• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Rate Their Chances MultiVersus Edition: Day 119 - Homelander (The Boys) and Gilligan (Gilligan's Island)

Do you want me to start locking in the top 14 instead of top 7?

  • Yes

    Votes: 7 77.8%
  • No

    Votes: 2 22.2%

  • Total voters
    9
  • Poll closed .

DanganZilla5

Smash Champion
Writing Team
Joined
Mar 5, 2019
Messages
2,338
Thanks to Ramen Tengoku Ramen Tengoku and SneakyLink SneakyLink for approving this thread.

List of characters rated + Top 10 of Chance and Want

Characters/ConceptsChanceWantTop 10 of ChanceTop 10 of Want
Scorpion88.9565.241. Joker (DC)1. Maxwell (Scribblenauts)
Ruby Rose79.6579.232. Raven (DC)2. Eric Andre
John Oliver23.2973.213. The Flash (DC)3. Sam Spade
Freddy Krueger55.8878.754. Daffy Duck4. Neo
Joker (DC)97.2876.065. Neo5. Daffy Duck
Godzilla40.63856. Static (DC)6. Shuichi Kitaoka
Tony Soprano5579.297. Concept: Animaniacs rep7. Ash Williams
Popeye51.82658. Scorpion8. King Kong
Wiz and Boomstick20.45489. Ben 109. Sarge (Red vs Blue)
Ben 1088.3178.6410. Concept: Regular Show characters10. Static (DC)
Austin Powers26.4381.43
Eric Andre28.2993.57Note: These lists are only for unconfirmed characters. No confirmed or deconfirmed characters.
Paul Atreides82.8676.43
Gumball6558.13
Harvey Birdman17.1457.14
Agent K13.559.17
Daffy Duck93.291.88
Dastardly Richard74.2982
The Grinch35.5674.6
Mucha Lucha rep21.6757.2
Michael J. Caboose12.1972
Willy Wonka38.7568.33Reminder: Those two chance scores are not a mistake
Ed, Edd n Eddy38.7575.63
Numbuh 138.4379.17
Eustace Bagge6.821.25
Quan-Chi4.537.5
Rebecca Bunch2.7580
Agent Smith39.8878.33
The Protagonist (Tenet)361.25
Top Cat4567.5
Dio Brando2082.5
Neo93.1792
Ellie Williams6.441.25
Lola Bunny4040.56
Samurai Jack66.8367
Maxwell33.494
Pim and Charlie40.2558.75
Big Chungus44.6742.75
The Winchester Brothers60.8355
Peacemaker47.682.5
Zatanna23.885
Mad Max6986
Concept: Peanuts Rep17.565.83
Harry Potter33.3351.25
K.O4062.5
Fred Flintstone81.375.55
Renee Montoya7.2527.5
The Powerpuff Girls82.576
Stede Bonnet11.6786.67
Deathstroke52.565.83
Gizmo89.17%96
Rick Sanchez98.43%43.33
Scooby-Doo8080
Characters w/ no WB Connection60.7114.29
Concept: Total Drama content2865
KuroyukihimeNo scores
Weiss Schnee65.8386.67
Cinder Fall26.6768.33
Concept: Cats Don't Dance rep6.575
Charles Kane11.2971.43
Johnny Bravo4075
Juliet Starling9.1772.5
Doomsday41.6724.17
Static90.4387.86
Sweeney Todd4.560
Concept: Impractical Jokers rep11.6776.67
Bilbo Baggins2567.5
Beetlejuice59.1782.5
Concept: Rampage rep17.478
Lion-O38.285.2
Agent Washington5.2967.5
John Constantine43.8669.29
Concept: Hunter X Hunter rep9.4156.25
Dexter60.475
Pinkie Pie2853.75
Homura Akemi5.268.5
Concept: All Elite Wrestling rep9.450
Raven (DC)96.3883.13
Blake Belladonna6071.57
Jessica Cruz57.577.6
Knight & Ostrich18.3366.67
King Kong82.1490
Ash Williams42.590.63
Concept: Yu-Gi-Oh rep10.8655.67
Yang Xiao Long63.5779.29
Sarge (Red vs Blue)8.490
Concept: Pacific Rim fighter29.685
Princess Bubblegum49.1434.29
Henry HillNo chance score50.33
Sam Spade26.2592.5
Vilgax2875
Concept: Transformers rep31.1372.14
Sub-Zero82.7877.14
He-Man27.280
Mami Tomoe1.7552
Gandalf87.8970.63
Poison Ivy64.8669.29
Shuichi Kitaoka2.3691.67
Ultraman14.8882.86
Johnny Cage4662.5
Concept: Animaniacs rep89.6376.33
Jack Torrance26.7175
William Cage26.6764
Roger Smith12.6779.17
Elvis Presley22.1758.33
Discord (MLP)1723.75
Goku57.2282
Monkey D. Luffy49.566.67
Pennywise68.7580.71
Kyoko Sakura2.3650.83
Jotaro Kujo27.3375.63
Audrey II3977.25
Grim (Billy & Mandy)30.6751.88
Steve Urkel32.564
Concept: Six Flags content14.3325.83
Jaime Reyes/Blue Beetle69.2979
Gone With The Wind content5.7110
Another Steven Universe character67.7127.57
Sailor Moon27.1454.17
Shao Kahn35.8652
Tetsuo Shima14.2273.75
Guy Fieri4057.86
Jason Voorhees27.1477.86
Mob (Mob Pyscho)3370
Courage The Cowardly Dog71.4386.33
The Doctor2980
Gilmore Girls3141.67
Naruto Uzumaki35.7170
Larry DavidNo scores
Haruko Haruhara1975.8
lion2.8669.75
Concept: Code Lyoko rep15.3349
Madoka Kaname8.1360.71
Sayaka Miki6.8851.43
Dream (The Sandman)3573.6
House of the Dragon rep53.7160
Tien Shinhan7.6738.33
John Spartan18.7546.67
Jolyne Cujoh28.3375.83
Mac & Bloo39.4443.75
Concept: MythBusters contentNo Score74
Sheldon Cooper67.1436.86
Geralt of Rivia2061.25
The Mask3883.75
Rhedosaurus11.7568.75
Spear & Fang61.2567.50
Pikachu0.9721.11
Tyrion Lannister42.7583
Terry McGinnis5762.8
Bob Odenkirk6.2527.75
John F. Kennedy (Clone High)19.472
Chowder30.9260
Beerus2346
John Gotti0.2522
Concept: The Conjuring Universe rep50.8380.83
Marceline50.548.5
Huey Freeman2255
The Flash95.1763
Edward Malus5.7565.5
Tales From The Crypt contentNo scores
Jaune Arc27.3354.33
Youngblood Priest582.5
Concept: Evangelion character20.6773.33
Simon The Digger1078.67
Aqua Teen Hunger Force character5739
Wile E. Coyote69.2271.88
Concept: Sesame Street content6.1362.14
Spy (Spy vs Spy)2678
Craig Williams73.2575.33
Mothra14.671


