Brelee / Mawl

[-=Untamed-Beast=-]

Who finds the following idea interesting?

Modify the characters of one game's engine to play as close as it possibly can to their respective physics in the other game, and pit them against their regular version in said game. So essentially, you could literally pit Melee Sheik versus Brawl Sheik.
Yeah, the physics differences make it obvious who would win these matches, but wouldn't it make for interesting watch?

Unfortunately, that's neither easy to pull off nor realistic enough to even think about. It's just a thought, a fantasy even, and I'm wasting your time. Stop reading this post.

But think about it. Thoughts?

 

[-ShadowPhoenix-]

I'd love to see my Melee sweeties poop on their barwl counterparts.

 

[GCS Gaming Customs]

melee falco vs brawl falco

both players would be watching the melee falco the whole time..

 

[SAUS]

Haha I have thought about this. I'm actually curious about how melee characters would do against metaknight.

 

[IndianapolisCentralGaming]

But brawl falco would air doge out of stuff and win the laser game super hard and chain throw to dair

 

[-ShadowPhoenix-]

But brawl falco would air doge out of stuff and win the laser game super hard and chain throw to dair

IF barwl falco can air dodge out of melee combos, then melee falco would just tech the down throw

 

[IndianapolisCentralGaming]

But brawl falco has a different d-throw… they are different charcters with different engines

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

So Brawl is safe on shield where as Melee characters aren't safe on shield?

 

[IndianapolisCentralGaming]

Your vague explamle of comparison fails to explain it's self.

I'm just saying brawl vs melee falco would be semi boring cause brawl falco would run the projectile game so hard and look for grabs melee falco would eat brawl falco alive if he gets in but would likly miss his normal 0% death but would still rock punish to a degree. Idk what the problem with this is?


What ifs without any thoughts of the answer is mad boring

 

[SAUS]

Who would get which engine's hit-stun? Do melee characters get melee hit-stunned or do they apply melee hit-stun on other characters? It can't be both because then they'd force the opponent to play melee with their brawl character.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

Your vague explamle of comparison fails to explain it's self.

If each character had their mechanics of their respective, melee moves suddenly aren't safe on shield because you can drop shield faster.

Melee has to wait longer to drop shield so suddenly done brawl moves are safe in shield.

Brawl Peach could probably Fair to Grab guaranteed.

Melee would lose a lot of advantages in that respect.

 

[-=Untamed-Beast=-]

Let's assume the hit's effects are determined primarily by the user of the attack.

 

[IndianapolisCentralGaming]

That's way to funny brawl falco would be calling all the shots in the neutral game xD yeah movement is amazing in melee but two lasers in the face are two lasers in the face as far as movement goes

 

[Ezzee]

Honestly, the Brawl characters would probably win because of the games stupidly low hitstun, meaning the Melee character's can't combo.

 

[IndianapolisCentralGaming]

So melee samus for top tier?