• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Rating the fan-requested characters: do you want them playable or not?

QuintonShark8714

Smash Apprentice
Joined
May 30, 2015
Messages
188
Location
Houston, TX
NNID
Monroeshark8713
These are the remaining characters people want to be playable, deconfirmed or not

Toad or Captain Toad (Super Mario)
Waluigi (Super Mario)
Paper Mario (Super Mario)
Ashley (WarioWare)
Dixie Kong (Donkey Kong)
Funky Kong (Donkey Kong)
Impa (The Legend of Zelda)
Skull Kid (The Legend of Zelda)
Midna (The Legend of Zelda)
Ghirahim (The Legend of Zelda)
Bandana Dee (Kirby)
Krystal (Star Fox)
Gengar (Pokemon)
Sceptile (Pokemon)
Gardevoir (Pokemon)
Zoroark (Pokemon)
Decidueye (Pokemon)
Lycanroc (Pokemon)
Mimikyu (Pokemon)
Ninten (Earthbound/Mother)
Black Shadow (F-Zero)
Samurai Goroh (F-Zero)
Lyn (Fire Emblem)
Black Knight (Fire Emblem)
Medusa (Kid Icarus)
Shadow (Sonic the Hedgehog)
Knuckles (Sonic the Hedgehog)
Elma (Xenoblade Chronicles)
Rex & Pyra (Xenoblade Chronicles)
Octoling (Splatoon)
Issac (Golden Sun)
Chorus Kids (Rhythm Heaven)
Karate Joe (Rhythm Heaven)
Takamaru (The Mysterious Murasame Castle)
Excitbiker (Excitbike)
Mach Rider (Mach Rider)
Chibi-Robo (Chibi-Robo)
Spring Man (ARMS)
Bomberman (Bomberman)
Zero (Mega Man)
Geno (Super Mario RPG)
Banjo & Kazooie (Banjo & Kazooie)
Rayman (Rayman)
Shovel Knight (Shovel Knight)
Shantae (Shantae)
Alucard (Castlevania)
Sora (Kingdom Hearts)
Crash (Crash Bandicoot)

Who will qualify for a chance to appear in my top 10 list of fan-favorite characters who should become playable characters in a future game? You decide. To participate, you must assign a rating from S to E to each character. Failing to rate every single one of them will invalidate all of your ratings. Bear in mind that you're not rating how much you like the fan-favorite character itself but how much you want it to be made playable in the future. See the table below to understand how the rating system works.

Characters you want to be playable:
S: It's one of my top 10 most wanted newcomers.
A: It's one of my top 20 most wanted newcomers.
B: Not a most wanted, but I'll be happy if confirmed.

Character's you don't want to be playable:
C: Neither happy nor unhappy, just meh.
D: I would hate it if confirmed.
E: NO GOD PLEASE NO!

Please use the format below by copy pasting it and replace the Xs with your ratings. It's very important that you respect the meaning of each rating and not change it to suit your tastes.

X: Toad or Captain Toad
X: Waluigi
X: Paper Mario
X: Ashley
X: Dixie Kong
X: Funky Kong
X: Impa
X: Skull Kid
X: Midna
X: Ghirahim
X: Bandana Dee
X: Krystal
X: Gengar
X: Sceptile
X: Gardevoir
X: Zoroark
X: Decidueye
X: Lycanroc
X: Mimikyu
X: Ninten
X: Black Shadow
X: Samurai Goroh
X: Lyn
X: Black Knight
X: Medusa
X: Shadow
X: Knuckles
X: Elma
X: Rex & Pyra
X: Octoling
X: Issac
X: Chorus Kids
X: Karate Joe
X: Takamaru
X: Excitbiker
X: Mach Rider
X: Chibi-Robo
X: Spring Man
X: Bomberman
X: Geno
X: Banjo & Kazooie
X: Rayman
X: Shovel Knight
X: Shantae
X: Alucard
X: Zero
X: Sora
X: Crash

Alternatively, you may also use a similar format as the one below, which is by the way my own personal submission. Just make sure not to forget a single one if using this format. Notice that I don't have any D or E. It doesn't matter if your submission is polarized, for example they could coincidentally all have the same rating.

S: Gardevoir
A: Toad or Captain Toad, Bandana Dee, Waluigi, Bomberman
B: Shadow, Issac, Impa, Skull Kid, Geno, Black Shadow, Ghirahim, Dixie Kong, Sceptile, Mach Rider, Takamaru, Paper Mario, Chorus Kids, Octoling
C: Spring Man, Black Knight, Ninten, Gengar, Shovel Knight, Rex, Banjo & Kazooie, Midna, Ashley, Shantae, Pyra, Alucard, Zero, Excitbiker, Zoroark, Decidueye, Lycanroc, Mimikyu, Chibi-Robo, Samurai Goroh, Crash, Rayman
 
Last edited:
D

Deleted member

Guest
S: Any of the Zelda characters mentioned, Sylux, Isaac, Rex & Pyra, Sora, Alucard.
A: Banjo & Kazooie, Zero, Gardevoir, Sceptile, Zoroark, Lycanroc.
B: Crash
C: Waluigi
D: Everyone else.
 

