• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

GA Brawl PR updated 3/14/10. Now with Salt level status!

Stage Striking or Random Select?

  • Stage Striking (FD, BF, YI, LC, SV)

    Votes: 58 66.7%
  • Random Select (FD, BF, YI, SV)

    Votes: 13 14.9%
  • Mutual agreement between players

    Votes: 16 18.4%

  • Total voters
    87
Status
Not open for further replies.

Player-3

Smash Hero
Joined
Nov 11, 2008
Messages
8,992
Location
Georgia
what happens if we got foostooled by the level 1 barline after he was spiked by his teammate at 100%

|:<
 

hichez50

Smash Lord
Joined
Oct 27, 2008
Messages
1,464
Location
Georgia
NNID
Player-00
3DS FC
2122-6108-1245
What if you get footstooled on stage then you trip. That would actually be johnable.
 

Rayku

Smash Lord
Joined
Feb 21, 2004
Messages
1,831
Location
Minot, ND
hmmm, this sounds crazy enough to actually work.

I like it.
This is what my idea was, essentially, and BigLou thinks it's dumb.

Basically, if you can't beat my Ike as a barline, you won't even be considered to be put on the Power Rankings. I think that sounds fair.

BigLou just says "What if they're bad against Ike" as his logic.
 

Player-1

Smash Legend
Joined
Apr 27, 2008
Messages
12,186
Location
Rainbow Cruise
This is what my idea was, essentially, and BigLou thinks it's dumb.

Basically, if you can't beat my Ike as a barline, you won't even be considered to be put on the Power Rankings. I think that sounds fair.

BigLou just says "What if they're bad against Ike" as his logic.
well...you know...they could main that one character that is bad against Ike. You know the one, right?
 

BigLøu

Smash Lord
Joined
Sep 21, 2007
Messages
1,652
Location
Marietta, GA
This is what my idea was, essentially, and BigLou thinks it's dumb.

Basically, if you can't beat my Ike as a barline, you won't even be considered to be put on the Power Rankings. I think that sounds fair.

BigLou just says "What if they're bad against Ike" as his logic.
actually what comes to mind for me as the problem ( I don't really care for a barline or not, it will not sway my decision as to where I would personally place them on the pr.) is a few different things. I will personally not view defeating your ike as my standard to which I will want to put people on the pr. I will base it off evidence of tournament placements and consistency as well as who beats who, the same way that pretty much all power rankings are made.

You mentioned to me that, if someone say can't beat your ike for whatever reason they would be disregarded from bring on the pr. You also told me that some exceptions for this barline were enlisted, such that if someone that places high loses to your ike for whatever reason. You either go all the way with this or not, there is no exceptions.

Like I said, this may help you as being part of the panel to decide whether or not you feel should be on the power rankings, but I will be using my own methods to do this.
 

kismet2

Smash Ace
Joined
Apr 22, 2008
Messages
816
Location
Columbus, GA
The first level of the barline should be my Snake, second level my Metaknight, then third level my Falco.
 

Player-3

Smash Hero
Joined
Nov 11, 2008
Messages
8,992
Location
Georgia
good

my fox was playing pretty nasty last saturday, i was waveshining like pew pew pew

my cf was playing decent


fox is so fun lol
 

Dynomite

Smash Champion
Joined
Feb 23, 2008
Messages
2,899
Location
Atlanta, GA
NNID
GA_Dyno
The first level of the barline should be my Snake, second level my Metaknight, then third level my Falco.
or our power rankings could just change to
1) Kismet2's Falco
2) Kismet2's Metaknight
3) Kismet2's Snake
 

Rayku

Smash Lord
Joined
Feb 21, 2004
Messages
1,831
Location
Minot, ND
Stuff about not half-assing stuff even though it's logical
Think of it like the Melee barline. No one has qualms over that, probably because there is no representation to give other than donating to Sleepy's church

If they were making the Melee Power Rankings *hint*, would you honestly want to put someone who can't beat SleepyK's Mewtwo on the power rankings?

Replace that with me, and you get:

Would you honestly want someone who can't beat Rayku's Ike to be put on the Power Rankings? BBQ is constantly concerned about the image of GA's Brawl scene and him not wanting it to look bad.
 

Player-1

Smash Legend
Joined
Apr 27, 2008
Messages
12,186
Location
Rainbow Cruise
I should be #1 b/c of these results:
Place Description #
1.Hunter (Wigi/Ice Climbers/Diddy/Yoshi) 1-------------------p1
2.Julius (Lucario) 3-----------------chez
3.Joe (C. Falcon/Olimar/Ike/Link/Marth) 2-------------------------p3
4.Travis (ROB/Game & Watch/Yoshi) 6
5.Braendon (Pit/Wolf) 5
6.Michael (Diddy) 8
7.Alex (Falco/Ike) 4
8.Jeremy (Sonic/Pit) 9
 

BBQ°

Smash Champion
Joined
Mar 26, 2008
Messages
2,017
Location
Woodstock, GA
good

my fox was playing pretty nasty last saturday, i was waveshining like pew pew pew

my cf was playing decent


fox is so fun lol
Yeah and every time you shine spike someone, you can be like "Fox McCloud!!!11" lol

Replace that with me, and you get:

Would you honestly want someone who can't beat Rayku's Ike to be put on the Power Rankings? BBQ is constantly concerned about the image of GA's Brawl scene and him not wanting it to look bad.
yeah idk why. I just want GA to get better. I only have respect for the current top 5.
But I'll take the barline for the lolz.
 

