The ‘Would you rather have in smash?’ game thread

[osby]

Retro ones. Though don't they also suprise characters? And I don't think we got something close to a joke character apart from them, if you don't count Wii Fit Trainer or Pichu but they aren't exactly in the same boat.

WYR have Rosalina without Luma or Link with Navi?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

Link with Navi I guess, though that would be really weird...

WYR have Alph as an Olimar clone with rock pikmin, or leave him as an alt?

 

[Blargg888]

Link with Navi I guess, though that would be really weird...

WYR have Alph as an Olimar clone with rock pikmin, or leave him as an alt?

Olimar Clone.

Would you rather have Master Chief or Steve added to the game?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

Steve, fits smash way better.

WYR have Bomberman added or have Snake back?

 

[osby]

Snake back.
WYR have Ulala from Space Channel 5 or Aiai from Super Monkey Ball to have trophies in the game?

 

[Freduardo]

Aiai

Would you rather Navi’s “Hey listen” be turned into a taunt for Link or Baby Mario’s crying sound from Yoshi’s Island Be turned into a taunt for Bowser Jr.... knowing full well that whichever one you pick will be spammed incessantly?

 

[Blargg888]

Aiai

Would you rather Navi’s “Hey listen” be turned into a taunt for Link or Baby Mario’s crying sound from Yoshi’s Island Be turned into a taunt for Bowser Jr.... knowing full well that whichever one you pick will be spammed incessantly?

Baby Mario's crying. It's the more annoying of the two.

Would you rather have the ability to insert your own custom stage music via SD Card, or your own custom stage backgrounds via SD Card?

 

[osby]

Custom music. Custom BG would be too weird.
WYR have five new Assist Trophies or ten new Pokeball Pokemon?

 

[LoZ00]

Custom music. Custom BG would be too weird.
WYR have five new Assist Trophies or ten new Pokeball Pokemon?

Ten new Pokéball Pokémon. Honestly, I've always thought that Pokéballs make more sense than Assist Trophies.

WYR have Eevee (the new mascot alongside Pikachu) or Decidueye?

 

[Blargg888]

Ten new Pokéball Pokémon. Honestly, I've always thought that Pokéballs make more sense than Assist Trophies.

WYR have Eevee (the new mascot alongside Pikachu) or Decidueye?

Decidueye. I like the idea a bit more than Eevee.
Would you rather have a new character with lots of Projectile reflecting moves, or one with lots of counters?

 

[osby]

Decidueye. I like the idea a bit more than Eevee.
Would you rather have a new character with lots of Projectile reflecting moves, or one with lots of counters?

Reflectors. But are any of them is possible?
Would you rather use Jigglypuff or Ganondorf against Bayonetta?

 

[Blargg888]

Reflectors. But are any of them is possible?
Would you rather use Jigglypuff or Ganondorf against Bayonetta?

Ganondorf

Would you rather have Ivysaur and Squirtle or Pichu and Wolf return?

 

[osby]

Ganondorf

Would you rather have Ivysaur and Squirtle or Pichu and Wolf return?

Pichu and Wolf.
WYR have new Kid Icarus stage or assist trophy?

 

[Violenceman]

WYR have new Kid Icarus stage or assist trophy?

Stage. An Underworld stage would be BOSS.

Would you rather have a de-cloned Gannondorf that fights with dark magic and a giant sword or a de-cloned Toon Link with an arsenal of items from the handheld Zelda games (Whip, Tornado Rod, etc)?

 

[osby]

Stage. An Underworld stage would be BOSS.

Would you rather have a de-cloned Gannondorf that fights with dark magic and a giant sword or a de-cloned Toon Link with an arsenal of items from the handheld Zelda games (Whip, Tornado Rod, etc)?

I mean, Ganondorf already uses dark magic and swords won't make him interesting at this point, so Toon Link.
Two Samus or two Links?

 

[Yoshi-Thomas]

I mean, Ganondorf already uses dark magic and swords won't make him interesting at this point, so Toon Link.
Two Samus or two Links?

Two Links.
Best Stage Editor ever made but no adventure mode at all
or
Brawl's adventure like mode but no Stage Editor at all?

 

[osby]

Two Links.
Best Stage Editor ever made but no adventure mode at all
or
Brawl's adventure like mode but no Stage Editor at all?

