM TRIPPING can go bye-bye)
11. Gamecube controller input - (Uh, no)
12. Low prices (fyi the won't be low) - (It will be $59.99, at my estimate)
13. For this game to save Nintendo - (Nintendo is doing fine)
14. Huge rostet - (No more than 40 characters, please)
15. Banjo-Kazooie playable - (Not gonna happen)
16. Faster paced game - (I'd want the pace to be somewhere between Brawl and Melee, but a little more like Melee)
17. Cool adventure mode - (Okay)
18. A Wii U exclusive game mode - (Yeah, that'll probably happen)
19. The break the targets are all different for each character again (from Melee) - (Totally, Brawl completely bummed me out about that)
20. Chrom playable - (Sure)
21. Ridley as a boss character - (It'll happen on the Metroid stage)
22. NFP to be used for smash - (HECK NAW)
23. NFP NOT to be used for smash! - (HECK YES!)
24. Fair release dates - (Yes, I'ld like that)
25. FOR THIS GAME TO BE BETTER THAN BRAWL - (I want it to be WAY better than brawl!)

My responses are in bold and underlined.

 

[KatKit]

Ha, I would've thought it was requesting an immediate release, or at least an official release date.

 

[MargnetMan23]

I think Chrom playable and Chrom not playable should go on the same wish-list if we're only counting smashboards.

 

[Mr. Mumbles]

What methodology did you use to compile these?

 

[MargnetMan23]

Also, in that same vein Miis NOT playable probably places higher than Miis playable if we judge only by smashboards xD

 

[Morbi]

I would say that most people request for innovation in the game, but I would be lying.

 

[Dr.Megaman]

You forgot Goku

 

[Dr. James Rustles]

What methodology did you use to compile these?

He used a complex algorithm that combed through every post on Smashboards, GameFAQs, and Miiverse, searching for desired ideas and objects through regular expressions for preference. If the desirable already existed in its array, it incremented the number of times it had seen it; if it did not exist in the array it slapped it on the end of it. When it was finished, the array of desirables was sorted greatest to least in the number of times seen with the top 25 posted here.

The algorithm is located in his ass.

 

[Aninymouse]

What methodology did you use to compile these?

Yeah, seriously. Where is this stuff coming from, OP? Just pulling it out your butt, or are you basing this on something?

 

[Rich Homie Quan]

#25 should probably be #1.

 

[Morbi]

Yeah, seriously. Where is this stuff coming from, OP? Just pulling it out your butt, or are you basing this on something?

It is supposed to be based on popular requests discerned by the OP, so empirical knowledge basically.

 

[Aninymouse]

It is supposed to be based on popular requests discerned by the OP, so empirical knowledge basically.

I wish I were as based as OP.

 

[Chiroz]

I don't think Mewtwo is on the list outside of this close-knit community, honestly. It's kinda fascinating to see lol. If he is on the list I don't think he's #1.

There was a poll done by Sakurai after Brawl in which Mewtwo was 2nd only to Megaman if I remember correctly.

Mewtwo was also the 2nd most popular pokemon right after Charizard in a poll about 2-3 years ago. (before X/Y were even announced and mega evolutions were still not known, which means his "popularity" has only risen since then).

He also made it to the quarter finals (top ~30 out of all video game characters in existence) next to Charizard and Pikachu (and I believe Squirtle) in Gamefaqs most popular characters of all time, which include characters like Sephiroth, Link, Mario, etc.



Mewtwo's popularity is not only confined to this community.

 

[Canuckduck]

There was a poll done by Sakurai after Brawl in which Mewtwo was 2nd only to Megaman if I remember correctly.

Mewtwo was also the 2nd most popular pokemon right after Charizard in a poll about 2-3 years ago. (before X/Y were even announced and mega evolutions were still not known, which means his "popularity" has only risen since then).

He also made it to the quarter finals next to Charizard and Pikachu (and I believe Squirtle) in Gamefaqs most popular characters of all time, which include characters like Sephiroth, Link, Mario, etc.



