Marth Community Stage List Votes

[Pugwest]

Like people Rate the Tier list i was wondering if the marth community wants to rate marths stages that YOU guys perform well on using Marth.

Rate it from

-2 = Little to no hope
-1 = Stage isn't friendly towards marth
0 = Doesn't affect my performance at all
+1 = I feel comfortable bringing people to this stage
+2 = Feel Unstoppable

I will count up the stage votes and re-post them here with the communities overall average of each stage.

The Stages will be the current "Neutrals" and some "Counter Picks"

Starters

Final Destination
SmashVille
Battle Field
Lylat
Yoshi's Island

CP's

PS1
Frigate
Halberd
Castle Seige
Delfino

 

[Pugwest]

Starters

Final Destination -1
SmashVille 0
Battle Field +1
Lylat 0
Yoshi's Island 0

CP's

PS1 +1
Frigate +1
Halberd -1
Castle Seige +1
Delfino -1

 

[Jeos]

Starters

Final Destination = 1
SmashVille = 1
Battle Field = 1
Lylat = -1
Yoshi's Island = 0

CP's

PS1 = 1
Frigate = -1
Halberd = 1
Castle Seige = 0
Delfino = 0

 

[ScareMl]

Starters

Final Destination = 0
SmashVille = 1
Battle Field = 2
Lylat = -1
Yoshi's Island = 0

CP's

PS1 = 0
Frigate = -1
Halberd = **** this stage, marth sucks *** here -100
Castle Seige = 1
Delfino = -1

 

[MasterOfGalaxies]

Starters

Final Destination = 0
Smashville = 0
Battlefield = 1
Lylat = 1 (mostly because I just like the stage and am comfortable there)
Yoshi's Island = 0

CP's

PS1 = -1 (Never been much of a fan...)
Frigate = 0
Halberd = 0
Castle Seige = 0
Delfino = -1 (Sometimes kind of awkward imo)

I think perhaps a 2 to -2 system would work better, as some of these I feel are way better, like Battlefield, where as some I think are only a little better due to trivial things like personal preference, like Lylat.

 

[Sane]

Starters

Final Destination 0
SmashVille +1
Battle Field +1
Lylat -1
Yoshi's Island 0

CP's

PS1 +1
Frigate -1
Halberd -1
Castle Seige +2
Delfino 0

Unless there is another obvious counterpick, I almost always cp to CS. I don't know why, it's just my favorite stage and being so comfortable on it seems to give me a larger advantage than any other stage.

 

[Raziek]

Starters

Final Destination = -1 (CP for SELECT Match-ups, absolutely hate it otherwise.)
SmashVille = +1
Battle Field= +1
Lylat = +1
Yoshi's Island = 0

CP's

PS1 = -1
Frigate = 0
Halberd = -1/+1 (Varies heavily depending on the matchup. Some I love, some I hate)
Castle Seige = +1
Delfino = +1

To the Lylat haters, learn to move on the stage. We trap SO WELL here.

 

[C.J.]

Final Destination = 0
SmashVille = 0
Battle Field= +1
Lylat = +1
Yoshi's Island = -1 (I hate this stage so much. Ruins my gimps all the time. /mad)

CP's

PS1 = 0
Frigate = 0
Halberd = -1
Castle Seige = +1
Delfino = 0

 

[Foodies]

Final Destination = 0/-1 (depending on MU)
Smashville = 0
Battlefield= +1
Lylat = +1
Yoshi's Island = 0

CP's

PS1 = 0
Frigate = 0/-1 (I usually get screwed more than my opponent here, but that could just be me being bad. I can see how it would be a good CP against some characters but I've never really experimented much)
Halberd = 0
Castle Siege = +1 (I like the first stage transition, and the other ones are okay)
Delfino = -1 (Never really liked this stage)

 

[Ayce God]

final destination 0
smashville +1,000,000 or just +1
battlefield +1
yoshi island 0
lyat cruise 0

castle siege -1
frigate orpheon 0
Pokemon stadium one 0
delphino plaza 0
halberd 0

 

[Prydeless]

Starters

Final Destination -1
SmashVille +1
Battle Field +1
Lylat 0
Yoshi's Island 0

CP's

PS1 0
Frigate -1
Halberd -1
Castle Siege 0
Delfino +1

 

[Nike.]

