Smashboards Creates: Animation Superstar Showdown, a Cartoon Super Smash Bros. (Animated Smash Bros. Reboot)

[DragonRobotKing26]

while Super Smash Bros. is a celebration of gaming, an alternate universe is created another Smash-styled game, but it's uses animation characters and it will be a celebration of animation or a kind of Cartoon All-Stars game, also this game is a reboot of another thread called Animated Smash Bros.

Rules:
-Anime characters are allowed
-Web Animation characters are allowed, but are just original characters
-Book/Comic Book adaptations in animation are allowed
-Adult Cartoons characters are allowed, but it have to censoring a lot for get more kid-friendly
-Video Games adaptations in animation characters aren't allowed (no Ash & Pikachu, no Sonic, no Mario, etc.)
-Animation Movies characters are allowed
-Commercial Food mascots aren't allowed

Spoiler: Characters (10/36)

Mickey Mouse (Mickey Mouse & Friends) Debut: Steamboat Willie (1928) Default Character Moveset/Misc​	Bugs Bunny (Looney Tunes) Debut: A Wild Hare (1940) Default Character​	Betty Boop (Betty Boop) Debut: Dizzy Dishes (1930) Submitted by: cashregister9​	Homer Simpson (The Simpsons) Debut: Good Night (1987) Submitted By: Otoad64 Moveset/Misc​	Spongebob Squarepants (Spongebob Squarepants) Debut: Help Wanted (1999) Submitted By: D darkvortex​
Popeye (Popeye The Sailor Man) Debut: Timble Theatre (1929) Submitted By: TheGipper​	Sailor Moon (Sailor Moon) Debut: The Crybaby: Usagi's Beautiful Transformation (1995 / in Anime) Submitted By: TheGipper​	Son Goku (Dragon Ball) Debut: The Secret of The Dragon Balls (1986 / in Anime) Submitted By: Otoad64​	Shrek (Shrek) Debut: Shrek (2001) Submitted By: MartianSnake​	Wallace & Gromit (Wallace and Gromit) Debut: A Grand Day Out (1989) Submitted By: D darkvortex​
?​	?​	?​	?​	?​
?​	?​	?​	?​	?​
?​	?​	?​	?​	?​
?​	?​	?​	?​	?​

?​

BONUS ?​

Spoiler: Characters in List

1. Mickey Mouse (Moveset/Misc)
2. Bugs Bunny
3. Betty Boop
4. Homer Simpson (Moveset/Misc)
5. Spongebob Squarepants
6. Popeye
7. Sailor Moon
8. Goku
9. Shrek
10. Wallace & Gromit

Spoiler: Items

1. ACME Anvil (Looney Tunes)
2. Spinach Can (Popeye)
3. Luxo Ball (Pixar)
4. Chemical X (The Powerpuff Girls)

Spoiler: Stages (5/40)

Steamboat Willie (Mickey Mouse & Friends) Submitted By: Otoad64​	The Woods (Looney Tunes) Submitted By: Otoad64​	Mystery Cave (Betty Boop) Submitted By: M Master Hero Sock-on-Rye​	Springfield Nuclear Power Plant (The Simpsons) Submitted By: Louie G.​	Krusty Krab (Spongebob Squarepants) Submitted By: D darkvortex​
?​	?​	?​	?​	?​
?​	?​	?​	?​	?​
?​	?​	?​	?​	?​
?​	?​	?​	?​	?​
?​	?​	?​	?​	?​
?​	?​	?​	?​	?​
?​	?​	?​	?​	?​

BONUS ?​

Spoiler: Assists

Speed Racer (Speed Racer)
Scrat (Ice Age)
Taz (Looney Tunes)
Toodles (Mickey Mouse & Friends)
Dragon (Shrek)
Squidward (Spongebob Squarepants)

Spoiler: Bosses (1/10)

Bill Cipher (Gravity Falls) Submitted By: D darkvortex​	?​	?​	?​	?​
?​	?​	?​	?​	?​

Spoiler: Game Modes

Classic Mode
-Bonus Levels
--Vaudeville Revue
Versus Mode
-Stock Battle
-Time Battle
-Team Battle
Training Mode
Toon Force Mode

Spoiler: Film Reels

Steamboat Willie (Mickey Mouse & Friends)
Get a Horse (Mckey Mouse & Friends)
Rabbit Fire (Looney Tunes)
Swing You Sinners (Betty Boop)
St. James Infirmary Dance (Betty Boop)
Good Night (The Simpsons)
Krusty Krab Training Video (Spongebob Squarpants)
Far Far Away Idol (Shrek)

