Argue YOUR final roster!

[Frogla2]

Mario Series:
1.Mario
2.Bowser
3.Peach
4.Luigi
5.Petey Pirahna/ King Boo*
6. Toad


Yoshi
7. Yoshi
8. Birdo

DK
9. Donkey Kong
10. Diddy Kong

Wario
11. Wario

Punch- Out
12. Little Mac

F- Zero
13. Capatain Falcon
14. Samuri Goroh
Zelda
15. Link
16. Zelda/ Sheik
17. ganondorf/ ganon
18. Windwaker Link
19.Skull Kid*

Metroid
20. Samus/ Zero Suit Samus
21. Ridley
22. Possibly Dark Samus*
23 One of the Prime Hunters*


Star Fox
24. Fox
25. Falco
26.Krystal
27. Wolf O’ Donnel*


Earthbound
28. Ness
29. Lucas/Poo

Custom Robo
30. Ray 01


Kirby
31. Meta- Knight
32. Kirby
33. King Dedede*


Pokemon
34.Pikachu
35. Jigglypuff
36. Mewtwo
37. Doexys
38. Munchlax/ Blaziken/ or Meowth


Fire Emlem
39.Marth
40. Roy
41. One other*

Retro/Misc
42. Pit
43. Baloon Fighter
44. Mr Game and watch
45. Ice Climbers
46. Captain Olimar
47. Stafy*


Third Party
48. Geno/ Boberman/ Mega Man
49. Sonic
50. Snake


Extra that are possibly and characters that may be replaced by extras are *.

1. Shadow the Hedgehog
2. Bubbles
3. Duck Hunt Dog
4. Muddy ( Mole Mania)
5. Tom Nook
6. Golden Sun Guy
7. Dixie Kong/Waligui

 

[Treos]

frogla you as well forgot dash rendar in your list

 

[#HBC | marshy]

And I already pointed that out.

And I was agreeing with that.

Treos, I think he forgot him on purpose.

 

[Frogla2]

frogla you as well forgot dash rendar in your list

and he is??

 

[McFox]

A guy from a Star Wars game.

Stop talking about Dash Rendar. He won't be in the game.

 

[Epok]

Here is my list of 40 plus a few extras that would be cool. i personally thingk that they wont ad too many non nintendo franchise characters. i herd snake was just a special request by konami and i dont think were going to see anything creazy like Final Fantasy or Pac Man. i think maybe sonic and tales just because nintendo has rights. but anyway enjoy my list


1. Mario
2. Pikachu
3. Link
4. Kirby
5. Samus
6. Captin Falcom
7. Fox
8. Ness
9. DK
10. Bowser
11. Yoshi
12. Peach
13. Zelda/ Shiek
14. Metta Knight
15. Wario
16. Zero Suit Samus
17. Pit
18. Wind Waker Link
19. Dr. Mario
20. Falco
21. Marth
22. Pichu
23. Daisy
24. Paper Boy
25. Oliver (pickman)
26. Waluigi
27. King Dedede
28. Gannondorf
29. Solid Snake
30. Thomas (kung fu)
31. Ridley (metroid)
32. Krystal (Star Fox)
33. Hammer Bro
34. Diddy Kong
35. King K Rool
36. Bowser Jr.
37. Birdo
38. MewTwo
39. Jiggly Puff
40. Balloon Fighter

Others/wishful thinking
Sonic
Tales
Paper Mario
Racoon Mario (Super mario 3)
Baby Mario/ Luigi
Poo (earthbound)
Bomber Man
Banjo Kazooie
Mega Man
Dark Link

 

[McFox]

I'm sorry, but if Pichu, Daisy, Waluigi, and Bowser Jr. are on your list, your list sucks. You left out all of the GOOD characters, like Geno and the Skull Kid.

 

[Muffin_man]

Not to mention he put in three make that four seperate variations on the same bloody character rather than think up of a new one.

