1-up mushroom item in brawl

[sprittles]

Finally a great item that can save or overpower a person in the match! The 1-up mushroom!

What it does?

It appears like a normal item, and if you get it...It simply adds another life to your stock. This is one of those simple yet clever items that should appear in brawl.

PS: You can also turn this feature off in the item selection if you don't want it. Simple as that.

But should appear in brawl as a goodie item.

 

[Wob-Wob]

I thought it was a spotted item in the trailer from friday's update
Untill I saw the rest of the post

 

[Banjodorf]

Interesting, but since it is so powerful, why not just make it very a very rare replacement to the mega mushroom?

That would work better imo.

 

[spindash]

That is the greatest idea I've ever heard for an item. I'd go for it!

 

[Blindman]

And in Time Mode, your opponent gets a -1 kill. (As if you hadn't died once.)

 

[omiz144]

It's a great idea, but what about in time matches? Maybe it could give you +1 points!

 

[sprittles]

But

Its awsome

 

[SaxyPlayah]

Yeah..i had the same idea earlier..except with 1-up mushroom i though of the rare candy from pokemon....i believe that pokemon needs more items from there franchise than just the pokeballs....

 

[Iris]

Eh, I think it's kind of cheap when you consider the speed of other characters and how much easier it'd be for others to get to. Great idea, but I think it'd be more balanced if there was a -1 stock version of it that looks exactly like it. Kind of like the giant mushroom. That way players have to take a gamble.

 

[sprittles]

All I am saying

Is that we should bring this item up, let brawl notice that we want it. Than "THEY" decide how they use it.

So that's 'a what we do.

 

[Blindman]

It's a great idea, but what about in time matches? Maybe it could give you +1 points!

And in Time Mode, your opponent gets a -1 kill. (As if you hadn't died once.)

Same time posting doesn't work...

 

[NastCF]

It's an ok idea I guess.

 

[omiz144]

Same time posting doesn't work...

..............agreed.

 

[00Elf]

I can just see the noob matches now:

Hyrule Temple
Stock Ten
1-up mushrooms (very high)
No time limit

THAT's going to end well.

But great idea man, I think it would be great if it occurred at a mew like frequency (once every thousand or so items). And besides, we can always turn it off if we don't want it, it's a win-win scenario!


Oh, and just as the Super Mushroom has the Tiny Mushroom, the 1-up Mushroom should have the Poison Mushroom-it deducts a stock!

 

[reu_1303]

Yeah I'm not so sure about it. A little to powerful if you ask me

 

[Florida]

It's been thought of many times before. Heck, even I thought I was the first to come up with it

Discuss all items, here.

 

[PRINCESS PEACH777]

a really fine idea

 

[sprittles]

Ah HA!

I got the idea solved. It appears as rare as when you saw a super mario star in super smash bros melle. Very rare, but seen almost at least once per match. Also the poison mushroom should deduct the life as well.

The creating of this item in many ways will work for brawl. We just got to get it put in.

 

[Grandeza]

The argument for cheapness isnt a good one because there are many cheap items. Starman,homerun bat, hammer, golden hammer etc.This could appear just a little more often than a smash ball.

 

[shadowyoshi2345]

it would be better to just power your character up more, giving someone another life is pretty cheap, but there would be a sudden change of the fight once it came down

 

[Ice man]

A 1-up mushroom sounds kind of cheap if you ask me.

 

[brawlmaniac]

Definitely a great idea. 1-up mushroom gives you an extra life, poison mushroom takes one away. I think they should look exactly alike so people won't know which is which. Since you can turn them off, there's no real reason it shouldn't be in.

 

[notftomearth7]

Items are all about turning the tide in a match.

This would do some serious tide turning
GO FOR IT!

 

[Youkai Master]

This idea is OLDOLDOLDOLD.

 

[gigasteve]

It would be like the team healer b/c it's made for a specific type of matches.

 

[SamuraiPanda]

Welcome to SWF sprittles!

Please discuss this in the official item discussion found here: http://smashboards.com/showthread.php?t=104437

And to get a better idea of how the Brawl community here at SWF works, check out the stickied Brawl FAQ.