Spoiler: List of Jobs

Job 1: Submit a Cartoon Character
Job 2: Submit How Many Characters and Stages It Need
Job 3: Submit a Title of The Game
Job 4: Submit a Stage for Mickey Mouse
Job 5: Submit Item
Job 6: Submit an Anime Character
Job 7: Submit a Stage for Bugs Bunny
Job 8: Pitch How Could Be The Gameplay
Job 9: Submit a Stage for Betty Boop
Job 10: Submit an Assist Character
Job 11: Submit a Game Mode
Job 12: Pitch How Many Alternate Costume The Fighters Need
Job 13: Submit a Stage for Homer Simpson
Job 14: Submit a Trophy/Spirit-Like Collectable
Job 15: Submit an Animated Movie Character
Job 16: Submit a Moveset for Any Character (Skipped)
Job 17: Submit a Stage for Spongebob
Job 18: Submit a Boss and/or a Boss Number
Job 19: Sumbit a Film Reel
Job 20: Submit a Character from a Represented Series
Job 21: Submit a Bonus Level
Job 22: Submit a Shooting or Melee Item
Job 23: Submit a Stage for Popeye
Job 24: Submit a Non-Fighter Stage
Job 25: Submit a Web Animation/Indie Animation Character

 

[DragonRobotKing26]

Job 1: Submit a Cartoon Character

for start go submit a character

 

[Louie G.]

Job 1: Fred Flintstone (The Flintstones)

I think Fred is a really efficient first draft pick for this roster. Historically, he's a precursor to television animation as we know it and the framework that built other iconic cartoons like The Simpsons and Family Guy. Functionally, he provides more of a heavy, blunt physical bruiser character in contrast to Mickey and Bugs likely being more all-rounder types. His caveman essence is easily interpretable into a fun, easily understood moveset. He's immediately iconic and a figurehead for one of animation's most influential studios. I think he's a no-brainer.

I contemplated more contemporary characters to balance out Bugs / Mickey's old school flair, like 90s onward, but I think there are a few meaningful picks from earlier in animation history like Fred here who can serve as the groundwork first much like they've done for the industry.

I'm assuming anime is fair game too? Just clarifying in case, since it's deliberately called "cartoon" all-stars that there could be a divide in understanding here.

 

[darkvortex]

Spongebob Squarepants
Our two current picks are both classic older characters, so I think it makes sense to go with something more relatively modern. Spongebob has already been in a fighting game so we have an idea of how he could potentially play, though we will obviously do things differently. I think his personality would make for a fun moveset, and there's plenty we could still pull.from that his previous appearances haven't

 

[DragonRobotKing26]

I'm assuming anime is fair game too? Just clarifying in case, since it's deliberately called "cartoon" all-stars that there could be a divide in understanding here.

anime is allowed on this thread,and it's planned having an Anime character job

 

[Otoad64]

Job 1: Homer Simpson

I always imagined him as a grappler.

 

[Northsouthmap]

Tom & Jerry
They would be a duo character, similar to their version in MultiVersus.

 

[DragonRobotKing26]

Job 1: Woody Woodpecker

Woody Woodpecker is the eponymous protagonist from a cartoon from Universal Pictures and he was created by Walter Lantz, Woody Woodpecker can have a good moveset based on his old cartoons or would be kinda original

 

[Qwerty UIOP]

Job 1: Felix The Cat (...)

One of the oldest faces in animation and one of the most recognizable. His moveset will probably be inspired by his Van Bueren incarnation, utilizing his Bag of Magic Tricks.

 

[cashregister9]

Job 1

Betty Boop

One of the most iconic women in the history of animation. She could pull from many of her cartoons from over the years for her moveset.

 

[MartianSnake]

Gertie the Dinosaur
Widely considered THE FIRST original cartoon star, Gertie is unique for really only having one short to pull from, one where she interacts with a real life man that isn't even present in the film itself, instead being physically present in the theater. Her short pioneered a ton of animation methods. Even the Disney company, a company that

From a character perspective, she's VERY unique. A massive quadrupled character is nothing to sneeze at, and although she's really only got one short to pull from, I think she'd be a great inclusion.

 

[Mamboo07]

Job 1:

Scooby & Shaggy
Since these two are pretty much seen together through the Scooby-Doo franchise a lot, I imagine they would utilize the many things they've done to fight their opponents, I guess.