Mewtwo's popularity is not only confined to this community.

I think that only Mewtwo or Lucario should be a smasher in SSB4. Their movesets, attack techniques, strengths, and weaknesses are too particularly similar to not be considered "clones".


But then again, most people do want Mewtwo, so I wouldn't object if they put him in.

 

[Morbi]

I think that only Mewtwo or Lucario should be a smasher in SSB4. Their movesets, attack techniques, strengths, and weaknesses are too particularly similar to not be considered "clones".


But then again, most people do want Mewtwo, so I wouldn't object if they put him in.

They don't really share anything other than their shadow ball and aura sphere though, so I don't see your point.

 

[Chiroz]

I think that only Mewtwo or Lucario should be a smasher in SSB4. Their movesets, attack techniques, strengths, and weaknesses are too particularly similar to not be considered "clones".


But then again, most people do want Mewtwo, so I wouldn't object if they put him in.

They have 2 moves which share the exact same properties and 2 that share the same animations (with completely different properties). There are 20+ moves in Smash.

Mewtwo is a relatively fast character (attack wise, he runs really slow) with hard to aim/land attacks, he also lacks range and priority and most of his attacks are just garbage. Lucario on the other hand is slow but effective. His abilities are easy to aim but have large windup which make it very easy to dodge. Completely different properties.

They are just both anthro pokemons which have similar attack styles and that's it. Luigi is closer to a clone of Mario than Lucario is to Mewtwo.

 

[DakotaBonez]

Although he pulled this list out of his a$#, I can't argue with it.

 

[soviet prince]

1.ridley
2.ridley
3.ridley
4.ridley
5.ridley
6.ridley
7.ridley
8.ridley
9. ridley
10.ridley
11.ridley
12.ridley
13.ridley
14.ridley
15.ridley
16.ridley
17.ridley
18.ridley
19.ridley
20.ridley
21.ridley
22. ridley
23.ridley
24. ridley
25. ridley

honprable mentions:
RIDLEY

 

[TJ-Works]

So more people haven't asked for K. Rool over Banjo-Kazooie?

Although it's your own list, I don't think you've done enough research.

 

[D-idara]

1. Mewtwo playable
2. Roy playabe
3. Reggie playabe for some odd reason
4. Miis playable
5. Wii U eshop demo
6. Customizable movesets
7. Customizable color swaps
8. Ridley playable
9. Wavedash return
10. Tripping go bye-bye
11. Gamecube controller input
12. Low prices (fyi the won't be low)
13. For this game to save Nintendo
14. Huge rostet
15. Banjo-Kazooie playable
16. Faster paced game
17. Cool adventure mode
18. A Wii U exclusive game mode
19. The break the targets are all different for each character again (from Melee)
20. Chrom playable
21. Ridley as a boss character
22. NFP to be used for smash
23. NFP NOT to be used for smash!
24. Fair release dates
25. FOR THIS GAME TO BE BETTER THAN BRAWL

I don't understand this NFP hate, Nintendo's not a moneygrubbing company, besides, who wouldn't want awesome Nintendo figurines? And most people have already moved on to the Wii U Pro.

 

[Moon Monkey]

1. Mewtwo playable Yes!
2. Roy playable Yes!
3. Reggie playabe for some odd reason. If Mii's are indeed in the roster I'm blaming everyone that requested this.
4. Miis playable No.
5. Wii U eshop demo Yes!
6. Customizable movesets Sounds interesting. Hopefully can be implemented in a good way.
7. Customizable color swaps
8. Ridley playable Would be nice, though it is just wishful thinking at this point
9. Wavedash return Not really an advocate for bringing this back, rather just streamline everything.
10. Tripping go bye-bye Yes.
11. Gamecube controller input It's time to move one. Wii U pro controller will be just find. I wouldn't mind a GC pro controller though!
12. FOR THIS GAME TO BE BETTER THAN BRAWL No tripping and signs of hitstun, Mission Complete