Welcome to the MultiVersus Rate Their Chances thread! In here, we discuss and debate potential candidates for Warner Bros.' platform fighter, MultiVersus. Each day, we rate a certain character or concept in terms of chance and want. We use a scale of 0%-100%. Just keep in mind that one person's interpretation of what a 25% chance (for example) means will differ from what another person thinks a 25% means. But don't overthink it, just go with your gut feeling and make a judgement based on your knowledge and research on the character. This is a forum game after all, so have fun!

A character must meet one of the following criteria to be nominated:
  • They are owned by Warner Bros.
  • They are co-owned by Warner Bros.
  • Their franchise has had/will have a product distributed by Warner Bros. This includes the following:
    • Home video releases - WB Home Entertainment, Turner Classic Movies, etc.
    • Theatrical releases - WB Pictures, New Line Cinema, Castle Rock Entertainment, etc.
    • Comics - DC and MAD
    • Video Games - WB Interactive Entertainment, Monolith Productions, TT Games, NetherRealm Studios, Midway properties, etc.
    • Broadcast and streaming - Cartoon Network, Adult Swim, Toonami, Boomerang, TBS, TNT, TruTV, HBO/HBO Max, etc.
    • Online productions - Rooster Teeth and official websites for WB's networks.
  • Characters who have made a significant appearance in a Warner Bros product, such as LeBron James. These characters are subject to approval.
  • Characters who are owned by Discovery or have had a significant appearance in a Discovery product such as Guy Fieri (again, subject to approval).
In terms of concepts, I'm more lenient on them but they must be related to Warner Bros or Discovery in some way.

By participating each day, you can earn nominations (noms) to use towards a character or concept you want to discuss. The goal is to obtain enough noms to push your idea into the top 14. At the end of each week the top 14 will be locked in, at that point nominations for those characters/concepts are null and void. Each day will last 3-4 days, depending on the amount of posts and conversations going on. As a rule of thumb I will typically end days if there aren't any new posts for 24 hours.

