The Sonic boards index thread Updated since the: 12th of August

[Super_Sonic8677]

If quotes thread gets made, The Owning Steak quote goes first lol.

 

[Chis]

Sonic boards tier list V.4
The one that started the fad >_>

This time tourney results and contribution to Sonic's metagame count more. But yes, also contribution to the boards, win, steak, etc is counted for.

Steak
Tenki
KASR

Top
Memphis
KID ~ ShadowLink84
Puffball
DJbrowny
Kojin
infzy
MalcolmM
ROOOOY!
__X__
Boxob.
Catinthehat
Terios
Sonicmaster5

High
darkNES386
Greenstreet
Camalange
Napi
Kinzer
MarKO X
ShadoFiend
Chis
Neon Ness
Knee
Teh Umby
Twinkletoes
aeghrur
LucKy
InterimOfZeal

Med
Super Sonic 8677
Anthinus
Knee
Rickerdy-doo-da-day
Raze
EMZ
Magnum
Gf2tw
Phoenix Dark
Dark Sonic
Sonic Orochi
Anther
Vyse
Xiivi
Kalm

Low
SonicLucario
Halloween Captain
BT
Black belt
Havokk
Orange_soda_man
dark_Illusion_hokage
-Blue-
Shugo
Blapius
Ithrowthings

Bottom
SonicX580
The_Dyne
Hypersupersonic
Sonic-Fan
Spin dash
Catt
Pain
SBR
Marry Sonic

Serious business?

 

[~TBS~]

woot, moved up! i am going to be steak tier one day, and that day is quickly approaching. keep an eye out, guys, or else you'll be too slow

 

[CalebSitton]

wait why am i not on this list?
shame on u mah boi....

patition to put me on the list!

 

[Camalange]

Whoo, I went higher up but still high tier.

I'll make top someday...SOMEDAAAY!

I should be above Terry, he doesn't even go to tournies ;o

 

[ROOOOY!]

Ouch, I shot down about 10 places.

To about where I should be lol.

Meh, I'll start pulling my weight around here more now.

 

[infomon]

As much as I <3 being top tier.... if tourney results count at all, I should be knocked down a tier at least

 

[JayBee]

Sonic boards tier list V.4
The one that started the fad >_>

This time tourney results and contribution to Sonic's metagame count more. But yes, also contribution to the boards, win, steak, etc is counted for.

Steak
Tenki
KASR


Top
Memphis
KID ~ ShadowLink84
Puffball
DJbrowny
Kojin
infzy
MalcolmM
ROOOOY!
__X__
Boxob.
Catinthehat
Terios
Sonicmaster5





High
darkNES386
Greenstreet
Camalange
Napi
Kinzer
MarKO X
ShadoFiend
Chis
Neon Ness
Knee
Teh Umby
Twinkletoes
aeghrur
LucKy
InterimOfZeal


Med
Super Sonic 8766
Anthinus
Knee
Rickerdy-doo-da-day
Raze
EMZ
magnificentmarth
Gf2tw
Phoenix Dark
Dark Sonic
Sonic Orochi
Anther
Vyse
Xiivi
Kalm




Low
SonicLucario
Halloween Captain
BT
Black belt
Havokk
Orange_soda_man
dark_Illusion_hokage
-Blue-
Shugo
Blapius
Ithrowthings


Bottom
SonicX580
The_Dyne
Hypersupersonic
Sonic-Fan
Spin dash
Catt
Pain
SBR
Marry Sonic

Serious business?

wow im higher than malcolm!!!....
Im higher than Malcolm? wtf?

 

[da K.I.D.]

1. do I seriously have to share the spot with SL84... /sigh

2. bottom tier should be exactly one spot bigger.

3. just because of the fact that he got to play irl friendlies with me, OrangeSodaMan, should be at least mid tier.

4. ayaz, is not on this list and my comment about OSM applys to him as well.

pretty good other than that...

also.
5. kojin, you work harder than most people on the sonic boards, and malcom comes to you asking how to get better, i think that validates you being higher than him.

6.ROOOOY should have his top tier spot guaranteed just because he put his SWF account on the line to say that sonic wouldnt make mid tier.

 

[Trillion]

i need to move myself higher up on this thing jeez. Also, if you could change mine to Magnum thatd be cool thanks.

 

[thecatinthehat]

No.

This list fails.

Why the hell are Memphis and ROOOOY above me and Boxob?

Camalange should be higher too.

 

[Orange_Soda_Man]

I like the new tier list, since I'm on it =0

@ Kid: thanks!

Also I'm gonna go to another tourney later this month closer to home and I've hacked my wii to get replays longer than 3 min. Those could bump me up a bit in the next one, but eh whatever it's all good.

 

[Chis]

wait why am i not on this list?
shame on u mah boi....

patition to put me on the list!

This is the first time I've seen you post though...