13. Online Voice Chat
14. King K. Rool playable
15 No Paper Mario
16. Toon Link using 1 or 2 moves from Windwaker
17. Yoshi has a tongue tether recovery
18. Sonic side special and down specials are two different moves.
19. Wario has more Wario Land moves.
20. Metaknight becoming the inverse of Little Mac, horrible on the ground good in the air.
21. Chrom being playable

22. Chrom to use a Javelin as a projectile.​

23. Chain grabs be fixed via implementation of grab teching
24. R.O.B becomes a Nintendo Megazord of all of Nintendo's systems for his final smash.
25. Game is released in Nov.

 

[Hitzel]

I feel that if Miis are playable, they will only be for the custom moveset modes or whatever.

 

[Pixxler]

Man i wanted dark samus to be playable but it's a assist trophy -.-

 

[R0Y]

Lol, this list is made up and the order is weird.

No Palutena yet Banjo-Kazooie, who are owned by Microsoft and impossible are on this list...

Chrom but no Lucina?

1. Mewtwo playable MEH
2. Roy playabe YES
3. Reggie playabe for some odd reason NO
4. Miis playable NO
5. Wii U eshop demo SURE
6. Customizable movesets MEH
7. Customizable color swaps MEH
8. Ridley playable YES
9. Wavedash return YES
10. Tripping go bye-bye YES
11. Gamecube controller input MEH
12. Low prices (fyi the won't be low) YES BUT NOT GONNA HAPPEN
13. For this game to save Nintendo YES
14. Huge rostet YES
15. Banjo-Kazooie playable YES BUT NOT GONNA HAPPEN
16. Faster paced game YES
17. Cool adventure mode YES
18. A Wii U exclusive game mode YES
19. The break the targets are all different for each character again (from Melee) YES
20. Chrom playable MEH
21. Ridley as a boss character ALREADY CONFIRMED HE'S AT LEAST A BOSS
22. NFP to be used for smash NOOOOOOOOOO
23. NFP NOT to be used for smash! YEEEEEEEEEEEESSSS
24. Fair release dates Ummm, what?
25. FOR THIS GAME TO BE BETTER THAN BRAWL ALREADY IS

 

[BADGRAPHICS]

1. Mewtwo playable
2. Roy playabe
3. Reggie playabe for some odd reason
4. Miis playable
5. Wii U eshop demo
6. Customizable movesets
7. Customizable color swaps
8. Ridley playable
9. Wavedash return
10. Tripping go bye-bye
11. Gamecube controller input
12. Low prices (fyi the won't be low)
13. For this game to save Nintendo
14. Huge rostet
15. Banjo-Kazooie playable
16. Faster paced game
17. Cool adventure mode
18. A Wii U exclusive game mode
19. The break the targets are all different for each character again (from Melee)
20. Chrom playable
21. Ridley as a boss character
22. NFP to be used for smash
23. NFP NOT to be used for smash!
24. Fair release dates
25. FOR THIS GAME TO BE BETTER THAN BRAWL

[citation needed]

 

[Dr.Megaman]

I would want them to make Sonic a little stronger

 

[Dark Dude]

I would also like to request a source for this information.


