t3h Icy
Smash Master
- Joined
- Jun 12, 2009
- Messages
- 4,917
As part of the Melee Match-Up Chart thread, I've created a thread for each character board to split up discussion. Currently the Melee chart is based on a collaborative opinion on each match-up, while we're going to slowly move towards spreading the discussion.
For now, the Melee Match-Up Chart will represent both sides of what the boards think, so for example, the Fox boards and the Falco boards will both have their respective opinions listed on the chart, so (for example) Fox may be 50:50, while Falco may be 55:45. This will be similar to Rajam's style for the current Brawl chart, which seems to be working well and staying accurate. Perhaps afterward, we can try to trim things down to one value for each match-up, but that will be a step in the future.
Currently, there is no order in which to discuss match-ups, but I may guide them if needed.
This topic is for Roy's match-ups. The format is the standard 0-100 (including 5s). Any opinions are helpful and appreciated, and once there's a consensus for a match-up, I'll add it to the match-up chart.
Thanks.
Moderator Edit:
Roy's matchups at a glance:
We're still working on these overall, but here's an update so you don't have to scour the thread
General consensus:
Bowser 55-45
CF 45-55
DK 50-50
Falco 40-60
Ganon 30-70
G&W 65-35
IC's 15-85
Mario 40-60
Pikachu 45-55
Samus 30-70
Yoshi 50-50
Y. Link 60-40
Disputed:
Doc 40-60 / 35-65
Fox 45-55 / 35-65
Jiggs 45-55 / 40-60
!Kirby 70-30 / 45-55!
Link 50-50 / 45-55
Luigi 40-60 / 30-70
Marth 45-55 / 35-65
!Mewtwo 50-50 / 35-65!
Ness 60-40 / 50-50
Peach 40-60 / 30-70
Pichu 70-30 / 60-40
Shiek 40-60 / 30-70
Zelda 50-50 / 40-60
We'll probably continue discussing these and never come to an agreement.
For now, the Melee Match-Up Chart will represent both sides of what the boards think, so for example, the Fox boards and the Falco boards will both have their respective opinions listed on the chart, so (for example) Fox may be 50:50, while Falco may be 55:45. This will be similar to Rajam's style for the current Brawl chart, which seems to be working well and staying accurate. Perhaps afterward, we can try to trim things down to one value for each match-up, but that will be a step in the future.
Currently, there is no order in which to discuss match-ups, but I may guide them if needed.
This topic is for Roy's match-ups. The format is the standard 0-100 (including 5s). Any opinions are helpful and appreciated, and once there's a consensus for a match-up, I'll add it to the match-up chart.
Thanks.
Moderator Edit:
Roy's matchups at a glance:
We're still working on these overall, but here's an update so you don't have to scour the thread
General consensus:
Bowser 55-45
CF 45-55
DK 50-50
Falco 40-60
Ganon 30-70
G&W 65-35
IC's 15-85
Mario 40-60
Pikachu 45-55
Samus 30-70
Yoshi 50-50
Y. Link 60-40
Disputed:
Doc 40-60 / 35-65
Fox 45-55 / 35-65
Jiggs 45-55 / 40-60
!Kirby 70-30 / 45-55!
Link 50-50 / 45-55
Luigi 40-60 / 30-70
Marth 45-55 / 35-65
!Mewtwo 50-50 / 35-65!
Ness 60-40 / 50-50
Peach 40-60 / 30-70
Pichu 70-30 / 60-40
Shiek 40-60 / 30-70
Zelda 50-50 / 40-60
We'll probably continue discussing these and never come to an agreement.