Mogisthelioma

Smash Master
Joined
Aug 24, 2018
Messages
3,596
Location
Ravnica
"Fan requested" includes literally any character who wants a fan request, so I'll base my answers on the most statistically popular and the ones I see the most online.
Bandana Dee: Yes
Banjo and Kazooie: Not really
Isaac: No
Shadow: Absolutely not
Geno: Maybe
Magolor: Yes
Impa: Yes
Skull Kid: Yes
Spring Man: Yes
Toad/C. Toad: Ish
Waluigi: Ish
Ashley: No
Dixie Kong: Yes
Krystal: No
Crash: No
Sora: No
Rayman: Ish-ish
Shantae: No
Shovel Knight: No
Any pokemon: No
Elma: Yes
Rex and Pyra: Yes
Marx: Yes
Adeline: Yes
Lyn: Yes-ish
Just about any third party except for Master Chief: No
Master Chief: Yes
Viridi: Yes
 

~Krystal~

True American Heroine
Joined
Nov 6, 2007
Messages
3,124
Location
Texas
S: Toad or Captain Toad
C: Waluigi
S: Paper Mario
A: Ashley
S: Dixie Kong
E: Funky Kong
B: Impa
C: Skull Kid
B: Midna
D: Ghirahim
C: Bandana Dee
S: Krystal
C: Gengar
B: Sceptile
C: Gardevoir
E: Zoroark
C: Decidueye
C: Lycanroc
B: Mimikyu
B: Ninten
C: Black Shadow
D: Samurai Goroh
C: Lyn
D: Black Knight
C: Medusa
C: Shadow
B: Knuckles
B: Elma
E: Rex & Pyra
C: Octoling
C: Isaac
E: Chorus Kids
E: Karate Joe
C: Takamaru
A: Excitebiker
B: Mach Rider
E: Chibi-Robo
C: Spring Man
B: Bomberman
A: Geno
A: Banjo & Kazooie
B: Rayman
D: Shovel Knight
C: Shantae
B: Alucard
C: Zero
C: Sora
C: Crash
 

Luigifan18

Smash Master
Joined
Feb 19, 2015
Messages
3,134
Switch FC
SW-5577-0969-0868
S: Toad or Captain Toad
C: Waluigi
C: Paper Mario
B: Ashley
A: Dixie Kong
D: Funky Kong
C: Impa
C: Skull Kid
C: Midna
C: Ghirahim
A: Bandana Dee
S: Krystal
B: Gengar
B: Sceptile
D: Gardevoir
B: Zoroark
A: Decidueye
A: Lycanroc
B: Mimikyu
B: Ninten
B: Black Shadow
C: Samurai Goroh
B: Lyn
C: Black Knight
B: Medusa
A: Shadow
C: Knuckles
B: Elma
C: Rex & Pyra
C: Octoling
S: Isaac
B: Chorus Kids
D: Karate Joe
B: Takamaru
C: Excitebiker
C: Mach Rider
B: Chibi-Robo
B: Spring Man
S: Bomberman
A: Geno
S: Banjo & Kazooie
A: Rayman
A: Shovel Knight
S: Shantae
B: Alucard
C: Zero
D: Sora
B: Crash

And now for characters who were omitted from the list in the OP:

S: Vaati
S: Lip
S: Arle
A: Blaziken
S: Corsola
S: Dragonite
S: Moge-ko
B: Spyro
A: Tails
A: Klonoa
 
Last edited:

Ninten DS

Smash Apprentice
Joined
Aug 11, 2018
Messages
152
Location
Spain, Galicia
NNID
64-MarioyLuigi
3DS FC
2208-5212-2045
Switch FC
SW-4108-5996-9683
There are quite a number of characters I don't know anything about or their games, so I won't really be able to rate them: basically Fire Emblem and Pokémon characters along with Alucard who I don't even recognize a bit.