BigLøu

Smash Lord
Joined
Sep 21, 2007
Messages
1,652
Location
Marietta, GA
Think of it like the Melee barline. No one has qualms over that, probably because there is no representation to give other than donating to Sleepy's church

If they were making the Melee Power Rankings *hint*, would you honestly want to put someone who can't beat SleepyK's Mewtwo on the power rankings?

Replace that with me, and you get:

Would you honestly want someone who can't beat Rayku's Ike to be put on the Power Rankings? BBQ is constantly concerned about the image of GA's Brawl scene and him not wanting it to look bad.

I don't have "qualms" about the melee barline because I'd like to show my actual skill and work in a tournament enviroment where a lot of things are on the line, (including spots on prs). You have your methods for deciding what you think (and like I said it's fine that you want to do the barline challenge, and I have no problem with people doing it with you) deem fit for being on the power rankings. Our lists for who should go where will turn out similarly anyways, because me and you have a good idea as to who is better then who.


I'm saying I personally wouldn't be taking it too seriously if I were to take this barline challenge, because being on the power rankings doesn't mean too much to me, I'm all about action. If I were to drop off the pr for losing to your ike I still would be placing consistently in tourney.

Go ahead and do the barline challenge, like I said I am not stopping you.
 

Player-3

Smash Hero
Joined
Nov 11, 2008
Messages
8,992
Location
Georgia
yeah bbq you shoulda seen it

i was nairing like a pro

i even gave fox tips to a bro whos trying to pick up melee and may come out to waba some time

told him to nair more
 

Rayku

Smash Lord
Joined
Feb 21, 2004
Messages
1,831
Location
Minot, ND
I'm saying I personally wouldn't be taking it too seriously if I were to take this barline challenge, because being on the power rankings doesn't mean too much to me, I'm all about action. If I were to drop off the pr for losing to your ike I still would be placing consistently in tourney.

Go ahead and do the barline challenge, like I said I am not stopping you.
I think it's a healthy experiment.

In regards to your personal thing, I think everyone here knows that you can beat my Ike with whatever character you want, so that's hardly a good hypothetical.

@Kismet: I beat your Snake with Ike, therefore no power rankings for it
 

bigman40

Smash Master
Joined
Oct 11, 2007
Messages
3,859
Location
Just another day.
yo scatz, I still love you big time. But at the current moment I strongly dislike Brawl, so getting respect from me doesn't matter.
I didn't care for your respect in the first place. It's just that your post is pretty mean to people that have problems to get taken care of or to people that are already working hard to attempt to be on the PRs. I love you too and all, but letting hatred of a game get in the way of showing respect to others is pretty ****ed up.
 

BBQ°

Smash Champion
Joined
Mar 26, 2008
Messages
2,017
Location
Woodstock, GA
yeah bbq you shoulda seen it

i was nairing like a pro

i even gave fox tips to a bro whos trying to pick up melee and may come out to waba some time

told him to nair more
to play fox:
nair
bair
shine
uptilt
upsmash
don't get grabbed

I didn't care for your respect in the first place. It's just that your post is pretty mean to people that have problems to get taken care of or to people that are already working hard to attempt to be on the PRs. I love you too and all, but letting hatred of a game get in the way of showing respect to others is pretty ****ed up.
Ok.... well I'm glad they are working hard, but I think what I meant by respect is that I don't view them as a *top* player unless they are in the current top 5. I'd feel good about sending our top 5 to an OoS tournament and expect to see solid results. I still respect all players for working hard but I can't respect them for being a good player (strong emphasis on "good").
 

BigLøu

Smash Lord
Joined
Sep 21, 2007
Messages
1,652
Location
Marietta, GA
I think it's a healthy experiment.

In regards to your personal thing, I think everyone here knows that you can beat my Ike with whatever character you want, so that's hardly a good hypothetical.

@Kismet: I beat your Snake with Ike, therefore no power rankings for it
I agree give it a shot, can't hurt at all.
 

kismet2

Smash Ace
Joined
Apr 22, 2008
Messages
816
Location
Columbus, GA
I think it's a healthy experiment.

In regards to your personal thing, I think everyone here knows that you can beat my Ike with whatever character you want, so that's hardly a good hypothetical.

@Kismet: I beat your Snake with Ike, therefore no power rankings for it
My Snake's gotten better. I'll show you next time we play. :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom