wow that 8 list needs to be updated something fierce. mainly because wario and donkey kong have actually made names for themselves and only really come back to the marioverse in party, sports, kart, ports, and remakes. so that makes it the original 6, and out of those six toad has done the least, practically nothing really. i mean hes only been playable in two adventure games, and one was a puzzle/tetris-esc game so i wouldn't really count that, and the other he was one of four selectable characters, but he was the best out of the four so ill give him that. so out of toads entire carear which has lasted as long as the test of time, hes only been a playable character in 2 adventure games. i personally dont think that counts for much at all, so lets admit that the only reason toad stands a chance is that he has a loyal fanbase willing to back him up. but then again so did samurai goroh who was a much more major character in his series, and we all know what happened to him. now granted that mario is a mega franchise and f-zero is not toad is still a blip on the mario radar as far as character importance goes.
now so far in fawful's carear he has been a major right-hand man to a big time villian and a diabolical shopkeeper. now the shopkeeper can be taken away as long as toads puzzle game goes with it. now so far this seems about equal character-wise. fawful isa young up and commer, and toad is a tired old man who has almost been forgotten about, placed in a retirement home if you will. so all in all the characters are equal except for one thing. the big toad pc scandle from melee, this incident might be what pushes toad over the edge into pcness because it is known that he is a wanted pc character
and that is all i have to say for right now