Though really, it's his roster, so unless he really thinks that's going to be the final roster for the game, let him be.

 

[spino19]

All 26 originals return as well as all confirmed newcomers, with some changes, see below

New:
1.Little Mac
2.Bald Bull
3.DK Jr.
4.Ridley
5.Dr. Wright (SNES SimCity)
6.Ganon/Ganondorf
7.Yoshi/Red Yoshi/Blue Yoshi (Is three-way switching possible?)
8.Dark Samus
9.Dark Link
10.Metroid
11.Chibi-Robo
12.Cpt. Olimar
13.Master Hand is playable

Third Party:
1. Sonic
2.Pac-man
3.Mega Man
4.Bomberman
5.Godzilla (Now this would be interesting)

 

[#HBC | marshy]

This topic reminds me why it was a good thing that America's votes weren't taken as seriously as the Japanese votes.

 

[Epok]

im basing this off of what logicical choices not just what would be cool by the common fanboy standards, im also taking in to consideration other mario sports games, classics games, and the versitility of what their attacks could be. so wheater what we think is cool or not is not the determinig factor. if that were the case you coul put anybody in the frikken game. not to mention many of that some of the charaters are gonna be clones. bottom line many of that characters people are hoping for are just whishful thinking, and in some cases i dont even think are possible. and Pichu is awesome, just because you dont like him doent mean he's not gonna be in the game.

 

[Thrillhouse-vh.]

My 50

1. Mario (Mario Bros)
2. Luigi (Mario Bros)
3. Bowser (Mario bros)
4. Yoshi (yoshi Story)
5. Captain Falcon (F-Zero)
6. Kirby (Kirby)
7. Ice climbers / Popo, doesn't matter (Ice Climber)
8. Samus / Zamus (Metroid)
9. Pikachu (Pokemon)
10. Donkey Kong (Donkey Kong)
11. Fox McCloud (Star fox)
12. Link (legend Of zelda)
13. Ness (Earthbound)
14. Peach (Mario Bros)
15. Zelda (Legend Of Zelda)
16. Jigglypuff (Pokemon)
17. Ganondorf (Legend Of Zelda)
18. Marth (Fire Emblem)
19. Mr. Game and Watch (Game and watch)
20. Meta-Knight (kirby)
21. Pit (Kid Icarus)
22. Wario (warioware Inc.,)
23. Kensuke Kimachi (1080 Snowboarding)
24. Ryota Hayami (Wave Race)
25. Little Mac / NES Version (Punch-Out!!)
26. Deoxys (Pokemon)
27. King Boo (Luigi's Mansion)
28. Petey Piranha (Super Mario Sunshine)
29. Tom Nook (animal Crossing)
30. Chibi Robo (chibi-robo)
31. Muddy the Mole (Mole Mania)
32. Balloon Fighter (Balloon fight)
33. Stafy (Legend Of stafy)
34. Demille (tomato Adventure)
35. Tin Star (tin Star)
36. Captain Olimar (Pikmin)
37. Isaac (Golden sun)
38. Wolf O'donnell (Star fox)
39. R.O.B. (NES Acessory)
40. M-09 (Project H.A.M.M.E.R)
41. Baseball Player (Baseball)
42. Excitebiker (Excitebike)
43. Mach Rider (Mach rider)
44. Ray-01 (Custom Robo)
45. Virus (Dr. Mario)
46. Snake (Metal Gear)
47. Pac-Man (Pacman)
48. Sonic (Sonic the Hedgehog)
49. Megaman.EXE (Megaman Battle Network)
50. Geno (super Mario Bros RPG)

Baseball Player would be awesome. Admit it.