 

[TheGipper]

Job 1:

Popeye. The classic brawler archetype. Probably comes with a boost mechanic once the spinach comes into play.

 

[DragonRobotKing26]

alright, that is the characters that we have for this job,it's all a great choices

Fred Flinstone ( Louie G. )
Spongebob Squarepants ( D darkvortex )
Homer Simpson ( Otoad64 )
Tom & Jerry ( Northsouthmap )
Woody Woodpecker ( DragonRobotKing26 )
Felix The Cat ( Qwerty UIOP )
Betty Boop ( cashregister9 )
Gertie The Dinosaur ( MartianSnake )
Scooby Doo & Shaggy ( Mamboo07 )
Popeye ( TheGipper )

vote on 5 on these characters,i will add 3 of them for the roster and your submission can't get on 1st

1. Spongebob (for complete the cartoon big 3)
2. Homer Simpson (for rerpesenting the adult cartoons)
3. Betty Boop (for have a female character on the roster)
4. Scooby Doo and Shaggy (a good Hanna-Barbera rep,and they're very iconic)
5. Felix The Cat (Felix is literally the Pac-Man from cartoons)

-------

The next job is....

Job 2: Submit How Many Characters and Stages It Need

yes,the roster and stages need a number of how many characters for the roster and how many stage does it need it

Job 3: Submit a Title for The Game

the game also need a title, give your idea for the title that it could be not Animated Smash Bros

Job 4: Submit a Stage for Mickey Mouse

one more job,this one is for you submit a Stage for the first character from the roster,Mickey Mouse

 

[Otoad64]

1. Spongeboy me bob
2. Homer
3. Gertie
4. Felix
5. Shaggy & Scoob

Job 2: 36 characters, 40 stages

Job 4: Steamboat Willie

The setting of Mickey's original debut itself.

 

[MartianSnake]

1. Popeye
2. Betty Boop
3. Scooby & Shaggy
4. Tom & Jerry
5. Gertie the Dinosaur

Sticking to classics with my votes, avoiding characters that fill the "funny talking animal that usually wears gloves" niche for now, seeing as Mickey & Bugs are both that.

Side note: SpongeBob deserves to be in the game but calling him part of the "big three" with mickey and bugs feels so wrong to me.

Job 2:
40 characters. Maybe a lot, but there's a lot of cartoon history to add, especially if film, anime, and comic-turned-cartoon characters are allowed. Even 30 feels too low. Oh, and 46 stages.

Job 3:
Animation Superstar Showdown!

Job 4:

Sorcery Cliff
There's a lot of options out there for mickey's stage, but I wanna focus on his magnum opus, Sorcerer's Apprentice. Fantasia is probably the definitive piece of "animation as art", atleast in terms of popularity. It's a piece that deserves to be represented in a game like this, and making it the mickey stage would allow us to represent it without having too much Disney rep down the line.

The stage would be set on a cliffside, with stars and waves swooshing and crashing around. Yen Sid's castle is in the background, as are the walking Broomsticks. No hazards are present, a simple two-plat stage.

 

[Louie G.]

1. Betty Boop - A great choice to represent Fleischer toons, and a strong leading choice for female characters which I fear we might have a shortage of early on. I would love to see her join the roster and I think her bubbly unassuming nature would make her a fun fighter.

2. Popeye - An absolute no-brainer, pretty much the defacto cartoon "bruiser" archetype. He'll be on the roster eventually so I say just get it over with.

3. Fred Flintstone - Already explained myself, sticking to my guns here that this is a good establishing choice. IMO a much more compelling and fun choice for a Hanna Barbera character than Scooby and Shaggy, with a more evident gameplan and moveset potential.

4. Gertie the Dinosaur - I considered this too, a wonderful out of the box pick although I wouldn't mind holding off til we get more of the bare essentials in. Still I wanna voice my support for her down the line. She could be a "giant" character and we could use some non-humanoids.

5. Spongebob - Well, duh. I think both he and Homer Simpson should (and will) be here but I'm opting for the Sponge as my pick for more 'contemporary' toon right now on account of his moveset potential. Homer's is a bit more generic whereas Spongebob's is vibrant and writes itself.

Homer Simpson and Tom & Jerry are must-haves at some point or another, but I'm not ready to vote them in yet. Felix and Woody feel like staples too, but I worry that having too many characters adjacent to Mickey / Bugs kind of everyman archetype is something we might run into. Felix gets to be more abstract and Woody much more wild and in your face, but I think they're just a bit too close for comfort for me at this particular moment.
----

Job 2: I'm gonna say 32 characters. I'm inclined to agree with Otoad's suggestion for 36 but just figure I'll throw another option out there. I don't mind keeping things on the tighter end for the sake of really maximizing what we have.