S: Toad or Captain Toad
A: Waluigi
B: Paper Mario
C: Ashley
B: Dixie Kong
D: Funky Kong
B: Impa
D: Skull Kid
D: Midna
D: Ghirahim
S: Bandana Dee
A: Krystal
S: Ninten
S: Black Shadow
E: Samurai Goroh
E: Shadow
S: Knuckles
C: Octoling
C: Issac
B: Chorus Kids
B: Karate Joe
C: Takamaru
A: Excitbiker
A: Mach Rider
S: Chibi-Robo
S: Spring Man
A: Bomberman
C: Geno
B: Banjo & Kazooie
S: Rayman
C: Shovel Knight
D: Shantae
D: Zero
E: Sora
D: Crash
 

Battiest Badger

Smash Cadet
Joined
Aug 14, 2018
Messages
33
Location
Ohio, USA
B : Toad or Captain Toad
A : Waluigi
C : Paper Mario
A : Ashley
C : Dixie Kong
C : Funky Kong
C : Impa
C : Skull Kid
C : Midna
C : Ghirahim
C : Bandana Dee
S : Krystal
C : Gengar
S : Sceptile
C : Gardevoir
C : Zoroark
B : Decidueye
C : Lycanroc
C : Mimikyu
C : Ninten
B : Black Shadow
C : Samurai Goroh
C : Lyn
C : Black Knight
A : Medusa
E : Shadow
D : Knuckles
A : Elma
A : Rex & Pyra
S : Octoling
A : Issac
C : Chorus Kids
C : Karate Joe
C : Takamaru
C : Excitebiker
A : Mach Rider
A : Chibi-Robo
A : Spring Man
C : Bomberman
C : Geno
B : Banjo & Kazooie
D : Rayman
C : Shovel Knight
B : Shantae
D : Alucard
D : Zero
E : Sora
E : Crash
 

nirvanafan

Smash Champion
Premium
Joined
Oct 14, 2016
Messages
2,465
B: Toad or Captain Toad
A: Waluigi
B: Paper Mario
B: Ashley
A: Dixie Kong
E: Funky Kong
A: Impa
S: Skull Kid
C: Midna
C: Ghirahim
D: Bandana Dee
B: Krystal
B: Gengar
D: Sceptile
D: Gardevoir
D: Zoroark
E: Decidueye
E: Lycanroc
D: Mimikyu
C: Ninten
C: Black Shadow
A: Samurai Goroh
S: Lyn
A: Black Knight
C: Medusa
C: Shadow
C: Knuckles
S: Elma
S: Rex & Pyra
C: Octoling
S: Issac
A: Chorus Kids
D: Karate Joe
A: Takamaru
B: Excitbiker
B: Mach Rider
A: Chibi-Robo
S: Spring Man
A: Bomberman
D: Geno
S: Banjo & Kazooie
A: Rayman
B: Shovel Knight
S: Shantae
C: Alucard
C: Zero
S: Sora
S: Crash
 

FirestormNeos

Smash Lord
Joined
Apr 4, 2013
Messages
1,647
Location
Location Machine Broke
NNID
FirestormNeos
HYPE (S/A):
Midna, Gardevoir, Lyn, Elma, Sora
Nod of Approval (B):
Waluigi, Funky Kong*, Impa, Skull Kid, Bandana Dee, Gengar, Black Shadow, Medusa, Shadow, Knuckles, Rex & Pyra, Octoling, Issac, Takamaru, Mach Rider, Bomberman, Shantae, Alucard, Zero, Crash
Indifferent (C):
Toad or Captain Toad, Paper Mario, Ashley, Ghirahim, Zoroark, Mimikyu, Ninten, Black Shadow, Samurai Goroh, Black Knight, Karate Joe, Excitbiker, Chibi-Robo, Banjo & Kazooie, Rayman, Shovel Knight
Slightly Annoyed (D):
Dixie Kong, Krystal, Lycanroc, Chorus Kids, Geno
"Are you out your ****ing mind?!" (E):
Sceptile, Decidueye, Spring Man
 
Last edited:

Mariomaniac45213

The Nintendo Villain main!
Joined
Sep 5, 2014
Messages
1,254
Location
Cincinnati, Ohio
Switch FC
SW 5604 9250 9133
HYPE:
Midna, Gardevoir, Black Shadow (inherits Smash 4 Ganondorf's moveset), Lyn, Elma, Pyra (Solo), Sora
Nod of Approval:
Toad w/ Captain Toad and Toadette alts, Toadette (Solo), Waluigi, Funky Kong*, Impa, Skull Kid, Bandana Dee, Gengar, Medusa, Shadow, Knuckles, Rex & Pyra, Octoling, Issac, Takamaru, Mach Rider, Bomberman, Shantae, Alucard, Zero, Crash
Indifferent:
Toad w/o Captain Toad or Toadette alts, Captain Toad (Solo), Paper Mario, Ashley, Ghirahim, Zoroark, Mimikyu, Ninten, Black Shadow (doesn't inherit Ganondorf's Smash 4 moveset), Samurai Goroh, Black Knight, Rex (Solo), Karate Joe, Excitbiker, Chibi-Robo, Banjo & Kazooie, Rayman, Shovel Knight
Slightly Annoyed:
Dixie Kong, Krystal, Lycanroc, Chorus Kids, Geno
"Are you out your ****ing mind?!":
Sceptile, Decidueye, Spring Man
Not trying to question your decisions/choices. But why is Funky Kong "nod of approval" but Dixie Kong is "Slightly annoyed?" I'm just really curious.
 

