Just wanted to make a note here as Marth discussion seems to have dropped off and we're not starting another character just yet:
Just went to Smash & Splash over the weekend in Gurnee, IL. Big regional tourney with big names there (Ally, Mew2King, Wizzrobe, and others). Didn't make it out of pools unfortunately because I was literally one win behind someone I actually beat 2-1. That said, I feel so much more enlightened about Zelda's MU's thanks to the high skill of players there.
Mario: Mario is a terrible MU for Zelda. I think my first score was something like 55:45 in Mario's favor. That is absolutely untrue. Mario tears right through Zelda with his near-unpunishable aerial game and forcing us to approach with fireballs which we can't do. His smashes are terribly fast so he doesn't have any trouble at all killing us whereas we have to work significantly harder to secure a kill on him.
40:60
revised score.
Luigi: I originally gave this MU an even score I think but I didn't have a ton of experience. This is far from true. This MU is also hell for Zelda. Like Mario, his fireballs force us into the offensive and Luigi is really good at punishing us for that since a grab means upwards of 40% in combos or a kill setup that is very difficult to avoid due to Zelda's terrible options when she is above the opponent.
40:60
Sheik: I cannot win against talented Sheiks with Zelda. I honestly have a better time using Palutena and I'm just now trying to pick her up as a Secondary. Sheik is mobile, has a projectile that is wickedly safe with needles, has a fair that can actually outspace a lot of our options, can punish us for using anything, and is ungimpable offstage. Honestly, this MU is
35:65
.
ZSS: Mobility, safe, disjointed hitboxes, and safe kill setups make her terribly difficult to handle. I found it nearly impossible to punish any of ZSS' options because as soon as she was in with an attack, she was out again and Zelda's no sprinter. I won one game in 2 sets against a very talented ZSS because I honestly could not even touch her.
40:60
Just wanted to update all of my opinions given I now have new information to base my opinions on. I now know that I have a lot to learn and a lot to practice. Zelda's a good character and can hold her own in any MU (Save Sheik, I honestly think this might be unwinnable unless your name is Nairo) but she will struggle to do it. I'm gonna look into going to more big tourneys like this one to perfect our princess and hopefully give her some representation. This was a wake-up call to really focus on learning what those high tiers can do. Once I understand what they can do...