Rating the fan-requested characters: do you want them playable or not?

[Rocketjay8]

Someone who's attracted to people in the 11-14 age range (without being in that age range or up to 4 years above it themselves) is not a paedophile. The proper term is ephebophilia.

You do realize that doesn't make it less creepy.

Can everyone in this thread agree that sexualizing minors is bad!

 

[Luigifan18]

You do realize that doesn't make it less creepy.

Can everyone in this thread agree that sexualizing minors is bad!

Oh, yes, I do realize that doesn't make it less creepy... I first heard of the concept via Mogeko Castle, after all.

 

[Verde Coeden Scalesworth]

Get back on-topic. How the artist draws them and definitions have nothing to do with Smash nor this. Same with the definitions of those terms.

 

[DarthEnderX]

A: Toad or Captain Toad
C: Waluigi
D: Paper Mario
C: Ashley
C: Dixie Kong
C: Funky Kong
A: Impa
C: Skull Kid
C: Midna
C: Ghirahim
B: Bandana Dee
C: Krystal
C: Gengar
C: Sceptile
C: Gardevoir
C: Zoroark
A: Decidueye
C: Lycanroc
C: Mimikyu
A: Ninten
A: Black Shadow
A: Samurai Goroh
C: Lyn
B: Black Knight
B: Medusa
C: Shadow
C: Knuckles
C: Elma
C: Rex & Pyra
C: Octoling
C: Issac
D: Chorus Kids
C: Karate Joe
C: Takamaru
C: Excitbiker
C: Mach Rider
C: Chibi-Robo
B: Spring Man
B: Bomberman
B: Geno
C: Banjo & Kazooie
C: Rayman
B: Shovel Knight
B: Shantae
B: Alucard
B: Zero
C: Sora
C: Crash

 

[TheTrueBrawler]

D: Toad or Captain Toad
A: Waluigi
F: Paper Mario
B: Ashley
B: Dixie Kong
C: Funky Kong
B: Impa
A: Skull Kid
A: Midna
F: Ghirahim
A: Bandana Dee
A: Krystal
F: Gengar
F: Sceptile
C: Gardevoir
F: Zoroark
B: Decidueye
F: Lycanroc
C: Mimikyu
F: Ninten
F: Black Shadow
F: Samurai Goroh
B: Lyn
F: Black Knight
A: Medusa
A: Shadow
C: Knuckles
C: Elma
S: Rex & Pyra
B: Octoling
S: Issac
F: Chorus Kids
D: Karate Joe
F: Takamaru
D: Excitbiker
C: Mach Rider
F: Chibi-Robo
A: Spring Man
B: Bomberman
A: Geno
A: Banjo & Kazooie
B: Rayman
B: Shovel Knight
B: Shantae
S: Alucard
C: Zero
C: Sora
B: Crash

Instead of E, I used F for “F*** No”.

 

[Vanguard227]

B: Toad or Captain Toad
B: Waluigi
B: Paper Mario
C: Ashley
B: Dixie Kong
C: Funky Kong
S: Impa
S: Skull Kid 2
B: Midna
B: Ghirahim
S: Bandana Dee
B: Krystal
C: Gengar
A: Sceptile
C: Gardevoir
C: Zoroark
A: Decidueye
C: Lycanroc
C: Mimikyu
B: Ninten
A: Black Shadow
B: Samurai Goroh
B: Lyn
B: Black Knight
C: Medusa
A: Shadow
B: Knuckles
B: Elma
C: Rex & Pyra
C: Octoling
S: Issac
C: Chorus Kids
C: Karate Joe
C: Takamaru
C: Excitbiker
B: Mach Rider
C: Chibi-Robo
B: Spring Man
A: Bomberman
S: Geno
S: Banjo & Kazooie (More like SS)
S: Rayman
S: Shovel Knight
A: Shantae
A: Alucard
B: Zero
B: Sora
S: Crash

 

[A-money2121]

E: Toad or Captain Toad
D: Waluigi
B: Paper Mario
S: Ashley
B: Dixie Kong
D: Funky Kong
B: Impa
B: Skull Kid
A: Midna
B: Ghirahim
A: Bandana Dee
A: Krystal
B: Gengar
A: Sceptile
C: Gardevoir
S: Zoroark
S: Decidueye
C: Lycanroc
D: Mimikyu
B: Ninten
A: Black Shadow
C: Samurai Goroh
C: Lyn
A: Black Knight
A: Medusa
B: Shadow
B: Knuckles
A: Elma
S: Rex & Pyra
A: Octoling
S: Issac
B: Chorus Kids
E: Karate Joe
C: Takamaru
D: Excitebiker
B: Mach Rider
A: Chibi-Robo
S: Spring Man
A: Bomberman
SSSSSS++++: Geno
SSSSSS++++: Banjo & Kazooie
A: Rayman
A: Shovel Knight
S: Shantae
C: Alucard
B: Zero
D: Sora (if Geno gets in before him, then it'd be a B)
A: Crash