Al-kīmiyā'

Smash the State
Joined
Apr 22, 2010
Messages
2,574
X: Toad or Captain Toad
C: Waluigi
C: Paper Mario
D: Ashley
C: Dixie Kong
C: Funky Kong
B: Impa
S: Skull Kid
B: Midna
B: Ghirahim
C: Bandana Dee
C: Krystal
C: Gengar
C: Sceptile
C: Gardevoir
D: Zoroark
C: Decidueye
D: Lycanroc
C: Mimikyu
D: Ninten
C: Black Shadow
C: Samurai Goroh
B: Lyn
B: Black Knight
C: Medusa
C: Shadow
B: Knuckles
B: Elma
C: Rex & Pyra
B: Octoling
A: Issac
C: Chorus Kids
C: Karate Joe
B: Takamaru
C: Excitbiker
C: Mach Rider
C: Chibi-Robo
C: Spring Man
C: Bomberman
B: Geno
A: Banjo & Kazooie
B: Rayman
C: Shovel Knight
C: Shantae
C: Alucard
B: Zero
B: Sora
C: Crash
You forgot some characters
S: Neku
S: Masked Link
S: Decloned Ganondorf
S: Ephraim (or similiar, e.g., Dimitri looks to be such)
S: Merric (or similar, e.g., Lewyn)
A: Hector (or someone else with a huge axe)
S: Someone with a whip-sword like Ivy's, but not Ivy (dominatrixes don't belong in Smash, and that includes Bayonetta)
A: Ray

Did you add this rating system in a late edit, or did all these people not read the OP?
 
Last edited:

Aetheri

W/E happens don't panic...
Joined
Jan 13, 2015
Messages
8,847
Location
ZDR
Switch FC
SW-3397-5428-2304
S: Midna, Elma, Crash Bandicoot, Impa, Banjo & Kazooie, Shantae
--
A: Skull Kid, Excitebiker, Krystal, Sceptile
--
B: Toad/Captain Toad, Waluigi, Ashley, Dixie Kong, Ghirahim, Gengar, Zoroark, Lycanroc, Mimikyu, Samurai Goroh, Lyn, Medusa, Shadow, Knuckles, Isaac, Takamaru, Spring Man, Bomberman, Rayman, Shovel Knight, Alucard, Zero, Sora
--
C: Rex & Pyra, Paper Mario, Funky Kong, Bandana Dee, Gardevoir, Decidueye, Ninten, Black Shadow, Black Knight, Octoling, Chorus Kids, Karate Joe, Mach Rider, Chibi Robo, Geno
--
D: --
--
E: --

I'm relatively easy to please at this point since I already got much more than I expected
 

TheCJBrine

Smash Legend
Joined
Jul 28, 2013
Messages
12,054
Location
New World, Minecraft
S: Skull Kid, Banjo-Kazooie, Geno, Creeper, Steve, Gengar, Porky Minch, Ninten, Chorus Kids, Sans & Papyrus

A: Alph, Louie, Plasm Wraith, Marx, Adeleine, Gooey, Dark Matter, Sandbag, Master Hand, Balloon Fighter

B: Other Pikmin characters, other Kirby characters, other Minecraft mobs, Slime from Dragon Quest, other Undertale characters, other Banjo-Kazooie characters, other Pokemon, other Mario characters (including Goomba), other EarthBound characters...I think you get the idea.

C: Literally anyone else.
 
Last edited:

QuinnyPooh

Smash Rookie
Joined
Jun 27, 2018
Messages
4
3DS FC
2724-3667-8510
Switch FC
SW 0408 4509 3500
First, I want to add another recommendation. I think Tiki from Fire Emblem would be an amazing addition to SSB. Also, she’s not a sword wielder so that helps.

S+: Tiki

S: Captain Toad, Lyn, Ninten, Skull Kid, Rex

A: Geno, Black Knight, Impa, Octoling, Mimikyu

B: Issac, Ghirahim, Mach Rider, Paper Mario, Chorus Kids, Gardevoir, Bandanna Dee, Banjo and Kazooie, Midna

C: Spring Man, Gengar, Ashley, Shantae, Alucard, Zero, Excitbiker, Zoroark, Lycanroc, Mimikyu, Chibi-Robo, Crash, Bomberman, Sceptile

D: Rayman, Waluigi, Shadow

Totally indifferent: Shovel Knight, Decidueye, Samurai Goroh, Pyra, Black Shadow, Dixie Kong
 
Last edited:

Aerospherology

Smash Lord
Joined
Nov 9, 2015
Messages
1,206
Location
Michigan
Toad or Captain Toad: c
Waluigi: a (but never happening this decade)
Paper Mario: b
Ashley: c
Dixie Kong: b
Funky Kong: S
Impa: c
Skull Kid: c
Midna: c
Ghirahim: c
Bandana Dee: b
Krystal: c
Gengar: c
Sceptile: c
Gardevoir: d
Zoroark: c
Decidueye: d
Lycanroc: c
Mimikyu: b
Ninten: c
Black Shadow: b
Samurai Goroh: c
Lyn: d
Black Knight: c
Medusa: c
Shadow: a
Knuckles: c
Elma: c
Rex & Pyra: d
Octoling: b
Isaac: a
Chorus Kids: b
Karate Joe: c
Takamaru: c
Excitebiker: c
Mach Rider: S
Chibi-Robo: c
Spring Man: b
Bomberman: c
Zero: c
Geno: S
Banjo & Kazooie: a
Rayman: b
Shovel Knight: a
Shantae: d
Alucard: c
Sora: c
Crash: c
 
Last edited:

Domino11332

Smash Apprentice
Joined
Jun 27, 2018
Messages
87
B: Toad or Captain Toad
B: Waluigi
A: Paper Mario
S: Ashley
B: Dixie Kong
C: Funky Kong
B: Impa
D: Skull Kid
D: Midna
D: Ghirahim
S: Bandana Dee
C: Krystal
C: Gengar
C: Sceptile
C: Gardevoir
A: Zoroark
D: Decidueye
C: Lycanroc
B: Mimikyu
B: Ninten
C: Black Shadow
C: Samurai Goroh
B: Lyn
B: Black Knight
C: Medusa
B: Shadow
C: Knuckles
S: Elma
S: Rex & Pyra
B: Octoling
B: Issac
S: Chorus Kids
S: Karate Joe
B: Takamaru
C: Excitbiker
B: Mach Rider
A: Chibi-Robo
B: Spring Man
B: Bomberman
C: Geno
B: Banjo & Kazooie
B: Rayman
D: Shovel Knight
A: Shantae
D: Alucard
C: Zero
C: Sora
D: Crash
 

smashingDoug

Smash Lord
Joined
Apr 9, 2014
Messages
1,623
Location
Behind you.
Characters you want to be playable:
S: It's one of my top 10 most wanted newcomers.
A: It's one of my top 20 most wanted newcomers.
B: Not a most wanted, but I'll be happy if confirmed.

Character's you don't want to be playable:
C: Neither happy nor unhappy, just meh.
D: I would hate it if confirmed.
E: NO GOD PLEASE NO!

C: Toad or Captain Toad
C: Waluigi
C: Paper Mario
C: Ashley
B: Dixie Kong
.B: Funky Kong
A: Impa
B: Skull Kid
B: Midna
B: Ghirahim
C: Bandana Dee
B: Krystal
A: Gengar
A: Sceptile
C: Gardevoir
B: Zoroark
C: Decidueye
C: Lycanroc
D: Mimikyu
B: Ninten
B: Black Shadow
C: Samurai Goroh
B: Lyn
B: Black Knight
C: Medusa
C: Shadow
B: Knuckles
A: Elma
C: Rex & Pyra
C: Octoling
A: Issac
A: Chorus Kids
C: Karate Joe
B: Takamaru
C: Excitbiker
A: Mach Rider
C: Chibi-Robo
D: Spring Man
C: Bomberman
C: Geno
B: Banjo & Kazooie
C: Rayman
C: Shovel Knight
C: Shantae
C: Alucard
C: Zero
C: Sora
B: Crash
 
Last edited:

SvartWolf

Smash Champion
Joined
Nov 4, 2007
Messages
2,156
Location
Santiago/Chile
C: Toad or Captain Toad
C: Waluigi
C: Paper Mario
S: Ashley
A: Dixie Kong
D: Funky Kong
B: Impa
A: Skull Kid
C: Midna
C: Ghirahim
C: Bandana Dee
C: Krystal
C: Gengar
C: Sceptile
B: Gardevoir
D: Zoroark
D: Decidueye
A: Lycanroc
A: Mimikyu
D: Ninten
C: Black Shadow
C: Samurai Goroh
S: Lyn
B: Black Knight
B: Medusa
B: Shadow
A: Knuckles
A: Elma
D: Rex & Pyra
C: Octoling
A: Issac
B: Chorus Kids
B: Karate Joe
B: Takamaru
D: Excitbiker
A: Mach Rider
C: Chibi-Robo
D: Spring Man
S: Bomberman
C: Geno
B: Banjo & Kazooie
C: Rayman
S: Shovel Knight
A: Shantae
S: Alucard
C: Zero
C: Sora
B: Crash
 