 

[Blazer]

All Originals except for: Pichu, Doc, Y. Link, Ice Climbers, and possibly G&W. Luigify Roy and Falco
(In order of importance)
1.Wolf
2.Sonic
3.Diddy Kong
4.Krystal
5.Olimar
6.Hector (FE)
7.Mega Man
8. Geno
All confirmed new chars. 34. That leaves room for any random chars. Nintendo wants to throw in

 

[Stryks]

My newcomers:

Dark Samus
Ridley
Sylux
Rundus (Metroid prime 3 hunter, heres a pic below...)

Geno
Megaman
Nightmare (sc2, I wish!)
Wolf
Krystal
General Scales
Lucario
Deoxys
Sonic
Ike
Hector
Ray01
Black Knight
Rakansen
Skull Kid

Plus all the melee characters minus the clones except for falco and Ganon who deserve a new moveset.

 

[xianfeng]

Man all of the lists on this page suck I mean Petey Piranah, Baseball Guy, General Scales, Waluigi! Your lists all suck.

 

[zombie7775]

Some people dont seem to be thinking too hard on these lists. Some of the ideas seem to be whatever comes to mind first. A lot of the characters wouldnt be good in brawl.

 

[Muffin_man]

And I bet your list would go something like this;

Mario
Link
Pikachu
Kirby
Samus
Marth
Roy

Because really, who cares about the characters in Smash Bros of all things?

 

[zombie7775]

And I bet your list would go something like this;

Mario
Link
Pikachu
Kirby
Samus
Marth
Roy

Because really, who cares about the characters in Smash Bros of all things?

If i cared enough to waste my time and come up with 40 to 50 characters I would want in brawl it wouldnt matter anyway. The creators arnt going to come here pick the best list and use it. They probably have there characters all picked out.

 

[Muffin_man]

So the character poll on Sakurai's website was 'just for fun', hmm?

Anyway, I just noticed that Stryks suggested Rundus for another Metroid character, who makes more sense than Weavel who I suggested a couple weeks back. Just thought I'd give props.

EDIT: And for the record, Meta Knight, Pit and Wario all made it in due to huge amounts of fan support. I would not be surprised if many of the characters people are rooting for at the moment, (Geno, Diddy Kong, Dedede, Little Mac, Flint, the list goes oooooooonnnnnnn) make it in.

 

[Lu-Gi-Oh!]

First post, but I've been browsing around here for awhile.

OK, this ISN'T my dream list, but this is the list of who I seriously, HONESTLY, think will be in the game, whether some people like it or not, so don't say my list sucks and all that ****!


Mario
Luigi
Peach
Bowser
Toad
Daisy (NOT a clone, unless they run out of time AGAIN! O_o)
Waluigi (Can't be a clone due to having a different body structure than both Luigi & Wario)

Wario

Donkey Kong
Diddy Kong

Yoshi

TP Link
TP Zelda(and no Shiek )
WW Link (Luigified Young Link)
Ganondorf (Completely new moveset)
Midna

Samus/Zero Suit Samus
Ridley

Kirby
Metaknight

Fox
Falco (Either Luigified or new moveset)
Krystal

Pikachu
Jigglypuff
Mewtwo
Munchlax
Lucario

Captain Falcon
Samurai Goroh

Ness

Marth
Ike

Pit
Ice Climbers
Game & Watch

Snake
Sonic
Either Mega Man, Pac-Man, Bomberman, or Black Mage (Depending on what big company will practically BEG for their mascot character to be in the game)


OK, I think that makes 40 characters, which is probably the very maximum amount of chars to expect in this game. For the most part, I'd say this is the best prediction possible at this time, without taking into consideration the really oddball choices Nintendo may put in there. I may put up dream list later if I feel like it.

 

[Muffin_man]

Actually that makes about 38 characters. Plus I think another Mother related character is a given now if that Mother 3 rumour in the other forum means anything.

 

[zombie7775]

So the character poll on Sakurai's website was 'just for fun', hmm?

Anyway, I just noticed that Stryks suggested Rundus for another Metroid character, who makes more sense than Weavel who I suggested a couple weeks back. Just thought I'd give props.

