If you could trade Sonic or Snake for another 3rd party character, would you?

[SuperLink9]

Snake as a WTF character FTW though (lol, WTF and FTW)

If Snake is a WTF character than he pwns ROB in every way, and that means ROB isn't in it! That means the 35 roster is fake! (crazy logic rulz)

EDIT: ... triple post... sorry

 

[Patinator]

Snake for Bomberman.

Sonic stays.

Random empty third party slot for Megaman.

It's nearly perfect... :D

 

[Peeze]

Sonic no. If megaman didnt get the third party slot then i would consider him over snake.

 

[Zevox]

Sonic would stay, period. No third-party character deserves to be in more than he does.

I'd trade Snake for Mega Man in a heartbeat though. Or Knuckles, but of course thats not realistic for Brawl anyway.

Zevox

 

[SiegK]

No.
10char

 

[kaibyaku]

Snake doesn't belong in Smash. I'd switch him out for Megaman for sure.

 

[SuperLink9]

Seeing the Smash Bros community united over Sonic's rightful place is actually pretty moving ^^

I'm not anti-Snake at all, I would have just chosen someone else. Though if Snake is the WFT character over ROB, then YES PLEASE. Keep Snake XD

 

[ComradeCanada]

Sonic I'd get rid of in a heart beat, especially in favor of someone like Ryu, Pheonix Wright, or really just about any non-furry character.
Snake MUST stay, he is the best possible character, and has been wanted since Melee.

 

[~tgm_Zeej]

No way. If Snake was gone, I'd lose the hilarity of beating him with Sonic. :XD

 

[Uchiha.Sanosuke]

Meh, the third party reps are pretty good as they are now. I'd want Megaman in, but not if he was going to replace one of the ones we have now.

Phoenix Wright, on the other hand...I'd take him over anyone any day.

 

[Deathstroke22]

I'd keep Sonic but trade Snake for Crash Bandicoot. I agree that the realism of Snake feel out of place in Smash Bros. but I'm sure I will learn to love it.

 

[DeuceBlade]

Take out Snake for sora.

 

[JohnAnon]

Hell no.

There doesn't need to be any more 3rd parties.

 

[SuperLink9]

I wouldn't have Phoenix Wright over Sonic or Bomberman... but absolutely anyone else... XD

He'd be so cool O_O he'd be such a WTF character... I can't even imagine how he'd move... :S

 

[ROOOOY!]

I would sacrifice Snake for Megaman in a heartbeat...

You've said it all there, really.

 

[Machete]

Sonic I'd get rid of in a heart beat, especially in favor of someone like Ryu, Pheonix Wright, or really just about any non-furry character.
Snake MUST stay, he is the best possible character, and has been wanted since Melee.

Sonic has been wanted since the Sega-Nintendo rivalry.

 

[T.U.C.]

sonic for goku
snake for naruto

P.S. i'm just kidding

 

[Astrinax]

snake out, megaman in

 

[Macrofly]

Snake for Megaman for sure.

Anyone who doesn't hate everything that's good should want to keep Sonic for the 3rd party slot...there's just no reason for anyone else to have it.

(First time I've been able to get through to SWF in THREE DAYS... Freaking lag, I don't even have a slow computer/internet either...)

 

[Grandeza]

Sonic stays. Snake goes for Crash Bandicoot. Pshhh i wish..

 

[Shuma]

Sonic out, Megaman in. I never liked Sonic, and Snake is Rambo.

 

[super ginger kid]

I would get rid of sonic for a megaman rep any day, yeah i like sonic i want to play as him, but i rather be a megaman character........As for snake, nope i would never get rid of him, i have been wanting to play as him since he was announced, you may call a mgs fanboy(i have played most of the mgs games).Sonic just lost his place with me ever since he was on the dreamcast. I would rather have metal sonic than sonic. There is some i would trade for snake, it would be gray fox or liquid...........

 

[plasmatorture]

-Snake
+Simon Belmont

And if we could do other trades as well...
-Sheik
+Geno
-Zamus
+Ridley

>>

 

[darkhamsterlord]

I would definately, without a doubt trade Snake for Megaman

 

[Windlord]

-Snake
+Amaterasu (Okami)

 

[lint789]

I'd replace snake with sonic and sonic with snake.

 

[BraveDave88]

Oh man, I love Sonic and Snake both, but I'm afraid I would have to trade Sonic for the Blue Bomber.

 

[Igneous42]

I would trade Sonic for Dante any day.

 

[Noypi_GjD]

Neither, I'm quite satisfied with Snake and Sonic. Geno and Megaman are both good... but they simply aren't as awesome as Snake/Sonic. I'd rather have Viewtiful Joe over Megaman anyday.