There are several ways to earn noms. The first way is to abstain. If you do not want to rate a character for any reason, you can write "Abstain" and you will still get 5 noms. Explaining why you abstained is appreciated, but not required. The next method is by writing 4 sentences per character, 2 sentences for chance, 2 for want. This will grant you 5 noms. Keep in mind that you need these 4 sentences, not just to get 5 noms, but also to have your scores be counted towards the total. However, you can abstain on one of the scores and still get 5 noms. So for example if you don't want to give a character a chance score but you want to gush about them and give them a want score, you can provide two sentences of reasoning for want and your want score will be used in the average. In addition, you can earn 10 noms for giving a character 10 sentences of reasoning. It doesn't matter if you have more sentences explaining chance than want, or vice-versa as long as there are 10 sentences in total.

Update: Since we are doing double days now, everyone starts with 10 noms.

Keep in mind that you can also divide your noms among different characters and concepts. For instance, if you earn 5 noms you can use 3 towards Joker and 2 towards Concept: another Looney Tunes rep.

Here is an example of an adequate rating:

Superman
Chance: 95%
He is one of DC's flagship characters and one of the most iconic superheroes of all time. With how popular DC movies have become, I can see them getting at least a couple reps and Superman is a prime candidate.

Want: 100%
I grew up with Superman's comics and movies so I have an attachment to him. Plus he has plenty of powers and abilities to make for a cool moveset.

After each day, I will calculate and share the average for the character/concept's want and chance scores. We won't be doing much with these scores other than seeing if we end up being accurate or not in the long-term.

Now that the groundwork has been set, let's get into the rules.

1. Please follow the global rules, listed here.

2. Debates are allowed and encouraged! However, please be civil. A back and forth conversation is fine as long as it doesn't get out of hand. Any name calling, trolling or harassing will get you a warning.

3. After a character's day has ended, you are allowed a grace period of one hour to get your rating in. After that, discussing the character further will be considered off-topic.

4. Characters DO NOT need support threads to be nominated. But any character who does will have their support thread be linked in the post that starts their day. The purpose for this is to give people an easy way to do some research on a character before making a judgement on them.

5. If there is a tie in the top 14 when its locked down, we do triple days where we discuss three characters or concepts in the same day. These days will generally last longer.

6. In the event that there are too many abandoned ideas sitting at the bottom of the noms list, we'll do what's called a purge where the nominated characters and concepts below a certain nom threshold will be taken off the list. The exact threshold will vary with each purge. And don't worry, I will warn the thread way before the purge happens to allow adequate time for some ideas to be saved.

7. Any character or concept can be nominated an unlimited amount of times. However, you have to wait two weeks after their day has ended to re-nominate them. I encourage you all to only re-nominate characters or concepts if there is a drastic change in speculation that warrants a rerate.

8. You can edit your ratings anytime during the day. However, you are not allowed to edit your ratings after their respective day has ended. Doing so will render your scores and noms null and void. This is to prevent cheating. You can still edit your ratings during the one hour grace period, though.

That is all. If you have any questions, concerns, or recommendations for the thread, feel free to PM me or the two moderators listed above. Now debate until your hearts are content!

______________________________________________________________________

Day 0

The goal of this day is to decide what the first top 7 will be. The assignment will be to vote for seven characters you want to talk about. The seven characters with the most amount of votes will become the first top 7. The next day, Day 1, will be the first rating and that's when you will be able to start earning noms. No noms will be awarded during today.

A reminder that you can vote for any character who is completely/partially owned by Warner Bros, or any characters that have made a significant appearance in a Warner Bros. comic book, TV show, movie, etc. Examples of I.Ps and media that Warner Bros owns includes, but is not limited to:
  • Looney Tunes
  • DC Universe
  • HBO shows
  • Cartoon Network
  • Adult Swim
  • Boomerang
  • Mortal Kombat
  • Rooster Teeth

I will start:
  • Joker (DC comics)
  • Scorpion (Mortal Kombat)
  • Ed Edd n Eddy
  • John Oliver
  • Pennywise the Clown (IT)
  • Doomsday (DC comics)
  • Tony Soprano
 
Last edited:

3DSNinja

Smash Lord
Joined
Oct 30, 2018
Messages
1,389
Hm. I'll nominate...
  • Ed Edd n Eddy
  • John Stewart/Green Lantern (DC Comics)
  • Ruby Rose (RWBY)
  • Elmer Fudd (Looney Tunes)
  • Jack (Samurai Jack)
  • Freddy Kreuger (Nightmare on Elm Street)
  • Sub Zero (Mortal Kombat)
 

amageish

Smash Master
Joined
Jul 21, 2018
Messages
3,558
Welcome back, everyone! Can't say I would have rated "Concept: Rate Their Chances But For a Warner Bros Platform Fighter That Has Ultra Instinct Shaggy in It's Base Roster" particularly high back in the day...

