-
If there is a reboot or roster shrinkage, she isn't priority as she doesn't even do anything in her games.
Ya if we ignore Paper Mario, Mario & Luigi, Super Princess Peach, Super Mario RPG, and Super Mario Bros 2. She's Nintendo's #1 Female Icon (she could benefit from another game starring her being the hero) and deserves respect.
-
Koopalings should be cut, Bowser Jr deserves the spot alone.
As someone who played the Super Marios, I can say having the Koopalings feels very nostalgic and fun to have. While I understand concern in regards to development time making all their models, I argue that having the Koopalings actually adds more to the character slot than just having Jr. They all have such varying looks and personalities that it's cute to have Bowser's family together.
-
He's a lame clone. Krystal deserves it more than him!
Wolf is not a clone or at the very least differs from Fox more so than pretty much any other character labeled as clone. It'll never end though, people will always act like he is Dark Pit of Fox. As for who deserves the 3rd spot most, I actually think Wolf deserves the 2nd slot for Star Fox as he adds more than Falco and is more important to Star Fox as a series than Krystal can ever dream to be. She simply got tacked on to add drama to the series which was very poorly received. She is basically Andrea from TV Walking Dead as some angry lady jumping sides and chasing bad boys. She'd be a fine 4th rep or replacing Falco, though I don't think she exactly deserves a spot over Fox, Wolf, Falco, Slippy, or maybe even Leon.
-
He should be cut, flavor of the month Pokemon.
He's been one of the more successful, well received, and marketable Pokemon in quite some time. Pokemon from later Gens shouldn't be trashed cause you didn't grow up with them. Greninja is a popular and still relevant (plays a role in that Detective Pikachu movie) Pokemon that offers his fill on the roster. And as a reminder, Greninja beat a fire magic, fox girl rival for popularity, that is pretty impressive as he beat out something that seemed made for the furry fandom. He literally was the #1 Pokemon i Japan and even got a special form in the anime that got promoted going into Sun and Moon.
-
He's not important and should be cut going forward.
He's the most popular lord that was the star in two games that helped further the series being known in America. And to add to that, Ike took off in popularity in the Smash community as well. Ike is a pretty powerful marketable tool now and remakes or sequels to his games would likely sell well cause Ike has become a icon for the series more so than even Marth. We have plenty of other fodder in the FE Smash cast that are more expendable than Ike who was even the FE starter character for Brawl and 4 which seemed to indicate him as staple to me.
-
This small series doesn't really deserve a spot on the roster, I don't like him or his series.
If Olimar doesn't deserve to be on the roster, then basically half the roster could be cut (EX- Ness, Lucas, Captain Falcon, Rob, Shulk, Ice Climbers) and most of the hyped characters should be 0% chances. (EX- Geno, Banjo, Isaac, Spring Man) Pikmin is an ongoing series sporting 3 main games, a spin off thing, multiple little movies, and a anticipated 4th entry. Anyone who thinks Pikmin doesn't deserve to be in Smash is just being selfish.
-
The male should be removed.
Why? Does a good bodied male make you uncomfortable with your identity? Get over it. There is literally no reason for Male or Female versions of split characters like Robin, Corrin, Villager, Inkling, or Wii Fit Trainer to ignore one gender cause someone can't deal with the other one. Also as usual, it's usually young males freaking about the male version of some hot girl or the SJW getting upset someone may view something as male that they have labeled as female.
-
He's weird and doesn't really fit in. Should be cut for someone else.
Pacman is probably one of the, if the THE most deserving 3rd party icons to be in Smash. Pac Man was HUGE and it's an honor to have him.
-
I don't like, nobody likes him. Anything else would be better. He ruined everything!
Incineroar is more popular than Decidueye, let that sink in. Incineroar brought something new and fresh with him. He isn't just a fire type and fave Sakurai his chance to design a very fun and expressive grappler heel. His VA also passed away, so it's nice to have this character carry on his legacy for a bit longer. And you're pick is not better just cause you think so and the guys in your support thread think so to. I watched a lot of reaction videos and a lot of people liked Incineroar and his moves. Maybe you should enjoy the 68+ other characters then?
-
He shouldn't of made it in over some other Echo.
Seeing as Simon borrowed heavily from Richter and Richter is very iconic and popular as well, I think it made perfect sense to add both of them. While other Echoes could be cool, Richter really was an awesome pick that shocked and awed many people as most were not expecting him! He also helped end the argument that no 3rd party series could ever getting something more than 1 fighter. It's nice for characters like Tails and Ken to not of been so shut down towards by fans.
"His Radiant Dawn design sucks!" (This one steams me real good.)
Radiant Dawn Ike is best Ike. He stands out from the other guys as some guy who fought hard and grew up in a rough situation. PoR Ike is basically him before growing up and becoming who he'd up being, so he is blander at that stage.
