Fake select screen

[Collective of Bears]

This also sums up my character predictions for Brawl. Comment, discuss, suggest, eat a piece of toast, and do whatever the hell you feel like. Just don't flame.

 

[Phlemingo]

I like how you included Jimmy T. and Fawful.

 

[Griffard]

really good list except that there are better choices than fawful =[

 

[Collective of Bears]

really good list except that there are better choices than fawful =[

He's better than Geno, and he speaks of Mustard and fink-rats. What's not to love?

 

[Griffard]

well personally i like him much more than geno, but he just isn't likely at all

 

[Rakath]

If you're going to make a fake select screen... at least put the characters in a proper order... I mean really...

 

[kunai_abuser]

Not too bad, but some are a little strange, but Fawful would make a great WTF character.

 

[Collective of Bears]

well personally i like him much more than geno, but he just isn't likely at all

Actually, he was highly requested (I'm not talking about Sakurai's poll).

 

[Rakath]

Oh right, you lack Rock Man and with only one Fire Emblem rep you've basically spit on a good Nintendo series. Congrats on making your list fail.

 

[Collective of Bears]

Oh right, you lack Rock Man and with only one Fire Emblem rep you've basically spit on a good Nintendo series. Congrats on making your list fail.

I'm personally not that big on Fire Emblem.

 

[Rakath]

Even if you aren't big on Fire Emblem, you made it the only series that went DOWN in reps from Melee. Removed a high tier character, and for what? Fawful and Paper Mario? Yeah, even if you hate Fire Emblem 2 rep minimum, Marth ain't gone.

I ain't a huge fan of F-Zero, even I know Falcon is gettin' a spot. If I said "I'm not a big fan of Starfox" and removed Falco and ignored Krystal you'd probably complain. (Realize, I'm not a huge fan of Starfox, and I know that Falco isn't gone and Krystal has a fair shot.)

 

[Darkfur]

SEARCH FUNCTION! *facepalm*

http://smashboards.com/showthread.php?t=74816&highlight=photoshop+screen

 

[CottonEyedJoe]

As Sideshow Mel would say...

TERRIBLE!

 

[paralasalud]

i think everyone's stuck on what the melee one looked like.

 

[Thirdkoopa]

Horrible, No offence but i would die inside if this was the final roster.

What i don't like; Kawashima, Midna, Fawful, JR AND PAPER? Lucario mewtwo AND Jiggs? Overkill much.

What i would suggest to add; Geno (You hate him however...) Claus, WWLink, Moar sukapon.

 

[Cinder]

He's better than Geno, and he speaks of Mustard and fink-rats. What's not to love?

You mean besides the fact that he's only been in one game, in which he is killed when his own machine overheats, and has no real chance at the roster, while Geno, number two on Sakurai's poll, does? I better hunker down, cuz it's gonna take a while...

 

[Cinder]

Whoops...my computer wasn't showing my post, so I assumed it wasn't there (it didn't show a second page either...how was I supposed to know >.<)

 

[Viscano]

Needs moar Geno and less Fawful, Kawashima, and Paper Mario.

 

[Mad555]

He's better than Geno, and he speaks of Mustard and fink-rats. What's not to love?

Whats with the hate you have for Geno? He is better than Fawful.

 

[Brawler360]

The list seems a little lacking...sorry. Again, I'm no Geno fan, but I really do think he has a good chance of being in the game. Honestly.

 

[A2ZOMG]

Horrible, No offence but i would die inside if this was the final roster.

What i don't like; Kawashima, Midna, Fawful, JR AND PAPER? Lucario mewtwo AND Jiggs? Overkill much.

What i would suggest to add; Geno (You hate him however...) Claus, WWLink, Moar sukapon.

JR is good. He's consistently appeared as an important villain in the recent Mario franchise games. Paper Mario is also viable considering that after all, he's a rather famous variation of Mario as we know him. This would not be the first time Mario has had a famous variation of himself as a separate playable character. Ever heard of Doc? Oh, and Jiggs is staying since she's famous from the TV show AND from the previous Smash games. Mewtwo I believe is staying being one of the better legendary Pokemon that stars in a movie, but that's just my opinion.