Exact same mode? Still take it over stage editor, I'm emotional.
WYR have all musics available on all stages but no new remixes or vice versa?

 

[nirvanafan]

all music on all stages w/ no remixes (tend to prefer the originals anyway)
would you rather geno or sora be added

 

[ZagarTulip]

I'd say Sora

Would you rather have Micaiah (from Fire Emblem) or Krystal (from StarFox) be playable?

 

[CannonStreak]

Krystal.

Would you rather have a new story mode or an all new solo mode?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

New story mode would be craaazy awesome


WYR have Crash or Spyro added?

 

[CannonStreak]

Crash Bandicoot, of course!

Would you rather have new items or new stages?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

New stages, items are pretty boring.


WYR have Midna or Skull Kid?

 

[Autumn ♫]

Midna!

WYR have the music uncut or have a battlefield stage option like the omega option in 4?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

Uncut music id say!

WYR have omega forms return or have an option to just turn off hazards on regular stages?

 

[CannonStreak]

Omega Forms.

Would you rather have Simon Belmont or Bomberman?

 

[Arcadenik]

Omega Forms.

Would you rather have Simon Belmont or Bomberman?

Simon Belmont

Would you rather have Toad or Captain Toad as the default character (the other will be alternate costume)?

 

[Gameboi834]

Simon Belmont

Would you rather have Toad or Captain Toad as the default character (the other will be alternate costume)?

If the other is gonna be a costume, then I'd say regular Toad. We can have different colored Toads as alt skins and Captain Toad as another skin, a la Alph or Skyward Sword Link. Plus we get other source material such as SMB2 and SM3DW that way.

Would you rather have Smash 5 have 70+ okay characters or less than 30 amazing characters?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

70+ OK characters

WYR have Poison Mushrooms changed to Mini Mushrooms and give higher jumps, faster speed and stronger attack in exchange for a lighter weight, or have them be 1HKO items?

 

[osby]

70+ OK characters

WYR have Poison Mushrooms changed to Mini Mushrooms and give higher jumps, faster speed and stronger attack in exchange for a lighter weight, or have them be 1HKO items?

Mini Mushrooms, lightweight.
WYR Flipper or Bumper?

 

[nirvanafan]

Flipper
Would you rather balloon fighter or excite biker as a new rep

 

[osby]

Excite Biker, I can't really see how Balloon Fighter can... well, fight.
WYR have Lip or Mach Rider?

 

[LoZ00]

Excite Biker, I can't really see how Balloon Fighter can... well, fight.
WYR have Lip or Mach Rider?

I guess Mach Rider, just because Lip would use her stick, that would make her broken.

WYR have Waluigi or Captain Toad?

 

[osby]

I guess Mach Rider, just because Lip would use her stick, that would make her broken.

WYR have Waluigi or Captain Toad?

Captain Toad, Waluigi is gross.
WYR have a new Paper Mario stage or a Super Mario RPG stage?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Paper Mario, preferably based on Colour Splash.

would you rather give R.O.B. his own Gyromite stage, or give the Ice Climbers a new 8-bit stage?

 

[osby]

Paper Mario, preferably based on Colour Splash.

would you rather give R.O.B. his own Gyromite stage, or give the Ice Climbers a new 8-bit stage?

I think R.O.B. deserve a stage at this point.
Would you rather have a 8-bit Kid Icarus stage or a modern Duck Hunt stage?

 

[ZagarTulip]

A modern Duck Hunt Stage

Would you rather bring back Brinstar Depths or Fourside as a stage?

 

[Autumn ♫]

A modern Duck Hunt Stage

Would you rather bring back Brinstar Depths or Fourside as a stage?

Fourside! Fourside was so frickin cool!

Would you rather bring back Spear Pillar or N's Castle?

 

[Freduardo]

N’s castle. People get too whiny when Dialga does a time shift.

Would you rather have the original Super Mario Bros. Stage (the one with the platforms on a pulley) OR Subcon OR a similar stage, but this one done in Super Mario Bros. 3 style?

 

[ZagarTulip]

The Original Super Mario Bros. Stage

Would you rather have a 3rd Gen Pokemon or a 5th Gen Pokemon playable?