Match-Up Leaders

[Shök]

Thanks to IvanEva for creating and posting the chart.

I've looked it over and Made an average for the leading characters.

A Big Advantage is worth 2 points, a slight advantage is worth 1, a neutral is 0, a slight disadvantage takes away one point and a big diadvantage takes away 2 points.

Snake:
BA: 1
SA: 26
N: 9
SD: 2
BD: 0
AVG: 26

Meta Knight:
BA: 1
SA: 29
N: 6
SD: 2
BD: 0
AVG: 29

Marth:
BA: 4
SA: 24
N: 7
SD: 3
BD: 0
AVG: 29

Falco:
BA: 2
SA: 23
N: 9
SD: 3
AVG: 24

G&W:
BA: 8
SA: 23
N: 5
SD: 2
BD: 0
AVG: 37 (Shocker)

R.O.B.:
BA: 0
SA: 24
N: 8
SD: 6
BD: 0
AVG: 18 (Shocker)

Toon Link:
BA: 1
SA: 23
N: 12
SD: 3
BD: 0
AVG: 22

Pit:
BA: 0
SA: 24
N: 5
SD: 5
BD: 0
AVG: 19

Olimar:
BA: 1
SA: 21
N: 10
SD: 6
BD: 0
AVG: 17

In order
G&W
Marth/MK
Snake
Falco
Toon Link
Pit
R.O.B.
Olimar

I'll edit and get the rest later.
Comment and if you can help w/ some of the averages, it would be greatly appreciated.

 

[∫unk]

You should list all the chars and you should list it in a more readable format... I don't think anyone really cares about anything except the average number. They can find the other data on the matchup chart pretty easily. The actual calculation part is the key of this thread.

And yeah G&W Turtle is good.

 

[House M.D.]

while this is interesting, it is not tantamount to a tier list; in melee sheik had the best total and falco had the fewest bad match-ups (or seemed the best holistically) but fox was still the to pof the tier list.

 

[SnatchForFree]

Just so you know. That match up chart is horribly wrong.

 

[Browny]

this has been done like 10 times before, seriously

 

[acv]

ZOMG GW has so many advantages...everybody should main him over snake.o noes .GW has an avergae of over eleven avobe snake who is considered the best character.GW for god tier.

 

[TehBo49]

while this is interesting, it is not tantamount to a tier list; in melee sheik had the best total and falco had the fewest bad match-ups (or seemed the best holistically) but fox was still the to pof the tier list.

QFT

And this has been done like 50 times before.

 

[ThaRoy]

I edited this to make it n00b friendly, so yeah...

Template:
Number of characters who grants a big advantage (+2 points each):
Number of characters who grants a slight advantage (+1 point each):
Number of characters who grant neither an advantage or disadvantage and are neutral (+/- 0 points each):
Number of characters who grant a slight disadvantage (-1 point each):
Number of characters who grant a big disadvantage (-2 points each):
Sum of points using the formula to calculate the given points to define the placement:

Snake:
Number of characters who grants a big advantage (+2 points each): 1
Number of characters who grants a slight advantage (+1 point each): 26
Number of characters who grant neither an advantage or disadvantage and are neutral (+/- 0 points each): 9
Number of characters who grant a slight disadvantage (-1 point each): 2
Number of characters who grant a big disadvantage (-2 points each): 0
Sum of points using the formula to calculate the given points to define the placement: 26

Meta Knight
Number of characters who grants a big advantage (+2 points each): 1
Number of characters who grants a slight advantage (+1 point each): 29
Number of characters who grant neither an advantage or disadvantage and are neutral (+/- 0 points each): 6
Number of characters who grant a slight disadvantage (-1 point each): 2
Number of characters who grant a big disadvantage (-2 points each): 0
Sum of points using the formula to calculate the given points to define the placement: 29

Marth
Number of characters who grants a big advantage (+2 points each): 4
Number of characters who grants a slight advantage (+1 point each): 24
Number of characters who grant neither an advantage or disadvantage and are neutral (+/- 0 points each): 7
Number of characters who grant a slight disadvantage (-1 point each): 3
Number of characters who grant a big disadvantage (-2 points each): 0
Sum of points using the formula to calculate the given points to define the placement: 29