As for GeNO....I will personally stab Sakurai multiple times if he's made playable. Geno is a fricken RPG PARTY MEMBER in the ONE game he supposedly stars in. Saying Geno should be playable is like saying other Paper Mario characters should be playable too, which quite frankly most of us should agree here is unacceptable, but somehow other people place different values on Geno. And furthermore, Square Enix seriously has better options. >_>

 

[Zevox]

...yeah, not that good, definitely has several no chance characters among it. Jimmy T, Fawful (wth?), Paper Mario, and Dr Kawashima (wtf?!) all need to go at the bare minimum. No way in hell they'll make it. Definitely needs Marth - Fire Emblem needs its fair representation, whether you like it or not, just like any other major Nintendo series - and if its going to be that large, another third-party ought to be there, probably Mega Man, though thats somewhat debatable. Arguable beyond that - I'd put in Isaac for sure myself, but thats just me - but those would be some basic problems with it.

Zevox

 

[RegalBuster]

Your idiocy amuses me.

 

[Pluvius]

Rockman isn't present. I don't like it.

 

[bballstar23]

Why call it a prediction thread when it's clearly filled with opinions?

Actually, he was highly requested (I'm not talking about Sakurai's poll).

Any evidence of this at all?

 

[pcamtz]

I'm going to let go the fact that there is no geno (even though he's uber cool), because I understand that not everybody has the same likes, but here is a list of glaring mistakes:

>Fawful: one game, not mentioned on polls, lack of moves to use...
>Jimmy T: WTF? Ashley has better chances
>Prof. Kawashima: Floating heads FTL, seriously, he could be the WTF character but I still don't like it
>Lack of Megaman: he has pretty good chances and you do need the 3° third party char, at the very least there are 3
>I understand that not everyone is a pro at photoshop (being not that good myself) but both players are in red and the background says P1 in both, change that if you can
>SUGGESTION put the characters in some kind of order, the one you have is pretty random
>Maybe you could use some better pics as the coins used to select chars., and there are no hands (cursors)

 

[Memo326]

There is a difference between wishlist and prediction, you know.

 

[Shuma]

Whats with the hate you have for Geno? He is better than Fawful.

Pft, he hates everything, just ignore him.

 

[susu_atari]

I think any character roster without Claus, WW Link and possibly Megaman is already wrong.

Also, those characters are in NO ORDER!! Get back to work!! Lazy...

 

[Collective of Bears]

You mean besides the fact that he's only been in one game, in which he is killed when his own machine overheats, and has no real chance at the roster, while Geno, number two on Sakurai's poll, does? I better hunker down, cuz it's gonna take a while...

Geno has been in one game plus a cameo appearance that nobody notices.

 

[StoleUrCar]

lawl at brain age man

 

[Collective of Bears]

lawl at brain age man

I don't see what everyone has against him. He scored high on Sakurai's poll.

 

[Cinder]

Geno has been in one game plus a cameo appearance that nobody notices.

The Ice Climbers would like to say hello...

I'd love to continue this debate, but a) you've got obvious biased hatred toward Geno that can't be changed, no matter how unfounded, and b) I've got a life, and need to leave...so, I bid you farewell, and I will continue as soon as I return...

 

[Snakz]

I don't see what everyone has against him. He scored high on Sakurai's poll.

I think the tiny little fact that he's actually a real person MIGHT hinder him from being playable.

 

[Zevox]

I don't see what everyone has against him. He scored high on Sakurai's poll.

Two mentions on that "poll" is not a high score.

Besides, the fact that your roster doesn't include Geno, a highly popular character who did genuinely score high on that (4 mentions), makes it rather impossible for you to seriously defend Kawasima, a character person almost nobody wants in Brawl, as getting in based on that alone.

And yeah, as Snakz said, the fact that hes a real person, and ergo does not originate from a video game, kind of disqualifies him anyway.

Zevox

 

[Zubyyyy]

Swap out Fawful for Geno, Jimmy for Sukapon, and add in some Megaman and you got a nice recipe cooking.

 

[Mic_128]

Please use the Photoshopped screens thread in General, please.