Kuragari

Smash Apprentice
Joined
Mar 21, 2014
Messages
152
B: Toad or Captain Toad
C: Waluigi
C: Paper Mario
C: Ashley
B: Dixie Kong
C: Funky Kong
C: Impa
C: Skull Kid
A: Midna
C: Ghirahim
D: Bandana Dee
D: Krystal
C: Gengar
C: Sceptile
C: Gardevoir
B: Zoroark
A: Decidueye
A: Lycanroc
D: Mimikyu
D: Ninten
D: Black Shadow
D: Samurai Goroh
D: Lyn
C: Black Knight
D: Medusa
C: Shadow
C: Knuckles
D: Elma
D: Rex & Pyra
C: Octoling
B: Issac
B: Chorus Kids
C: Karate Joe
C: Takamaru
D: Excitbiker
D: Mach Rider
D: Chibi-Robo
B: Spring Man
B: Bomberman
B: Geno
A: Banjo & Kazooie
A: Rayman
D: Shovel Knight
C: Shantae
D: Alucard
C: Zero
B: Sora
B: Crash

My list. Im more or less super happy with who we have already. I cant think of anyone that I would jump through the ceiling to have added at this point. With 77 characters plus 5 still on the way, Its just extra icing on what Im sure will be an amazing cake.
 

Room100

Smash Apprentice
Joined
Sep 25, 2018
Messages
177
Location
PA
S: Sylux, Doom Slayer, Geno, Banjo, Rayman
A: Bandanna Waddle Dee, Tails, Sora
B: Dixie Kong, Impa, Black Shadow, Elma, Mach Rider
C: Paper Mario, Ninten, Karate Joe, Shantae
D: Waluigi
E: Captain Toad
 

Putuk

Smash Lord
Joined
Sep 29, 2014
Messages
1,286
Location
None of your beeswax!
3DS FC
2723-9688-6533
Switch FC
SW-8387-2163-6416
At the point the roster is at currently, I really don't have any further requests that are realistic.

I do have one thing to note when it comes to this ranking system:
E: Rex & Pyra
 

Quetzal77

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Sep 6, 2014
Messages
300
NNID
yomugo
3DS FC
1349-4940-0147
A: Toad or Captain Toad
C: Waluigi
C: Paper Mario
C: Ashley
C: Dixie Kong
D: Funky Kong
A: Impa
A: Skull Kid
B: Midna
C: Ghirahim
C: Bandana Dee
C: Krystal
B: Gengar
B: Sceptile
B: Gardevoir
C: Zoroark
B: Decidueye
C: Lycanroc
D: Mimikyu
C: Ninten
C: Black Shadow
C: Samurai Goroh
S: Lyn
A: Black Knight
B: Medusa
B: Shadow
C: Knuckles
S: Elma
S: Rex & Pyra
D: Octoling
S: Issac
C: Chorus Kids
C: Karate Joe
B: Takamaru
C: Excitbiker
C: Mach Rider
C: Chibi-Robo
C: Spring Man
C: Bomberman
C: Geno
C: Banjo & Kazooie
C: Rayman
D: Shovel Knight
C: Shantae
B: Alucard
C: Zero
S: Sora
E: Crash
 

Kevandre

Ivy WAS Saurly missed
Joined
Jun 19, 2013
Messages
2,520
Location
Pacific Northwest
NNID
Kevandre
3DS FC
1736-1095-5393
Switch FC
SW-2226-3590-9812
Honestly the only highly requested character I specifically don't want in Smash is Sora. Everything else is at worst a C rank for me here

C Toad or Captain Toad
C Waluigi
S Paper Mario
C Ashley
S Dixie Kong
B Funky Kong
A Impa
A Skull Kid
C Midna
C Ghirahim
B Bandana Dee
C Krystal
C Gengar
B Sceptile
B Gardevoir
C Zoroark
B Decidueye
C Lycanroc
C Mimikyu
C Ninten
B Black Shadow
C Samurai Goroh
C Lyn
C Black Knight
C Medusa
C Shadow
B Knuckles
C Elma
B Rex & Pyra
C Octoling
B Isaac
B Chorus Kids
C Karate Joe
C Takamaru
C Excitbiker
B Mach Rider
A Chibi-Robo
C Spring Man
B Bomberman
B Geno
S Banjo & Kazooie
A Rayman
S Shovel Knight
S Shantae
C Alucard
C Zero
E Sora
C Crash
 

MyDude213

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Nov 1, 2018
Messages
357
I only really want one character that being Sora I don't care about anyone else that gets in as long as he got in. There's no one else I personally actually want honestly so I'm cool with whoever really as long as Sora gets in. But if I did have to pick a top 10 popular picks or not mind you these would be my picks.

1. Sora (obviously)
2. Diablo
3. Doomguy
4. Shantae
5. Sans (bite me I know how cringy people find the idea of this but I like Undertale a lot, and any excuse for some of the awesome music in that game I'm down for.)
6. Naganadel (think they'd make an interesting poison type Pokemon edition since it's also a dragon type I feel like a kit kinda just write's itself really.)
7. Kamek (since he's in pretty much every mainline Mario game I feel like he kinda deserves it since he's such a prominent character in the Mario games.}
8. Ghost the character you play in as in Hollow Knight
9. Sephiroth (though I know he'd be broken as **** I think they should finish off the duo, you can't have Cloud without Sephiroth.)
10. Lastly the obligatory troll character Cooking Mama for the memes.