And we can do 40 stages. That'll be enough for every character to have a home stage as well as extra stages for those less equipped to provide or just missing the boat for a playable character.

 

[Mamboo07]

Character Votes

1. Betty
2. Popeye
3. Gertie
4. Homer
5. Fred

Job 2: 34 characters and 42 stages (some stages without a fighter representation)

 

[DragonRobotKing26]

1. Betty
2. Popeye
3. Gertie
4. Homer
5. Fred

Job 2: 34 characters I guess

You should submit both characters and stages number,not just a character number for the roster

 

[darkvortex]

1. Popeye
2. Betty Boop
3. Fred Flinstone
4. Scooby & Shaggy
5. Homer

 

[TheGipper]

1. Scooby & Shaggy
2. Betty Boop
3. Popeye
4. Homer
5. Spongebob

Job 3: "The Art of War."

Job 4: The House of Mouse

Easiest way to include a large number of references from the biggest animation studio on earth plus excerpts of old cartoons can be played in the background as you fight on the stage.

 

[Qwerty UIOP]

1. Scooby and Shaggy
2. Spongebob Squarepants
3. Betty Boop
4. Homer Simpson
5. Felix The Cat

 

[cashregister9]

1. Spongebob
2. Homer
3. Popeye
4. Betty
5. Fred

 

[Northsouthmap]

1. SpongeBob
2. Homer
3. Scooby & Shaggy
4. Popeye
5. Betty Boop

39 Characters and 40 Stages

Animation Domination

Mickey Mouse Clubhouse
The stage spins around similar to Spiral Mountain in Smash.

 

[DragonRobotKing26]

Fred Flintstone: 8
Spongebob: 26
Homer Simpson: 23
Tom & Jerry: 2
Woody Woodpecker: 0
Felix The Cat: 4
Betty Boop: 32
Gertie The Dinosaur: 9
Scooby Doo & Shaggy: 21
Popeye: 26

the winner from the first place is the iconic female character from the golden age of cartoons, Betty Boop, with 32 points, congratulations cashregister9

the winner from the second place, we have a tie, it's Spongebob Squarepants and Popeye, but we need to break a tie here on Strawpoll

and the winner from the third place is the the iconic cartoon dad, Homer Simpson with 23 points, good job Otoad64

sorry,i got confused Homer with Scooby & Shaggy

---------

Animation Superstar Showdown! ( MartianSnake )
The Art of War ( TheGipper )
Animation Domination ( Northsouthmap )

36 Characters, 40 Stages ( Otoad64 )
40 Characters, 46 Stages ( MartianSnake )
32 Characters, 40 Stages ( Louie G. )
34 Characters, 42 Stages ( Mamboo07 )
39 Characters, 40 Stages ( Northsouthmap )

Steamboat Willie ( Otoad64 )
Sorcery Cliff ( MartianSnake )
The House of Mouse ( TheGipper )
Mickey Mouse Clubhouse ( Northsouthmap )

well,this is the submissions that we have, for the title, you just vote on 2, for the character and stage number, you go vote on 3 and for Mickey's home stage, you have to vote on 3, the vote options for Mickey's stage and character and stage number that you submitted you can't vote in first

1. Animation Superstar Showdown!
2. Animation Domination

1. 40 Characters and 46 Stages
2. 32 Characters and 40 Stages
3. 34 Characters and 42 Stages

1. Steamboat Willie
2. Sorcery Cliff
3. The House of Mouse

-------

The next job is...

Job 5: Submit Items

yes, the next job is you submit items for the game, like the own Smash

Job 6: Submit an Anime Character

yes,and if you read the first post, Anime characters are allowed to join this fake game, and you can submit anime characters on the next future jobs, the manga originated characters that gained the own anime are allowed, but the anime characters from a toy/video game franchise aren't allowed (no Beyblade, no Pokémon, no Bakugan, no OVA/Anime from any video game series )

Job 7: Submit a Stage for Bugs Bunny

now Bugs is the next one to get a stage, you can submit a stage related on Looney Tunes

 

[Otoad64]

1. Animation Superstar Showdown!
2. The Art of War

1. 32 Characters, 40 Stages
2. 36 Characters, 40 Stages
3. 34 Characters, 42 Stages

1. Sorcery Cliff
2. Steamboat Willie
3. Mickey Mouse Clubhouse

Anime Character: Goku (kid version)

I think he fits in with the cartoon characters a bit better. And he's the original version of Goku

 

[MartianSnake]

1. Animation Domination
2. Animation Superstar Showdown

The Art of War is too vague for what this thread is about, I feel.

