Kadano
Magical Express
Disclaimer: This is a serious thread and I ask you all to refrain from trolling and writing sarcastic or short / meaningless posts. These can be funny in threads without a goal, but we have a goal here that is improving the tournament experience for everyone and I hope that you will cooperate on this.
This discussion is a fork from a Facebook discussion so that we can have a serious and constructive discussion here on smashboards. Please don’t derail it to the same low niveau of discussion we had in a good portion of posts over there.
Purpose: To agree on a set of liberal rules on how to interact at tournaments and smashfests. Liberal as in only prohibiting actions that definitely compromise another person’s freedom or pursuit of happiness.
Issues that need to be adressed
1. Disrespect to girls
Milktea wrote a blog entry recently in which she made a demand for awareness to the issue that male behavior is discouraging girls from entering the Melee scene.
There was an objection by SchlimmShady who said that the reason why we have so few girls at tournaments lies somewhere else, namely in girls being discouraged to partake in competitive gaming by social pressure.
The only way we can find out for sure is by getting firsthand experience. So if you are a girl, please tell us here whether you go to events less than you’d actually like to because of sexual agression. If you are a man and also have some kind of experience with this, it is appreciated as well.
My personal stance on this is that whenever sexual comments occur or somebody is , all persons present should encourage the victim to speak out if she feels uncomfortable / assaulted by them. If she does so and the offender does not stop or ridicules the victim’s speaking out, he should be kicked from the venue.
Preliminary rules (draft status, very open to suggestions)
1. Treat others with respect
Do not approach another person in a sexual way unless you made sure that she / he is fine with it.
If somebody tells you that you are making him or her uncomfortable with a certain behavior, stop it. Do not argue about it. Exception: your behavior was only a response to a former offense by the opposite party. In that case, conduct a third person who is known to be neutral and considerate and let him sort out the problem.
2. Help the tournament organisators on your own accord
Hosting a tournament is a lot of work with mostly little reward. If you see something that needs to be done, ask a TO if you can help with that. Don’t just sit around and spectate whether they will solve it on their own.
This discussion is a fork from a Facebook discussion so that we can have a serious and constructive discussion here on smashboards. Please don’t derail it to the same low niveau of discussion we had in a good portion of posts over there.
Purpose: To agree on a set of liberal rules on how to interact at tournaments and smashfests. Liberal as in only prohibiting actions that definitely compromise another person’s freedom or pursuit of happiness.
Issues that need to be adressed
1. Disrespect to girls
Milktea wrote a blog entry recently in which she made a demand for awareness to the issue that male behavior is discouraging girls from entering the Melee scene.
There was an objection by SchlimmShady who said that the reason why we have so few girls at tournaments lies somewhere else, namely in girls being discouraged to partake in competitive gaming by social pressure.
The only way we can find out for sure is by getting firsthand experience. So if you are a girl, please tell us here whether you go to events less than you’d actually like to because of sexual agression. If you are a man and also have some kind of experience with this, it is appreciated as well.
My personal stance on this is that whenever sexual comments occur or somebody is , all persons present should encourage the victim to speak out if she feels uncomfortable / assaulted by them. If she does so and the offender does not stop or ridicules the victim’s speaking out, he should be kicked from the venue.
Preliminary rules (draft status, very open to suggestions)
1. Treat others with respect
Do not approach another person in a sexual way unless you made sure that she / he is fine with it.
If somebody tells you that you are making him or her uncomfortable with a certain behavior, stop it. Do not argue about it. Exception: your behavior was only a response to a former offense by the opposite party. In that case, conduct a third person who is known to be neutral and considerate and let him sort out the problem.
2. Help the tournament organisators on your own accord
Hosting a tournament is a lot of work with mostly little reward. If you see something that needs to be done, ask a TO if you can help with that. Don’t just sit around and spectate whether they will solve it on their own.
Last edited: