YOU Decide! - Mario Edition

[Venus of the Desert Bloom]

YOU Decide!​

We all care deeply for characters and get excited when one of our favorites is confirmed and become sad when deconfirmed. I was going to post this in the discussion thread but decided maybe a separate thread was good. I will provide a long list of potential unconfirmed characters and you get to decide where they should be implemented in Ultimate.

You can skip up to 8 characters if you think they don’t deserve to be in the game.

Categories include:

• Playable launch character
• Echo character
• Playable DLC character
• Echo DLC character
• Alternate Costume (Alph and Female Trainer)
• Assist Trophy
• Pokeball
• Item
• Collectible Trophy
• Stage Hazard
• Background Element
• Moveset Element (Waddle Doo and Toad)
• Final Smash Element (Fiora and Shadow Mario)
• Additional Element (Victory Screen and Codecs)
• anything else you can think of
• Pass if you think they are undeserving to be repped

Do not use this thread to bash and/or attack a character, fans, or what people post. This is not a thread to debate why people chose a character over another.

To post, simply copy the list of characters and include the category afterward like so:

Ronald McDonald: Ganondorf Echo
Spongebob: Collectable Trophy
Iron Man: Pass

Mario Edition

List of Mario and related Characters

Captain Toad
Toadette
Toadsworth
Dry Bowser
Nurse Peach
Dr. Luigi
Birdo
Dry Bones
King Boo
Petey Piranha
Professor E. Gadd
The Broodals
Lord of Lightning aka Ruined Dragon
Dorrie
Tiara
Tryclyde
Mouser
Wart
Paper Mario
Paper Luigi
Paper Peach
Paper Bowser
Fawful
Dimentio
Count Bleck
Kamek
Shy Guy
Baby Mario & Luigi
Baby Bowser
Yarn Yoshi
Poochy
Boshi
Geno
Mallow
Smithy
Ashley
Mona
Kat & Ana
Wario Land Wario
Captain Syrup
Metal Mario
Metal Luigi
Pink Gold Peach

The Mario Edition will last for a week or so and I will then include the list along with which category the characters appeared in. Once this is finished, I’ll file it into the below post and start the next edition.

 

[Venus of the Desert Bloom]

Saved for later

 

[Venus of the Desert Bloom]

Captain Toad: Playable Launch character
Toadette: Alt costume of Capt Toad
Toadsworth: Trophy
Dry Bowser: Alt costume of Bowser
Nurse Peach: Trophy
Dr. Luigi: Trophy
Birdo: Assist Trophy
Dry Bones: Assist Trophy
King Boo: Stsge Hazard
Petey Piranha: Trophy
Professor E. Gadd: Background Element
The Broodals: Trophy
Lord of Lightning aka Ruined Dragon: Stage Hazard
Dorrie: Trophy
Tiara: additional Element (visible during Peach’s Up Special)
Tryclyde: Trophy
Mouser: Trophy
Wart: Trophy
Paper Mario: Playable Launch Character
Paper Luigi: Trophy
Paper Peach: Pass
Paper Bowser: Pass
Fawful: Pass
Dimentio: Trophy
Count Bleck: Assist Trophy
Kamek: Stage Hazard
Shy Guy: Assist Trophy
Baby Mario & Luigi: Assist Trophy
Baby Bowser: Trophy
Yarn Yoshi: Alt costume for Yoshi
Poochy: Assist Trophy
Boshi: Trophy
Geno: Playable Launch Character
Mallow: Assist Trophy
Smithy: Trophy
Ashley: Assist Trophy
Mona: Trophy
Kat & Ana: Assist Trophy
Wario Land Wario: Trophy
Captain Syrup: Trophy
Metal Mario: Pass
Metal Luigi: Pass
Pink Gold Peach: Pass

 

[AIM0001]

Captain Toad -Perhaps DLC (As long as Geno is in)
Toadette -Costume swap to Captain Toad
Toadsworth - Trophy
Dry Bowser - Alt costume for Bowser
Nurse Peach -PASS
Dr. Luigi -PASS
Birdo -Smb2 stage background
Dry Bones -Trophy
King Boo -If Luigi mansion ever got a second rep then King Boo is your guy! He would have an awesome stage and move set. I’d be a huge fan!
Petey Piranha - Assist Trophy it King Boo was playable. If not then just a regular Trophy.
Professor E. Gadd -Somehow implement him in Luigi’s Final Smash.
The Broodals - Background in Oddessy stage.
Lord of Lightning aka Ruined Dragon -PASS
Dorrie -PASS
Tiara -PASS
Tryclyde -PASS
Mouser -PASS
Wart -Assist Trophy
Paper Mario -Playable with original moveset passed mostly off Paper Mario 64 and TTYD.
Paper Luigi - Trophy
Paper Peach -Trophy
Paper Bowser -Trophy
Fawful -Trophy
Dimentio - Trophy
Count Bleck -Assist Trophy
Kamek -In new Super Mario Stage
Shy Guy - Trophy
Baby Mario & Luigi -Trophy
Baby Bowser -Trophy
Yarn Yoshi -Alt costume for Yoshi
Poochy - In Yoshis win pose screen
Boshi -Alt costume for Yoshi
Geno -PLAYABLE! Please!
Mallow -Assist trophy
Smithy -Trophy
Ashley - Playable?
Mona -Trophy
Kat & Ana -Trophy
Wario Land Wario -Trophy
Captain Syrup - PASS
Metal Mario -Alt Costume
Metal Luigi -Alt Costume
Pink Gold Peach -Alt costume

 

[smashingDoug]

Captain Toad dlc
Toadette dlc alt for cap toad
Toadsworth background
Dry Bowser echo
Nurse Peach pass
Dr. Luigi trophy
Brido hazard
Dry Bones hazard
King Boo assist boss?
Petey Piranha assist boss?
Professor E. Gadd trophy
The Broodals
Lord of Lightning aka Ruined Dragon
Dorrie
Tiara
Tryclyde
Mouser
Wart fighter or echo
Paper Mario trophies for the paper cast
Paper Luigi
Paper Peach
Paper Bowser
Fawful
Dimentio
Count Bleck
Kamek Hazard
Shy Guy hazard
Baby Mario & Luigi not sure
Baby Bowser
Yarn Yoshi
Poochy
Boshi alt
Geno not sure
Mallow ttrophy
Smithy trophy
Ashley fighter
Mona
Kat & Ana what are they now?
Wario Land Wario should be in Warios moveset
Captain Syrup
Metal Mario
Metal Luigi
Pink Gold Peach

Blank is pass

 

[MacDaddyNook]

Captain Toad - DLC
Toadette - Collectible Trophy
Toadsworth - Collectible Trophy
Dry Bowser - Pass
Nurse Peach - Pass
Dr. Luigi - Pass
Birdo - Stage Hazard (Mushroom Kingdom II)
Dry Bones - Collectible Trophy
King Boo - Collectible Trophy
Petey Piranha - Collectible Trophy
Professor E. Gadd - Collectible Trophy
The Broodals - Collectible Trophy
Lord of Lightning aka Ruined Dragon - Pass
Dorrie -Pass
Tiara - Collectible Trophy
Tryclyde -Pass
Mouser - Pass
Wart - Collectible Trophy
Paper Mario - Collectible Trophy
Paper Luigi - Pass
Paper Peach -Pass
Paper Bowser- Pass
Fawful - Collectible Trophy
Dimentio -Pass
Count Bleck - Pass
Kamek - Collectible Trophy
Shy Guy - Stage Hazard (Yoshi Story)
Baby Mario & Luigi - Collectible Trophy
Baby Bowser - Pass
Yarn Yoshi - Collectible Trophy
Poochy - Collectible Trophy
Boshi - Pass
Geno -Pass
Mallow -Pass
Smithy - Pass
Ashley - Assist Trophy
Mona - Collectible Trophy
Kat & Ana - Assist Trophy
Wario Land Wario - Wario Alt Costume
Captain Syrup - Collectible Trophy
Metal Mario - Mario w/ Metal Box Item
Metal Luigi - Luigi w/ Metal Box Item
Pink Gold Peach - Pass

 

[nirvanafan]

Playable launch character - Ashley
Echo character - Birdo
Playable DLC character - Captain Toad, Paper Mario, Geno
Alternate Costume - Captain Toadette, Dry Bowser, Nurse Peach, Dr. Luigi, Baby Bowser (Bowser Jr.), Yarn Yoshi, Boshi, Wario Land Wario, Baby Mario & Luigi (with Yoshi)
Assist Trophy - Kat & Ana, Mona, Poochy
Stage Hazard - Dorrie, Kamek, Shy Guy, A couple of the Paper Mario characters in a new stage (not sure which ones though)
Moveset Element - Toadette & Toadsworth (Alts for Toad move with Peach & Daisy's other alts)
Final Smash Element - Professor E. Gadd (with Luigi or maybe an assist trophy instead)
Enemy Mob (Adventure or Smash Run if Back) - Dry Bones, Mouser
Boss (Stage, Classic, Adventure, or Smash Run if Back) - King Boo, Wart, Captain Syrup, Metal Mario, Metal, Luigi, Pink Gold Peach
Collectible Trophy for everyone else because why not.

