All of you should play each other in mms, whoever has best record would be in a higher ranking than others, you guys completely ignore the people you haven't played, play them in money matches, it'll help you get a better and more accurate PR ranking.
It's not inconsistence, but the characters people play. Dyno sure you beat artdude, but you play wario, against dk of all characters. With that chaingrab to 80, and the fact wario can live forever, AND you camp, dude has very little options and it's difficult to win for dk. He's beaten you in a money match, regarrdless that brings it to being 2-1, not 2-0. That money match counts.
I personally see Dude as more consistent than you in this season. You lose to unranks, dude has lost to top 4-5 only, and beats many people in the PR, plus he has more tourney information on him. Then again, you did get third in a tourney he's gotten 5th in. We'll see next tournament. All i can say, is that if you don't play him in tournament, i recommend money matching and securing your spot above him. Grief as well.
Also dyno, isn't wario great against dedede as well (if played right)? Considering wario never touches the ground and in that sense never gets cg'd?
@scatz -if you can come to one more tourney, and money match a **** load of people you haven't played in tourney, you should be straight for PR. I just want to have alot of information so this can be accurate