Falco
Number of characters who grants a big advantage (+2 points each): 2
Number of characters who grants a slight advantage (+1 point each): 23
Number of characters who grant neither an advantage or disadvantage and are neutral (+/- 0 points each): 9
Number of characters who grant a slight disadvantage (-1 point each): 3
Number of characters who grant a big disadvantage (-2 points each): 0
Sum of points using the formula to calculate the given points to define the placement: 24

Mr. Game and Watch
Number of characters who grants a big advantage (+2 points each): 8
Number of characters who grants a slight advantage (+1 point each): 23
Number of characters who grant neither an advantage or disadvantage and are neutral (+/- 0 points each): 5
Number of characters who grant a slight disadvantage (-1 point each): 2
Number of characters who grant a big disadvantage (-2 points each): 0
Sum of points using the formula to calculate the given points to define the placement: 37

ROB
Number of characters who grants a big advantage (+2 points each): 0
Number of characters who grants a slight advantage (+1 point each): 24
Number of characters who grant neither an advantage or disadvantage and are neutral (+/- 0 points each): 8
Number of characters who grant a slight disadvantage (-1 point each): 6
Number of characters who grant a big disadvantage (-2 points each): 0
Sum of points using the formula to calculate the given points to define the placement: 18

Toon Link
Number of characters who grants a big advantage (+2 points each): 1
Number of characters who grants a slight advantage (+1 point each): 23
Number of characters who grant neither an advantage or disadvantage and are neutral (+/- 0 points each): 12
Number of characters who grant a slight disadvantage (-1 point each): 3
Number of characters who grant a big disadvantage (-2 points each): 0
Sum of points using the formula to calculate the given points to define the placement: 22

Pit
Number of characters who grants a big advantage (+2 points each): 0
Number of characters who grants a slight advantage (+1 point each): 24
Number of characters who grant neither an advantage or disadvantage and are neutral (+/- 0 points each): 5
Number of characters who grant a slight disadvantage (-1 point each): 5
Number of characters who grant a big disadvantage (-2 points each): 0
Sum of points using the formula to calculate the given points to define the placement: 19

Olimar
Number of characters who grants a big advantage (+2 points each): 1
Number of characters who grants a slight advantage (+1 point each): 21
Number of characters who grant neither an advantage or disadvantage and are neutral (+/- 0 points each): 10
Number of characters who grant a slight disadvantage (-1 point each): 6
Number of characters who grant a big disadvantage (-2 points each): 0
Sum of points using the formula to calculate the given points to define the placement: 17

Just made a template, copy and pasted it, and just re-entered what values the OP assigned.

kthxbai

 

[Tenki]

But then you'd have to edit it whenever a match-up changes.

It may be all filled in, but as IvanEva said, it's far from "complete"

 

[brawlmaniac]

Well we all knew G & W was the best to begin with, so what's the big surprise???

 

[Arrian]

Here is definitely not surprised with R.O.B.

 

[wasabicheese]

this chart is confusing me...

 

[BEES]

That is about what I would expect the tier list to be.

I still think that too many matchups are marked as advantages for one character, when they probably should be even.

 

[Shök]

Don't get this confused with a tier list.
I'm just listing the Match-Ups and the characters in order.
This doesn't Mean That G&W will be 1st place or Snake will be 3rd.
Sorry if it's been done before.

 

[Crizthakidd]

who are the chars that have that big advantage on? should i go see the matchup chart then>?

 

[Hype]

I still think that too many matchups are marked as advantages for one character, when they probably should be even.

I agree, very slight advantages should just be even.

who are the chars that have that big advantage on? should i go see the matchup chart then>?

yeah just go check the chart. http://www.smashboards.com/showthread.php?t=157979

if he told you anymore info might as well be reposting the whole chart.

To SHOK: I suggest you make the characters ordered from highest average to lowest. this would make it alot easier to compare.