1. Otoad's Numbers
2. Mamboo's Numbers
3. Louie's Numbers

1. House of Mouse
2. Sorcery Cliff
3. Steamboat Willie

Astro Boy
Yet another classic, but I feel it's really important we get Astro Boy in this game. He's a very influential character on a global scale. While guys like Goku are deserving, there's a fear of mine that we'll accidentally leave behind some of the classics that predate all the shonen jump fellas

 

[Mamboo07]

Title

1. Animation Domination
2. Animation Superstar Showdown

Character/Stage Numbers

1. Otoad
2. Northsouthmap
3. MartianSnake

Mickey's Stage

1. House of Mouse
2. Steamboat
3. Clubhouse

Job 5: Items

ACME Anvil
The ACME-produced anvils that have appeared in various Looney Tunes cartoons, usually as a part of a "heavyweight gag", with their most famous appearances being in the Road Runner and Wile E. Coyote shorts.

The ACME Anvil can be picked up and thrown at opponents, dealing major damage.

Job 6: Anime Character

Ayumu "Osaka" Kasuga
One of the main girls from the comedic slice-of-life anime and manga series, Azumanga Daioh.

By far the most unusual of Yukari's students. She was given the nickname "Osaka" by Tomo since she's a transfer student from Osaka, though she only lived there for a year. Much to her chagrin, everyone else starts to call her by the nickname; even the school uses it over her actual name.

I imagine her moveset being like Villager/Isabelle from Smash Bros, using items/objects to fight with.

Job 7: Bugs Bunny Stage

The Woods
Bugs Bunny is iconic, and one of the most common scenes that come to mind from the cartoons is The Woods where he gets up to shenanigans with Daffy Duck and Elmer Fudd.

This stage could have the hole in the ground that Bugs pops out of as a trap door to knock your opponent through, as well as the Duck Season and Rabbit Season signs on trees.

Elmer Fudd himself would be a stage hazard shooting at fighters with his gun.

 

[Qwerty UIOP]

1. 40 Characters, 46 Stages
2. 32 Characters, 40 Stages
3. 34 Characters, 42 Stages

1. Steamboat Willie
2. Mickey Mouse Clubhouse
3. House of Mouse

Job #5: Item - Spinach Can (Popeye/Thimble Theatre)

A can of vegetables that holds great power. Once someone eats it, they get a small portion of their health healed and a temporary boost in strength.

Job #6: Anime Character - Kenshiro (Fist Of The North Star)

The main protagonist from the anime, Fist Of The North Star. I went for him because FotNS helped inspire some of other popular animes, like Berserk and Jojo's Bizarre Adventure. Also the anime was the birthplace of the infamous "You're Already Dead." meme.

Job #7: Bugs Bunny Stage - What's Opera, Doc?

A location from one of the most popular Looney Tunes cartoons. Occasionally, the shadow of Elmer will rise and thunder will strike the stage, damaging anybody that gets caught in their crosshairs.

(Note: If it wasn't a Bugs Bunny specific job, I would have picked Wackyland.)

 

[DragonRobotKing26]

Job 5: Pixar Ball

the pixar ball is an object used on some Pixar movies, the ball would be used as a common throwing item

Job 6: Monkey D. Luffy (One Piece)

Monkey D. Luffy is the protagonist from the long-running anime series One Piece, he is a pirate that stretch his limbs and he is from a crew called Straw Hat Pirates, and it could be good a moveset from him as a grappler

 

[ssbashworld]

Guts (Berserk)

On my watchlist so dont have much to say but think a big sword fighter from a dark fantasy series would make for a fun, unique fighter.

 

[TheGipper]

Names:
1. Animation Domination
2. Animation Superstar Showdown

MartianSnake makes a solid point about my suggestion, I was just extremely proud of my pun lol.

Character/Stages:
1. 34 Characters, 42 Stages
2. 40 Characters, 46 Stages
3. 36 Characters, 40 Stages

Mickey Stage:
1. Steamboat Willie
2. House Of Mouse
3. Mickey Mouse Clubhouse

Job 5: Chemical X (From the Powerpuff Girls)

When thrown, the Chemical X creates an explosion of energy, causing random effects: it can deal damage, randomly buff the user, or disorient enemies for a few seconds.