1. John Oliver (Last Week Tonight)
2. Neo (The Matrix)
3. Usnavi de la Vega (In the Heights)
4. Betelgeuse (Beetlejuice)
5. Harvey Birdman (Harvey Birdman)
6. Pennywise the Dancing Clown (It)
7. Princess Bubblegum (Adventure Time)
 

Simplythe1

Smash Apprentice
Joined
May 7, 2015
Messages
138
1. George (Rampage)
2. Blizzard (Primal Rage)
3. Afro Thunder (Ready 2 Rumble)
4. Pilot X (Freaky Flyers)
5. Yuri Hyuga (ShadowHearts)
6. Johnny Garland (ShadowHearts 3: From the New World)
7. Mina (Battle Chef Brigade)
 

Flyboy

Smash Hero
Joined
Aug 26, 2010
Messages
5,255
Location
Dayton, OH
Love that this forum is getting going! This is gonna be fun.

1. Austin Powers (Austin Powers series)
2. Sweeney Todd (Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street)
3. Roger Smith (The Big O)
4. Eric Andre (The Eric Andre Show)
5. Sam Spade (The Maltese Falcon)
6. Freddy Krueger (A Nightmare on Elm Street)
7. Godzilla (Godzilla Monsterverse films)
 

Pizza Robo

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Aug 23, 2007
Messages
298
1.Plasticman(DC Universe)
2.The Monarch(The Venture Bros)
3.Daffy Duck(Looney Tunes)
4.Mordecai(Regular Show)
5. D Dastardly(Wacky Races/Scoob)
6.Master Shake(Aqua Teen Hunger Force)
7.Richard Watterson(Amazing World Of Gumball)
 
Last edited:

silenthunder

Smash Ace
Joined
Aug 5, 2015
Messages
639
3DS FC
0490-6839-9144
1. Khameleon (Mortal Kombat) (But make her Nintendo exclusive)
2. Scorpion (Mortal Kombat)
3. Sub Zero (Mortal Kombat)
4. Maxwell (Scribblenauts)
5. Godzilla
6. Freddy Kruger
7. Rorschach (Watchmen)
 

fogbadge

Smash Legend
Joined
Jun 29, 2012
Messages
18,264
Location
Scotland
well hopefully it will be easier than trying to think whats in sakurais head

1: daffy duck
2: flash (barry)
3: wil.e
4: time drake
5: marceline the vampire queen
6: Connie (SU)
7: ice king
 

osby

Smash Obsessed
Joined
Apr 25, 2018
Messages
22,576
I never joined a Rate Their Chances thread but this looks like a fun opportunity and I'm excited for MultiVersus so here goes
  1. Static / Virgil Hawkins (DC Comics)
  2. Granny (Looney Tunes)
  3. Lion-O (ThunderCats)
  4. Ruby Rose (RWBY)
  5. Dorothy (The Wizard of Oz)
  6. Buttercup (Powerpuff Girls)
  7. Marvin the Martian (Looney Tunes)
EDIT: Added a seventh character I forgot, whoops.
 
Last edited:

DanganZilla5

Smash Champion
Writing Team
Joined
Mar 5, 2019
Messages
2,338
Alright it has been about 48 hours now since the day started and activity has slowed. I've tallied up the votes and here are the results:

THESE CHARACTERS ARE NOW LOCKED DOWN. NOMINATIONS FOR THEM ARE NULL AND VOID.
Day 1 - Scorpion (Mortal Kombat)
Day 2 - Ruby Rose (RWBY)
Day 3 - John Oliver (Last Week Tonight)
Day 4 - Freddy Krueger (A Nightmare on Elm Street)
Day 5 - Joker (DC Universe)
Day 6 - Godzilla
Day 7 - Tony Soprano (The Sopranos)


What a heck of a first lineup we got here.

Day over. Rate Scorpion from Mortal Kombat in terms of chance and want.