Honorary pick the main characters from the original three Contra games ( Just for my nostalgia boner really that and the ****ing fantastic music from those games.)

Yes I know a lot of these are unlikely just my personal list It's not a list of expectations just stuff I'd personally find cool to see.
 

Kevandre

Ivy WAS Saurly missed
Joined
Jun 19, 2013
Messages
2,520
Location
Pacific Northwest
NNID
Kevandre
3DS FC
1736-1095-5393
Switch FC
SW-2226-3590-9812
I only really want one character that being Sora I don't care about anyone else that gets in as long as he got in. There's no one else I personally actually want honestly so I'm cool with whoever really as long as Sora gets in. But if I did have to pick a top 10 popular picks or not mind you these would be my picks.

1. Sora (obviously)
2. Diablo
3. Doomguy
4. Shantae
5. Sans (bite me I know how cringy people find the idea of this but I like Undertale a lot, and any excuse for some of the awesome music in that game I'm down for.)
6. Naganadel (think they'd make an interesting poison type Pokemon edition since it's also a dragon type I feel like a kit kinda just write's itself really.)
7. Kamek (since he's in pretty much every mainline Mario game I feel like he kinda deserves it since he's such a prominent character in the Mario games.}
8. Ghost the character you play in as in Hollow Knight
9. Sephiroth (though I know he'd be broken as **** I think they should finish off the duo, you can't have Cloud without Sephiroth.)
10. Lastly the obligatory troll character Cooking Mama for the memes.

Honorary pick the main characters from the original three Contra games ( Just for my nostalgia boner really that and the ****ing fantastic music from those games.)

Yes I know a lot of these are unlikely just my personal list It's not a list of expectations just stuff I'd personally find cool to see.
You know... I don't particularly want Sans in the game, but I'd be 100% cool with at least an Undertale stage so we could get that amazing soundtrack in Smash.
 

Mr. Meow-Meow

Smash Rookie
Joined
Nov 25, 2018
Messages
2
C: Toad or Captain Toad
C: Waluigi
D: Paper Mario
C: Ashley
C: Dixie Kong
B: Funky Kong
C: Impa
C: Skull Kid
C: Midna
C: Ghirahim
D: Bandana Dee
C: Krystal
C: Gengar
C: Sceptile
C: Gardevoir
C: Zoroark
C: Decidueye
C: Lycanroc
C: Mimikyu
B: Ninten
B: Black Shadow
B: Samurai Goroh
C: Lyn
C: Black Knight
C: Medusa
C: Shadow
C: Knuckles
C: Elma
C: Rex & Pyra
D: Octoling
S: Issac
A: Chorus Kids
B: Karate Joe
S: Takamaru
C: Excitbiker
A: Mach Rider
A: Chibi-Robo
D: Spring Man
C: Bomberman
A: Geno
C: Banjo & Kazooie
C: Rayman
A: Shovel Knight
C: Shantae
C: Alucard
C: Zero
E: Sora
S: Crash
 

TAnimal

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Aug 14, 2018
Messages
311
S: Rayman, Banjo & Kazooie, Heihachi Mishima, Lara Croft
A: Crash Bandicoot, Geno, Dixie Kong, Paper Mario, Doomguy
B: Sora, Mach Rider, Chorus Kid, Decidueye, Bandana Dee
C:
D:
E: Everyone Else
 
Last edited:

letsgetsmashing

Smash Apprentice
Joined
Jun 18, 2018
Messages
183
S: Captain Toad, Dixie Kong, Impa, Bandana Dee, Isaac, Chorus Kids, Spring Man, Rayman, Banjo & Kazooie, Bomberman
A: Excitebiker, Chibi-Robo, Medusa, Skull Kid, Waluigi, Midna, Zoroark, Ashley, Paper Mario, Crash Bandicoot
B: Ninten, Takamaru, Mach Rider, Decidueye, Ghirahim, Krystal, Rex & Pyra, Sceptile, Zero, Knuckles

C: Funky Kong, Black Shadow, Gardevoir, Geno, Elma, Shadow, Lyn
D: Samurai Goroh, Karate Joe, Mimikyu, Alucard, Sora
E: Octoling, Lycanroc, Shovel Knight, Shantae, Black Knight, Gengar
 

Putuk

Smash Lord
Joined
Sep 29, 2014
Messages
1,286
Location
None of your beeswax!
3DS FC
2723-9688-6533
Switch FC
SW-8387-2163-6416
Just curious, any particular why you wouldn't be happy with those two?
Ignoring that they look like something a pedophile would draw, they somehow manage to simultaniously have incredibly cluttered designs with a bunch of pointless details and also have incredibly bland color schemes. And the way their faces are drawn... oh my gosh, how I hate that!
I've also had the absolute misfortune of once seeing a cutscene from XC2 and... wow, yeah, that's what I expected from something that looks like that.

