Gimpyfish's Brawl Impressions - Brawl Talk Episode 1 Added

[OmegaXXII]

even weirder, I never seen or knew the existence of this good thread until now, oh well. it's too bad that Brawl didn't even turn out like it's Demo counterpart.

 

[Cerozero]

Thankfully we can still salvage some of it with hack patches.

 

[0megaZer0]

It's amazing what was put into this thread.....and now the game has come to all most literally two characters....minus a few others with some time

wow, good thing Melee didn't get dumped to the side -- Brawl?

 

[JOE!]

It's amazing what was put into this thread.....and now the game has come to all most literally two characters....minus a few others with some time

wow, good thing Melee didn't get dumped to the side -- Brawl?

so, in brawl we have :



all doing fairly good...more emphasis on the 1st two

in melee:

, (slower&blue) , , , :shiek: , , and finally,

 

[pizzapie7]

so, in brawl we have :



all doing fairly good...more emphasis on the 1st two

in melee:

, (slower&blue) , , :shiek: , , , , , , and

Fixed.

10fixes

 

[JOE!]

Fixed.

10fixes

er, no

Samus you never see, Peach you never see, Dr Mario you never see (and is also the worst smash char besides pichu...dude is just ****ing mario with pills) ICs are rare, and only like Mango lays Jiggz...and there isnt enough Fox on there

if you want, Ill list all the viable brawl characters:

Spoiler

highlighted ones are just barely viable

 

[Morrigan]

But still your Brawl list was wrong lol. Sure, they place, but not as much as the first two.

 

[JOE!]

But still your Brawl list was wrong lol. Sure, they place, but not as much as the first two.

you mean like fox and marth in melee?

or just Marth, doesnt he hold like 51% of all tourney wins?

 

[Hyesz]

What? Peach is quite commonly seen in Melee.

Doctor Mario, sorta. IC, not too much. Samus... basically never.

 

[tocador]

Yoshi isnt viable =/.

Heck, DK is viable, but only with a second :D.

 

[GunmasterLombardi]

Please don't bump this again.

You're not contributing anything new so what's the point?

 

[NJzFinest]

you mean like fox and marth in melee?

or just Marth, doesnt he hold like 51% of all tourney wins?

I haven't seen many Foxes actually winning huge tourneys, however I will admit there's a strong number of them placing well.

As for Marth, I would be more correct to simply replace that name with Mew2King... lol.

Fox, Marth, Sheik, Falco, Peach, Jiggs, and CFalcon are all represented extremely well in tourneys. Trust me, there's more Jigg players than you think, at least take another look at the Genesis bracket lol. There were barely any Foxes too.
Also, it's much more common to see mid/low tier characters in Melee tourneys than Brawl. I think that's because there's more bad Fox players then bad Metaknight players (Fox is easily harder to be good with) and basically every character in Melee can punish/combo Fox to hell if he messes up.

 

[iamthemicrowave]

I haven't seen many Foxes actually winning huge tourneys, however I will admit there's a strong number of them placing well.

As for Marth, I would be more correct to simply replace that name with Mew2King... lol.

Fox, Marth, Sheik, Falco, Peach, Jiggs, and CFalcon are all represented extremely well in tourneys. Trust me, there's more Jigg players than you think, at least take another look at the Genesis bracket lol. There were barely any Foxes too.
Also, it's much more common to see mid/low tier characters in Melee tourneys than Brawl. I think that's because there's more bad Fox players then bad Metaknight players (Fox is easily harder to be good with) and basically every character in Melee can punish/combo Fox to hell if he messes up.

shut up *****

 

[festizzio]

Why in the world are people still posting here?

 

[GunmasterLombardi]

Welcome to the boards. You're ignored here if you don't have a good tournament record.

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

What the ****.

Bumping something this old is ridiculous, how do you people even find this ****?

 

[pizzapie7]

er, no

Samus you never see, Peach you never see, Dr Mario you never see (and is also the worst smash char besides pichu...dude is just ****ing mario with pills) ICs are rare, and only like Mango lays Jiggz...and there isnt enough Fox on there

if you want, Ill list all the viable brawl characters:

Spoiler

highlighted ones are just barely viable

Kirby is worse than Pichu, and Dr. Mario is mid tier lolol (and higher than Mario). Jiggz's completely dominated Genesis ( wasn't there like 3 in the top 10? with Mango and HBox both top 3 or something like that?).

Lucario is more viable than GW, Pit, Pika, and ZSS. Yoshi and Sonic aren't viable at all, nor is Pit.

Why was this thread bumped again?

 

[JOE!]

yoshi and sonic both arent truly shut down by anybody, theyre just barely viable

 

[Vyse]

Bumping this doesn't particularly contribute to anything. There's also no need to compare character representation between Melee and Brawl's respective metagames.

Everybody here is walking a fine line between a civil analysis and a Melee Vs Brawl thread, so I'm just going to close this now.