 

[Oddball]

Captain Toad - costume for playable Toad
Toadette - color scheme for playable Toad
Toadsworth - Pass
Dry Bowser - Trophy
Nurse Peach - Trophy
Dr. Luigi - Pass
Birdo - stage hazard
Dry Bones - stage Hazard
King Boo - Pass
Petey Piranha - Pass
Professor E. Gadd - Trophy
The Broodals - Pass
Lord of Lightning aka Ruined Dragon - pass
Dorrie - Pass
Tiara - Pass
Tryclyde - Trophy
Mouser - DLC playable
Wart - Starting Playable
Paper Mario - DLC playable
Paper Luigi - Pass
Paper Peach - Pass
Paper Bowser - Trophy
Fawful - Trophy
Dimentio - pass
Count Bleck - Trophy
Kamek
Shy Guy
Baby Mario & Luigi - Trophy
Baby Bowser -- Pass
Yarn Yoshi
Poochy -- Pass
Boshi -- Pass
Geno
Mallow
Smithy
Ashley
Mona
Kat & Ana
Wario Land Wario -- costume
Captain Syrup
Metal Mario -- powerup for regular Mario
Metal Luigi -- power up for regualr Luigi
Pink Gold Peach -- Pass

 

[YoshiandToad]

Captain Toad - Playable Launch character
Toadette - Alt costume for Captain Toad
Toadsworth - Should replace Toad frankly as the counter and free the shroom, but if not; trophy(Toadsworth hasn't done much in ages)
Dry Bowser - Alt costume for Bowser
Nurse Peach - Trophy. Can't work as a Peach alt due to the dress being too short
Dr. Luigi - Trophy
Birdo - Stage hazard/ At a stretch a Yoshi echo fighter(tongue is made transparent so Birdo appears to suck up enemies instead, slight tweak where the egg lay comes from(mouth instead of butt), but everything else the same)
Dry Bones - Trophy
King Boo - Unkillable Assist Trophy
Petey Piranha - Boss
Professor E. Gadd - Guidance/Codec on Luigi's Mansion stage
The Broodals - Trophy
Lord of Lightning aka Ruined Dragon - Stage Hazard/ Stage
Dorrie - An actual stage. Fight on Dorrie's back.
Tiara - Peach's crown occasionally reveals itself to be Tiara, similar to Cappy and Mario's hat.
Tryclyde - Trophy
Mouser - Trophy
Wart - Trophy
Paper Mario - Playable Launch character
Paper Luigi - Alt costume for Paper Mario(albeit with wonky hit boxes)
Paper Peach - Trophy/ background element in the Paper Mario stage.
Paper Bowser - Trophy/ background element in the Paper Mario stage
Fawful - Assist Trophy
Dimentio - Assist Trophy
Count Bleck - Stage hazard on the Paper Mario fighting theatre stage
Kamek - Assist Trophy(Summons other Mario antagonists)
Shy Guy - Background character for a Yoshi or Captain Toad stage
Baby Mario & Luigi - DLC echo fighters of the Ice Climbers
Baby Bowser - Trophy
Yarn Yoshi - Trophy
Poochy - Assist Trophy/ Victory screen character to join Yoshi
Boshi - Alt costume for Yoshi
Geno - DLC fighter(with Mallow)
Mallow - DLC fighter(with Geno)
Smithy - Background element for Geno and Mallow's SMRPG stage
Ashley - DLC fighter with a summoner moveset.
Mona - Part of Ashley's moveset(summons her on her bike to run people over)
Kat & Ana - Part of Ashley's moveset (act much like their assist; slashing anyone in their path upon being summoned)
Wario Land Wario - Alt costume for Wario.
Captain Syrup - Stage hazard on a Wario stage.
Metal Mario - mid boss in Adventure Mode
Metal Luigi - Mid boss in Adventure mode
Pink Gold Peach - Peach's default metal box skin

If it's alright to add a few others in;
Goombella: Codec on the Paper Mario stage
Draggadon: Captain Toad's Final Smash
Wingo: Captain Toad's entrance animation/stage hazard on the Captain Toad stage
Jimmy T: Part of Ashley's summonable moveset.
Vivian: Assist Trophy

 

[Deleted member]

Captain Toad - Assist Trophy
Toadette - Trophy
Toadsworth - Trophy
Dry Bowser - Alternate Costume
Nurse Peach - Alternate Cosumte
Dr. Luigi - Alternate Costume
Birdo - Stage Hazard (MKII is returning, so...)
Dry Bones - Trophy
King Boo - Stage Hazard
Petey Piranha - Stage Hazard
Professor E. Gadd - Trophy
The Broodals - Trophy
Lord of Lightning aka Ruined Dragon - Stage Hazard
Dorrie -Trophy
Tiara - Trophy
Tryclyde - Trophy
Mouser - Trophy
Wart - Stage Hazard
Paper Mario - Trophy
Paper Luigi - Trophy
Paper Peach - Trophy
Paper Bowser - Trophy
Fawful - Assist Trophy
Dimentio - Trophy
Count Bleck - Trophy
Kamek -Stage Hazard
Shy Guy - Trophy
Baby Mario & Luigi - Trophy
Baby Bowser - Trophy
Yarn Yoshi - Alternate Costume
Poochy - Trophy
Boshi - Trophy
Geno - Assist Trophy
Mallow - Assist Trophy
Smithy - Trophy
Ashley - Assist Trophy
Mona - Trophy
Kat & Ana - Assist Trophy
Wario Land Wario - Alternate Costume
Captain Syrup - Trophy
Metal Mario - Trophy
Metal Luigi - Trophy
Pink Gold Peach - Trophy