If Sega or Namco ownership is the preventative factor, how did sonic make the cut? Did nintendo buy the rights to Sonic or something? I realize sonic is a bigger character in general. Really what i was getting at was a more traditional rpg oriented group of character. I said partner companies because I meant pretty much anything that had been released on a Nintendo platform. I understand the rights issues, but smash is such a popular thing that it makes a certain kind of sense that it'd be a pretty good thing for any franchise.
The ownership is a factor because we know for a fact that we aren't getting many third-party characters. Sakurai gave a rough estimate of 2-3 in his journal, and we have two now. Even presuming the estimate was changed upward, theres really no way to argue more than 4 as realistic unless Brawl is much, much larger than anticipated. Snake got in because his creator is close friends with Sakurai and requested it way back when Melee was in development, plus hes a fairly popular character to boot. Sonic got in on his immense fan demand (Miyamoto and Sakurai both confirmed even long before Sonic was revealed that he was the single most requested character for Brawl). Other third-party characters aren't going to just get chosen at random - they need something big to recommend them.
Guys with popularity similar to Sonic's and a long history with Nintedo, such as Mega Man or Bomber Man, are at the top of the expectation list. Most other characters just don't have that kind of iconic status with the gaming community that would mean their presence helps sell the game, and games like Tales of Symphonia and Skies of Arcadia, which most people would see as randomly-selected RPGs, sure don't. When it comes to third-party characters, there are a handful with a chance of getting in (not even necessarily a good one, just a chance), and a lot with no chance. ToS and SoA characters are among the latter.
gannondorf4ever said:
\
Ergh Tales of Symphonia.. please...no... that game was too long, and any mention of it makes me shudder =(
Too long? I have to disagree - ToS' length was wonderful, one of its better aspects. We need more games with that kind of length to them IMO.
Zevox