Extended universe characters

[Squadalah]

think the interesting Sonic characters from SATAM, AOSTH, the comics, maybe SU, and maybe SX, (as long as Chris Thorndyke isn't in it) C'mon these characters are way better than the stupid furries Sega created recently :((Princess Cat? Blatant pshycic mary-sue Hedgehog? PASS

[2007]

nope. two Sonic characters is one Sonic character too many.
Sonic's enough.
=2007=

[SonicMario]

Not only that, but IF a 2nd rep was even possible. It would never ever go to any of these characters, they never were main parts of a game even (Which mean Cameos of SatAM and StH cartoon characters in Sonic Spinball is out of the question) once. If a 2nd rep was possible I'd reckon it'd be Tails, Knuckles, or Shadow. IMO, my bets would be on Tails. But I'm only sure he'll be an AT.

But characters like Sally, Rotor, Manic, Sonia, Julie-su, Cosmo, etc. don't even have a chance of being mentioned in Brawl, most of them haven't even been mentioned in an actual game

[Dragonbreath]

Sega of Japan HATES Archie comics. Why do you think they made Sonic X? And I doubt a Sonic character would get into Brawl without Seg's approval.

There's already a thread for discussing other Sonic characters. You'll find that the idea was not well-received.

And even if Sakurai could put Princess Sally in Brawl, he wouldn't. Tails, Knuckles, Shadow. . .Hell, even Big has more priority than a character who's never even appeared in a videogame. And that's saying something.

[Phoenix_Dark]

I believe Sally made an appearance in Sonic Spinball. A few others too actually in that game. During that minigame thing or whatever it was. Its been so long since I've played that game. But still, no they won't be mentioned in SSBB. Tails or Knuckles as an assist trophy is more than enough.

Edit: Oh and Dr. Robotnik as a boss of course! He neeeeds to be a boss..

[Formula1]

Maybe it would be a good idea...
But sally isn't in a nintendo consle videogame, which is part of the necessity

[SonicOfDarkness]

Are you sure sega of japen hates the archie comics. Do you have the truth. Need I mention that the sonic X comics are also from archie. If this is not true then you should think before what you say about the sonic comics alright!!!!!

[Tyeforce]

Those Sonic comics...AAAARGH!!! They're terrible!! Why would you even consider putting one of them in?! If another Sonic character does get in (which won't happen), it would be Tails. (I'm sure he'll be an Assist Trophy.)

[Puffball64]

Sega of Japan avoids Archie like a plague.

Besides, like it has already been said, other characters from SoJ already have priority.

Also, I like Blaze :(

Silver, Marine, Eggman Nega, and Captain Whisker's on the other hand, is where I draw the line.

[Squadalah]

Hey, Maria's relationship with Shadow was good in Sonic Adventure 2, then when Shadow came back he became a blatant emo brat

[Squadalah]

Sorry, had trouble posting

[Viral]

Haha wasn't Shadow always an emo brat?. I can see why people like him since he has the whole dark and mysterious thing which a lot of fans go nuts for, but i'm not a particular fan of his character at all.
There's no denying his popularity though and I wouldn't really mind much if he was one of the Sonic universe's AT's since it would obviously please the majority.