Starters

Final Destination 0
SmashVille +1
Battle Field +1
Lylat +1
Yoshi's Island 0

CP's

PS1 -1
Frigate -1
Halberd -1
Castle Siege -1
Delfino 0

I absolutely hate PS1 and Castle Siege.

 

[C.J.]

And you wonder why you're a terrible person, Nike
>

CS is amazing.

 

[Nike.]

Remember when you told me to make MK's there that one time and then this happened?

Have NEVER taken anybody there since.

**** that stage.

 

[Shaya]

Getting cged by Dojo as Marth would happen on any stage.

 

[Metakill]

Starters

Final Destination 0
SmashVille +1
Battle Field +2
Lylat +1
Yoshi's Island -1

CP's

PS1 -1
Frigate +1
Halberd -1
Castle Seige 0
Delfino 0

 

[Clel]

Starters

Final Destination +1
Smashville +1
Battlefield +1
Lylat -1
Yoshi's Island -1

CPs

PS1 -1
Frigate -1
Halberd -1
Castle Siege -1
Delfino -1

 

[-J-]

Starters

Final Destination +1
SmashVille +1
Battlefield +2
Lylat +1
Yoshi's Island -1

CP's

PS1 +1
Frigate +1
Halberd -1
Castle Siege +1
Delfino 0

 

[sarajayd]

Starters

Final Destination -1
SmashVille +1
Battle Field +1
Lylat -1
Yoshi's Island 0

CP's

PS1 0
Frigate -1
Halberd -2
Castle Seige +2
Delfino +1

 

[Roy's ouR boy]

Starters

Final Destination 0
Smashville +2
Battlefield +2
Lylat 0
Yoshi's Island 0

CPs

PS1 -1
Frigate 0
Halberd -1
Castle Siege 0
Delfino 1

 

[Sane]

Remember when you told me to make MK's there that one time and then this happened?

Have NEVER taken anybody there since.

**** that stage.

It's not the stages fault you played like trash. No johns on my stage plz ty.

 

[C.J.]

^Bahahahahaha

 

[MasterOfGalaxies]

@Nike
If you actually took people to the stage you would have enough practice with the wonky ledges that you wouldn't kill yourself like that.

 

[Nike.]

Who the **** are these guys?

 

[C.J.]

I have no idea, but I'm dying.

 

[MasterOfGalaxies]

I'm a lurker. Join Date - Oct 2010
I've been frequenting these forums since then, just not posting much. =D

 

[MasterOfGalaxies]

EDIT: glitchy slow Alaskan internet causes double posting. Sorry.

 

[Reizilla]

**** your stage list, it sucks.

Battlefield: +2
Smashville: 0
Pokemon Stadium 1: 0
Pokemon Stadium 2: +2
Yoshi's Island: -1
Lylat Cruise: +1
Final Destination: -1

Halberd: -1
Frigate: 0
Delphino: 0
Japes: -1
Norfair: +1.5
Brinstar: +1
Rainbow Cruise: +1
Castle Siege: +1

 

[C.J.]

wtf Rei, no CS?/

Ihu

 

[Reizilla]

I realized I had forgotten it, but was waiting for someone to post so this thread would show up in my User CP.

Wow. Smashville got way too many +1s. You wimps don't even like fighting MK.

 

[Starline]

Starters

Final Destination -1
Smashville +1
Battlefield +2
Lylat +1
Yoshi's Island 0

CPs

PS1 -1
Frigate 0
Halberd -1
Castle Siege 0
Delfino 0


Edit: But CS is extremely bad vs Dedede.