Recent content by PKNintendo

^ Man... talk about a false dilemma. The fact that you're using my argument against Conda to illustrate why tier list discussion is bad is a major logical fallacy. Your rule is also pretty silly; people don't debate because they want to convince their opponents.They debate because they want to...

Nice try. And you really just don't get it. I'm not looking for a tier list. I'm looking for information. Informed opinions from somewhat knowledgeable players. (This thread is called the Character Competitive Impression thread for a reason). Hence why I don't give a **** if you try to shut...

"Healthy discussion" is completely subjective, and your "we don't have enough tools to discuss this" is a bull****, reductive statement. I'm not looking for the most accurate tier list, but a preliminary view is fine. I got more out of SFP's latest post than the last 2-3 pages of squabbling. In...

No, that's wrong. SFP's tier list is acceptable because he's got a wide range of experiences in Smash at a level that most people don't. As a result, his opinion is more valid than yours because he can approach these issues from all angles. I'm pretty sure he knows what he's talking about more...

Man, that Robin. Such a bad character. :059:

You say that but I remain unconvinced. Your logic is flawed, and it doesn't support your argument: Robin isn't a good character because Nairo isn't consistently placing in top 3? 1. That's a logical fallacy. 2. That isn't even true (he's placed outside of top 3 twice, out of 9 tournaments)...

Thoron+ begs to disagree Plus Nairo and NAKAT have both argued in favor of Robin being pretty good

Something like that. We just got a solid assessment on Greninja's viability in Smash. And furthermore, SFP just dropped a mega ton by stating that Peach might be top 5. What? Really? How? Go on...? There's also the Jigglypuff hype. I want a follow up on it. I wanna hear about things like that...

Agreed Let's be honest here, what we ultimately want to see is informed opinion from experienced/intelligent users on the various smash characters. I couldn't care less what Sonicbuster756 thinks about X character, but posts from A2ZOMG, Amazing Ampharos, SFP, etc on character X would be...

Hell no, I'd be all for it. I'd love to see your informed thoughts and opinions on the cast. Even if it isn't objectively accurate, we could use it as a springboard for other topics. It beats aimless discussion and pointless semantics.

Yeah Thoron+'s pretty good character, all things considered. I love robbing unsuspecting opponents with him. I'll always charge Thoron+, even if I have to micro charge it against an opponent who's good at pressuring. It's "that" good.

And i'd like that posit that one character (a forgetable one at that) doesn't make my point any less valid. I'll concede that Lucario has a lot of overpowered nonsense, but that command grab is simply the cherry on top of an overpowered cake

The hitbox being nerfed doesn't change the fact that it's completely absurd how that move can KO at obscenely low percentages.

Well, neither of those characters had a full screen projectile that could dish out 33% and KO at low percentages. Don't get me wrong; Robin still loses to rushdown characters, and it's pretty much impossible to charge it against the likes of Sheik and other anti-zoners, but if the opponent can't...