Recent content by JackieRabbit5

Yeah true it feels like the ban criteria could be organized better... I'll try to think of something and will take any suggestions. But at least with the list we have a simple framework of discussion with all the different thoughts/points clearly noted and distinguished so people don't just...

So I believe what you're saying is that majority isn't always justified. This may be true, but for the sake of making a decision I think majority is important. And like I said to Massive, are you saying the minority should win out? Because that doesn't seem fair either.. Maybe we need to more...

Whoa k lots to discuss now heh. You make many good points Kal. For now lets see what I can agree with. Overuse- yeah just because its overused doesn't necessarily mean its the best. By itself this would be bad ban criteria. Hard evidence- yep already agreed its important, and even if its like...

Hmm good point hotdog, maybe this should be moved to like Brawl Metagame Data & Ruleset Discussion afterall heh...although Melee players would still be welcome to contribute. Agreed or other ideas on this? He's right M2K, raising of awareness could really help. And I think organizing the...

So following the MK ban decision and the "What does it take to be banned?" thread, I think for the sake of the entire smash community we should make a list of specific things that it should and should not take to get something banned. Hope this is the right place for this heh, may want to...

MK mains have some bias too for wanting to continue using a character they know to be clearly the best in the game ..but i agree with most you said. So I think we should make a list of specific things that it should and should not take to get something banned, and I think this deserves its own...

ok alright Kal i see your point heh >.< Tbh i'm glad to see some actually good anti-ban arguments. It doesn't really matter to me either way what happens, even if all this does is help us realize MK really doesn't deserve to be banned once and for all. I just think the issue needs to end and...

Looks like topic's getting back on track heh. So look, Brawl's just not the greatest game competitively, wasn't intended to be.. So anything we can do as a community to make it better, even if it means taking the seemingly drastic measure of banning a character, then we have it in our power to...

think of MK as like a character in melee with just about all the advantages of the top tiers, fox's speed, jigglypuff's recovery and gimp ability, marth's disjointed hitboxes/range, and sheik's at least initial ease of use (only thing missing would be falco lasers heh)... Could u put up with...

Kal, I see what you mean, "scrub" doesn't necessarily have to do with skill, but the playing to win mindset. Pretty sure proban players like #1 ranked Ally and #3 ranked ADHD, have that, granted those kind of top of the top ppl weren't on the URC directly responsible for the final decision. I...

its true whether he's actually "broken" or not is highly debatable and controversial, cause for most of the MK ban issue's most heated discussion.. and it almost depends on how you define the meaning of the word itself. I won't get into it all but there are also facts on how he has so many...

this shouldn't effect melee imo melee players should try to understand how the Mk ban subject has torn the brawl community, all the pro and anti-ban points have been discussed over and over, numerous polls and arguing over the past 2-3 years... but in the end I think a big part of it was the...

wow this has been a long time coming, surprising it was 14-0.. since this is the first time in smash a char is banned, i just wonder if this will effect decisions made in the next smash game, or i hope we have at least learned how to handle this kind of decision better

i think the problem here is that ur friended with Dad on facebook haha jk i don't even really like stereotyping tbh, though I understand its a useful tool for organizing thoughts and ideas about people in our heads and help us decide how to act, so its almost unavoidable... yeah i don't think...

Blue/silver triforce controller Here is my new, finished painted controller! the design turned out tougher than i thought, and i got a little overspray at first heh but i think it turned out well.. i used this thread, thanks for the help!