Some music to get into the mood for some MORTAL KOMBAAATTT!

 

Wario Wario Wario

Smash Hero
Joined
Sep 3, 2017
Messages
8,603
Location
Hell
Hold up, I thought we were nominating first then voting? If that being voting was the case I would've put the Ed boys on my list.
 
Last edited:

CheeseAnton

Smash Ace
Joined
Oct 1, 2020
Messages
535
Chance: 100%
Chance It'll Happen This Year: 95%

When it comes to Scorpion I don't think there's anything needing to be said, he's apart of one of Warner's biggest game franchises and is a character with huge popularity. When it comes to moveset he has lots to work with. When it comes to memes (seemingly important, as Ultra Instinct Shaggy apparently inspired this game and we got UI Shaggy in), he doesn't have much but "Get Over Here!" is still iconic. When it comes to being too mature, I admit I haven't seen it but from what I heard Game of Thrones is mature yet we have Arya Stark so I don't see it as an issue. The only thing holding him back from me being 100% certain he'll happen this year is maybe other characters out prioritize him (maybe characters like Gandalf or Rick who I think the devs see as more popular or memeable) or that character making would be slow (we don't know the schedule, it could take 6 months for one character for all we know), but Scorpion will happen.

Want: 80%

Honestly weird spot for me where I really want him but I can't imagine me being excited because I'm sure he'd be here. Yeah, I like Luigi but I don't get excited seeing him confirmed for Smash, that's just gonna happen. There are also Mortal Kombat characters I want over Scorpion like Johnny Cage, Raiden, Sonya, Johnny Cage, Scorpion would still be cool but he's not my most wanted MK character.

Ruby Rose Predictions: 96.4%

Noms: Gumball x5
 
Last edited:

DanganZilla5

Smash Champion
Writing Team
Joined
Mar 5, 2019
Messages
2,338
Do we still vote after we participate?
So basically the voting was only for Day 0. From now on the characters/concepts will be chosen by nominations that you and others earn by participating. After Day 7, the top 7 characters on the nominations list will be locked in, and the cycle repeats. For more info on how noms work, check the first post.
 

silenthunder

Smash Ace
Joined
Aug 5, 2015
Messages
639
3DS FC
0490-6839-9144
Chance: 100%

One of the devs asked what Mortal Kombat characters people want to see in the game and Scorpion is, of course, number 1. I imagine he would be a dumbed down version of his normal self, with sword attacks, punches and kicks and, of course, his classic spear. I would also like to see him make hell fire rise from the floor. I always thought that was cool.

Want: 100% I want plenty of Mortal Kombat reps. I love Mortal Kombat. I played every fighting game from Trilogy to present but 4. I want Mortal Kombat to be the next fire emblem even and add so many it makes people mad.

Noms: **** Grayson x3 (He's Nightwing but he's also the OG Robin)
Maxwell x1
Jackie Chan x1 (Can I nom him? He had that cartoon on toonami)
 

DanganZilla5

Smash Champion
Writing Team
Joined
Mar 5, 2019
Messages
2,338
Jackie Chan x1 (Can I nom him? He had that cartoon on toonami)
I guess so. The rules of the thread state that characters with a product distributed by Warner Bros is allowed, and I think letting the show air on Toonami and CNN technically counts. So while the connection is loose I've allowed characters in a similar situation already so I'll say yes because I don't want to be hypocritical.
 

OrpheusTelos

Smash Lord
Joined
Dec 9, 2018
Messages
1,075
Location
the garfield state
Chance: 100%
Considering Mortal Kombat is the most iconic game franchise Warner Bros. owns, I think a character from it would be an incredibly high priority for Multiversus. It’s one of the first things that spring to mind to most people when they think of arcade fighting games, and it was one of the main catalysts for the ESRB rating system coming into place. Even today the games are still doing gangbusters and Warner Bros is still making animated and live action films for the franchise. The only concern I could potentially see is Scorpion being too violent, but considering we have Arya Stark in this game, I don’t consider that too much of an issue. I doubt they’d have him ripping out Steven Universe’s heart or anything, but I think you could still tone him down while still staying true to his fighting style.

Want: 80%
Scorpion is one of those inclusions where I’d respect it more than I’d be actively excited for him. I’m not much of a Mortal Kombat person and him being of those “no duh” characters does make his inclusion here less exciting than it would be in Smash or something, but he’s more than worthy of being included in Multiversus.

Nominate: Eric Andre x5
 
Top Bottom