Job 6: Sailor Moon

It's Sailor freaking Moon. The face of the magical girl genre and one of the most recognisable names in anime if not animation period. I would imagine a lot of ranged attacks mixed with martial arts melee moves.

Job 7: The Medieval Castle from "Knighty Knight Bugs"

Might as well have a stage that represents the only Bugs Bunny short that ever won an Oscar. Fight in the royal hall as The Black Knight (Also known as Yosemite Sam) rests in the corner. Meanwhile every now and then the green dragon sneezes fire in a wide array which the fighters must avoid.

 

[Louie G.]

the winner from the second place, we have a tie, it's Spongebob Squarepants and Popeye, but we need to break a tie here on Strawpoll

I'm a bit confused about this, if Spongebob and Popeye both beat Homer then shouldn't they be #2 and #3? We're breaking a tie for second place (26 votes each) and added the third place to the roster already (24 votes). Correct me if I'm wrong but I feel like Homer missed the boat this round.

 

[DragonRobotKing26]

I'm a bit confused about this, if Spongebob and Popeye both beat Homer then shouldn't they be #2 and #3? We're breaking a tie for second place (26 votes each) and added the third place to the roster already (24 votes). Correct me if I'm wrong but I feel like Homer missed the boat this round.

i couldn't put two characters on same vote points, so i decide to make to break a tie, the vote result is the winner having more vote points, even the characters have less votes but a little higher

or i can make an example

Character A can have 25 points for being a winner in first place
Character B can have 23 points for being a winner in second place
and Character C nad D can have 15 points but one of them needs to be eliminated

the vote session depends the user that created the thread,on this thread it's just by my choices but even that the other users voted more on their posts

 

[Louie G.]

Job 6: Lupin III (Lupin the Third)

A master thief and anime / manga icon in his own right, I think Lupin contributes a great deal to keeping our roster full of diverse fighting styles with his thieving techniques and firearms and also represents one of the most historically resonant manga series of all time. Lupin still receives anime adaptations to this day and while his popularity never fully translated overseas, he's a household name in Japan. Everyone so far is pretty toony, or not really a fighter perse, and I anticipate a lot of shonen nominations here so I'd like to break the mold and offer Lupin as an alternative. One with more historical roots who can similarly offer a fun and pretty straightforward premise for a moveset.

Honorable mention goes to Doraemon. I actually think Doraemon is THE anime / manga character to add, and I'l vote them if someone else were to nominate them. But Lupin is not far behind and adds a pretty different flavor to the current lineup.

i couldn't put two characters on same vote points, so i decide to make to break a tie, the vote result is the winner having more vote points, even the characters have less votes but a little higher

I don't really understand why you'd do this, instead of simply taking the three highest voted characters like we've done in similar threads.

You're saying that a character can perform better than another character (say, Popeye - 26 vs Homer Simpson - 24) and still get screwed just because they tied with someone else (Spongebob - 26)? Feels like overcomplicating things and frankly does not feel very fair at all. But it's your thread. I will just be transparent and say if this is the precedent we're setting I might not participate for very long.

 

[DragonRobotKing26]

I don't really understand why you'd do this, instead of simply taking the three highest voted characters like we've done in similar threads.

You're saying that a character can perform better than another character (say, Popeye - 26 vs Homer Simpson - 24) and still get screwed just because they tied with someone else (Spongebob - 26)? Feels like overcomplicating things and frankly does not feel very fair at all. But it's your thread. I will just be transparent and say if this is the precedent we're setting I might not participate for very long.

i counted how many votes Spongebob and Popeye get it, and the result is both got the same vote number, and i was thinking on change the roster based on the votes by that you said

guys,what are you think?,does Popeye and Spongebob needs to get both joins the roster or just one of them needs to be eliminated for break the tie?

 

[Otoad64]

Yeah, I do think it makes more sense for them both to be added. Doing it this way is just kinda confusing.

 

[MartianSnake]

Yeah I didn't really fully grasp what was going on at first, but yeah louie's perspective makes a lot more sense in retrospect. If there's multiple winners and a tie for second or first place it just makes sense to include both and push out the character that is, by all accounts, fourth place. If this were a tie for third place, it'd be another story

 

[Qwerty UIOP]

1. Animation Superstar Showdown
2. Animation Domination

 

[DragonRobotKing26]

alright,you ordered,so it mean that i'll put both Spongebob and Popeye on the roster

and let's continue the current jobs that we're doing