EDIT: And for the record, Meta Knight, Pit and Wario all made it in due to huge amounts of fan support. I would not be surprised if many of the characters people are rooting for at the moment, (Geno, Diddy Kong, Dedede, Little Mac, Flint, the list goes oooooooonnnnnnn) make it in.

I never said his poll was a joke. I said that what people are writting on this website will not be checked and taken into consideration. I dont doubt that some of these characters are going to be in brawl, its just my opinion that they shouldnt.

 

[LanceKing2200]

all of the origional characters and the ones announced, minus roy and dr. mario, new moves for ganondorf, pichu, and falco, young link becomes cel link and this group:

1. Little Mac
2. Blaziken
3. Lucario
4. Vatti
5. R.O.B.
6. Lyn
7. Hector
8. Ike
9. Diddy Kong
10. King K. Rool
11. King Dedede
12. Lip
13. Capitan Olimar
14. Wolf O'Donnel
15. Krystal
16. Samurai Goroh
17. Black Shadow
18. Jeff
19. Prince Poo
20. Paula
21. Toad
22. Ray 01
23. Issac
24. Ridely
3rd party:
25. Sonic
26. Megaman
27. Rayman
28. Bomberman
29. Geno

 

[Lu-Gi-Oh!]

Actually that makes about 38 characters. Plus I think another Mother related character is a given now if that Mother 3 rumour in the other forum means anything.

What rumor? Is it coming out to the States or somethin'?

I suppose you may have a point either way, though.

 

[Muffin_man]

Hahahaha, I wish it were, but knowing Nintendo, it'll just be wave after wave of Brain Age trash.

No, it was this that I was talking about. Read through it, then you'll see why atleast one more Mother character is likely.

 

[Lu-Gi-Oh!]

^Oh, I see. Mother 3 music in Brawl, eh? Cool!

 

[rock_in_reo]

Ooo, nice. i have always wanted to see what other characters came from Ness's universe (i have never played a earthbound/mother game but i have always wanted to)

 

[Rouse]

Remember people, there's only 26.
1.Mario
2.Doc
3.Peach
4.giga bowser
5.bowser
6.wario
7.waluigi
8.sonic
9.knuckles
10.tails
11.link
12.sheik
13.Ganondorf (with sword)
14.kirby
15.dark mind
16.nightmare
17.ryu
18.ken
19.dark ken
20.dark metaknight
21.samus
22.ridely
23.dark samus
24.marth
25.roy
26.mew

 

[Iggy K]

Only 26? Where the hell did you get that completeley wrong information?

 

[Rouse]

hm, I thought the 1st thread limited your choices to 26. It doesn't matter, just rate the **** list please.

 

[Iggy K]

You want your list rated? Sorry, but your list sucks, badly, for the following reasons.

You replaced Yoshi, G&W, Ness, Ic's, Pikachu, Mewtwo, Jigglypuff, DK, Fox, Falco, Zelda and Luigi.

You kept Doc and Roy.

You added Giga Bowser, Waluigi, Knuckles, Tails, Nightmare, Ryu, Ken, Dark Mind, Dark Ken, Dark Metaknight and Mew.

Hey, you said you wanted it rated.

 

[Rouse]

Yes. I did replace them. Apart from pikachu, none of them are official. And i shouldn't have kept roy, but i'm sticking with doc. so i'll agree to switch roy with pikachu.

 

[Iggy K]

Peach, Bowser and Ganon aren't official either. Neither is doc, oh, and you ditched Falcon, another reason why your list is bad.