And, I'll also give my two cents on each one, just for excrements and giggles.
1. Mewtwo playable - I would like to see Mewtwo back, personally.
2. Roy playabe - I did like Roy in Melee, but wouldn't be too concerned if he didn't return.
3. Reggie playabe for some odd reason - Not interested in this at all.
4. Miis playable - I expect this to happen and so have already come to terms with it. I don't care.
5. Wii U eshop demo - This would be great.
6. Customizable movesets - Already been confirmed in the direct.
7. Customizable color swaps - Would be neat.
8. Ridley playable - Not gonna happen. Already been confirmed as a stage hazard for pyrosphere.
9. Wavedash return - Sure.
10. Tripping go bye-bye - I think this has already been confirmed.
11. Gamecube controller input - Already possible with an adapter.
12. Low prices (fyi the won't be low) - Well, yeah. I'm sure most people would like that.
13. For this game to save Nintendo - Nintendo doesn't need saving, the Wii U does. It would be nice, but even if the Wii U doesn't do much better Nintendo isn't going to give up.
14. Huge rostet - Didn't Brawl already have like 40-something characters? I'm sure this game will at least have as many, so that's big enough for me.
15. Banjo-Kazooie playable - Entirely unrealistic. Might as well group him in with Goku and Buttercup.
16. Faster paced game - Faster than Brawl? Yeah.
17. Cool adventure mode - Yeah, I'd like that.
18. A Wii U exclusive game mode - I have no doubts that there will be. Why would the 3DS get an exclusive game mode but not the game on the system that is capable of doing much more than the 3DS? This shouldn't even need to be said, imo.
19. The break the targets are all different for each character again (from Melee) - I don't care about this one. I do find it interesting to see how better / worse characters are in the same situation, plus asking for 40+ BtT stages seems to be asking a bit much.
20. Chrom playable - Sure.
21. Ridley as a boss character - Already confirmed as a stage hazard.
22. NFP to be used for smash - Not interested.
23. NFP NOT to be used for smash! - Sure.
24. Fair release dates - I don't know what constitutes as fair here.
25. FOR THIS GAME TO BE BETTER THAN BRAWL - Yeah, I think people typically expect sequels to be better than the game before it.

 

[Joe73191]

please OP, give a source, this interesting but I need to know where you are getting this from.

 

[Aguki90]

1. Mewtwo playable-Yeah
2. Roy playabe-Kinda yes
3. Reggie playabe for some odd reason-Not yet
4. Miis playable-NO!
5. Wii U eshop demo-YES!!!
6. Customizable movesets-Its happening!
7. Customizable color swaps-Want!
8. Ridley playable-Eww nope.
9. Wavedash return-Put that in melee mode!
10. Tripping go bye-bye-RANDOM TRIPPING NEED TO BE GONE, normal tripping is ok.
11. Gamecube controller input-The melee fanbase never change. is ok for real.
12. Low prices (fyi the won't be low)-Well, Is gonna 59.99 Wii U, I hope 3DS are 39.99.
13. For this game to save Nintendo-Nintendo is ok but need more money from this.
14. Huge rostet- I wish but the 3DS LACK FOR THIS.
15. Banjo-Kazooie playable-"Belong to Microsoft"T_T.
16. Faster paced game-Somehow is becoming faster than brawl.
17. Cool adventure mode-I think in Wii U version with the melee style.
18. A Wii U exclusive game mode-Boss Battle pls.
19. The break the targets are all different for each character again (from Melee)-We need this!
20. Chrom playable-Is ok
21. Ridley as a boss character-YES AGAIN YES!!!
22. NFP to be used for smash-I dont kwon!
23. NFP NOT to be used for smash!-I dont kwon
24. Fair release dates-Fair and smart.
25. FOR THIS GAME TO BE BETTER THAN BRAWL-This need to happen.

 

[R0Y]

please OP, give a source, this interesting but I need to know where you are getting this from.

He pulled it out of his bum. Palutena not being on it is one of many problems.

 

[pwnzorz]

1.ridley
2.ridley
3.ridley
4.ridley
5.ridley
6.ridley
7.ridley
8.ridley
9. ridley
10.ridley
11.ridley
12.ridley
13.ridley
14.ridley
15.ridley
16.ridley
17.ridley
18.ridley
19.ridley
20.ridley
21.ridley
22. ridley
23.ridley
24. ridley
25. ridley

honprable mentions:
RIDLEY

This list makes more sense and is well sourced.

 

[Kevandre]

It's strange because I generally see Smashboards as the only place that legitimately prefers Melee over Brawl. Talking to humans irl they definitely prefer Brawl or Project M over Melee, myself included