Recent content by williamsga555

Nah, but I do love almost all of the swordies across the series, so I've played a lot of Marth in all of them since Brawl (don't care for Melee much uh-oh). More importantly here though is that I used to commentate our local scene and Marth was a decently popular pick at that time (Smash 4...

Speaking of more specific character/hitbox stuff and Lucina/Marth, I want to hear a bit about their dtilt's place in Ultimate Way back in the days of Smash 4 I played a good amount of Marth in friendlies and was a huge believer in dtilt as a key component of his neutral (in theory). In general...

Very fun read-a-long with the match, cheers for taking the time and effort to go through that. I think your point about not taking the bread-and-butter followup in advantage (Cloud up air against a landing opponent in this case) and instead focusing on a more matchup-specific, nuanced choice...

Yeah, his recovery is fantastic, no doubt there. If he's coming back from a typical position off stage, there's not much that can be done to intercept it due to the number of angle mixups and stalls he's capable of. That said, if he finds himself in a position where he needs to exploit that...

I should first say that "fine as he is" for me doesn't mean "not overtuned." I use it as "assuming that patches are finished, is the game in a decent spot with this character as they are now" and I believe that answer is yes, personally. Doesn't mean Steve is perfect or that I wouldn't want to...

Don't worry, I 100% agree that Incineroar is not as good as Steve. I was pointing out that just listing strengths by themselves doesn't tell us much because other (worse) characters might have those exact same strengths. If someone complained about Steve because his damage-to-frames ratio is...

It's all well and good to mention your gripes about things like frame data and skewed risk-reward, but this particular point is, frankly, exaggerated nonsense. There's no special property about his shovel or fair that makes it "win nearly every exchange," it's just a stubby disjointed move...

I'd disagree that it proves anything, because Incineroar never should have been lumped in with the "bad" characters to begin with. He's not some secret top tier, but he's far from the likes of Ganon and company.

Yes, all of this is true. The Shulk comparison is fine as long as it qualifies that the two are certainly not equal techs -the Steve tech is absolutely better without question, and I don't think anyone is really disputing that. The only real point of the comparison is to matter-of-factly state...

Thanks for the solid replies. One more thought point, however: Every example given above as to why banning the tech would be logistically infeasible has been centered around the inconsistency of multihits specifically, but that's not really what I'm trying to bring up. Multihits failing to work...

Honestly I'm not sure why the tech itself is being written off as something that we can't ban without banning Steve himself. I've seen some comments here-and-there about how it's not an easily noticed animation, but at that same merit, completely ignoring hitstun is a pretty obvious occurrence...

One important distinction between wobbling and Kazuya's ZTD is the level of player involvement. In wobbling, the player getting wobbled may as well set their controller down -there is literally nothing they can do to influence whether the wobble gets dropped once it starts. Brawl banning MK's...

Another aspect to keep in mind with these results is that nearly anything regarding viewership (especially this first tournament) needs to be taken with a grain of salt until much later on. I would nearly guarantee you that the massive jump in numbers can largely be attributed to curiosity -this...

Biggest thing I noticed from grands is that Riddles has started implementing Kazuya's aerials a lot, especially up air as a combo breaker/air-to-air pressure tool and fair as a momentum mixup/poke. Looked like a way more rounded version of his Kazuya than we'd seen in the past and it paid off...

I'm not convinced that dealing with Hero with dyslexia is as equivalent as the visual noise of Northern Cave, but it's at least worth discussing. The main objection I have is that the counterplay to his spells is largely the same regardless of which one he chooses -often times, mid-match, you...