 

[Starálfur]

Confirmed Characters:

Mario
Link
Kirby
Pikachu
Samus
Zero Suit Samus
Pit
Metaknight
Snake
Wario

Returning Characters:

Bowser
Captain Falcon
Donkey Kong
Falco
Fox
Mr. Game & Watch
Ganondorf
Ice Climbers
Jigglypuff
Luigi
Marth
Ness
Peach
Yoshi
Zelda

Dropped Characters:

Doctor Mario
Young Link
Sheik
Pichu
Roy
Mewtwo

New Characters:

Wolf O'Donnell - (Starfox franchise)
Krystal - (Starfox franchise)
Ridley - (Metroid franchise)
Little Mac - (Super Punch Out!! franchise)
Grimer - (Pokemon franchise)
Hector - (Fire Emblem franchise)
Diddy Kong - (Donkey Kong franchise)
Takamaru - (Nazo no Murasaemjou)

Megaman - (Megaman franchise)
Geno - (Super Mario RPG)
Sonic - (Sonic franchise)


Total characters = 36

 

[NukeA6]

Remember people, there's only 26.
1.Mario
2.Doc
3.Peach
4.giga bowser
5.bowser
6.wario
7.waluigi
8.sonic
9.knuckles
10.tails
11.link
12.sheik
13.Ganondorf (with sword)
14.kirby
15.dark mind
16.nightmare
17.ryu
18.ken
19.dark ken
20.dark metaknight
21.samus
22.ridely
23.dark samus
24.marth
25.roy
26.mew

Dark Ken? Dark Metaknight? I hope your not thinking they have a chance in SSBB.

 

[FlipTroopa]

Well, it's been a while since my topic was started, and I posted my own roster, but you guys are STILL going and that's awesome. So here's my new roster, after reading up other ideas and the like for almost a month now.

Smash Bros. Brawl Roster -- FlipTroopa

Confirmed
Mario
Link
Kirby
Pikachu
Samus
Meta Knight
Pit
Wario
Zero-Suit Samus
Snake

99.9% Likely
Fox
Donkey Kong
Yoshi
Captain Falcon
Luigi
Peach
Bowser
Zelda (with Sheik? Sheik may or may not return)
Ganondorf
Mewtwo
Ice Climbers
Mr. Game and Watch

Might be Replaced by a Newer Version/Star from Series
Marth
Ness

24 so far...

50% Chance of Staying
Falco
Jigglypuff
Young Link (as self or Wind Waker version)

So that's 27 if they stay, but let's assume they DON'T

New Additions (Ascending Tones of Blue means Increased Likelihood)
Takamaru
Little Mac
Lolo and Lala
Krystal
King Dedede
Stafy
Sukapon
Lucario
Ike (or some other new FE Lord, or possibly mage)
Diddy Kong

Third Party Additions
Sonic
Bonk

And that makes 36!

Other potentials, in case some of these fail...
Demiru
Jill from Drill Dozer
Waluigi
Lip
Mega Man
Simon Belmont
Goemon
Geno
Toad
Vaati
Pacman

 

[Deleted member]

What's up with all the Roy hate? Sure, he might be more an advertising character, but he's certainly incredibly popular in the West.

 

[nux23]

1. Mario
2. Link
3. Fox
4. Kirby
5. Captain Falcon
6. Metaknight
7. Pikachu
8. Falco
9. Ganandorf
10. Bowser

 

[#HBC | marshy]

Time for my roster

1. Vanessa (First girl in my sig, far left)
2. Girl who's gyrating her butt in the second pic.
3. See above, but in the 3rd pic.
4. See above, but in 4th pic, same with all my pics actually.
5. Mario
6. Geno
7. Sigurd
8. Celice
9. Little Mac, NES, not Brian Peppers Mac
10. Krystal
11. Zero Suit Samus
12. Random DOA girl, hell, why not all of them.

Characters who should never been in the game, no matter what.
1. pokemon, that's about 300 right there
2. Eliwood
3. Roy, because he's related to Eliwood
4. Waluigi
5. Daisy
6. Toad
7. Simon Belmont

I know I'm missing A LOT of characters that suck, if you can remind who they are, that'd be greatly appreciated.

Spoiler

Anyone who thinks those are the only characters I want is silly.

 

[nuro]

G `