I should be above Terry, he doesn't even go to tournies ;o

Terry is Terios right?

As much as I <3 being top tier.... if tourney results count at all, I should be knocked down a tier at least

But you've contrubited some much, plus being one of the best reseacrhers here.

i need to move myself higher up on this thing jeez. Also, if you could change mine to Magnum thatd be cool thanks.

Okay then.

No.

This list fails.

Why the hell are Memphis and ROOOOY above me and Boxob?

Camalange should be higher too.

What have you guys done lately for the board or Sonic's Metagame? Everyone above you has done a lot more.

Step it up!

I like the new tier list, since I'm on it =0

I'm sure I've forgotten somebody.

 

[Super_Sonic8677]

YES! I'm in the new list!

....

It's 8677 not 8766 ;>_>

 

[JayBee]

also.
5. kojin, you work harder than most people on the sonic boards, and malcom comes to you asking how to get better, i think that validates you being higher than him.

when u say it like that then i guess i understand it. awesome...

 

[thecatinthehat]

Chis, your argument stands, but it works for me too.

Memphis hasnt done ****.

ROOOOY a lil more but still.

Me and Box have done loads too.

Box and his Box Techs.

I've contributed here and there many times. Especially with Spinshot ^_^

 

[Jim Morrison]

How can Knee be above me?
He doesn't even play Sonic

Ah **** this list, it makes no sense at all.

 

[thecatinthehat]

Chis, you alone cant be the sole creator of the tier list. You need more than one person, so the list will stand unbiased.

 

[Trillion]

I'm not trying to attack you on your opinion here, but I'm trying to understand how it was formulated and the criteria you used. I believe you said that it was based on not just skill and tourney results, but also on contribution to the board and to the evolution of Sonic metagame and etc.

So, if you put more emphasis on tourney placings then Malcolm should be steak tier. If you put more emphasis on posting and making intelligent helpful posts, then shouldn't CiTH and Boxob be higher than Memphis (nothing against you Memphis, I just usually see a lot more CiTH and Boxob posts)? Explain please? Just looking for clarification.

 

[Chis]

lol, like you guys tell me what to do.

Over some light hearted fun.

 

[Kinzer]

Nobody else is willing to do that though.

Also LOL at you people taking this seriously, of course it can be flawed/biased, it's all for fun... or if you're so low on the list, that should make you work to get higher.

There's that, and I wanted to suggest if we should put Xyro's "Mr. 3K is inhuman!" thread up in here or not.

I see no problems with getting it up, but I wouldn't really care if it didn't either.

Edit: I'm too slow.

 

[thecatinthehat]

you see...

you dont make a legit rebuttal, because you know you're wrong...

Anyone can just look at the facts and see....

this thread fails, and doesnt rep the Sonic boards..

Why is Knee so high?

He doesnt even play SOnic.

Memphis doesnt do ****.

me and Box are so low becuase we all know we've been *****es to you.

you're the only one to make the list.

its WAAYY too biased.

edit: Kinzer, I'm bored, and I enjoy debates.

 

[Kinzer]

If you want to debate, you should go into the Hall, they got some serious junk going on there... Hell, you don't even have to do THAT, we gots lotsa other junk here on SWF.

Either that, or give us a topic we both disagree on and we'll go from there.

Here's something you can take to PMs

I think Brawl > Melee.

/sarcasm.

 

[Chis]

Take this to my profile.

Any more posts like this from this point will be reported.

For realz.

 

[infomon]

edit: meow, I'm sleepy, and I enjoy catfights.

fixed.

 

[Kinzer]

Anyway Chis, how about that Mr. 3K thread?

You haven't answered that yet.

 

[Chis]

I'll add it when I'm less peeved. I'm peeved IRL then come here and read all this ****.

 

[Kinzer]

Not sure what peeved means but okay.

*Goes to dictionary.com.*

 

[Camalange]

lolol, Imma make my own Tier list D:<

Steak Tier:
Steak
Camalange

Other Tier:
Others

How's THAT for biased?

lol, it's not that bad, but it could use a little tweaks. I understand it's for fun, but I'll just post some ideas for the bigger ones.

Sonic boards tier list V.4
The one that started the fad >_>

This time tourney results and contribution to Sonic's metagame count more. But yes, also contribution to the boards, win, steak, etc is counted for.

Steak
Tenki
KASR

Top
Memphis
KID ~ ShadowLink84
Puffball
DJbrowny
Kojin - Snap Kojin, way to step it up! XD
infzy
MalcolmM - I feel like Malcolm should be higher. He's become a big part of the community lately and he's been reppin' in tournies like crazy.
ROOOOY!
__X__
Boxob.
Catinthehat
Terios - Terry is an AiB ***, lol. He also doesn't go to tournies like me and I'm the best PA Sonic ;o
Sonicmaster5 - Should be top of high tier imo. He's a great Sonic, but he doesn't have too many results to back it up and doesn't partcipate all that much in major discussion. He could get this spot someday though.