Also they look like something a pedophile would draw. Never celebrate garbage like that.
 

lucasla

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Jul 24, 2018
Messages
481
I think people request some characters just to have a feeling of "team completed" on the select screen. Cause there's no reason at all for so much request for Waluigi (or even Geno). In which game Waluigi is important? He doesnt have his game, he is not important in any game he is in. But because we have Mario and his opposite Wario (that has a lot of games), seems like people think that because we have a Luigi, we necessarily need to have Waluigi. Ignoring that the character itself has no importance in games at all. Some say that Piranha Plant is lower the bar of Smash characters, but actually, Waluigi is the one that would do that. He is nothing.. literally nothing. He just exists in games there, but he is no good villain, he has no games, he is mostly "an option" in mario tennis. With so many good characters out there we will reserve a place to a filler character?
 
Last edited:

Frizz

Will Thwack You At 0%
Joined
Mar 20, 2015
Messages
1,257
Location
Massachusetts
Characters you want to be playable:
S: It's one of my top 10 most wanted newcomers.
A: It's one of my top 20 most wanted newcomers.
B: Not a most wanted, but I'll be happy if confirmed.

Character's you don't want to be playable:
C: Neither happy nor unhappy, just meh.
D: I would hate it if confirmed.
E: NO GOD PLEASE NO!
B: Toad or Captain Toad
D: Waluigi
A: Paper Mario
B: Ashley
B: Dixie Kong
C: Funky Kong
B: Impa
C: Skull Kid
B: Midna
B: Ghirahim
B: Bandana Dee
B: Krystal
C: Gengar
C: Sceptile
B: Gardevoir
B: Zoroark
C: Decidueye
C: Lycanroc
C: Mimikyu
B: Ninten
C: Black Shadow
C: Samurai Goroh
S: Lyn
B: Black Knight
B: Medusa
C: Shadow
C: Knuckles
C: Elma
C: Rex & Pyra
B: Octoling
C: Issac
D: Chorus Kids
C: Karate Joe
C: Takamaru
C: Excitbiker
C: Mach Rider
B: Chibi-Robo
B: Spring Man
B: Bomberman
D: Geno
D: Banjo & Kazooie
D: Rayman
C: Shovel Knight
B: Shantae
C: Alucard
B: Zero
C: Sora
B: Crash
 

KickleCubiclist

Smash Apprentice
Joined
Sep 6, 2018
Messages
152
B: Toad or Captain Toad
E: Waluigi
B: Paper Mario
E: Ashley
B: Dixie Kong
B: Funky Kong
B: Impa
B: Skull Kid
B: Midna
?Who is he?: Ghirahim
S: Bandana Dee
C: Krystal
B: Gengar
B: Sceptile
B: Gardevoir
B: Zoroark
S: Decidueye
B: Lycanroc
B: Mimikyu
B: Ninten
B: Black Shadow
B: Samurai Goroh
C: Lyn
C: Black Knight
C: Medusa
E: Shadow
A: Knuckles
C: Elma
B: Rex & Pyra
A: Octoling
D: Issac
D: Chorus Kids
C: Karate Joe
C: Takamaru
B: Excitebiker
C: Mach Rider
S: Chibi-Robo
B: Spring Man
B: Bomberman
E: Geno
B: Banjo & Kazooie
A: Rayman
A: Shovel Knight
C: Shantae
C: Alucard
B: Zero
B: Sora
B: Crash
 

FirestormNeos

Smash Lord
Joined
Apr 4, 2013
Messages
1,647
Location
Location Machine Broke
NNID
FirestormNeos
Ignoring that they look like something a pedophile would draw
Not going to argue with you on Rex because you're unfortunately right (he's 15) and anime's habit of putting their protags in that age range is quite frankly starting to get on my nerves (yes, I know that Japan's ****awful work culture means that they consider teenage life to be their "point where someone is free to express themselves fully" stage of life whereas us Americans have that point of our lives in our 20's. However, it's still creating all sorts of malignant side-effects-- creepy character designs being just the tip of the iceberg --and that's just not ****ing acceptable).

However, isn't Pyra an adult? Like, sure, a blade or whatever they're called, but a grown-*** adult nonetheless? Or am I just giving the developers too much benefit of the doubt again?

they somehow manage to simultaneously have incredibly cluttered designs with a bunch of pointless details and also have incredibly bland color schemes. And the way their faces are drawn... oh my gosh, how I hate that!
Makes sense. Okay, thanks for replying.
 
Last edited:

Al-kīmiyā'

Smash the State
Joined
Apr 22, 2010
Messages
2,574
I'm not sure if I should quote the rules to people, or just enjoy the schadenfreude of their votes not counting and their time wasted.
 
Top Bottom