Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
No, that isn't a typo. Thug made a big read post, a portion of which was dedicated to yours truly with respect to him thinking I'm Town. I was making a joke.
Sorry, I went to bed right after posting that. My top 3 scum leans at the moment are Zaixl and Glyph for reasons I mentioned yesterday, and the Fanny because his play this game seems drastically different from the only other game I've played with him and I don't really see anything of significance that came from his slot D1. I really want to give Zaixl a vote, but I also want to give his slot another chance when the new person replaces in. I'd vote Glyph so he's have to get his butt in here, but I feel like if I voted him right now, the WIFOM garbage surrounding the first shot would crop up again and waste everyone's time. I'll definitely look into hin later today, but for now, I'll do this:
What disagreement? There's no "disagreement" to be had because J wasn't making any argument there. He made what I thought was a dumb and pointless question, hence the tone, I was trying to get an answer, and a read, out of him.
"Mechanical" Suggest Thug was looking at the game from a perspective that ignores player's intents and thread context, try again.
I know you can read Bardul, so read again. I didn't chalk up his actions to WIFOM I was telling everyone else NOT TO because everyone keeps saying "why would Scum!Glyph put so much attention on himself?" A textbook-definition WIFOM approach, something that you are STILL doing with this slot.
Invalid, given the above.
lmao, me trying to bounce off Laundry to get better reads on him, and his targets is bothersome just because you are part of the question? Please.
Startk reads doesn't mean much., just as having similar reads with someone else shouldn't mean much either. How is this worrisome? Why act now instead of before?
He doesn't have to do a damn thing to "lead" once he has set the seeds and the rest of thread moves in motion, specially considering that if he is scum, his teamates would do that for him.
what
You conveniently leave out that it was about 1 hour to deadline, Maven had 6 votes, and Glyph had 3. No one else was gunning for glyph, it was either vote Maven, or risk a no lynch. Get out of of here with this nonsense.
How do you feel after mavens flip
I will when you get out of black and white valley and realize nobody's citing Glyfe's meta as a major reason for him being town.
"my d1 play is clean"
If anything, the consistency to the WIFOM argument as an explanation of "why would Glyfe do this scum" and an earnest interest to that slot reads far more townie than Maven's silly backpedal and is a significant reason the latter got lynched despite similarities in their play. Regardless, I don't like the "well this isn't as bad as I thought" despite your vote remaining and you going through the wall and still explaining why you think he's scum. It fits right in with that "clean play" image.
Based on Revivial of DGames D1, Fanny posted 43 times, a vast majority of which were legitimate questions that others didn't ask, observations that progressed the game along, or stating his viewpoint on how the game has progressed thus far. In D1 of this game, however,I'mma need some major citations on that Fanny claim.
Kinda sorta not really? I'm curious as to why J 180'd on him so quickly but given the circumstances of it I'd rather not press further. Regardless, I still think he and Bardull are my priority picks coming into today, I just haven't gotten moving yet. You'll see me tonight almost certainly.
lol that lynch was ofc bad. There was practically no way he was scum because A. he had the same reads as me B. came up with them naturally with read progression in thread. We had the same reads in our Newbie game together as town and basically won the game by working with each other.
? What do you mean by this?Thank you Spak.
Having the same reads (or vastly different reads) means absolutely nothing. Jussayin
"he wasn't scum because he had the same reads but I voted him anyways"
I never voted Maven. Hello?
Whos this directed to
I do have to go back and see his reasoning on Maven, but he was one of the first people to scum read Maven and the primary pusher behind his lynch. Laundry actually believed in his push and it makes more sense for Mafia to sneak into the lynch line later on seeing how the Maven wagon was gaining steam at that time.
Because my main concern with the slot was inconsistency of playstyle between a confirmed townie Fanny and a currently playing, unconfirmed Fanny. I was adamant because I remembered very little about his slot from this game (even after re-reading) and still remember a TON from RoDG, but when I went back and tried to see what the big differences were, I couldn't find any huge discrepancies. The only substantial differences I saw were the distribution of content throughout the day (because we exited RVS so quickly this game) and he seemed to use his vote slightly more in this game, whereas in the other one he tried to seem impartial about everything.
I would've voted Glyph, but that might have brought up the gun WIFOM and wasted more of everyone's time (I planned refrain from switching my vote to him until halfway through the day so that we ). I would've voted Zaixl, but he's replacing out and I want to give the new guy (if there will be one) a chance to read up before barraging his slot. I was voting for my third suspect, which when Laundry told me to go back and fact-check, I was wrong about.
Was to moosy.
The point still stands that reading someone as town just because they think the same is good.
Yes and I said not to vote for Maven during the limited time that I had at deadline.
Mafia push bad lynches all the time, along with townie jumping on them. This is a one-sided way of looking at things that won't get us anywhere. I really have given you the most benefit of the doubt this game as I believe most of the things you say are so fortright that it couldn't possibly be a scum trying to play appearances, much like you claiming that maven was town because he agreed with you. That line of logic would get you killed if you had more experience.
It's strange because my apparently terrible line of logic is netting me all the right reads while the rest of you are floundering.