High
darkNES386
Greenstreet
Camalange - I should be right above/below Terry XD
Napi
Kinzer
MarKO X
ShadoFiend
Chis
Neon Ness
Knee Knee is cool and all, but he should definitely be Mid. He only really talks in the SBR and mains Falcon...
Teh Umby - Should be Steak Tier since he loves our memes soooo much <3
Twinkletoes
aeghrur
LucKy
InterimOfZeal

Med
Super Sonic 8677
Anthinus
Knee - Wait a sec...this looks right...why is Knee High AND Mid tier? >_> Delete the High one...
Rickerdy-doo-da-day
Raze
EMZ
Magnum - Should be a little higher imo. Contributed more than R4ZE/EMZ. Also his guide is steak.
Gf2tw - Same as Magnum minus guide.
Phoenix Dark
Dark Sonic
Sonic Orochi
Anther
Vyse
Xiivi
Kalm

Low
SonicLucario
Halloween Captain
BT
Black belt
Havokk
Orange_soda_man
dark_Illusion_hokage
-Blue-
Shugo
Blapius
Ithrowthings

Bottom
SonicX580
The_Dyne
Hypersupersonic
Sonic-Fan
Spin dash
Catt
Pain
SBR - Too high, imo
Marry Sonic - Too high, imo

Serious business?

Pleez dun report meh D:

EDIT: Oh, why isn't this in the OP?

 

[Jim Morrison]

I just dun understand why Knee would deserve to be above Sonic mains O_o... I mean really, he's cool, but not Sonic main cool...

And I made a thread on how to play on the edge (which died)

 

[Zeallyx]

wow you guys are kinda mean about it though..
even cat

Its not like I asked to be on there at all..
still, thanks for listing me..twice ^_^

but if you all dont want me to be on there, or not that 'high' just put me bottom of bottom, everyone will be happy..

and gf2, not sonic main cool? wanna take this online?

 

[Jim Morrison]

wow you guys are kinda mean about it though..
even cat

Its not like I asked to be on there at all..
still, thanks for listing me..twice ^_^

but if you all dont want me to be on there, or not that 'high' just put me bottom of bottom, everyone will be happy..

and gf2, not sonic main cool? wanna take this online?

Apologies accepted.

 

[Kinzer]

This why serious business and internet don't mix well.

I told you people already, this is silly, and you should look at the tier list from my perspective... I already told you how to do that in a previous post.

 

[Camalange]

Again, we have someone misinterpretting(spelling? lol, I don't have the spellcheck function) something over the internet.

Knee, I don't think I came off rude about it at all. And all I said was that you should be lower since you don't even main/second Sonic, and you only post in the SBR...you're not bottom of bottom tier...

 

[Kinzer]

As long as you think Sonic is cool, you're better than the false SBR.

 

[Zeallyx]

Again, we have someone misinterpretting(spelling? lol, I don't have the spellcheck function) something over the internet.

Knee, I don't think I came off rude about it at all. And all I said was that you should be lower since you don't even main/second Sonic, and you only post in the SBR...you're not bottom of bottom tier...

I didn't misinterpretted (wow, spelling? lol) anything, this list is obviously something to take with a grain of salt, and my addition to the list is a joke, I understand that, but I thought you guys did too. I guess you do though ^_^

As I don't main sonic, and only post in the SBR (normally ^_^), I shouldn't be able to get out of bottom tier of this list at all. ^_^

 

[Camalange]

You you should be Knee Tier.

Which can be right in the middle of Mid Tier, lol.

 

[Jim Morrison]

Being in the sBR already justifies a low-mid tier position, regardless of anything.

 

[thecatinthehat]

wow you guys are kinda mean about it though..
even cat

hmm?

I really dont see what I said to offend you. D:

 

[Zeallyx]

hmm?

I really dont see what I said to offend you. D:

you see...

you dont make a legit rebuttal, because you know you're wrong...

Anyone can just look at the facts and see....

this thread fails, and doesnt rep the Sonic boards..

Why is Knee so high?

He doesnt even play SOnic.

Memphis doesnt do ****.

me and Box are so low becuase we all know we've been *****es to you.

you're the only one to make the list.

its WAAYY too biased.

edit: Kinzer, I'm bored, and I enjoy debates.

yeah..
I am mid tier..as the High tier was clearly a mistake, as I was listed twice.
As this list seems to based off of opinion rather than anything else, you saying I should be lower than mid tier is not very nice..

also you capatalized the 'S' and the 'O' in sonic, this probably means nothing, but beeing the paranoid person as I am, to me it implied something insulting.

But the fact is, I don't belong on this list. You guys are my favorite people on swf, but your tier list is yours ^_^

and @ cam: knee tier..lulz